News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Take my money, HBO by trotsky on Tuesday June 05, 2012 @11:13PM (#4072214)
I worked on several commercial digital music projects in the time span between early napster and entrenched itunes. One regularly repeated meme of the era was that people didn't want to pirate music, they just wanted it "as easy" or "no drm" or "ala carte" or "all you can eat".

While statistically these were all guaranteed to be true for at least some users, in aggregate they were red herrings. The industry was in the process of significant decline due at least in part to online infringement. Over the course of several years mainstream services that more or less broke down all these barriers appeared but they failed to reverse any of the macro trends.

While many of the reasons are nuanced and disputed, a number of observations are relatively uncontested. Online sales severely cannibalized physical sales but failed to significantly cut down on online infringement. ASP dropped much faster than production and distribution costs. New, powerful intermediaries formed that dictated sales practices to the labels instead of the other way around.

Anecdotally, among friends and colleagues no one I knew significantly shifted their behavior. Everyone bought at least some music, and I don't think I knew anyone who refused to touch anything pirated. 12+ years on that really hasn't changed much, I still get emailed songs from rights holders or people who sell music and my friends with shared raid 5 arrays with all_the_music still buy downloads from their favorite bands.

The thing that did change is the reasons for piracy. Instead of the previous concerns people were now unwilling to support the majors, or wanted higher quality encodes, or simply thought that IP sales were outdated and believed that music acts should shift to solely making their money through touring and merchandise sales.

Whether these are reasonable new barriers or not I'm not at all interested in debating. I've thought many of them were compelling at various times. Rather what I think is interesting is that some number of objections always seem to exist.

There was an interview with a researcher on NPR yesterday that I caught. The discussion was on cheating (on things like taxes, etc.) and how in controlled settings almost all of us are small time cheats but few of us are huge cheats. The researcher attributed a key part of this to the idea that we all want to be the good guy - and that cheating within a tolerance allowed us to continue to view ourselves that way, but cheating too much made it hard for us to view ourselves that way.

While he didn't make any connection to reasons or extenuating circumstances, it seemed to jibe well with my own unscholarly impressions. That many of the reasons for intellectual property theft are constructed to allow a person to continue to see themselves as the good guy while doing something they consider immoral.

"Well, I want to pay them, but [barrier X] won't let me" is almost the perfect storm of this type of mental construct - pretty much unassailable, at least until barrier X is removed.

Re:Take my money, HBO by burke on Tuesday June 05, 2012 @11:23PM (#4072240)
I'm only one data point, but:

I used to pirate (all of my) music. I have bought a grand total of one CD ever. Now I happily consume most of my music through a paid subscription to Rdio.

Similarly, I pay for netflix. I (grudgingly) go to theatres occasionally. I don't own and have no desire to own a dvd player, and pirate movies occasionally when they're not conveniently available.

Similarly, I pirate Game of Thrones, but would happily pay up to $5 per episode if it were an option. I will not buy the DVDs, as I have no desire to see it again. If I could buy the DVDs at the same time as the show airs (without getting off my couch), I would happily do so.

It is quite literally all about convenience for some people.

Re:Take my money, HBO by peeters on Wednesday June 06, 2012 @12:47AM (#4072461)
> Similarly, I pirate Game of Thrones, but would happily pay up to $5 per episode if it were an option. I will not buy the DVDs, as I have no desire to see it again. If I could buy the DVDs at the same time as the show airs (without getting off my couch), I would happily do so.

How about when you pirate the episode, you put the $5 aside, and when it's released on DVD, buy the DVDs, regardless of whether you want to watch it again? This has essentially the same result as buying the DVD "at the same time as the show airs".

This is what I have done with shows that are cable-exclusive. And as a perk, I end up with the DVDs.

