News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:A Revolution in Biology by RivieraKid on Sunday June 09, 2024 @04:19PM (#40627267)
It's incredible that the information necessary to create a human is just about 750 MB uncompressed. For example the very specific shape of the scapula bone or fear of spiders...
Re:A Revolution in Biology by tsimionescu on Sunday June 09, 2024 @05:31PM (#40627798)
It's really not. If nothing else, conditions in the uterus, especially in the first few months, are extremely crucial. Take 10 identical fertilized eggs and put them in 10 different people and you'll get 10 different humans, not 10 clones as people generally assume. And this is not just genetics of the mother, differences in diet and lifestyle will also significantly (not to mention history) impact the development of the fetus, especially in the early months.
Re:A Revolution in Biology by sho on Monday June 10, 2024 @12:09AM (#40630044)
> Take 10 identical fertilized eggs and put them in 10 different people and you'll get 10 different humans

Well, some would say if you took 10 identical fertilised eggs and put them in the same human in serial you'd get 10 different humans. Some would say there's no such thing as 10 identical fertilised eggs, or 10 identical anything.

The question is how different? 10 identical eggs in 10 well-nourished, healthy people and the results should be pretty similar, no?

Re:A Revolution in Biology by tsimionescu on Monday June 10, 2024 @12:45AM (#40630252)
> Some would say there's no such thing as 10 identical fertilised eggs, or 10 identical anything.

Sure, "identical" is a strong word for anything biological.

> The question is how different? 10 identical eggs in 10 well-nourished, healthy people and the results should be pretty similar, no?

My understanding is that they would be less similar than "identical" twins, more similar than regular siblings.

Re:A Revolution in Biology by calf on Monday June 10, 2024 @01:23AM (#40630442)
But wouldn't "surrogate clones" as the category be closer to twins than siblings? They would be closer to twins than fraternal twins.
Re:A Revolution in Biology by tsimionescu on Monday June 10, 2024 @01:37AM (#40630532)
Honestly I don't think it's very clear. The practicalities of cloning processes make it so that we are very far from exploring what's in principle possible. All of the cloned mammals so far have died pretty young even when the original organism lived a long and healthy life, so in that sense they are technically way more different than even siblings. Of course, this is almost certainly just a limitation of our currently imperfect cloning technology, so it's hard to judge what a perfected cloning tech would do.

Of course, certain aspects of appearance are known to be almost exclusively genetically determined, such as eye, hair, and skin color. Some fine details are known from identical twin studies to not be fully determined, such as fingerprints (twins have slightly different fingerprints). For the majority of other fine details, it's actually pretty unclear.

Re:A Revolution in Biology by pvaldes on Monday June 10, 2024 @07:34AM (#40632436)
Lots of red flags here.

To start, in the 99% of the times this question can be answered with: no.

I bet that the man being promoted here as the best thing since the invention of Banjo, didn't discovered the effect of chemical gradients in Embryology. (I don't know everything, and I could be wrong. I'm open to discuss his published scientific articles in the field).

That the same process that makes your arm will be repeated later to build each one of your fingers is known since many decades ago (count the number of articulations, is always car, car plus a cdr). See the video of U2 "Even better than the real thing" for a graphic representation of the idea. Yes, this is how it works basically.

> Take 10 identical fertilized eggs and put them in 10 different people and you'll get 10 different humans

You can bet it. This big claims always worry me. They either reveal a basic lack of understanding about biology, or are predatory and directed to select people that don't understand even the most basic concepts on Biology.

An spermatozoa can be used just one or zero times. Period.

There is not such thing as "10 identically fertilized eggs put in the same woman will get exactly the same human ten times", because is impossible to find 10 genetically identical spermatozoans and 10 genetically identical ovules to match them. Each time meiosis happens what you have is a similar but genetically different cell

Re:A Revolution in Biology by ars on Monday June 10, 2024 @12:21AM (#40630107)
The design of the uterus was also included in that 750MB.

Which means this ability to usefully vary the final product is also included in the 750MB! If anything that makes it even more astonishing, not less.

