News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Semmelweis myth and why it's not true (2018) by steve_g on Thursday July 18, 2024 @04:31PM (#40999454)
I interpret the article to say the "myth" is exactly true. It may also be true that Semmelweis could have done a better job communicating his findings and persuading others. But that doesn't take away from the truth of the basic story.
Re:The Semmelweis myth and why it's not true (2018) by scblock on Thursday July 18, 2024 @05:41PM (#41000041)
Agree. This seems to just be a trashy clickbait headline with a vaguely related thought piece about effective communication following it.
Re:The Semmelweis myth and why it's not true (2018) by AlbertCory on Thursday July 18, 2024 @04:39PM (#40999525)
Exactly. The "myth" is true.

> Innovation takes more than having ideas and expecting others to immediately accept them.

This absolves the people who said, "Eh, he's just a nut" (as he was). Instead of calmly asking if he had something there, however badly he communicated it.

The idea is not responsible for the person who holds it.

Re:The Semmelweis myth and why it's not true (2018) by ginko on Thursday July 18, 2024 @05:30PM (#40999960)
He didn't just have an idea, though.

He performed experiments and showed that his washing regime dropped the maternal mortality rate at his ward from 12.3% to 1.27%. That's a 90% reduction in deaths!

Re:The Semmelweis myth and why it's not true (2018) by p_j_w on Thursday July 18, 2024 @05:02PM (#40999715)
>This absolves the people who said, "Eh, he's just a nut" (as he was). Instead of calmly asking if he had something there, however badly he communicated it.

Why shouldn't they receive their absolution? No one has time to evaluate every idea they come across. As a matter of practicality, one has to put poorly communicated ideas or those for which the data collection is sloppy or otherwise badly done lower on their priority list.

People's lives would've been saved if Semmelweis had been taken more seriously, but how many other advancements would have suffered if everyone followed up on every poorly thought out and represented idea and didn't prioritize?

Re:The Semmelweis myth and why it's not true (2018) by AlbertCory on Thursday July 18, 2024 @07:49PM (#41000828)
Wrong. Dead wrong. That's judging people's ideas by how pleasant they sound, rather than what they say.

When you say "evaluate every idea" you ignore the fact that that's what a scientist does: he or she should be trained enough to know when, "Oh, that's interesting!" or "Yeah, I guess I can ignore that." is the right answer. Their judgement of which is which is a good way to evaluate them.

Re:The Semmelweis myth and why it's not true (2018) by p_j_w on Friday July 19, 2024 @12:51PM (#41008430)
Nowhere in there did I say people are judging based on how pleasant an idea sounds. Try again.
Re:The Semmelweis myth and why it's not true (2018) by AlbertCory on Friday July 19, 2024 @01:03PM (#41008558)
You said, "As a matter of practicality, one has to put poorly communicated ideas or those for which the data collection is sloppy or otherwise badly done lower on their priority list."

"poorly communicated" is perfectly well characterized by "how pleasant [it] sounds"

You try again. Maybe you don't like the characterization but it's fair.

Re:The Semmelweis myth and why it's not true (2018) by p_j_w on Friday July 19, 2024 @01:50PM (#41009100)
>"poorly communicated" is perfectly well characterized by "how pleasant [it] sounds"

No, it absolutely is not. You should read what people write, not what you read into it to confirm whatever view you took ahead of time.

Re:The Semmelweis myth and why it's not true (2018) by AlbertCory on Friday July 19, 2024 @02:16PM (#41009373)
.. and you should say what you actually mean, instead of using corporate euphemisms like "poorly communicated," which can mean anything in the world.

Including, "I don't like that person."

And stop assuming you know anything about my world view.

Re:The Semmelweis myth and why it's not true (2018) by sottol on Thursday July 18, 2024 @05:40PM (#41000032)
This is not so much about prioritization but outright dismissal and comfortably not questioning the status quo.

Reminds of many surgeons refusal to use checklists a while ago despite showing general improvement in outcomes. Nobody wants to admit they could have done better, change their routine and think they don't need help as they're already really good. [1]

[1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19682451

Re:The Semmelweis myth and why it's not true (2018) by why_at on Thursday July 18, 2024 @05:40PM (#41000035)
This led me down a bit of a rabbit hole. Related to this is what is sometimes known as the "Backfire Effect" which is the idea that a person's belief in something untrue will only be strengthened when presented with evidence to the contrary.

I had thought this was well established by experimental psychology, but now that I am looking into it it seems like the evidence is not nearly as strong as I thought and the effect may be very small or nonexistent.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Belief_perseverance#Backfire_e...

Re:The Semmelweis myth and why it's not true (2018) by arijun on Thursday July 18, 2024 @05:47PM (#41000083)
But seeing all this evidence to the contrary has made your belief in the theory stronger?
Re:The Semmelweis myth and why it's not true (2018) by why_at on Thursday July 18, 2024 @05:52PM (#41000111)
Haha yeah I was thinking about that. Either way my decision will work as evidence for itself.

Either I stop believing in the backfire effect due to the new evidence, or I ignore the new evidence and keep believing in the backfire effect :)

Re:The Semmelweis myth and why it's not true (2018) by Beijinger on Thursday July 18, 2024 @05:43PM (#41000059)
It is true. How about linus pauling and quasicrystals?

https://www.newscientist.com/article/mg21328481-400-impossib...

Re:The Semmelweis myth and why it's not true (2018) by smitty1e on Thursday July 18, 2024 @07:20PM (#41000662)
> That’s why innovation needs communication

I package this as:

"Doing the do" is half the work; "advertising the do" is the other half.

Few ideas are so intrinsically obvious as to sell themselves.

Re:The Semmelweis myth and why it's not true (2018) by AlbertCory on Thursday July 18, 2024 @11:16PM (#41001775)
Faulting Semmelweiss for being a nutjob (as he was) doesn't excuse the doctors who refused to look at the evidence.

That's your intellectual test: How do you react when a crazy, unpopular person says something sensible? When the safe thing to do is to just dismiss it?

Re:The Semmelweis myth and why it's not true (2018) by smitty1e on Friday July 19, 2024 @04:22PM (#41010723)
Wasn't "nuke the messenger" the default?