Re:Singapore doubles down on lab-grown meat as Silicon Valle...
by andybak on Sunday June 23, 2024 @07:06PM
(#40771385)
I don't think they were denying thermodynamics. Merely denying that it trumps economics.
Re:Singapore doubles down on lab-grown meat as Silicon Valle...
by dekken_ on Monday June 24, 2024 @02:55AM
(#40773168)
Economics itself is a product of thermodynamics.
Re:Singapore doubles down on lab-grown meat as Silicon Valle...
by andybak on Monday July 01, 2024 @08:54AM
(#40845376)
Which is both true and also missing the point.
Re:Singapore doubles down on lab-grown meat as Silicon Valle...
by ben_w on Monday June 24, 2024 @08:49AM
(#40775388)
The phrase "not a question of $x" does not mean $x can't be asked at all, but that the question is unimportant.
In this case, cows exist, therefore thermodynamics is resolved to "yes you can make a cow for at most the cost of a cow, in the general case", and I don't need to show detailed working to know that. Existence proofs make it obviously "not a question of" any law of nature, including thermodynamics, that we can't reproduce that existence proof synthetically.
This doesn't tell me how to do it, how to make it cheap enough for anyone to care, what the actual ultimate limits are, etc.
it "absolutely" is, anything that exists, is fundamentally a question of thermodynamics, it's unavoidable.