News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Open-Sora does pretty good video generation on consumer GPUs by _flux on Thursday June 27, 2024 @06:55AM (#40809153)
It's probably not the best idea to base your clone on the name that is being trademarked: https://trademarks.justia.com/984/05/sora-98405663.html
Re:Open-Sora does pretty good video generation on consumer GPUs by __loam on Thursday June 27, 2024 @07:02AM (#40809193)
AI developers don't care about intellectual property.
Re:Open-Sora does pretty good video generation on consumer GPUs by jampekka on Thursday June 27, 2024 @07:16AM (#40809264)
Which is a positive turn of events. Intellectual property as a concept needs to go.
Re:Open-Sora does pretty good video generation on consumer GPUs by jsheard on Thursday June 27, 2024 @07:21AM (#40809295)
It's a one-way street with AI companies though, they are against IP protection for training data but support IP protection for the product of that training. Read the TOS/license of nearly any model and it's clear the creator considers it and its output to be their IP and they will fight to restrict how you can use it for commercial purposes or training competing models, because those being a free-for-all would get in the way of their business model.

In practice it's less "abolishing intellectual property" and more "transmuting everyone else's IP into their own IP so they can be the ultimate IP landlords".

Re:Open-Sora does pretty good video generation on consumer GPUs by jampekka on Thursday June 27, 2024 @07:33AM (#40809364)
Sure. And I wouldn't be surprised if e.g. Micr.. OpenAI can manage to brib.. convince a judge to make government to enforce this by force.

But how ML is at least currently developing, other megacorporations and universities are only a year or so behind OpenAI etc, and publishing their weights and models. Of course disregarding training set IP because otherwise keeping up would be impossible.

If the media and advertising megacorporations manage to get a ban on training on IP material, Micr.. OpenAI would be a huge benefactor, as they could afford some weird licensing deal on everybody's data and the actual open efforts would be extinguished.

Luckily US hegemony is fading and many other powers DGAF anymore what a US judge says. Or a WTO judge, because USA kind of destroyed WTO themselves already.

Re:Open-Sora does pretty good video generation on consumer GPUs by __loam on Thursday June 27, 2024 @05:23PM (#40815289)
If they ban training on IP, it's not unlikely that GPT 4 would be subject to algorithmic disgorgement
Re:Open-Sora does pretty good video generation on consumer GPUs by nortonsdad on Thursday June 27, 2024 @03:47PM (#40814319)
Unless the entity they're taking from can defend themselves in court. Just ask Copilot to generate an image in the style of AI hater Tim Burton and you'll get a ToS wrong-think violation. So really it is just for taking from small fries.
Re:Open-Sora does pretty good video generation on consumer GPUs by kriops on Thursday June 27, 2024 @07:39AM (#40809403)
If you think for more than a few seconds on the matter, you quickly realise that intellectual property is a moral necessity, because intellectual expropriation (which is what you are really talking about) would destroy a major incentive for positive contributions to society.

Everything political is rooted in morality, and while it is easy to point out political challenges on the topic, intellectual property is ethically an unambiguously good concept.

Re:Open-Sora does pretty good video generation on consumer GPUs by infostud on Thursday June 27, 2024 @08:15AM (#40809655)
Most creators work for hire and the company owns the IP. Anecdote: I can't remember the song written on a bus and sold to the record company for $250 to keep food on the table that has earnt billions for Warner, Sony, or Universal Music. Nothing more for the creator. Big company stealing from another big company to benefit the rest of us? Seems like fair use. Nothing to do with creators. That incentive was meant to be something like 20 years (same as patents) not almost "forever" like the Mouse wants who expropriated from all of those European folktales and sanitised them. No incentive if you live off the earnings of a "one-hit wonder".
Re:Open-Sora does pretty good video generation on consumer GPUs by vel0city on Thursday June 27, 2024 @10:01AM (#40810651)
> sold to the record company for $250

And without any form of copyright it would have gone "hey $RECORD_COMPANY here's this cool jingle I made" and they'd say "yeah we think so too, we'll use that and compensate you $0."

Way better.

Re:Open-Sora does pretty good video generation on consumer GPUs by jampekka on Thursday June 27, 2024 @10:34AM (#40810977)
A lot of creators, at least in music, are not even work for hire, but in a form of indentured servitude.
Re:Open-Sora does pretty good video generation on consumer GPUs by Joeri on Thursday June 27, 2024 @07:50AM (#40809475)
Most of the great art was created in a world without intellectual property, or with no effective IP enforcement on that art.

