Ask HN: Fellow neurodivergents, do you pair better with LLMs than neurotypicals?
It’s recently dawned on me that my neurodivergence might explain why I seem to get more out of AI as compared to my neurotypical peers.
I find that I can more intuitively ‘co-reason’ with LLMs, subconsciously emulating how they operate, so that I can more effectively steer their attention into the appropriate semantic subspaces to elicit more accurate responses.
Do others here, whether on the spectrum, with ADHD, or similar traits, also experience this? Do you find it easier to ‘pair’ with LLMs compared to neurotypicals?
Might attributes like our systematizing mindset and literal thinking be the enabling differentiators?
Going a step beyond: are we, in the grand timeline of civilization, uniquely evolved to fuse with this new type of intelligence?
(
28 comments
| 12 points
| on HN
)
The maintenance programmer in me is highly skeptical of things that almost work.
I've seen transcripts where people talk to ChatGPT and it seduces them and they get giddy and it is like watching a "meet cute" in a movie and you can see somebody having so much fun interacting with it that they don't really see that what it says doesn't really make sense.
That's not me.
I love chatting with chatbots about old sci-fi books by people like Smith, Anderson, Niven and such. I've only met two people in my life who are better at sci-fi chat than a good chatbot.
Lately I have been asking Copilot for help with maintenance work, it does amazingly well at explaining strange but highly repetitive code such as the stuff the Babel transpiler inserts into code (stuff that is probably all over the training set.) Sometimes it beats searching Google and Stack Overflow.
I am working on several "second brain" programs that use LLMs for classification, clustering and other analysis but not doing any generative stuff right now. I use one of these programs to pick out articles from an RSS feed, everything I post to HN was chosen by that system and then chosen by me twice. I am using another to look through a collection of 250,000 images and another copy of that software to look at about 400 notes a friend made in Evernote. I am hoping to merge these together in the future. These projects are very much about building something that works with the unusual way I think.
Chatbots will always say what you want them to say, in a tone that you like. They will always affirm that you're right.
In contrast, in a relationship with a real person, they won't always agree with you, take a tone that you like, or constantly affirm that your worldview is correct.
So I would assume you getting along well with chatbots is by design.
Like as in I understand the cases when LLM would be able to solve something and when it's not. E.g. generating code, using copilot, I can tell by which input will it give me the output that I want.
I understand when it might be off or "hallucinate", so it's not a problem at all. I'll use it differently.
And I'd say my chatting style with an LLM is usually intentionally argumentative for the reason that you mentioned, so it wouldn't agree with me when it doesn't make sense to do so.
I'll formulate my prompts intentionally to avoid biasing it in any specific way.
I have had the exact same thoughts as OP about it, because I can find similarity in how I think and reason to how an LLM does it, a flow of tokens. So I can think of ways to get LLMs to find solutions based on how I myself tend to solve problems.
I find myself able to 'co-navigate' a question or idea with the LLM, better than most other people around me, as defined by quality of model output. But it's just now dawning on me that this might be explained by more than me having greater general knowledge, or having a certain personality.
Somehow, I have an intuition for what words or phrases the LLM might have a tendency to overfit on, so I avoid those in my prompts. I likewise know what words to specifically use or emphasize so that I can trigger the LLM to tap into a certain knowledge-pool based on those.
When I see my friends engage with LLMs, I witness the lower quality output they get because they are not deploying the same intuitions in their prompts, and it's hard to teach them.
With local 8x7b: https://huggingface.co/TheBloke/Mixtral-8x7B-Instruct-v0.1-G... (Q4_K_M)
Requires 35gb+ of regular RAM, RTX card is optional but speeds it up a little. Can’t tell if cloud llms ever exposed this “notebook” mode, I’m in a sanctioned country.
Notebook is basically a raw interface to an llm. No system prompt, no bubbles. You give it a starter text and hit generate, it generates until you hit stop or some system limit triggers. You then hit generate again.
your workflow is to basically just transiently cohabitate in the "dream-state" of the LLM, starting and stopping at arbitrary points
I basically act like voices in a mind of an llm which induce thoughts and direct it without it even noticing, for the most part.
