News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Pattern of Brain Damage Is Pervasive in Navy SEALs Who Di... by erva on Tuesday July 02, 2024 @10:21AM (#40856990)
Qualifier: Former US special operations operator that served in multiple wars.

My anecdotal take is there are many ways that shock and trauma can accumulate through training and war that are far beyond the minimal effects of an M4.

Firearms: While the primary weapons systems are the M4 and side arm (pistol), there are many weapons systems utilized by special operations such as sniper rifles, crew serve weapons, and niche small arms.

The M82 sniper rifle shoots a 50 BMG round. In either the bolt action or semi-auto versions they feel like you are getting punched in the face when you shoot them.

Crew serve weapons like the MK19 and M2 do pack a punch. The MK19 is a machine gun that shoots 40mm grenades. The M2 is a .50 cal machine gun. These weapons systems are mounted, but the percussion of them is still far greater than an M4.

More niche arms like the M249 SAW, M16 HBAR, full-auto AKs, M240 Golf, MP9, etc are not as mild as the standard M4/M16.

Blasts: There are many types of blasts encountered such as Mortars (inbound and outbound), Flash Bangs, Entry charges, IEDs, Landmines, etc. These do make your head ring if you are close enough to them.

In my own personal experience there are many other daily jarring events that aren't nearly as sexy to talk about. Riding in the back of a 5 ton will almost shake your brain out of your head. Riding in an LCAC (hovercraft) is like riding in a 5 ton. Doing boat work in Zodiacs will bounce you all over the place, especially when doing surf passages. Doing hydrographic surveys right where the surf breaks will pound you for hours and make you a little sick afterwards. When your chute opens on a jump, if jumping round chutes, will make you see stars...the landing is not a soft pretty one like rectangle chutes...you hit the ground hard.

There are many more ways your body gets pounded on a daily basis far in excess of the weapons you use.

Re:Pattern of Brain Damage Is Pervasive in Navy SEALs Who Di... by vimbtw on Tuesday July 02, 2024 @12:02PM (#40857941)
The tools used, as you’re undoubtedly aware, go far beyond small arms. Family members in the Army have talked about training to clear houses where they want to avoid going through a heavily defended doorway so they put an explosive against a wall, duck around the corner, light it off, pick themselves up, and run through the newly created entryway.
Re:Pattern of Brain Damage Is Pervasive in Navy SEALs Who Di... by bumby on Tuesday July 02, 2024 @10:29AM (#40857054)
The article links to a USSOCOM-funded study. In your opinion, are they (as a whole) seriously concerned with mitigating this issue or is it just checking the box? The worry is this can be similar to the buried diesel tank issue contaminating water, which was known for decades but seemed to be ignored (possibly out of liability concerns).
Re:Pattern of Brain Damage Is Pervasive in Navy SEALs Who Di... by erva on Tuesday July 02, 2024 @10:45AM (#40857209)
I'm not sure how much of it you can minimize. You can only control what you can control...and war/combat is chaos. Honestly it seems most things in relation to this over the years has been on treatment, not so much prevention.
Re:Pattern of Brain Damage Is Pervasive in Navy SEALs Who Di... by Gravityloss on Wednesday July 03, 2024 @02:45PM (#40868874)
Wouldn't using silencers reduce the pressure peak? The new standard assault rifle has one integrated IIRC.
Re:Pattern of Brain Damage Is Pervasive in Navy SEALs Who Di... by tamimio on Tuesday July 02, 2024 @11:48AM (#40857811)
There are a lot of sports where players experience constant hits to the head or extreme physical contact, like MMA, boxing, rugby, hockey, and more. Some of these players do get brain damage, but I rarely hear about them committing suicide. What makes these Navy SEALs commit suicide is definitely the guilt. In these wars, they must have killed innocent civilians either directly, as ordered, or as casualties. That’s something most people can’t live with. No one is validating their feelings about it, and they can’t ask for forgiveness from those they harmed, so I disagree.
Re:Pattern of Brain Damage Is Pervasive in Navy SEALs Who Di... by __s on Tuesday July 02, 2024 @11:54AM (#40857865)
Concussion is a film about football players & suicide
Re:Pattern of Brain Damage Is Pervasive in Navy SEALs Who Di... by tamimio on Tuesday July 02, 2024 @11:58AM (#40857911)
Do you happen to have statistics about that? I would love to see them
Re:Pattern of Brain Damage Is Pervasive in Navy SEALs Who Di... by hinkley on Tuesday July 02, 2024 @01:08PM (#40858553)
Depression is a lot like being drunk. There’s a point where you wish you could puke and get it over with but it’s just not happening. As I understand it there’s a lot of ex football players in this state. Just hopelessly miserable but not on suicide watch. Or on their way to Parkinson’s.
Re:Pattern of Brain Damage Is Pervasive in Navy SEALs Who Di... by _DeadFred_ on Tuesday July 02, 2024 @02:02PM (#40859003)
They need to implement weight limits in football just like are in use in most other contact sports. You don't force boxers to go up against guys 50+ lbs heavier than they are, over and over, daily in practice and weekly in games.
Re:Pattern of Brain Damage Is Pervasive in Navy SEALs Who Di... by theGnuMe on Wednesday July 03, 2024 @09:59AM (#40866017)
How about just change it to flag football? That would prioritize speed.
Re:Pattern of Brain Damage Is Pervasive in Navy SEALs Who Di... by bumby on Wednesday July 03, 2024 @11:04AM (#40866655)
NFL fans don’t want to watch flag football, generally
Re:Pattern of Brain Damage Is Pervasive in Navy SEALs Who Di... by erva on Tuesday July 02, 2024 @12:57PM (#40858434)
I think the whole point of the study is exploratory. Looking for commonality in a search of a cause or suite of factors instead of making assumptions.