Re:Take my money, HBO by egypturnash on Wednesday June 06, 2012 @02:09AM (#4072642)
Having stuff you don't want cluttering up your life is a perk?
Re:Take my money, HBO by AjithAntony on Wednesday June 06, 2012 @02:58AM (#4072724)
Then donate the discs to someone who likes to collect physical media.
Re:Take my money, HBO by stevetursi on Wednesday June 06, 2012 @09:30AM (#4073684)
Assuming the pirate bought the disc as a penance/feelgood/whatever for downloading the media, this totally negates that whole motivation. To the studio/network, two people got to see the content for the price of one. Ironically, the giftee becomes the beneficiary of the piracy, but with none of the risk. And the pirate, who assumed all the risk, was the person who paid for it.
Re:Take my money, HBO by icebraining on Wednesday June 06, 2012 @08:26AM (#4073347)
Therefore promoting the DVD business instead of incentively them to move to digital distribution.

This is why we can't have nice things.

Re:Take my money, HBO by scott_s on Tuesday June 05, 2012 @11:47PM (#4072301)
Re:Take my money, HBO by pretz on Tuesday June 05, 2012 @11:53PM (#4072321)
Key phrase in OP: "at the same time as the show airs"
Re:Take my money, HBO by waterlesscloud on Wednesday June 06, 2012 @01:37AM (#4072580)
Strangely, I find I'm capable of waiting a few months.
Re:Take my money, HBO by masklinn on Wednesday June 06, 2012 @02:23AM (#4072666)
Sure, why not, or waiting for ever and not watching it at all.

Issues: the marketing blitz and news don't wait for a few months, and the various communities around the show don't wait either, "waiting for a few months" means ignoring the marketing blitz (easy), deftly skipping all news of the show to avoid spoilers (annoying), being completely split from any possible community built around the show (annoying, and often a significant loss) and finally avoiding significant interactions with colleagues who watch the show, because they probably won't remember that you're not watching it yet when discussing the episode which just eared (downright shitty).

Meanwhile pirating the episode has none of these drawbacks, it's available hours after the broadcast on every country on the planet in high quality.

Re:Take my money, HBO by zecho on Wednesday June 06, 2012 @11:45AM (#4074473)
One minor correction for you. It's rare that a popular show is available hours after the original broadcast. Usually a few minutes and sometimes before the show even airs on the west coast.
Re:Take my money, HBO by masklinn on Wednesday June 06, 2012 @04:22PM (#4075990)
It is available a few minutes after the show airs, but usually not in a very high quality. And I did qualify my notes with that.
Re:Take my money, HBO by waterlesscloud on Wednesday June 06, 2012 @02:35AM (#4072682)
OK, seriously? Watercooler discussion is the rationale now? That's a reason to take money from the pockets from the 1000s of people who worked months or years to make something you like?

Really?

Re:Take my money, HBO by masklinn on Wednesday June 06, 2012 @04:24AM (#4072872)
> Watercooler discussion is the rationale now?

No, it's an argument. And it's got nothing to do with "watercooler discussions", people can talk without involving you, people can talk at the bar, people will talk, art is not just a personal experience it's also a social one and the social part is actually important — hell, there are a number of cases where it's fundamental.

It's especially the case for TV series (with significant and/or cult followings) as they become shared/group cultural artefacts and values and a significant section of social interaction.

> That's a reason to take money from the pockets from the 1000s of people who worked months or years to make something you like?

No, but I should not be surprised by your mis-representation since you seem to have no interest in discussing this.

It's a reason why "waiting a few months" is not an acceptable alternative.

And by the way, pirating does not "take money from the pockets of [people]" any more than not watching at all does. That doesn't even remotely make sense.

Re:Take my money, HBO by waterlesscloud on Wednesday June 06, 2012 @04:31AM (#4072878)
So you want the experience without compensating the people who made the experience possible.

It's entirely possible to compensate them if the experience is valuable to you. Not doing so is wrong. Sorry, but that's how I see it.

Re:Take my money, HBO by masklinn on Wednesday June 06, 2012 @07:26AM (#4073217)
> So you want the experience without compensating the people who made the experience possible.

No. But yet again you're intent on strawmanning your way to feeling good about yourself, so I'm just going to stop this worthless "interaction".

> Not doing so is wrong. Sorry, but that's how I see it.

Sure, and you're free to do so, but — again — this has no relation to "tak[ing] money from the pockets [of people]".