Re:A Revolution in Biology by tsimionescu on Monday June 10, 2024 @12:41AM (#40630223)
Biological systems don't work this way. You need a fully living organism + DNA to produce a new organism. You can't "bootstrap" just from the DNA. DNA is not a blueprint: it is more like a recipe that assumes an intricate set of tools already exist. If you only had the DNA and not the "tools" (a living, healthy enough mother), you wouldn't get more than a few cells from it.
Re:A Revolution in Biology by ars on Monday June 10, 2024 @02:25AM (#40630776)
That's not what I said. The "tools" were also created from DNA, i.e. the mother.

Or are you saying that there's essentially undocumented-code that exists inside a living organisim and is transmitted mother to daughter, by virtue of being gestated, but is not in DNA?

Re:A Revolution in Biology by tsimionescu on Monday June 10, 2024 @03:20AM (#40631053)
I'm sort of saying that, yes.

Some of this is actually very well known - at the cellular level, when a cell divides, the nuclear DNA doesn't uniquely determine every aspect of the new cells, certain organelles divide separately and by their own mechanisms. So, it's trivial to observe that you can't recreate a cell fully knowing just its DNA, you also need the mitochondrial DNA but also other bits.

But there is even more than that. Imagine you had a program that explained exactly how to build a PC that can run this same program, starting from raw sand and ending up with a fully powered PC. So, if you boot a PC and give it access to a smart factory, this program will create a new smart factory from scratch that is a near perfect copy of the original smart factory. The question is: if you don't have a smart factory at all, you just found this program on printed paper, would you be able to use it to build a smart factory?

Most likely, no, because the program can easily depend on certain details of the original smart factory that it was used to copy. Let's say, it could have instructions like "measure the length of original.robot_arm_7 and cut this piece of metal to the same length", or, "combine the liquid in original.vat3 with two parts "water" and 1 part liquid from original.vat7, and pour the result in copy.vat3". This is how life works: it uses DNA to build copies of itself, but DNA can't help you build the original base cell, that was arrived at by an entirely different process.

Edit: for another simple example, consider that, if some ultra-advanced alien species found a population of living mammals, but they were all female, they would be fully able to create more females of the same species. But, it would be completely impossible for them to create a male of the original species, because there is no DNA whatsoever in a female mammal that explains how to build a testicle or a sperm cell. They could build artificial males, but they couldn't ever know if those males resemble the originals or not. So again, the DNA of an organism doesn't encode all the information necessary to create the species, that is transmitted through a more complex mechanism.

Re:A Revolution in Biology by sho on Monday June 10, 2024 @11:06PM (#40641841)
Thanks for your well-informed contributions to this thread. Food for thought. I must admit that I hadn't known the "factory environment" made such a big difference in outcomes.

In your opinion then, do we need to add a 3rd "variable" to the nature/nurture question? "Nature" is generally understood to be DNA, "Nurture" is generally accepted to be the post-birth development environment. If the "embyronic toolkit" at hand is so important, surely this popular concept needs a 3rd leg.

I'd also be interested in your thoughts on surrogacy. I had naively assumed that, so long as the surrogate mother was well-nourished, the baby would likely be fine. But it seems it's a lot more complicated than that, and I feel like a lot of people are underinformed about this.

Re:A Revolution in Biology by pas on Thursday June 13, 2024 @04:47PM (#40674551)
Nature is the heritable part nurture is the "seems easiest to change" part.

Of course turns out that gene-environment interactions are common and complicated, so most of the things are mixed.

Brain development takes about 20 years, driven by genes, but the environment is extremely important to help people to learn how to get most out of that setup they got.

This is most evident in learning disabilities, for example stimulants are regularly described as life-changing by ADHD folks.

Re:A Revolution in Biology by kortilla on Monday June 10, 2024 @02:30AM (#40630806)
No, because each baby comes from a uterus, there is a second possible information transmission mechanism at play. Until we see a baby formed outside of a uterus that has a functioning uterus itself, you can’t be certain that the DNA has the requisite data.
Re:A Revolution in Biology by TeMPOraL on Monday June 10, 2024 @09:12AM (#40633260)
Remember "Reflections on Trusting Trust"[0]? This is biology in a nutshell: the "source code" may be 750MB, but since every organism has been built by another organism, there's $deity knows how much information accumulated in, and copied by, the reproduction mechanism itself, without ever being present in the "source code".

