News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Home-Cooked Software and Barefoot Developers by fragmede on Tuesday June 11, 2024 @06:50PM (#40652582)
It sounds like you've discouraged yourself from learning the skill of using an LLM to help you code.
Re:Home-Cooked Software and Barefoot Developers by _heimdall on Tuesday June 11, 2024 @11:22PM (#40654133)
That only matters if the assumption is that any skill is worth learning simply because it's a skill.

You could learn the skill of running yourself over with a car, but it's either a skill you'll never use or the last skill you'll use. Either way, you're probably just as well off not bothering to learn that one.

Re:Home-Cooked Software and Barefoot Developers by rrr_oh_man on Wednesday June 12, 2024 @01:04AM (#40654717)
"running yourself over with a car" feels very different from "learning to use LLMs to your advantage".
Re:Home-Cooked Software and Barefoot Developers by _heimdall on Wednesday June 12, 2024 @07:42AM (#40656933)
The GP was pointing out that learning to use an LLM, in their opinion, would stop them from learning other new skills and erode their existing ones.

In that context I think the analogy holds. Using an LLM halts your learning, as does running yourself over with a car. It's an exaggerated point for sure, but I think it points to the fact that you don't have to learn to use LLMs simply because it's a skill you could learn, especially if you think it will harm you long term.

Re:Home-Cooked Software and Barefoot Developers by fragmede on Wednesday June 12, 2024 @07:43PM (#40664386)
what's better, I stare at my code for 3 hours to find a missing semicolon, or ChatGPT explains it to me in minutes. what lesson am I learning by staring at my code?
Re:Home-Cooked Software and Barefoot Developers by _heimdall on Thursday June 13, 2024 @08:40AM (#40668949)
The skill of finding errors is actually a very useful one. I can count on one hand how many times I've made similar mistakes in code, after 3 hours staring at it that lesson really sticks and you don't make it again.

When an algorithm tries to fix it for you you only learn how to send the code to the algorithm to fix it for you. It's convenient in the moment for sure, but you haven't learned how to fix your own code and won't know how to fix it when the algorithm is the cause of the error.

That also ignores secondary risks, like giving your codebase to a nonprofit / very much for profit company. That isn't always possible depending on the codebase, and in general why bother giving them access to it when you instead learn how to find your own missing semicolons? Why spin up a pipe of GPUs and burn all that power rather than learning to do it yourself?

Re:Home-Cooked Software and Barefoot Developers by JohnFen on Wednesday June 12, 2024 @10:19AM (#40658475)
I would disagree with that take, actually. Perhaps I haven't yet figured out how to leverage LLMs for that (and don't get me wrong, I have certainly experimented as has most of my team), but I'm not discouraged from it.

I'm just trying to be clear-eyed about the risks. As an example, code completion tools in IDEs will cause me to get rusty in important baseline skills. LLMs present a similar sort of risk.

Re:Home-Cooked Software and Barefoot Developers by fragmede on Thursday June 13, 2024 @08:16AM (#40668716)
Are you preparing for some sort of cataclysmic world event that results in us living in a world where IDEs with code completion don't exist, and we're tested on whether we can code without code completion? letting those skills get rusty because other skills are being sharpened is not a bad thing. if they're getting rusty because you're not doing anything else, then that's a bad thing, but you can get yourself out of lazy mental traps, no matter where they are, if you're proactive and diligent, no matter the skill.