News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Ask HN: Who has had a successful PWA product? by joshstrange on Wednesday June 19, 2024 @03:12AM (#40725675)
Whenever this argument comes up it reminds me of how detached from reality HN is on this subject.

Customers want apps. Companies want apps. No one except us nerds want PWAs. We can talk about how PWAs are second class citizens and how unfair that is or we can remember that end-users _do not care_ about the underlying technology. We constantly make this mistake, customer don’t care what language you are using, they don’t care what framework you use, they don’t care about native vs web, they just want it to work.

I’ve been developing cross platform mobile apps (web, iOS, native) for around 15 years (Titanium, Cordova, and now Capacitor) and while the lesson has been painful: no one cares about PWAs. I will tell clients “you can go to <website> and see exactly what your app will look like once it’s packaged for the app stores” and they will simply wait for the native app instead. I’ve lost count of the number of times the code has been running on the web for weeks+ and it’s not till it’s in the stores that I get _any_ feedback (things they could have easily seen in the web version but didn’t bother with till it was an “app”).

You can complain about this, you can talk about how unfair it is, you can extol the virtues of PWAs but at the end of the day it just doesn’t matter. Customers have spoken, they want apps. I launched my current company as a website/PWA and all I got was a lot of heartache: “I can’t find it in the App Store”. Not a single person said “thank you for making this a website”. In fact, I get 1-2 complaints (from thousands of users) of “I don’t want to download an app” to which I tell them “you don’t have to, the website spells this out very clearly, you can use the website and/or save it to your home screen, no app install needed”. I tell that story to illustrate how few people even say they care, but also can’t grok that they don’t need to install an app. That “1-2” pales in comparison to the people who complained about it not being a “real app”.

So if you want to fight against native apps be my guest but you’re fighting a battle that customers do not care about (I cannot stress enough that: HN != normal customers) and they will not thank you for. Yes, the 15-30% “tax” can suck but 15% of $X is better than 0% of $Y. You will simply miss out on a large number of customers if you refuse to make an app.

No customer has ever cared if you use spaces or tabs internally and they don’t care if you provide a PWA, they just want open their platform’s App Store and search for your app. The ship has sailed on this topic and you can complain about it or you can live in reality and go to where your customers are, the app stores.

You can say this isn’t fair but as my dad used to say: the fair comes once a year and if you miss it, it’s your own damn fault.

Re:Ask HN: Who has had a successful PWA product? by throwaway9143 on Wednesday June 19, 2024 @03:39AM (#40725838)
"customer don't care what language/framework you are using" is a strange way to support a claim they do care about having a native app over a PWA. The first statement highlights that the user just wants something that works as advertised, and doesn't care about the framework. But the second statement highlights that, despite their disinterest in the technology, they care deeply about the app's delivery tech (PWAs vs native). I think this juxtaposition reveals a lot about why things are the way they are, and why users are forced to care about native apps over PWAs.

Just like language is a vehicle for logic, the app delivery tech is just a vehicle for a UI. PWA tech sucks because platforms are incentivized to make it suck. People prefer native apps because they're being funnelled down that path by anti-competitive interests. You don't seem to make that connection.

I get it, you were burned by PWAs and now you just want to build something that works for everyone relatively painlessly and makes money. Nothing wrong with that. But some of us also want support tech that fulfills the goals of the open web. You don't seem to care about that, but others do. Telling everyone its basically a lost cause is a silly and pointless endeavor, because PWAs are the long game, and you're playing the short game.