While I don’t think all IP should be abolished, I think in general there is too much of it, protected for too long, and society would be better off getting rid of patents and dramatically downsizing copyright to at most a few decades of protection.

(And yes I have thought a lot on this matter. The evidence behind patents being overall beneficial is weak, and there is no effective societal argument for the current copyright terms.)

Re:Open-Sora does pretty good video generation on consumer GPUs by dagw on Thursday June 27, 2024 @08:02AM (#40809562)
Most of the great art was created in a world without intellectual property

It was also created at a time when copying work was almost as hard and expensive as creating it.

Re:Open-Sora does pretty good video generation on consumer GPUs by fletchedx on Thursday June 27, 2024 @08:01AM (#40809552)
I tend to agree with your takeaway, but I want to pick a nit on your point about great art being made without copyright.

"The Most Powerful Idea in the World" basically makes the case that intellectual property is what enabled the Industrial Revolution. I won't try to summarize or defend the entire thing here, but I think it makes a very compelling case that the notion of "owning ideas as property" was the thing that made Britain unique (among other factors of course) and led to runaway technological explosion. It points out how in earlier times, inventors were literally killed for coming up with better methods that threatened some established system. So there is a big difference between art and technology there, and while I think debating the merits of copyright as it pertains to art is valid (and 100% agree it's overdone in our current system), I'm not convinced the current issues are serious enough to undermine the entire concept of intellectual property.

Re:Open-Sora does pretty good video generation on consumer GPUs by jampekka on Thursday June 27, 2024 @08:26AM (#40809725)
Enslaving half of the world also played a slight part in that uniqueness.
Re:Open-Sora does pretty good video generation on consumer GPUs by jampekka on Thursday June 27, 2024 @07:54AM (#40809507)
I have thought on the matter for millions of seconds.

Politics and economics don't have anything to do with morality. It's about power. The moral fairytailes are there to justify whatever the state of affairs are. When these change, new fairytales justifying them will be adopted.

If right to property is a God given right, why the hell I as a atheist should give a damn?

Re:Open-Sora does pretty good video generation on consumer GPUs by spacebanana7 on Thursday June 27, 2024 @08:11AM (#40809627)
> If right to property is a God given right, why the hell I as a atheist should give a damn?

You can argue it from political necessity.

Some kind of property rights are necessary for the operation of any social group. Even in a communist society you can't have the air force stealing land from the navy, or the transport department taking electricity from hospitals, or neighbours taking each others food allocations.

There needs to be some kind of organised transfer of property or you get chaos.

Re:Open-Sora does pretty good video generation on consumer GPUs by jampekka on Thursday June 27, 2024 @08:21AM (#40809694)
You can argue divine right of kings or white supremacy from political necessity.

Some kind of systems to allocate scarce resources is needed. This doesn't have to be property. Access to e.g. the moon and earth's orbits and international waters and polar regions have systems of allocation, but they are not property.

Re:Open-Sora does pretty good video generation on consumer GPUs by spacebanana7 on Thursday June 27, 2024 @08:46AM (#40809890)
> You can argue divine right of kings or white supremacy from political necessity.

Those arguments can be incorrect without entailing all arguments from political necessity are false.

I can incorrectly argue a justification of the flat earth theory from physics - but that would discredit my own intellect rather than the subject of physics.

> Some kind of systems to allocate scarce resources is needed. This doesn't have to be property.

I agree not everything has to be property, but some things must. Essentially anything that's both important and "stealable" needs to be protected by property rights of some kind.

Regardless of how your food and water come into your possession (trade, charity, gov allocation), it's necessary that some of it remains in your possession for you to consume.

Re:Open-Sora does pretty good video generation on consumer GPUs by jampekka on Thursday June 27, 2024 @10:32AM (#40810952)
> Those arguments can be incorrect without entailing all arguments from political necessity are false.

> I can incorrectly argue a justification of the flat earth theory from physics - but that would discredit my own intellect rather than the subject of physics.

Do you mean the right to (certain very specific form of) property is somehow an empirically shown fact like the geometry of the earth?

Am I right in guessing that you have inclination towards praxeology?

> I agree not everything has to be property, but some things must.

Why do some things must? Because it leads to more desirable consequences than other options, or because it is some metaphysical truth you're somehow privy to?