--

[0] - https://www.cs.cmu.edu/~rdriley/487/papers/Thompson_1984_Ref...

Re:A Revolution in Biology by snowwrestler on Monday June 10, 2024 @01:52PM (#40636153)
People think DNA is the source code. It’s more like an API response. DNA is sufficient to pass traits down to the next generation. It is not sufficient to bootstrap life from nothing. It has to be interpreted by a very specific system.
Re:A Revolution in Biology by seydor on Monday June 10, 2024 @12:58AM (#40630305)
A lossy compression
Re:A Revolution in Biology by sameoldtune on Sunday June 09, 2024 @04:25PM (#40627313)
To be fair that’s just the size of the installer
Re:A Revolution in Biology by B1FF_PSUVM on Sunday June 09, 2024 @05:11PM (#40627657)
That's a good comeback, especially if you can say something about the site where the rest of the info is pulled from ;-)
Re:A Revolution in Biology by aspenmayer on Sunday June 09, 2024 @05:34PM (#40627812)
DNA has been in development hell for billions of years, and yet compile/install times still vary widely between platforms and is not ABI compatible cross-platform.

Don’t get me started on the unauthorized use of proprietary code!

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Horizontal_gene_transfer

We keep getting asked about “checksums” and “reproducible builds” and if the BDFL is going to implement them, to which they say: “already landed in upstream,” “works on my machine,” “notabug,” and/or “wontfix” sometimes in the same reply.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lamarckism

https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3730912/

https://www.nature.com/articles/nrg.2016.106

Re:A Revolution in Biology by Angostura on Sunday June 09, 2024 @05:33PM (#40627805)
Well, the egg’s cytoplasm contains quite a few of the frameworks
Re:A Revolution in Biology by sameoldtune on Sunday June 09, 2024 @08:29PM (#40628818)
I know you were joking, but what I was thinking of was that our DNA creates cells, but I don’t think that we would grow into proper humans without interacting with the rest of the earths environment. And there’s a lot more than 750 MB of information out there
Re:A Revolution in Biology by B1FF_PSUVM on Monday June 10, 2024 @08:54AM (#40633077)
I was thinking only of the hardware - call it a feral human, as in raised by wolves - of course otherwise you get the "it takes a village" line.
Re:A Revolution in Biology by ars on Monday June 10, 2024 @12:24AM (#40630130)
> about the site where the rest of the info is pulled from

That's what Dualism posits: The rest of the info is elsewhere, and joins with the physical body. Dualism is usually discussed in regards to sapience, but it doesn't have to, it can also include the behavior of animals.

Re:A Revolution in Biology by seydor on Monday June 10, 2024 @12:59AM (#40630308)
but if i pirate it, i have a full copy
Re:A Revolution in Biology by 1auralynn on Sunday June 09, 2024 @04:44PM (#40627457)
Well until they succeed in creating artificial wombs it's technically a much larger amount of information (e.g. the cellular composition of the womb, how many and what kinds of nutrients that flow through, etc). We are still scratching the surface of epigenetics too.
Re:A Revolution in Biology by thaumasiotes on Sunday June 09, 2024 @08:00PM (#40628652)
> Well until they succeed in creating artificial wombs it's technically a much larger amount of information (e.g. the cellular composition of the womb, how many and what kinds of nutrients that flow through, etc).

You might note that this information is also contained in the same notional 750MB bundle.

Imagine a piece of software that works poorly the first time you run it, but modifies its environment so that it will work better in future runs.

There was an experiment in birds related to this. Someone had the question of whether birdsong was genetically or culturally determined.

The cultural side noted that, for whatever species of bird was under investigation, birds raised without parents produced abnormal song.

But upon continuing the experiment, the genetic side noted that the children of those birds, exposed only to the abnormal song of their parents, produced normal song.

Raising one bird in isolation isn't enough to express the information contained in that species' DNA, but the information is there anyway.

Re:A Revolution in Biology by klipt on Sunday June 09, 2024 @11:11PM (#40629777)
Or the bird's DNA contained some objective function, and the song gradually converged to maximize that function? :-)
Re:A Revolution in Biology by thaumasiotes on Monday June 10, 2024 @05:10PM (#40639140)
That would be an example of the song being specified in the DNA.
Re:A Revolution in Biology by alexey-salmin on Sunday June 09, 2024 @11:46PM (#40629951)
> You might note that this information is also contained in the same notional 750MB bundle.