Re:Take my money, HBO by gizzlon on Wednesday June 06, 2012 @06:40AM (#4073109)
What if you download it and then buy it later.. what would you call that?
Re:Take my money, HBO by goostavos on Wednesday June 06, 2012 @12:15PM (#4074620)
I do this with movies sometimes. I don't always feel like watching things in my crappy local theater, so I'll buy a ticket online, and then torrent the film.

Still illegal, but.. my conscience is at least clear.

Re:Take my money, HBO by waterlesscloud on Wednesday June 06, 2012 @09:28AM (#4073664)
That would be fine, since you compensated the people who made the experience possible, as they have very clearly asked you to do.

No offense, but this stuff is not a complicated moral dilemma by any means.

Re:Take my money, HBO by gizzlon on Wednesday June 06, 2012 @10:09AM (#4073885)
But between the download and the buy there's just a "promise" to buy. Would this make it just as illegal (or illegal) as just downloading it?

"No offense, but this stuff is not a complicated moral dilemma by any means"

Well, I agree to some extend, but moral != law.

Re:Take my money, HBO by algorias on Wednesday June 06, 2012 @03:01AM (#4072732)
Well it is definitely a reason why the alternative offered isn't a good one. lots of things people do have "silly" social reasons, so don't dismiss those factors out of hand. Also, "taking money from the pockets of others" is an incredibly biased way to frame the discussion, and doesn't help at all.
Re:Take my money, HBO by waterlesscloud on Wednesday June 06, 2012 @03:04AM (#4072736)
In what way is money not being taken from the pockets of others?

The rationale that someone wouldn't buy it anyway doesn't hold when the argument is that they want it so much they can't wait for it.

Re:Take my money, HBO by algorias on Wednesday June 06, 2012 @04:33AM (#4072882)
Economically speaking there is no difference between losing money and not making money, but socially there's a clear distinction. You're not automatically indebted to someone just because they built something you want. No value is lost when a digital good is duplicated. The only thing lost in this case is an opportunity.

>The rationale that someone wouldn't buy it anyway doesn't hold when the argument is that they want it so much they can't wait for it.

The point is that customers wouldn't buy the show under the conditions it's currently offered to them anyway.

Re:Take my money, HBO by waterlesscloud on Wednesday June 06, 2012 @05:17AM (#4072943)
" No value is lost when a digital good is duplicated. The only thing lost in this case is an opportunity."

I know this is a popular justification for piracy, but surely you can see that a lost opportunity is in fact lost value.

Re:Take my money, HBO by masklinn on Wednesday June 06, 2012 @07:28AM (#4073227)
> a lost opportunity is in fact lost value.

I know this is a popular justification for curtailing liberties, but surely you can see that this makes no actual sense.

Re:Take my money, HBO by waterlesscloud on Wednesday June 06, 2012 @09:25AM (#4073649)
So now it's "curtailing liberties" to ask someone to pay for value they are provided.

Right.

Re:Take my money, HBO by masklinn on Wednesday June 06, 2012 @02:33PM (#4075364)
You seem to have no issue ascribing ideas they have never written to people who reply to your comments. I therefore assume (and assumed) you are in full and complete agreement with the various *AA over the handling of piracy. Including but not limited to rights-restriction, network monitoring, traffic shaping and mass legal threats.

Also, your comment was idiotic and I was spinning it the other way 'round to demonstrate this.

Re:Take my money, HBO by waterlesscloud on Wednesday June 06, 2012 @03:28PM (#4075675)
Your assumptions are completely incorrect. I support none of those things.

I do support content creators being compensated in the manner and amounts they choose to ask.

These are different things.

Re:Take my money, HBO by burke on Wednesday June 06, 2012 @04:06AM (#4072850)
"In what way is money not being taken from the pockets of others?"

In the way that they are taking money out of their own pockets by not catering to this sizeable crowd.

Intellectual Property does not fit neatly into our existing socio-economic framework. This is one of the areas where that really shows.

Re:Take my money, HBO by waterlesscloud on Wednesday June 06, 2012 @05:13AM (#4072938)
I'd have more sympathy for this line of argument if I wasn't currently watching season 1 of Game Of Thrones.

When it aired, sure I wanted to see it. People I know were talking about it. But I didn't want to pay what it cost to see it then.

So you know what choice I made? I waited.