Maybe it is a physical phenomenon like adrenal fatigue or brain injury, maybe it isnt; that is why people study it.

Re:Pattern of Brain Damage Is Pervasive in Navy SEALs Who Di... by bumby on Tuesday July 02, 2024 @03:10PM (#40859590)
This is discussed in the article, the mechanism is thought to be different:

>It was not chronic traumatic encephalopathy, or C.T.E., which is found in football players and other athletes who have been repeatedly hit in the head. It was something new.

Re:Pattern of Brain Damage Is Pervasive in Navy SEALs Who Di... by engineer_22 on Wednesday July 03, 2024 @08:54AM (#40865504)
This is wild speculation, further an insult to the dead. Shame on you.
Re:Pattern of Brain Damage Is Pervasive in Navy SEALs Who Di... by bumby on Wednesday July 03, 2024 @11:06AM (#40866677)
Combat troops, and especially SOCOM, have lower rates of PTSD than other troops. That data doesn’t seem to align with your guilt hypothesis.
Re:Pattern of Brain Damage Is Pervasive in Navy SEALs Who Di... by jvanderbot on Tuesday July 02, 2024 @11:17AM (#40857493)
Thank you for sharing. It's a tragedy that this does not have enough mitigation and follow-up treatment. Armed forces are a necessity, and should not damage a generation beyond repair, and especially not in relative peace.
Re:Pattern of Brain Damage Is Pervasive in Navy SEALs Who Di... by gunapologist99 on Tuesday July 02, 2024 @10:39AM (#40857158)
Thank you for your service and sacrifice, and for helping us celebrate another Independence Day.
Re:Pattern of Brain Damage Is Pervasive in Navy SEALs Who Di... by lttlrck on Tuesday July 02, 2024 @05:06PM (#40860420)
Thank you. That is enlightening. Not something I had ever thought about, but why I...
Re:Pattern of Brain Damage Is Pervasive in Navy SEALs Who Di... by sdwr on Wednesday July 03, 2024 @01:11AM (#40862888)
That's so disillusioning it must be true.

The special forces tale is heroism - being brave and tough in dangerous situations.

That the danger comes from your own equipment, used as intended, is just sickening.

Re:Pattern of Brain Damage Is Pervasive in Navy SEALs Who Di... by seabird on Wednesday July 03, 2024 @10:07AM (#40866085)
Why is the danger sickening? Of course the equipment is dangerous -- it all exists so you can kill people and not die well beyond any natural level, and there's no such thing as a free lunch.
Re:Pattern of Brain Damage Is Pervasive in Navy SEALs Who Di... by sdwr on Wednesday July 03, 2024 @11:58AM (#40867231)
Sickening like working a construction job. When you're killing yourself in slow motion (the impact, the noise, the chemicals!), and there's no way out.

Most injuries involve an element of luck or skill, so the ego can serve as a natural buffer.

Consistent, unavoidable, permanent damage is different. It hurts in its own (sickening) way.

Re:Pattern of Brain Damage Is Pervasive in Navy SEALs Who Di... by solardev on Wednesday July 03, 2024 @10:44AM (#40866409)
Side question: Why are round chutes so much worse than rectangular ones?
Re:Pattern of Brain Damage Is Pervasive in Navy SEALs Who Di... by dumah on Wednesday July 03, 2024 @01:01PM (#40867856)
Round parachutes are typically deployed with a static line and open very quickly, resulting in significantly higher acceleration.

Ram air parachutes can effectively open in a more gradual manner due to the cellular design.

Re:Pattern of Brain Damage Is Pervasive in Navy SEALs Who Di... by solardev on Wednesday July 03, 2024 @01:06PM (#40867903)
Really cool! Falls squarely in the realm of "stuff I didn't even know I didn't know". Thank you.
Re:Pattern of Brain Damage Is Pervasive in Navy SEALs Who Di... by robertsibue on Wednesday July 03, 2024 @08:10PM (#40871258)
(former - non-US - army airborne captain)

Round chutes (cupolas) are designed to get soldiers from the plane to the ground quickly.

Quickly enough to remain the least possible amount of time in the air where they are an easy target for any ground troop. (This is why soldiers are dropped from very low altitudes; 400m is usual, but some combat drops occurred at even lower altitudes) But not too quickly that too many of the dropped soldiers end up unable to fight from the hardness of the landing. Please note that it is assumed that some will get hurt on the landing, and the calculus is designed to balance the risk in the air with the risk of the landing.

In contrast, rectangular chutes (wings) are designed to be dropped from higher than 900m, steered in the air, and to provide a very comfortable landing (as long as the surface of the wing is adequate for the suspended weight). They were also introduced for skydiving as a sport, and only later found some military use.