This elides over the cost differential and where that "cheaply enough" wall is. Animal grown meat is currently rising in costs and will continue to rise in costs as both demand is rising and the habitat for those animals is constricting due to climate change. How much cheaper does lab grown meat and how much more more expensive does animal grown meat need to be before it becomes viable. From what I've read they are closer than this argument assumes.
They (like us) have been evolving under thermodynamic pressures for millions of years, I would like us to be able to not have to produce them to have high quality protein/fat/etc, but I haven't seen anything to say it's remotely possible.
It's clearly possible to make muscle cells (and other components of meat) reproduce rapidly: cattle exist.
It's clearly hard, or we'd have already have all this plus vat-grown organs and (affordable) vat-grown leather.
And some (non-meat) cells are already convenient to grow in vats (you just don't want to get all your protein from nutritional yeast and/or spirulina).
"1000 ways to not make a lightbulb", or whatever the real original Edison quote was — what's the number, 90% of start-ups fail?
For instance, even the most efficient cell lines used in pharmaceuticals aren't efficient enough for low-cost production of bulk cell mass. This implies cultured meat companies are attempting to solve problems that have long eluded a much larger, better-funded industry. The absence of these breakthroughs in pharma, where the financial rewards would be enormous, suggests they may be fundamentally unattainable with foreseeable technology.
This I agree with; it's just… well, I'm 40 now[0], and a lot of biology that can be done today involved technology that was not foreseeable when I was born.
So, yes, pharmaceuticals getting the hard problems solved first, sure — I'd say that I'd know not to invest in vat-meat startups until pharmaceuticals companies have solved problems I'm oblivious to except for the logical impossibility with such a test.
[0] aaaaaaa
For generics and biosimilars, more efficient production could be a major competitive advantage. The fact that we haven't seen breakthroughs in this area, despite clear financial motivation, suggests these are not easily solvable problems.
[0] https://www.fiercepharma.com/manufacturing/car-t-manufacturi...
The persistence of process-related challenges in both industries, despite significant financial motivation to solve them, underscores their complexity. This relates back to the "fractal no" concept from the original article, where each obstacle in cultured meat production is composed of many smaller obstacles. Importantly, monoclonal antibodies can sell for thousands of dollars per gram, orders of magnitude more than meat, yet even with this immense profit incentive, the pharmaceutical industry hasn't solved these bioprocessing issues. This suggests that cultured meat production, with its much lower profit margins, faces an overwhelming set of challenges,
[0] https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S15700...
it "absolutely" is, anything that exists, is fundamentally a question of thermodynamics, it's unavoidable.
In this case, cows exist, therefore thermodynamics is resolved to "yes you can make a cow for at most the cost of a cow, in the general case", and I don't need to show detailed working to know that. Existence proofs make it obviously "not a question of" any law of nature, including thermodynamics, that we can't reproduce that existence proof synthetically.
This doesn't tell me how to do it, how to make it cheap enough for anyone to care, what the actual ultimate limits are, etc.
Either every single company is wholesale lying about key parts of their processes and outputs…or this is just another hitpiece by Big Ag with exaggerated claims.
I'm sure that's all harder than it sounds. But I doubt it's the same "wall of no" as muscles in a vat.
The NYT carried another opinion piece by the same author this year[1] along with a number of reader rebuttals[2], including this one from Mindy Kursban:
> It is surprising that in his obituary for cultivated meat, Joe Fassler spends so few words on the viability of the science and cites more chief executives than scientists.
> Just recently, the chair of Tufts University’s biomedical engineering department, David Kaplan, who has published more than 1,000 peer-reviewed papers, told[3] a room full of cultivated meat scientists that progress over the past five years gives him “complete confidence that we’re going to get to where we need to go.”
> There are many eminent scientists all over the world who share Dr. Kaplan’s view, but readers would not know that from reading Mr. Fassler’s essay, which argues that cultivated meat is a project of Silicon Valley “dreamers with a fancy prototype, a pitch deck and a good amount of natural charm.”
> This groundbreaking science may be taking longer than initially thought, but it’s making strides, so it’s a shame that Mr. Fassler spends so little time exploring it.
[1] https://www.nytimes.com/2024/02/09/opinion/eat-just-upside-f...
[2] https://www.nytimes.com/2024/03/02/opinion/lab-grown-meat.ht...
This feels incredibly dismissive? Sure I will concede that most likely the 9 year timeline mentioned in that article is incredibly optimistic and very likely will not come to fruition.
But I think it is also naive to think, regardless of how much you know on a particular subject, that there are not solutions to problems that have not been developed yet or that there are already examples to those problems that are not public knowledge (it even mentions that the paper was written with NDA knowledge).
Then it is even more naive to try to paint a "wall of no" seemingly in a way to shut down research on this subject.
Just look at the silicone chips allowing us to have what once would have been considered a super computer in our pockets compared to when computers were tubes. Of course at that time anyone suggesting that a personal computing device would even be possible would likely be laughed out the room, the core technology didn't even exist to think that maybe some day it would be possible.
Are these companies and that paper making lofty promises that may be borderline lying to investors, maybe. But I don't think we should be saying it is impossible at this point in time.
Somethings are just rather complicated at scale and both cultured meat and fusion belong to this category.
But there is a difference between it being very complicated and likely relying on technology (or a fundamental understanding of something we don't know about) we don't have yet, and a "big no" and "never". Which is what this paper seems to be saying (reinforced by the comment I was replying to also saying "never").
That is the part of this that bothers me. Yeah we should admit that it is going to be very hard (if not impossible) and we should examine the reality of the timeline claims. But we should not be discouraging the research on both of these topics at this time by making claims that it will never happen.
We can criticize the timeline and the promises made to investors, that is incredibly valid.
But "never" is naive.
The only time I am really comfortable with saying "never" is something like, we will never travel faster than the speed of light. That seems to be fairly well proven at this point in time and if we ever fight a loophole around it, likely the core law will remain true.
Even GFI, the tech hype bros in that article that's being responded to, is showing a pretty big lack of vision. "This gradual progression is necessary; you can’t just throw a small amount of cells into a large bioreactor and hope they’ll start dividing. Cells are “fastidious,” Hughes told me, and have strict metabolic requirements for growth, including oxygen tension." <- pretty comfortable saying that under those constraings, 100% agree on the fractal of nos. But like, yeast and other things we grow in bioreactors aren't that picky. The hype bros want to try and convince people it's happening now so they're pitching some nonsense vision of mass manufacturing based on tech that obviously can't scale, and taking their vision of how things are going to work as ground truth is kinda silly. Almost by tautology, a successful bioreactor based approach is going to be one that uses bioengineering to create cells that don't need that sort of pickiness. It doesn't exist yet, sucks for the hype bros, but how sure are you that nobody will ever figure out how to engineer yeast to work as meat so you can use bioreactors from defunct breweries or something?
The first cow genome was only published 15 years ago - at least wait for biology and medicine to plateau and for the incentive of fixing climate change to go away before convincing yourself it's never gonna happen!
> Humbird likened the process of researching the report to encountering an impenetrable “Wall of No”—his term for the barriers in thermodynamics, cell metabolism, bioreactor design, ingredient costs, facility construction, and other factors that will need to be overcome before cultivated protein can be produced cheaply enough to displace traditional meat.
> “And it’s a fractal no,” he told me. “You see the big no, but every big no is made up of a hundred little nos.”
I've posted this comment before, but the linked article is relevant to every story about lab-grown meat as the entire concept is a fantasy, or less charitably, a scam.