And now it's available in a format I want at a price I'm willing to pay. So I paid and I'm enjoying it.

And, in a development that would evidently be quite shocking to some in this thread, I'm finding that I have plenty of people to talk to about it.

Look. I would love it if they made the show available online the next day, like Mad Men does. I think they're mistaken not to do so. I think they'd make more money if they did.

But they don't.

So I wait.

Re:Take my money, HBO by Shivetya on Wednesday June 06, 2012 @08:42AM (#4073415)
Well I watched it at a friends who had it copied on his DVR. Does that make me a pirate? I was given a copy by another friend who did copy if off a DVR. I do have the blu-ray version of season one as well.

I will be watching season two without ever paying for HBO, again I am watching it via a DVR. How is my watching it on someone's DVR not the same as downloading it and watching it? In neither case did I pay for it, someone else did in both.

The true issue is that HBO sees more money at risk than they see to gain.

Re:Take my money, HBO by acdha on Wednesday June 06, 2012 @07:33AM (#4073239)
Suppose instead his solution was to find a buddy with HBO and watch the show together. Would you still say money is being taken, despite the 100% legality of this approach? If not, why?
Re:Take my money, HBO by waterlesscloud on Wednesday June 06, 2012 @09:24AM (#4073641)
Because someone paid for it, and more than one person watching at one location is factored into the price.
Re:Take my money, HBO by barrkel on Wednesday June 06, 2012 @03:38AM (#4072807)
One of the biggest reasons for art existing at all - before it was ever about money - is as a social object, something to be talked about.
Re:Take my money, HBO by antihero on Wednesday June 06, 2012 @07:26AM (#4073219)
It's a rational. Remember, we're not looking for excuses, we're looking for reasons.
Re:Take my money, HBO by dagw on Wednesday June 06, 2012 @02:36AM (#4072683)
For many people TV-shows are a shared cultural event. Discussing the show is at least as big a part of the experience as watching it. Remove the shared experience and the show loses much of its total value.
Re:Take my money, HBO by etherealHN on Tuesday June 05, 2012 @11:58PM (#4072339)
I still pirate all of my music, but I give money to and promote artists that I listen to.

Rdio, Spotify, and other 'legal' solutions give pathetic amounts of money to the artist. I'd rather have a copy of the music in whatever format I want, on whatever device I want, played with whatever software I want, and spend a little extra time figuring out how to compensate the artist fairly for their contribution to my human happiness.

Re:Take my money, HBO by Atrus6 on Wednesday June 06, 2012 @01:07PM (#4074894)
https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4074288

Your logic works if you only are going to listen to a song a few times, but after a certain threshold, the artist would receive more money than from a CD or iTunes purchase.

Re:Take my money, HBO by falling on Tuesday June 05, 2012 @11:40PM (#4072285)
I also pay an Rdio subscription and enjoy it, but I still buy the records I find myself listening more often.

My reason is simply this: http://www.informationisbeautiful.net/2010/how-much-do-music...

Re:Take my money, HBO by cgmorton on Wednesday June 06, 2012 @11:16AM (#4074288)
Okay lets do some simple math on this.

If I buy a song off iTunes, the artist gets $.09

Every time I listen to it on Rhapsody, they get $.0022

Some quick division: .09/.0022 = ~41

What this means is that, if I've listened to a song less than 40 times, the artist makes more if I buy it off iTunes. But once I've listened to it 41 times or more, the artist is making more profit if all those listens were on Rhapsody.

Now I don't know about you, but when it comes to songs I like I listen to them a hell of a lot more than 40 times. You say you buy the records you find yourself listening to more often? Then you are taking money out of the artists' pockets, because every 40 listens through the album on Rhapsody is equivalent to buying the album anew on iTunes.

To make it even more lopsided, consider just how many times more you would listen to those songs throughout your lifetime. Buy the CD once, and the artist will never see another cent from you, whereas the streaming services continue to pay them, forever.