Re:Ask HN: Who has had a successful PWA product? by lynx23 on Wednesday June 19, 2024 @03:56AM (#40725941)
I have a different take. As a person reliant on accessibility, PWAs almost always deliver a worse experience for me. So after a while, I learnt to prefer native apps, simply because PWAs typically deliver a worse UX for me.
Re:Ask HN: Who has had a successful PWA product? by throwaway9143 on Wednesday June 19, 2024 @03:59AM (#40725956)
That's interesting. In what way is a PWA worse than a website wrt accessibility? I understand that you are comparing PWAs to native apps, but presumably you have a fine time with normal websites? PWAs shouldn't be any different.
Re:Ask HN: Who has had a successful PWA product? by lynx23 on Thursday June 20, 2024 @01:18AM (#40735160)
Haha, nice suggestive questioning, but I am not falling for it. Your base assumtion is wrong, websites are not nice and dandy, its more like throwing dice to see if you're happy or not. In fact, the more "progressive" a website is, the less likely it is accessible.. If it is nominally accessible, its often not comfortable to use.
Re:Ask HN: Who has had a successful PWA product? by iudqnolq on Wednesday June 19, 2024 @06:54AM (#40727007)
The user doesn't care about the delivery tech. They care about the installation and usage experience. They want to go search the app store, click the button, and get an icon on their homescreen.
Re:Ask HN: Who has had a successful PWA product? by Turing_Machine on Wednesday June 19, 2024 @11:25AM (#40729156)
How is requiring the user to open a completely different application a better "user experience" than installing it from the web page they're already on?

Yes, I know that installing a PWA is confusing (especially on Apple's systems), but there no reason it has to be that way.

PWA (if it were implemented properly): "Click here to install app". Click. Confirmation dialog. App is installed. App opens in the same window.

App store: "Click here to install app". Click. An entirely different application opens. Confirmation dialog. App is installed. You open it, but now you're in a different context.

Re:Ask HN: Who has had a successful PWA product? by throwaway9143 on Wednesday June 19, 2024 @12:12PM (#40729615)
Bingo. Defenders of the app store have severe stockholm syndrome. Apple ruins the PWA experience intentionally, so they blame people who use PWAs, instead of Apple.
Re:Ask HN: Who has had a successful PWA product? by meiraleal on Wednesday June 19, 2024 @12:27PM (#40729785)
PWA has no marketing budget and a lot of people invested on private app stores attacking it.
Re:Ask HN: Who has had a successful PWA product? by jmb99 on Wednesday June 19, 2024 @01:13PM (#40730215)
> PWA (if it were implemented properly): "Click here to install app". Click. Confirmation dialog. App is installed. App opens in the same window.

> App store: "Click here to install app". Click. An entirely different application opens. Confirmation dialog. App is installed. You open it, but now you're in a different context.

You’re unfortunately oversimplifying the PWA installation. Say a user has heard of a new service called “Florb” which has a PWA and a native app. To install natively:

1. Open the App Store

2. Tap the search button (optional, might already be selected)

3. Search “Florb”

4. Tap Get

5. Confirm download

For the PWA:

1. Open Safari

2. Search for Florb using your chosen search engine

3. Open Florb homepage

4. Tap “share”

5. Hunt and scroll for “Add to Home Screen”

6. Tap “Add to Home Screen”

7. Give the app a name

8. Tap Add

This is ignoring the possibility that searching Florb returns other sites first (maybe news articles about the neat service, or a wiki page), nor that there are usually enough ads on google pages to completely obscure the first real results from the screen on page load. Yes, the App Store also shows an ad, and it’s possible for other similarly named apps to appear first in the list, but it’s generally less of a problem than relying on google searches.

Even ignoring the fact that the average user doesn’t know or care that PWAs exist, the first option is simply easier and more reliable. There’s no getting around that. And that’s also ignoring that PWAs are, to an average user, “installing a website” rather than “installing an app,” which just feels wrong.

“Add to Home Screen” has been available on iOS since at least iOS 4 (that’s the first time I remember seeing it, but it may have been around longer). If people don’t care about it yet, I have a hard time believing they will any time soon unless it is substantially and objectively better than the App Store.

Re:Ask HN: Who has had a successful PWA product? by mvdtnz on Wednesday June 19, 2024 @07:01PM (#40733311)
This is an idiotic way of breaking it down. How does the user even know Florb exists? They're already on the web at this stage. You're also being totally disingenuous with your break down. Why does the user have to "hunt and scroll" for the app on the PWA side but not the app store? Go ahead, search for "fastmail" on your Android app store and tell me what the first and most prominent result is.

And when I click "add to home" in my browser's menu I don't need to name the app. The app has a name. What are you talking about?