The first kind of argument is fine, the latter is just blunt rhetorics. I don't see why the former should be spoiled with the latter.

Re:Open-Sora does pretty good video generation on consumer GPUs by spacebanana7 on Thursday June 27, 2024 @04:53PM (#40814977)
> Do you mean the right to (certain very specific form of) property is somehow an empirically shown fact like the geometry of the earth?

> Am I right in guessing that you have inclination towards praxeology?

Yes for both. I’ve not formalised it but I suspect we can a draw a line from philosophy -> game theory -> evolutionary dynamics -> socially stable systems of “rights”

Re:Open-Sora does pretty good video generation on consumer GPUs by jampekka on Thursday June 27, 2024 @05:48PM (#40815508)
I'm all for socially stable systems of "rights". And deriving theories from assumptions is all good. Where I depart from praxeology is that I think the assumptions must be changed when they lead to empirically invalid conclusions.

Also, I don't believe ownership rights like we have currently lead to stable societies. This is kind of core of Marx's critique of capitalism.

Re:Open-Sora does pretty good video generation on consumer GPUs by spacebanana7 on Thursday June 27, 2024 @07:19PM (#40816226)
I actually think we do live in very socially stable societies. Not to say it’s always a good thing.

But we do have clear systems of who gets power, through what means, and what they can do with it. The various classes of society have a relatively peaceful system of competing with one another.

I’m writing from a British perspective but it largely applies to most developed countries.

Re:Open-Sora does pretty good video generation on consumer GPUs by jampekka on Friday June 28, 2024 @06:30AM (#40819300)
Europe had two world wars in the last century, and there's a major war right now. The (private) economy has collapsed at least twice. The post-war stability was largely due to reigning in private propery rights.

From a Finnish perspective, where ownership rights are somewhat lesser, the British system's trajectory didn't seem particularly stable when I lived there 2019-2020, and looks even less so now.

Re:Open-Sora does pretty good video generation on consumer GPUs by spacebanana7 on Friday June 28, 2024 @10:30AM (#40820944)
I think too much stability is self defeating. It creates fragility like a monocultured ecosystem. Self correction mechanisms are important, even if they're painful. Bad governments and bad enterprises need to be wiped out now and again by war and recession, as a last resort when other forms of reform fail.

Britain never seems stable at first glance. Read a newspaper from 5, 50, 150 or 250 years ago and they'll all be lamenting economic uncertainty, geopolitical dilemmas and social injustice. Yet in that time no revolutions have killed more than 1% of the population, long term economic growth has averaged couple percentage points annually and nobody has successfully invaded the Islands.

Re:Open-Sora does pretty good video generation on consumer GPUs by andsoitis on Thursday June 27, 2024 @08:40AM (#40809832)
> Some kind of systems to allocate scarce resources is needed. This doesn't have to be property.

I should not be coerced to give output of my labor (whether physical or mental) to others based on some burocrat’s allocation system or my neighbor’s wishes. That would be immoral.

Re:Open-Sora does pretty good video generation on consumer GPUs by jampekka on Thursday June 27, 2024 @09:05AM (#40810050)
Per your morality perhaps. But morality is just an opinion, and one that can't be justified otherwise.

I should not be coerced not to enter a piece of land just because somebody made a contract with somebody who killed or evicted by force the people (and other animals) who previously inhabited the land. That would be immoral, right?

Re:Open-Sora does pretty good video generation on consumer GPUs by kriops on Thursday June 27, 2024 @08:29AM (#40809749)
Examine your definitions of politics and morality. Morality encompasses all actions made by actors with (presumed) free will.

"God given" means "natural". [Natural rights does not require a god](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Natural_rights_and_legal_right...)

And if your argument ("... god given ... atheist ... etc.) can be copy-pasted into a valid defence of arbitrary evil (I like to use Hitler for a concrete example, but avoid it in public because some subset of people erroneously thinks that is an automatic fallacy), then it is trivial in the sense that it doesn't add anything to the discussion, regardless of your opinion or pov.

Re:Open-Sora does pretty good video generation on consumer GPUs by jampekka on Thursday June 27, 2024 @08:58AM (#40809987)
"Natural" rights are clearly a social construction, and indeed largely the same thing that was theologically justified with God.

They were literally just invented few hundred years ago. And have even changed since then (owning another human being was somehow a natural/god given right). Humans have organized (and keep on organizing) without any such conception for at least tens of thousands of years, but suddenly its natural?