Re:Take my money, HBO by falling on Wednesday June 06, 2012 @01:09PM (#4074908)
Despite the irritating and condescending tone, that’s a good argument.
Re:Take my money, HBO by mseebach on Wednesday June 06, 2012 @07:35AM (#4073244)
While Rdio and Spotify has some wrinkles to iron out, that chart is simply lying with pretty colours. Full album != single track != single play.
Re:Take my money, HBO by falling on Wednesday June 06, 2012 @10:37AM (#4074060)
do you have better sources? it seems simple math to me. I have also seen a few articles from artists (not record companies) that say the same thing. if you have proof of the contrary it would make me feel better.
Re:Take my money, HBO by mratzloff on Wednesday June 06, 2012 @09:27AM (#4073658)
Ultimately, the best solution for audiences and companies is to simulcast the episode on TV and online. If you're a paid subscriber you can watch it for no additional charge; otherwise, the cost is $3 (or whatever).
Re:Take my money, HBO by vibrunazo on Wednesday June 06, 2012 @01:04AM (#4072497)
Why do humans are always trying to oversimplify that which is already simple? People choose to pirate because their impression is that the pros (easier, no drm, cheaper) outweigh the cons (risk of getting caught, risk of all art ceasing to exist). That's all, just a simple pros vs cons we all quickly do for every decision we ever do in our lives.

No need to try to find cheap pseudo-psychological explanation to why people cheat just so you can justify why you feel comfortable calling piracy "theft". It is what it is, trying to oversimplify the simple with pre-made labels, will just end up making the simple look complicated (as your explanation) for no good reason. Because your oversimplification is throwing variables away, you end up having to make stuff up to explain the gaps, which will always be an imprecise bandage. Which will have more gaps, and need more bandage. So you end up with these Frankenstein hypothesis that won't get you anywhere. All of this mess can be easily avoided if you accept people pirate simply because the pros outweigh the cons.

Now I'll just go back to building a solution instead of whining.

Re:Take my money, HBO by masklinn on Wednesday June 06, 2012 @02:26AM (#4072668)
> risk of all art ceasing to exist

That isn't even a remotely realistic worry. Humans have been creating art and "giving it away" ever since they've been humans. There is a risk that more "expensive" art will stop being funded (though even that is a stretch right now), but there is no possible realistic threat that art will cease to exist short of a mass extinction.

Re:Take my money, HBO by mratzloff on Wednesday June 06, 2012 @09:16AM (#4073592)
I buy high-bitrate, DRM-free MP3s from Amazon. It really couldn't be much easier, and it's already pretty cheap (generally $0.99 per song), so the only reason remaining is that people get something for nothing. No one can compete with free.
Re:Take my money, HBO by Retric on Wednesday June 06, 2012 @10:07AM (#4073874)
I bought shows on blue-ray that Hulu has to watch once simply because of the advertising and bit-rate. So, IMO you can compete with free. It's just harder.
Re:Take my money, HBO by grhino on Wednesday June 06, 2012 @10:57AM (#4074180)
And then some blu-rays still include unskippable advertising anyways. It makes me feel like I cannot actually purchase content. I can only pay for the privilege of watching advertisements + content.
Re:Take my money, HBO by jack-r-abbit on Wednesday June 06, 2012 @12:37PM (#4074747)
9 times out of 10 (possibly even more) the "ads" on a DVD/BR are trailers (also a form of content) for other movies by the same people involved in the movie you're about to watch. I don't really have an issue with that. There is usually at least one trailer for a movie I've not seen and it reminds me to. And in my experience, I've usually been able to fastforward through them even if you can not directly skip them. Aside from the Anit-Piracy and FBI things, I've never seen an actual commercial for a product (Pepsi, Honda, etc) on my rented/purchase disk.
Re:Take my money, HBO by cletus on Wednesday June 06, 2012 @12:15AM (#4072383)
I somewhat agree that not all "take my money" calls are honest. While not deliberately untrue, the reality of what it costs will simply be above what some who say this are willing to pay (and some will lie to themselves and others that they would pay).

As far as cheating goes, I would put it this way: humans seem to have an appetite for risk. The irony of cars becoming safer is people drive faster and more dangerously. Every person has a different tolerance level. I see cheating as being in that same dimension, at least to some degree.

Part of it is also social constructs. Divorce once had a huge stigma. Now it doesn't. Now people get more divorced. This is of course a simplistic example and by no means demonstrate definitive causation but fundamentally it's reasonable to assume that the difference between being ostracized vs "nobody cares" has to have a significant effect.

