News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The tiny chip that powers Montreal subway tickets by bobthepanda on Sunday June 23, 2024 @01:38PM (#40769116)
This wasn’t super obvious to me until later in the article but this is about the single use tickets.

Neat stuff, though I can’t say I love the concept of e-waste NFC.

Re:The tiny chip that powers Montreal subway tickets by kens on Sunday June 23, 2024 @02:19PM (#40769409)
I don't like the e-waste aspect either, but realistically, the chip is so minuscule that the amount of waste is trivial compared to almost anything else you might discard. The chip is literally the size of a grain of salt.

The other factor is that people who use tickets regularly would use the rechargeable plastic cards, rather than the disposable tickets, so the amount of waste is reduced.

Re:The tiny chip that powers Montreal subway tickets by ComputerGuru on Sunday June 23, 2024 @04:08PM (#40770231)
You are discarding both the chip and every consumable that went into making that chip, though.
Re:The tiny chip that powers Montreal subway tickets by Reason077 on Sunday June 23, 2024 @03:10PM (#40769793)
> ”the chip is so minuscule that the amount of waste is trivial”

It does add significant costs to the transport system. Single-use NFC cards must cost at least a few cents to produce and dispense, which adds up when you’re talking about hundreds of thousands or millions of rides every day.

Even reusable NFC cards are costly in terms of providing all the infrastructure to support them: software, servers, enough top-up machines in stations to handle peak demand, commissions to retailers selling the cards, extra staff to deal with customer support, delays and congestion caused by top-up/ticketing queues, etc.

That’s one reason London’s TfL has been pushing everyone to just use their bank-issued contactless credit/debit cards (or NFC-enabled phones) for years now.

It’s also more convenient, of course, to never have to worry about your balance or recharging the card.

Re:The tiny chip that powers Montreal subway tickets by n_plus_1_acc on Sunday June 23, 2024 @07:34PM (#40771528)
Do they still issue single use tickets for transfers between the Heathrow Terminals?
Re:The tiny chip that powers Montreal subway tickets by Reason077 on Sunday June 23, 2024 @09:40PM (#40772078)
Last time I checked, yes. There’s a machine where you press a button for a free ticket that works the ticket gates.

Unfortunately the days where you could ride the buses for free around the whole Heathrow area are gone, however.

Re:The tiny chip that powers Montreal subway tickets by bboygravity on Sunday June 23, 2024 @02:27PM (#40769465)
The chip is the size of a grain of salt, but there's a relatively huge antenna inside made of conducting material (metal?) and glue and all that.
Re:The tiny chip that powers Montreal subway tickets by gruez on Sunday June 23, 2024 @02:30PM (#40769482)
all of that is probably negligible compared to how much disposable foil is used for cooking or packaging.
Re:The tiny chip that powers Montreal subway tickets by lxgr on Sunday June 23, 2024 @02:38PM (#40769544)
On one hand it is probably small in comparison, but on the other hand, it seems much more feasible to reuse transit ticket ICs than e.g. food packaging.

Many transit agencies do explicitly incentivize reuse, e.g. by offering cheaper fares using a reloadable contactless card and often charging a deposit for that card.

Even then, many of these systems have been struggling due to the IC shortage, given the low margins these single-use tickets have to operate on. In some Asian countries, including Japan and Malaysia, it was tricky to get a new transit card for several months or even years, even though there is a deposit charge.

Re:The tiny chip that powers Montreal subway tickets by idunnoman1222 on Sunday June 23, 2024 @07:39PM (#40771549)
just let people use their phones to open the gate
Re:The tiny chip that powers Montreal subway tickets by ximus on Sunday June 23, 2024 @02:48PM (#40769625)
I don't know about justifying or rationalising waste by pointing to a greater source of waste.
Re:The tiny chip that powers Montreal subway tickets by bboygravity on Tuesday June 25, 2024 @03:25AM (#40785502)
The question is whether it's negligible compared to good old fashioned paper tickets.
Re:The tiny chip that powers Montreal subway tickets by wkat4242 on Sunday June 23, 2024 @02:31PM (#40769491)
Yeah but also the antenna and I wonder how many chemicals are used in the lithography process.
Re:The tiny chip that powers Montreal subway tickets by bobthepanda on Sunday June 23, 2024 @06:09PM (#40771023)
I don’t really see why a chip is needed at all for single use tickets. Those have existed forever and there are a plethora of non-chip options ranging from the simple holepunch to the optical printed barcode or QR code.
Re:The tiny chip that powers Montreal subway tickets by ianburrell on Sunday June 23, 2024 @07:29PM (#40771496)
Because that would require a completely different way to read tickets than are used for stored value cards. Every ticket machine needs way to print which is less reliable than writing NFC chip. It is likely that printing a ticket costs more than NFC. Every fare reader needs two sensors, one NFC and one optical. The optical ones are going to be slower. People are going to get confused about which reader to use.
Re:The tiny chip that powers Montreal subway tickets by bobthepanda on Sunday June 23, 2024 @07:31PM (#40771512)
If people can manage the existence of both an optical scanner and contactless at the self checkout grocery store, this is way overblown.