Re:Ask HN: Who has had a successful PWA product? by neoberg on Friday June 21, 2024 @05:30AM (#40747797)
They can hear it from a TV/radio ad, they can see it on a billboard, they can hear it from a friend. Exploring that an app exists doesn't happen only on the product website.
Re:Ask HN: Who has had a successful PWA product? by Turing_Machine on Wednesday June 19, 2024 @07:07PM (#40733351)
> 4. Tap “share”

> 5. Hunt and scroll for “Add to Home Screen”

> 6. Tap “Add to Home Screen”

>7. Give the app a name

> 8. Tap Add

None of this is essential except maybe 8.

That is why I said "if implemented properly". In specific,

> Yes, I know that installing a PWA is confusing (especially on Apple's systems), but there no reason it has to be that way.

> PWA (if it were implemented properly):...

You're also pretending there aren't a bunch of junk/garbage/spam/ripped off apps in the App Store with names similar to the real app.

I assure you that is not the case.

Re:Ask HN: Who has had a successful PWA product? by nailer on Wednesday June 19, 2024 @08:10PM (#40733641)
> How is requiring the user to open a completely different application a better "user experience" than installing it from the web page they're already on?

Because it is strange and different. If Web apps were standard going to the iOS App Store would be weird. It’s not so PWAs are weird. Just give them an app, don’t make them work to install it.

Re:Ask HN: Who has had a successful PWA product? by joshstrange on Wednesday June 19, 2024 @07:49AM (#40727351)
> But some of us also want support tech that fulfills the goals of the open web. You don't seem to care about that, but others do. Telling everyone its basically a lost cause is a silly and pointless endeavor, because PWAs are the long game, and you're playing the short game.

Get off the cross, we could use the wood.

Spare me. I love the web, in fact all my “apps” are built with web tech and I offer them all as websites/PWAs in addition to apps but standing on principals of only using the web as some kind of middle finger to the app stores AND your customers is just silly.

So I bite the bullet and wrap my web apps in a thin wrapper and shove them into the App Store. You can call it principles but I just call it stubborn and dragging your customers into a crusade they don’t care about.

At the end of the day I care about the customers of my products more than I care about trying to wage a losing war against something they actively want, apps from stores.

Life is way too short to tie up your identity in things like this. I want to spend my time making products people enjoy using. If you actually care so much about PWAs then stop writing PWAs that your users hate using and go be a full time advocate for that instead. Right now shipping PWAs is a worse experience so the only one you hurt is yourself and your customers when you double down on them.

Re:Ask HN: Who has had a successful PWA product? by meiraleal on Wednesday June 19, 2024 @08:25AM (#40727600)
Are you ok?

Your hate for PWAs seems a bit excessive. Nowadays it's possible to build binaries for iOS and Android using PWAs and it'll behave just live your Cordova projects. Don't be stuck in the past.

Re:Ask HN: Who has had a successful PWA product? by joshstrange on Wednesday June 19, 2024 @08:37AM (#40727681)
Please read my full comment:

> I love the web, in fact all my “apps” are built with web tech and I offer them all as websites/PWAs

I'm well aware you can build binaries and ship a PWA, I literally do that. I don't hate PWAs, I dislike people that refuse to ship anything but PWAs and I especially dislike being told I don't care about the "open web".

If you want to be a martyr and _only_ ship PWAs be my guest but pretending it's noble is just silly and drags your customers (you know, the people you should actually care about) into a battle they don't give 2 shits about all while making their experience worse.

[dead]
Re:Ask HN: Who has had a successful PWA product? by dang on Thursday June 20, 2024 @11:19PM (#40745801)
Please don't cross into personal attack on HN.

https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html

Re:Ask HN: Who has had a successful PWA product? by throwaway9143 on Wednesday June 19, 2024 @09:14AM (#40727999)
>I dislike people that refuse to ship anything but PWAs

What a weird thing to get all bent out of shape over. People do things a different way than you, get over it. If someone wants to only ship PWAs, why does that bother you so much? Because they're hurting users, and you're trying to protect them?

Re:Ask HN: Who has had a successful PWA product? by mardifoufs on Wednesday June 19, 2024 @11:16AM (#40729087)
Yes, if so he's right. PWAs are a bad experience for the user or at least a worse one than even just a webapp wrapped in a native app, regardless of the reasons. I've never had a pwa not feel like a hanky browser tab, and this is on android.
Re:Ask HN: Who has had a successful PWA product? by throwaway9143 on Wednesday June 19, 2024 @12:18PM (#40729681)
Yeah but nobody here is making the case that PWAs are better than native apps. The point is that PWAs are worth getting better support because it's better for everyone.
Re:Ask HN: Who has had a successful PWA product? by throwaway9143 on Wednesday June 19, 2024 @09:46AM (#40728244)
>If you actually care so much about PWAs then stop writing PWAs that your users hate using and go be a full time advocate for that instead.