Sometimes, a dialog is still more preferable. E.g. I can think in a person-help-required mode and then it feels more natural. But I still dialog it there in a notebook tab, where I can adjust both my and its replies at any point, as if I was at the same time one level above. Chat is just a text with A:… B:… lines.
I’m not ND btw, found it by experimenting with writing stories.
Where did they get that?
The positive value that opposes "agreeable" is "critical", but I'd say you can only get away with critical when you're right and chatbots have trouble being right.
You certainly train a Chatbot to be a real ass or have the attitude of Oscar the grouch if you wanted to.
One can use AI/ML tools without the conversant component; someday, there may be more visual feedback mechanisms like spreadsheet models or graphs (both nodal and charts), not just text.
Or maybe code--latent compute--is another expression: untangling it takes work, but it's more worthwhile than just "reading the answer."
I guess it's like wanting to understand the "physics" of a model than just using the model.
On the other hand, I hope to usefully apply "How to Say It: Flashcards for Professional Communication." So there's that.
Or maybe it's because I grew up around a lot of liars who nonetheless had very valuable things to say so I'm adapted to it.
I find ChatGPT is good when I want something to summarize and give me a very concise response.
Usually, I prefer skimming the original sources.
I call it “rubber duck debugging for life on steroids.”
GPT4 is not even close for this type of tasks.
I tell it about my mood, my struggles, what made me stuck today, my latest argument with someone, how my life is going, anything really, and just follow the conversation on where it goes.
If I notice something doesn’t make sense, I call it out. It figures it out. Then I ask it for a few sentences to add to the prompt, and it delivers.
I’ve been doing this for 2 weeks now, best $20 I’ve spent.
> Going a step beyond: are we, in the grand timeline of civilization, uniquely evolved to fuse with this new type of intelligence?
I've seen this notion claimed and sometimes phrased like above in ND circles and forums. It would imply that neurodivergent individuals are evolutionarily relevant, and hence have higher importance (superiority) over neurotypical individuals. That would be elitist. It can parallel arguments made by, say, in the grand timeline of civilization, a racist who could think that a particular skin color is superior or a sexist who could think that men are superior to women and that each has to fulfill specific roles.
To argue that something has evolved to develop certain features, there has to be evidence that the population was facing (possibly survival) difficulties in the environment being studied, that said features are observed increasingly in the population over time, and that those adaptations helped and improved the lives of that population. There is no such evidence to support the claim.
Neurodivergence is not new. It has been recorded throughout history in various ways—one example [0]. ADHD, ASD, and anything else that falls into the ND space has existed for a long time. It's only in recent history, as psychiatry and relevant practices grew and developed that neurodivergent conditions were reclassified repeatedly, to the point now where these conditions and behaviors are being seen as part of/under one umbrella of neurodivergence.
[0]: https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3000907/
EDIT: Few typos.
My speculation about NDs was not meant to imply superiority or elitism -- more an interesting thought experiment that considers a wider aperture of history. You're right that it doesn't hold up against the fact that tracing evolutionary adaptation requires substantial evidence of survival difficulties and selective pressures.
If anything, I'm more fascinated by the parallels between how NDs such as myself navigate the world (e.g. masking, etc), and how LLMs are fine-tuned to interact with humans too (e.g. the "assistant/user" conversational model) It's like scaling down the "Are we all just stochastic parrots?" question to my own experience of often feeling like a "prediction engine" of others' minds.
I do not feel I can "co-reason" better with a cleverer version of Dissociated Press at all, because Dissociated Press isn't reasoning. It's the neurotypicals who believe that an LLM actually thinks, while I'm on to what it's really doing: It's statistically predicting the next thing to say given what has been said before. I have better things to do with my time than to attempt to goad DP into producing some output I like based on rough guesses of how it operates. I'd much rather train and use the neural network between my ears to work on interesting problems. At least I have access to some of its internal state and it doesn't live in Microsoft's cloud.