Who is the absolute arbiter of "evil"? USA of course holds itself as a force for good, and e.g. islamism as evil. Islamists do the opposite. Very rarely anybody thinks themselves as evil, but readily point out evil in others.

This is in no way to support islamism, or USA. Just that morality is just mostly an arbtrary justification for whatever somebody wants to or doesn't want to get done.

We can discuss the merits and shortcomings of e.g. ownership based on its societal consequences just fine without conjuring metaphysics.

Re:Open-Sora does pretty good video generation on consumer GPUs by spookie on Thursday June 27, 2024 @07:35AM (#40809385)
Why is that the case? The way its implemented is no longer fit for today's world, but as a concept? That's a whole other story.
Re:Open-Sora does pretty good video generation on consumer GPUs by jampekka on Thursday June 27, 2024 @08:06AM (#40809587)
IP is a huge drag on the progress of mankind.

Ideally there would other ways than economical to facilitate production of intellectual goods. Ownership economies are exceptionally bad in non-scarce resources.

There are some alternative and less destructive ways to handle the economy already in place. Academic institutions generally don't claim or enforce IP (paywalls are more a corporate than academic thing). Many library systems pay authors (notably not the publishers) for each loan from public funds. Open source software is funded via services (and increasingly with ads, which is not necessarily great).

State enforced monopoly on ideas or lumps of matter isn't the only way of structuring the economy. Alternatives haven't been discussed in 30 or so years, so it's understandable that many have hard time even conceptualizing such.

Re:Open-Sora does pretty good video generation on consumer GPUs by _flux on Thursday June 27, 2024 @08:31AM (#40809764)
Is IP on names also a huge drag? Would it be beneficial to the mankind if I—or anyone—were able to just make their own Linux or Nginx, with no relation to the group that originally made it?

Arguably "first come, first serve" policy on names per domain is a good one and serves to reduce confusion.

Re:Open-Sora does pretty good video generation on consumer GPUs by jampekka on Thursday June 27, 2024 @09:26AM (#40810257)
Monopoly on usage of a name not so much, although how it is implemented (or enforced) has substantial problems too. Companies regularly hijack commonly used words as "property" and/or push their monopolized names to the general vocabulary (e.g. iPhone, iPad, App Store, Googling, Kleenex, Xerox) especially in the USA and then literally police how people can use the words.

Yes, they should lose the "property" if they do so, but in practice they lose it decades too late if even then.

Also trademarks being sellable means that at any moment the product with a trademark can have nothing to do with the original holder, partly defeating the rationale.

Re:Open-Sora does pretty good video generation on consumer GPUs by croes on Thursday June 27, 2024 @07:47AM (#40809452)
That would give big companies a big advantage.

It maybe wrong how it is now, but it exists for a reason.

Same with patents.

Re:Open-Sora does pretty good video generation on consumer GPUs by jampekka on Thursday June 27, 2024 @08:29AM (#40809748)
Disney must be close to divine managing to get such a marketshare despite IP regulations holding them back.
Re:Open-Sora does pretty good video generation on consumer GPUs by croes on Friday June 28, 2024 @11:51AM (#40821879)
Without IP it wouldn't be Disney but the first company with enough power and money would crush any competition.

Even now they can fight in court until smaller opponents go bankrupt but without any IP they wouldn't even have to fight.

Remember when Amazon copied successful products on their marketplace? That would be the norm and you could even blame or sue them.

Re:Open-Sora does pretty good video generation on consumer GPUs by ADeerAppeared on Thursday June 27, 2024 @07:39AM (#40809398)
No. AI firms are a good example of precisely why copyright was put in place.

Right now, AI is taking people's original works and rehashing them in a way that directly competes with the original work. Some AI firms (e.g. perplexity) just have their LLMs paraphrase the work lightly.

This is a problem because it drives original work out of business. Even setting aside matters of originality, artistic value, and AI being vapid slop:

Gen-AI is and will remain a derivative work that is reliant on original human-made work

ChatGPT is not going to do investigative journalism. If we let AI push all journalists into bankruptcy, the news just becomes an endless sewer of PR statements recycled into AI slop.

If you don't want Google's woke "diverse nazis" to push real news into bankruptcy, copyright is needed to stop them.

