Re:A common misunderstanding about wave-particle duality
by crazygringo on Tuesday June 18, 2024 @04:43PM
(#40722042)
> just once and it still forms a wave-like interference pattern
That's not a thing. There's no pattern to observe from a single particle.
The situation you're describing doesn't exist.
Wave behavior and interference patterns can only be observed in statistically significant collections of particle interactions. Not single interactions.
Re:A common misunderstanding about wave-particle duality
by itishappy on Tuesday June 18, 2024 @05:03PM
(#40722175)
Somewhat reductive. Waves behave differently than classical particles, and we can measure this on the level of individual particles even though we can't image the full pattern with a single measurement. For example: a single particle can end up in the middle of a shadow, but this shouldn't be possible classically.
Re:A common misunderstanding about wave-particle duality
by l33tman on Wednesday June 19, 2024 @07:59AM
(#40727421)
You do have to assume at some point that if you fire individual electrons through the dual-slits and record their individual results, that the results are independent. If you can assume this, you're drawn to the current model which is that the electron is in a superposition (i.e. "interferes with itself") that when resolved gives the observed statistical outcome of your independent results. This seems also to be the simplest model (there has been 100 years of trying to find simpler models that reproduce these results).
Re:A common misunderstanding about wave-particle duality
by epgui on Tuesday June 18, 2024 @04:33PM
(#40721939)
A single particle is never observed as a wave afaik (not my area of expertise).
Re:A common misunderstanding about wave-particle duality
by dahart on Tuesday June 18, 2024 @04:33PM
(#40721931)
Where did you read about a single particle forming an interference pattern?
“The atoms themselves are only ever observed in a given experimental run as particles – just as quantum mechanics says they should be. The wavelike behaviour – which is to say, the smeared-out probability distribution – is reconstructed from many particle-like observations.”
Re:A common misunderstanding about wave-particle duality
by qsdf38100 on Tuesday June 18, 2024 @04:44PM
(#40722044)
If you fire a single particle just once, you don’t get an interference pattern, right? You get a single impact.
Re:A common misunderstanding about wave-particle duality
by JoeAltmaier on Tuesday June 18, 2024 @04:50PM
(#40722093)
What's the difference between that, and firing a singleton particles periodically? Shouldn't that just be a collection of 'single impacts'? Yet it isn't.
Re:A common misunderstanding about wave-particle duality
by itishappy on Tuesday June 18, 2024 @05:05PM
(#40722188)
You get both. You get a single impact in a location determined by the interference pattern.
Re:A common misunderstanding about wave-particle duality
by DavidHull on Tuesday June 18, 2024 @05:21PM
(#40722282)
Yes. The single particle interferes with itself. However the effect disappears if you measure which slit the particle went through.
Re:A common misunderstanding about wave-particle duality
by tetris11 on Wednesday June 19, 2024 @03:35AM
(#40725820)
Ah, this is where I was tripping myself up. Thanks
Re:A common misunderstanding about wave-particle duality
by qsdf38100 on Wednesday June 19, 2024 @04:06PM
(#40731900)
Ah, I see what you mean. Yes the sample you get comes from a distribution determined by the interference.
My point was that 1 sample in isolation won’t give you information about the underlying distribution, except that it’s non zero at that point, maybe?
If you fire a single particle between two slits just once and it still forms a wave-like interference pattern, then surely what is being observed is more than just a probability distribution?