I do care about PWAs, and so I am advocating, right now. I don't know why you come across as so angry about people who advocate for PWAs. Pushing companies to adhere to open web standards is a good thing, otherwise we'd still be stuck in IE6 world.

Re:Ask HN: Who has had a successful PWA product? by jmb99 on Wednesday June 19, 2024 @01:20PM (#40730293)
It doesn’t count as advocating is your audience is only people who (in general) agree with you. I don’t think anyone on hackernews wants PWAs to be a worse experience, but they are. If you want to make a difference, you’re not gonna make it here.

“Preaching to the choir” comes to mind.

Re:Ask HN: Who has had a successful PWA product? by throwaway9143 on Wednesday June 19, 2024 @02:26PM (#40731026)
>If you want to make a difference, you’re not gonna make it here.

I'm replying to the people who disagree with me here, and there are several. The readers who are on the fence can make up their own mind. Your discouragement is not necessary or useful.

Re:Ask HN: Who has had a successful PWA product? by JimDabell on Wednesday June 19, 2024 @04:09AM (#40726005)
> Customers want apps. Companies want apps. No one except us nerds want PWAs.

I used to work on a platform that offered native iOS apps, native Android apps, and PWA / web apps for all our customers. When users were given the choice, around two thirds opted for the native iOS app, about a quarter opted for the native Android app, and about 10% opted for the PWA / web app. That’s including desktop users, not just mobile.

Users want native apps.

Re:Ask HN: Who has had a successful PWA product? by KingMob on Wednesday June 19, 2024 @05:45AM (#40726613)
More likely, users want something that works, is a good experience, and don't care about apps _per se_ at all.

If Apple wasn't hamstringing PWAs, they might be viable for more categories of software.

Re:Ask HN: Who has had a successful PWA product? by scarface_74 on Wednesday June 19, 2024 @07:38AM (#40727273)
And if you are creating an app, most of the time you want a web page too for PCs. If it’s only Apple, then why don’t companies just build a PWA for PC users and Android users and only write an app for iOS users?
Re:Ask HN: Who has had a successful PWA product? by mdhb on Wednesday June 19, 2024 @06:36AM (#40726903)
Last time I engaged with this user you’re replying to was hands down one of the least intelligent conversations I’ve had all year. He is an absolutely dyed in the wool Apple fan boy and will defend them to the death no matter how legitimate the criticism.
Re:Ask HN: Who has had a successful PWA product? by lostfocus on Wednesday June 19, 2024 @03:38AM (#40725836)
That's why there are efforts to get platform companies to allow putting PWAs into their app stores. I think on Android it's already possible with a thin wrapper and with regulatory pressure it might be necessary for other platforms to enable that as well.
Re:Ask HN: Who has had a successful PWA product? by joshstrange on Wednesday June 19, 2024 @07:52AM (#40727371)
You can put PWAs in all the app stores today with a thin wrapper, I know, I do it for all my apps.
Re:Ask HN: Who has had a successful PWA product? by goosejuice on Wednesday June 19, 2024 @10:31AM (#40728668)
What is your preferred method of wrapping? No resistance from Apple? I've read of many instances of wrapped PWAs not getting approved for the app store. I guess mileage may vary
Re:Ask HN: Who has had a successful PWA product? by joshstrange on Wednesday June 19, 2024 @10:36AM (#40728712)
I use Capacitor (via Quasar, though you will only want to use this if you use Vue and like Quasar, else maybe look into Ionic if you sue React or Angular). If you don't use a framework or don't want to use Quasar/Ionic then you can use Capacitor "raw" but I've not done that before.
Re:Ask HN: Who has had a successful PWA product? by goosejuice on Saturday June 22, 2024 @09:34PM (#40763883)
Thanks. I was considering Capacitor. It looked a bit heavy. Really dreading this process to be honest. I'm hoping we can convert the majority iOS users to installing the PWA and have that hold long enough to either go native or better PWA support on iOS. Not holding my breath for the latter.
Re:Ask HN: Who has had a successful PWA product? by its-all-waves on Wednesday June 19, 2024 @10:31AM (#40728675)
Not for Apple/iOS!
Re:Ask HN: Who has had a successful PWA product? by joshstrange on Wednesday June 19, 2024 @10:34AM (#40728698)
I have over 10 apps in the Apple App Store store using Capacitor without any issues.
Re:Ask HN: Who has had a successful PWA product? by KingMob on Wednesday June 19, 2024 @05:49AM (#40726629)
You talk a lot about what customers want, but they want apps only because Apple makes PWAs so unpleasant. There are some tech limitations (games might be tougher), but most of what makes PWAs suck is Apple.

