News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:WebKit fix: Quirk news.ycombinator to skip TextAutoSizing by knallfrosch on Monday June 10, 2024 @05:48AM (#40631800)
My iOS/Safari is so bad, I have both Firefox and Chrome installed as a backup in case it doesn't work. They should start fixing Safari for real instead of adding Quirks.
Re:WebKit fix: Quirk news.ycombinator to skip TextAutoSizing by jraph on Monday June 10, 2024 @05:55AM (#40631850)
I have bad news for you. On iOS, Firefox and Chrome use the same WebKit as Safari (because Apple doesn't allow third party browser engines on its App store).
Re:WebKit fix: Quirk news.ycombinator to skip TextAutoSizing by dizhn on Monday June 10, 2024 @06:15AM (#40631958)
Didn't they allow alternative engines recently?

They even have emulators now. Undoubtedly a change forced on them by the EU.

Re:WebKit fix: Quirk news.ycombinator to skip TextAutoSizing by jraph on Monday June 10, 2024 @06:19AM (#40631982)
Apparently you are right, they do since around February on iOS 17.4. In the EU only.

https://developer.apple.com/support/alternative-browser-engi...

Re:WebKit fix: Quirk news.ycombinator to skip TextAutoSizing by tjoff on Monday June 10, 2024 @07:38AM (#40632472)
Neat, question is if any of the browsers actually have had time to make use of it though?
Re:WebKit fix: Quirk news.ycombinator to skip TextAutoSizing by galad87 on Monday June 10, 2024 @07:59AM (#40632636)
No.
Re:WebKit fix: Quirk news.ycombinator to skip TextAutoSizing by input_sh on Monday June 10, 2024 @08:37AM (#40632926)
It's not as simple as that, you're basically asking browsers to target a completely different platform, just for the EU users, where iPhones are nowhere near as popular to begin with.

Google might at some point maintain two completely different Chromes targeting iOS, but I doubt anyone else will (including Firefox). Even with Chrome, I wouldn't bet on it. It's a very difficult technical problem with no clear, easily-marketable benefit to most people.

Apple knew what they were doing, they've "complied", but in a way where nobody would bother.

Re:WebKit fix: Quirk news.ycombinator to skip TextAutoSizing by YmiYugy on Monday June 10, 2024 @09:23AM (#40633385)
As far as I know a native Chromium port to iOS is well under way. Whether Google will release Chrome is a different question, but I think it's likely. I think Google would love to bring Blink Chrome on iOS everywhere and there is a decent amount of momentum with developers and regulators to pressure Apple into allowing third party browser engines even outside the EU, but that completely goes away, if no actual engine get's ported to iOS. Blink Chrome on iOS probably gets a lot of enterprise web apps to drop WebKit support. That would probably that Chrome gets way more market share on iOS and with it lot's of telemetry for Google and also less money to Apple for default search engine placement. It's not great for the web as a standardized platform, but it will probably happen anyways.
Re:WebKit fix: Quirk news.ycombinator to skip TextAutoSizing by tjoff on Monday June 10, 2024 @09:27AM (#40633442)
No I agree, that was exactly my point.

It's not like iOS users care anyway, or they wouldn't use iOS in the first place.

Re:WebKit fix: Quirk news.ycombinator to skip TextAutoSizing by Y_Y on Monday June 10, 2024 @03:15PM (#40637407)
The EU is pretty big. For a population of about 450 million people with decent spending power maybe it is worthwhile.
Re:WebKit fix: Quirk news.ycombinator to skip TextAutoSizing by fallingknife on Monday June 10, 2024 @07:40AM (#40632485)
So Microsoft got dragged through anti-trust hell for just bundling IE with Windows and letting you install whatever browser you wanted after that, but Apple gets away with literally banning you from installing the browser you want on your own device, but that's ok? Make it make sense.
Re:WebKit fix: Quirk news.ycombinator to skip TextAutoSizing by revscat on Monday June 10, 2024 @08:04AM (#40632660)
The market shifted, and two decades passed. Most importantly the courts have been packed with jurists from the Federalist society, who are libertarian. As a result there are far more judges willing and able to throw out consumer protection cases such as what happened in the 90’s with Microsoft and IE.
Re:WebKit fix: Quirk news.ycombinator to skip TextAutoSizing by dspillett on Monday June 10, 2024 @08:20AM (#40632777)
MS went through anti-trust investigation for more than just bundling IE, and at the time commanded a much larger market share¹ of desktop computing than Apple do of the mobile market now.

But while your comparison is flawed, I agree with the assertion² that Apple should not be locking user choice like this. The EU agree too, hence Apple's immature little hissy fit nearly breaking their (already "not quite there") offline-first app support for EU users when they were told so.

--

[1] Avoiding the word "monopoly" to pre-counter the sort of "well actually" responses I got about dictionary definitions last time I said something like this.

[2] Unless I'm reading you backwards and you are saying MS should have been able to like Apple currently do!

Re:WebKit fix: Quirk news.ycombinator to skip TextAutoSizing by fallingknife on Monday June 10, 2024 @12:34PM (#40635338)
You are not reading me backwards. And MSFT is worse today. I had to make changes at the BIOS level in a new Windows laptop to make it let me install Firefox without creating a Microsoft account. Was an ordeal just to get it to let me log in in the first place with a local only account.
Re:WebKit fix: Quirk news.ycombinator to skip TextAutoSizing by kalleboo on Monday June 10, 2024 @09:40AM (#40633588)
The Microsoft ruling in the US was that Microsoft was forcing third-party OEMs (Dell, HP etc) to ship Internet Explorer, not that they shipped it themselves.

As for the EU, they have already forced Apple to allow third-party browser engines under the DMA, as well as are forcing Apple to show a "browser ballot" like they made Microsoft do.

Re:WebKit fix: Quirk news.ycombinator to skip TextAutoSizing by qingcharles on Monday June 10, 2024 @10:55AM (#40634298)
They didn't totally get away with, the EU has set them to rights at least. It's just a shame they didn't use it as an opportunity to do the right thing globally at that point rather than sharding the market.
Re:WebKit fix: Quirk news.ycombinator to skip TextAutoSizing by nozzlegear on Monday June 10, 2024 @10:40PM (#40641719)
> Make it make sense.

Microsoft’s anti-trust lawsuit with the DOJ was 23 years ago. There are people working at Microsoft and Apple who weren’t even alive when that happened.

Times change.

Re:WebKit fix: Quirk news.ycombinator to skip TextAutoSizing by hhh on Monday June 10, 2024 @05:55AM (#40631849)
what’s wrong with ios/safari? i don’t really ever have issues
Re:WebKit fix: Quirk news.ycombinator to skip TextAutoSizing by flessner on Monday June 10, 2024 @07:36AM (#40632459)
Safari on MacOS is really nice, fast and offers everything I need... but every 3 months or so I stumble on a website that refuses to work at all - rendering looks off, buttons don't work etc...

Switching to Chrome usually fixes it - but I always question my sanity for about 10 minutes until I try it in Chrome.

Re:WebKit fix: Quirk news.ycombinator to skip TextAutoSizing by SassyBird on Monday June 10, 2024 @09:02AM (#40633143)
It’s the opposite for me. I keep finding dumb bugs in Chromium, when it comes to correct website rendering and event handling (always regressions). Safari and Firefox on the other hand never have those issues.

The only problem is: Safari has piss-poor ad blockers. Firefox blocks custom system-wide keyboard shortcuts (on Mac).