A ticket needs to be printed anyways, the single use ticket with chip does not come from thin air.

Re:The tiny chip that powers Montreal subway tickets by ianburrell on Sunday June 23, 2024 @07:49PM (#40771584)
But why are you making it worse and more complicated? Disposable NFC card is better, cheaper, and easier to use.

The NFC doesn't need to be printed. It just needs to be dispensed.

My city went from printed paper tickets, that didn't even need to be scanned, to contactless fare system with paper NFC tickets. It saves money having simpler and less used ticket machines. It helps that most people use contactless credit card or fare card. They really should have more signs that can tap phone or credit card cause I suspect tourists think they need to buy ticket.

Re:The tiny chip that powers Montreal subway tickets by rtpg on Sunday June 23, 2024 @08:39PM (#40771831)
throughput, throughput, throughput.

Magstripes tend to work not so well when you have the ticket in your pocket for a couple days, printed codes involve people futzing with cameras. You can use a sort of card ingestion system to line up a QR code or the like... but those things are complicated and break down a lot! You end up needing staff to constantly be opening it and unclogging it. This works alright if you have like 6 turnstiles, less so when you have 2 or 3.

Obviously you can work with those models anyways, and plenty of transportation networks do! But if your rush hour involves moving a million+ people, you really do need this stuff to go fast.

Re:The tiny chip that powers Montreal subway tickets by lxgr on Sunday June 23, 2024 @11:14PM (#40772423)
> Magstripes tend to work not so well when you have the ticket in your pocket for a couple days

How very true... SWIPE CARD AGAIN AT THIS TURNSTILE in glowing turqouise-ish dot matrix letters will be forever etched into my brain long after the Metrocard is finally gone.

Re:The tiny chip that powers Montreal subway tickets by mig39 on Sunday June 23, 2024 @03:26PM (#40769929)
The ones I've used in the Netherlands and Portugal are similar, but can be refilled.

In Portugal, you pay extra for the initial ticket, but subsequent uses are cheaper, because you are using the same physical ticket.

Re:The tiny chip that powers Montreal subway tickets by lxgr on Sunday June 23, 2024 @11:17PM (#40772434)
I've actually always wondered what type of system the Portugese cards use: They don't seem to be based on anything ISO 14443 (or 15693) at least, since they don't react to my phone or external reader at all.
Re:The tiny chip that powers Montreal subway tickets by muxator on Sunday June 23, 2024 @02:20PM (#40769412)
Agreed! In Rome for some time now one can top up his paper NFC ticket; there is no reason to throw it away.
Re:The tiny chip that powers Montreal subway tickets by tzot on Sunday June 23, 2024 @03:24PM (#40769913)
Yep, the ones in Athens can be refilled too.
Re:The tiny chip that powers Montreal subway tickets by kwhitefoot on Sunday June 23, 2024 @02:17PM (#40769390)
Assuming that it doesn't become litter on the street what is the actual impact of such waste?
Re:The tiny chip that powers Montreal subway tickets by Teever on Sunday June 23, 2024 @02:19PM (#40769407)
All of the waste that went into producing it of course.

IC fabrication produces a lot of chemical waste, and I would imagine that these ICs aren't fabbed in a place that has a great track record on pollution.

Re:The tiny chip that powers Montreal subway tickets by kwhitefoot on Monday June 24, 2024 @04:50AM (#40773773)
These devices are so tiny that presumably this is also a tiny part of IC fabrication.

I'm not saying there is none, just trying get an idea of how much of a problem this really is. We also need to consider what impact any alternative solution would have.

What struck me from the description of the system was that it seems that no electronics is really needed at all, a unique QR or barcode would be just as good because the back end system records the use.

But that would require the installation of optical readers in a system that might not have them but does already have NFC readers. Adding those readers would add a considerable amount of e-waste too.

Re:The tiny chip that powers Montreal subway tickets by dheera on Sunday June 23, 2024 @02:33PM (#40769509)
I feel like 99% of people would not benefit from single use public transportation tickets. Even if you are a tourist, if you use public transportation once, there is a high likelihood you will use it multiple more times, in which case it makes sense to get a regular card. Most systems let you return the card and get the deposit back if you'd like.

Personally I collect the cards instead because I have a tendency to revisit cities years into the future. I just wish cities wouldn't make their cards expire so damn quickly. Wuhan's metro is nice, the cards don't expire until 10 years later. But I've found Singapore and Taipei expire within 3 years and you lose your stored money.

I have this "brick" of public transit cards for about 20 cities. It feels powerful. I kind of wish I could just swipe this brick in any city and just go. Unfortunately they all interfere with each other.