In another timeline, Apple chose to double-down on PWAs instead of the App Store after the iphone 1, and PWAs are the majority of non-performance-sensitive smartphone applications.

Re:Ask HN: Who has had a successful PWA product? by scarface_74 on Wednesday June 19, 2024 @07:35AM (#40727258)
Every single “write once run everywhere” technology has sucked compared to native apps.

Developers complained when the first iPhone came out and when Steve Jobs called web apps a “sweet solution”. Even Gruber called the solution a “shit sandwich”.

If it’s only Apple holding PWAs back, then why do most of the same companies write Android apps instead of just producing PWAs that work on PCs and Android devices?

Re:Ask HN: Who has had a successful PWA product? by KingMob on Monday July 01, 2024 @06:36AM (#40844430)
> If it’s only Apple holding PWAs back, then why do most of the same companies write Android apps instead of just producing PWAs that work on PCs and Android devices?

Google followed Apple's lead, so it's not like they have a choice.

And in case you haven't noticed, those same companies are happy to accept the performance hit of cross-phone libraries in order to not develop an app twice. If the PWA experience were better, they'd probably try that instead.

Most apps are boring, and don't require native performance.

Re:Ask HN: Who has had a successful PWA product? by iknowstuff on Wednesday June 19, 2024 @06:26AM (#40726837)
Tell that to users of https://sniffies.com nsfw

Can’t have that on the app store.

Re:Ask HN: Who has had a successful PWA product? by joshstrange on Wednesday June 19, 2024 @07:39AM (#40727287)
That’s not a good example, I’ll bet 99% of users of that website couldn’t tell you it’s a PWA or what a PWA is. All they know is that the only way to get this “app” is add it to the home screen and if it was allowed in the App Store they’d all get it from there instead.

That’s not customers choosing PWA over native, it’s customers forced to use PWA since native isn’t an option.

Re:Ask HN: Who has had a successful PWA product? by iknowstuff on Wednesday June 19, 2024 @03:25PM (#40731566)
Yeah, we don’t disagree on that. It just seems that for end users prudish app stores are the only option for procuring apps.
Re:Ask HN: Who has had a successful PWA product? by JoeyJoJoJr on Wednesday June 19, 2024 @06:27AM (#40726844)
Users also have their favourite messaging apps and services, completely oblivious to the fact that it’s actually completely stupid that there is basically no interoperability between these apps and services. Imagine if Yahoo mail could never send emails to Hotmail or Gmail.

People in the know rightfully care about the erosion of standards for which big tech have built their empires upon.

Re:Ask HN: Who has had a successful PWA product? by scarface_74 on Wednesday June 19, 2024 @07:31AM (#40727241)
How do you make messaging apps inoperable and guarantee end to end encryption? How do you add features to your messaging app without having to wait years for a standard body?
Re:Ask HN: Who has had a successful PWA product? by postalrat on Wednesday June 19, 2024 @12:42PM (#40729915)
Are you using a hackernews app to use hackernews?
Re:Ask HN: Who has had a successful PWA product? by joshstrange on Wednesday June 19, 2024 @12:45PM (#40729951)
On my phone? Yes, a combo of Octal and HACK, but I often fall back to the web since the apps don't expose everything.

On my computer I always use the web. I prefer the web on my computer but on my phone apps can provide a nicer experience (larger touch targets, swipe gestures, etc). But in general I find the phone (and tablet) limiting and if I need to do any actual "research" I immediately move to my computer where I can open multiple tabs and move between them easier.