It's also I think why law and order is such a tenuous thing. In the West where there are strong states, relatively low corruption and relatively strong enforcement (compared to, say, African countries). This keeps most people honest as the risk of getting "caught" is sufficiently high to stop such behaviour. In more lawless countries there seems to be a tragedy of the commons in play where many more people think to line their own pockets at the expense of the state because everyone else is doing it.

How you get above the line to sufficient conformity is a bit pf a mystery once you're below the minimum threshold.

Re:Take my money, HBO by atomi on Tuesday June 05, 2012 @11:36PM (#4072265)
The progress of our species depends on the passing of knowledge to the next generation. So "sharing information" has become an evolutionary trait.

We started with language then writing, then the printing press then telegraph radio, and phones and now digital information.

We'll eventually get to the point where all of the worlds digital information will fit in devices the size of dice. And we're not far off either.

I actually do agree with you that we tend to rationalize our actions, but that's not some kind of epiphany.

Edit: If you're going to down vote the least you can do is rebut.

Re:Take my money, HBO by mturmon on Tuesday June 05, 2012 @11:56PM (#4072334)
I did not downvote, but I don't think your idea about "all info will fit in a small space" holds up.

One problem is that sensor sizes are increasing at similar rates to storage sizes, for mostly the same reasons. Same goes for our ability to process data into novel forms, and in general to create new data.

Moore giveth, and Moore taketh away. Good for our line of work.

Re:Take my money, HBO by nahname on Wednesday June 06, 2012 @10:03AM (#4073856)
One thing, that I find particularly interesting, is that the bittorrent numbers in the U.S. are decreasing. BitTorrent traffic is now responsible for 11.3% of all U.S. Internet traffic during peak hours, compared to 17.3% last year. While that number appears to be decreasing in the U.S. it is increasing most everywhere else. How do you rationalize such a phenomenon when the "aggregate of users" are just a bunch of thieves?

Personally, I think it is easier for an industry to paint its customers as a bunch of vicious thieves, rather than people expecting content delivery to change with the times. This seems indicative of industries that are a monopoly and are out of touch with their customers, but I fear I would be painting them with an equally broad stroke.

Source: http://www.scribd.com/doc/94722096/Sandvine-Global-Internet-...

Re:Take my money, HBO by trotsky on Wednesday June 06, 2012 @12:55PM (#4074830)
In raw numbers P2P traffic continues to grow considerably, it is just falling in percentage as other high bandwidth services become more common.
Re:Take my money, HBO by SideburnsOfDoom on Wednesday June 06, 2012 @06:05AM (#4073047)
> One regularly repeated meme of the era was that people didn't want to pirate music, they just wanted it "as easy" or "no drm" or "ala carte" or "all you can eat".

Someone put it well recently: "We don’t want everything for free. We just want everything"

http://questioncopyright.org/we_want_everything

Re:Take my money, HBO by cremnob on Wednesday June 06, 2012 @05:19AM (#4072950)
I think people have an entitlement attitude about digital content (movies, music, software, games, etc) that doesn't exist for other tangible products. And I think this entitlement has come out of being able to get away with stealing the content easily.

Many people can't afford/don't want to pay for a Rolls Royce, they aren't their target market, but they don't feel entitled to drive one. So they don't go out and steal one and then say "if only you had made the Rolls Royce available at the local dealership in Randomtown, USA instead of Manhattan and at a more reasonable price of $30,000 I wouldn't have stolen the car".

Re:Take my money, HBO by gizzlon on Wednesday June 06, 2012 @06:50AM (#4073134)
"And I think this entitlement has come out of being able to get away with stealing the content easily"

Probably true. But it seems like it's shifting to some degree; A lot of normal people I know pay for Spotify, for example.

I also feel parts of the industry brought this upon them-self and are just reaping the fruits of their own decisions the last 12 (?) years.

Re:Take my money, HBO by icebraining on Wednesday June 06, 2012 @08:30AM (#4073365)
I'd feel entitled to drive a Rolls Royce if someone offered me one. Which is what happens with P2P: users offering others copies of stuff. There's no stealing except in some people's minds.