Re:The tiny chip that powers Montreal subway tickets by bbarnett on Sunday June 23, 2024 @02:59PM (#40769711)
I don't know how many times I've been in a city for a single day, or part of one, and have zero interest in spending precious minutes finding, buying, and returning a card.

Just let me pay with coins, or a credit card in seconds, with no return work.

Re:The tiny chip that powers Montreal subway tickets by dheera on Sunday June 23, 2024 @05:15PM (#40770626)
I believe Singapore's public transit does support tapping a credit card directly at the gates now, but there's an annoying step of having to register your card in advance on an app before it actually works.

My guess is this might be because on-the-fly credit card authorizations still take too long. Waiting 3 seconds for an EMV contactless verification would seriously hold up the line at rush hour in a country where most people live by public transit.

If I were to guess, the registration is probably what enables them to pre-authorize a credit line and allow you to tap in in a fraction of a second.

Re:The tiny chip that powers Montreal subway tickets by ianburrell on Sunday June 23, 2024 @07:31PM (#40771509)
That is a flaw of Singapore's system. Other places let people use contactless credit cards without any delay.

London has been using contactless for a while.

Re:The tiny chip that powers Montreal subway tickets by kccqzy on Sunday June 23, 2024 @06:36PM (#40771201)
Credit cards do not require online authorization.
Re:The tiny chip that powers Montreal subway tickets by bbarnett on Sunday June 23, 2024 @06:38PM (#40771218)
Interesting, and this hypothesis shows why twmp cards might be preferred.

I have no issue with temp cards, if I can buy them right at the pickup location. I once flew into a place late at night, and only stores had cards to buy, and all were closed.

Duh.

Re:The tiny chip that powers Montreal subway tickets by dheera on Sunday June 23, 2024 @06:44PM (#40771254)
Yeah that's a stupid system and I've seen it in many places. Being asked to go to <some random convenience store> to get the official public transit card, even the dude at the station couldn't sell me one.

The vending machines at every station should be capable of directly vending public transit cards. I think most of the better systems around the world do work that way.

Re:The tiny chip that powers Montreal subway tickets by lxgr on Sunday June 23, 2024 @11:20PM (#40772440)
That's odd. Most open-loop transit payment systems I know give new/unknown cards the benefit of the doubt, and put the card on a block list if it turns out to not be good for the fare that's eventually distributed to all readers.

Are you sure that's true? Their website says otherwise:

> Do I need to sign up for a SimplyGo account to use my contactless bank card for transit? You do not need to sign up for a SimplyGo account to use your contactless bank card for transit.

Re:The tiny chip that powers Montreal subway tickets by dheera on Monday June 24, 2024 @12:40PM (#40778160)
OK, it's confusing, I had seen some other information that suggested app registration was necessary. It seems that it's only necessary if you want to track your journeys which makes sense.
Re:The tiny chip that powers Montreal subway tickets by gsa on Monday June 24, 2024 @03:33AM (#40773377)
> there's an annoying step of having to register your card in advance on an app before it actually works.

Did this change recently? I travelled a little over a year ago and my Wise card worked right after I landed at the Singapore airport.

Re:The tiny chip that powers Montreal subway tickets by mattkrause on Sunday June 23, 2024 @08:32PM (#40771804)
I’m pretty sure that the Montreal paper tickets are non-refillable but can “contain” multiple rides or a pass (weekend, weekly, etc) if you buy them together.

I’d bet a lot of them are sold at the airport: the fare to downtown comes with a 24-hr pass for other buses and metros.

Re:The tiny chip that powers Montreal subway tickets by adolph on Sunday June 23, 2024 @02:06PM (#40769323)
It isn’t different from other anti-counterfeiting measures, the printing just happens to be really small and electrically react to certain frequencies.

Part of the “software eating the world” story is the decreased cost of precision that enabled the hardware substrate of software to be inexpensively and ubiquitously included in any mass produced object.

Re:The tiny chip that powers Montreal subway tickets by ClumsyPilot on Sunday June 23, 2024 @02:37PM (#40769536)
Indeed, I didn’t know what kind of ticket we are talking about - folks please include a picture and some context in your blogs, for people from other places and countries
Re:The tiny chip that powers Montreal subway tickets by kens on Sunday June 23, 2024 @02:58PM (#40769698)
The title says "Montreal" and the second photo in the blog post shows the specific ticket. I'm not sure what else I can do here.
Re:The tiny chip that powers Montreal subway tickets by bobthepanda on Sunday June 23, 2024 @06:14PM (#40771052)
Background information in an article is normally presented first.

Ticket in english sometimes refers to a season or monthly ticket, so it’s pretty ambiguous.

Re:The tiny chip that powers Montreal subway tickets by ClumsyPilot on Monday June 24, 2024 @09:09AM (#40775576)
Photo of the ticket / ticket machine is an obvious thing to include.

Some people live on a different continents and their environment looks completely different. This is giving me same vibes as those ‘probe you are not a robot’ tests that ask you to identify things that are specific to USA’