Re:Open-Sora does pretty good video generation on consumer GPUs by selestify on Thursday June 27, 2024 @08:20AM (#40809687)
We should find new ways to fund essential services like journalism and the arts, rather than artificially crimping the possibilities of new technology in order to get a half-assed solution under the current paradigm.
Re:Open-Sora does pretty good video generation on consumer GPUs by __loam on Thursday June 27, 2024 @05:32PM (#40815358)
Until we find the political will to do that, creating products that fuck over journalism is shitty.
Re:Open-Sora does pretty good video generation on consumer GPUs by FeepingCreature on Thursday June 27, 2024 @09:18AM (#40810172)
All (99%) the music I listen to is remixes, all (99%) the writing I read is fanfic.

> Right now, AI is taking people's original works and rehashing them in a way that directly competes with the original work.

Good. Taking people's original works and rehashing them in direct competition fosters, not harms, cultural flourishing.

Re:Open-Sora does pretty good video generation on consumer GPUs by spacebanana7 on Thursday June 27, 2024 @08:20AM (#40809685)
Intellectual property in the form of trademarks is generally good for consumers, you don't want a new database product to be called Postgres despite no association with the developers of PostgreSQL.

Intellectual property in the form of patents and copyrights is often harmful for consumers. In music, academia and mechanical engineering it's clearly been harmful in slowing the spread of innovation. It sucks to wait 20 years for a new excellent new dishwasher tray shape.

Re:Open-Sora does pretty good video generation on consumer GPUs by worldsayshi on Thursday June 27, 2024 @08:31AM (#40809766)
I think intellectual property is necessary given the current way the economy works. But we should strive for evolving how the economy works.
Re:Open-Sora does pretty good video generation on consumer GPUs by __loam on Thursday June 27, 2024 @05:30PM (#40815348)
I agree but in the mean time, stealing from millions of artists and writers to build systems with the goal of replacing them is incredibly shitty.

If we lived in an economic system where people don't starve or lose their house when they don't have a job then I wouldn't care. Until then, OpenAI and its ilk are looters.

Re:Open-Sora does pretty good video generation on consumer GPUs by worldsayshi on Monday July 08, 2024 @06:26AM (#40904167)
> an economic system where people don't starve or lose their house when they don't have a job

I think the AI industry is motivating this for themselves with the idea that this does (at least partially) lead us to that world.

Re:Open-Sora does pretty good video generation on consumer GPUs by __loam on Thursday June 27, 2024 @05:18PM (#40815240)
Interesting that most engineers have this view despite their paycheck largely depending on ip
Re:Open-Sora does pretty good video generation on consumer GPUs by Jiahang on Thursday June 27, 2024 @07:53AM (#40809499)
this is a issue
Re:Open-Sora does pretty good video generation on consumer GPUs by luqtas on Thursday June 27, 2024 @08:37AM (#40809806)
one of the phrases they used @ their example page maybe reads pretty clear :D

> there are no text or logos in the video

Re:Open-Sora does pretty good video generation on consumer GPUs by logicchains on Thursday June 27, 2024 @08:22AM (#40809697)
It looks like it's being developed by a Chinese group. What's OpenAI going to do, sue them in a Chinese court?
Re:Open-Sora does pretty good video generation on consumer GPUs by ramshanker on Thursday June 27, 2024 @08:43AM (#40809858)
Take down their GIT Repository with perfectly valid DMCA Notice, I guess?
Re:Open-Sora does pretty good video generation on consumer GPUs by kadoban on Thursday June 27, 2024 @09:04AM (#40810044)
Does DMCA cover trademarks? I think it might only be for copyright.
Re:Open-Sora does pretty good video generation on consumer GPUs by _flux on Thursday June 27, 2024 @09:44AM (#40810439)
They can probably sue GitHub then (their current hoster of their repo), the traditional way?

Though actually I imagine GH would just close the repo before it comes to that, because it looks like a pretty clear case.

I guess it's also possible OpenAI doesn't care about this.

Re:Open-Sora does pretty good video generation on consumer GPUs by kadoban on Thursday June 27, 2024 @12:49PM (#40812488)
Yeah I'd imagine that GH has a way to report trademark abuse, or yes of course you can get lawyers involved. Since it's international that might get annoying unless you're fine just getting it off of GitHub and other hosts you can easily reach.
Re:Open-Sora does pretty good video generation on consumer GPUs by echelon on Thursday June 27, 2024 @08:30AM (#40809752)
It's also kind of a humorous jab in that it's named "Open".