Not necessarily, that's the point. It's uncertain if you can recreate a human being from genome alone even with perfect technology. Some crucial information could be passed from one female to another without being present in the genome at all.

> There was an experiment in birds related to this.

I suspect none of these birds were rebuilt in a laboratory from their genome alone. The experiment proves that information is passed inside the egg but it doesn't specify via which medium.

Re:A Revolution in Biology by gus_massa on Monday June 10, 2024 @02:22PM (#40636493)
> Some crucial information could be passed from one female to another without being present in the genome at all.

Hard to know, but two interesting corner cases:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mitochondrion (but they have their own DNA...)

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Centriole (but it looks like they can grow again "However, [...] cells whose centrioles have been removed via laser ablation [...] centrioles can be synthesized later in a de novo fashion."

Re:A Revolution in Biology by tsimionescu on Monday June 10, 2024 @04:08AM (#40631288)
In general, the instructions for creating a copy of an object can be very different from instructions for creating an original from scratch, because instructions for copying can use information already in instance A. And DNA is certainly instructions for copying, not for building from scratch.

How far you'd get using DNA to create some organism from scratch is unclear, but it's certainly not very far at all. You certainly can't create a whole eukaryotic cell just from DNA, even with all put current knowledge of organic chemistry plus our ability to study how current cells actually work (no one has come even slightly close to building a self-replicating prokaryotic cell).

Edit: imagine source code for a compiler that is allowed to strcpy() bits of the currently running compiler. It's a legitimate way to create a running compiler, but it's not what we'd normally consider "source code".

Re:A Revolution in Biology by Terr_ on Sunday June 09, 2024 @04:37PM (#40627390)
> It's incredible that the information necessary to create a human is just about 750 MB uncompressed

Hold up, isn't the point of this article that genes do not have all the information?

The, er, bootup environment of a freshly-fertilized human egg normally provides a lot more than merely protection and raw materials for nine months. Likely a lot of required parameters, and definitely a lot of important tuning optimizations.

> For example the very specific shape of the scapula bone or fear of spiders...

There were some studies a decade back about mice inheriting fears of certain smells from the father, I wonder if anyone discovered the mechanism (or disproved the effect) by now.

Re:A Revolution in Biology by abecedarius on Sunday June 09, 2024 @07:41PM (#40628546)
To a programmer it's reminiscent of a self-hosting compiler that comes with working source and binary, but not the sequence of bootstraps. "Trusting trust" makes a nice example of the hastiness in taking the source to be all you really need to know. Similarly, metacircular interpreters that leave evaluation order ambiguous.
Re:A Revolution in Biology by agumonkey on Monday June 10, 2024 @02:22AM (#40630760)
> Hold up, isn't the point of this article that genes do not have all the information?

Yeah it is. The informational aspect (and the precision level) Levin and his friends are looking for is the main factor here. Cells are not just tissue building blocks, they're agents, limited but still, themselves with a lot more capabilities than we generally assume.

I believe multiple fields are mature enough (biology, computational biology, optics) to care and analyse this and make a new step in our understanding of complex organisms.

Re:A Revolution in Biology by goodpoint on Sunday June 09, 2024 @05:46PM (#40627885)
> create a human *body*
Re:A Revolution in Biology by hejdufufjrj on Monday June 10, 2024 @01:12AM (#40630376)
In compression contests you count the size of both the compressed data (DNA) and the decompressor binary (egg cell).

We don't know how much data is required to fully describe a living cell, but it's not just the DNA since you can't turn that into a cell without using an existing cell

Re:A Revolution in Biology by taylorius on Monday June 10, 2024 @04:14AM (#40631317)
It could be argued that the "decompressor binary" is actually a female human, which sounds a bit like the old "store large parts of the compressed data in the decoder to get a smaller file size" trick. :-) Maybe the sperm / egg are deltas? I wonder if there has been any research done with parental similarity with gestation using surrogacy vs. natural mother.
Re:A Revolution in Biology by grishka on Monday June 10, 2024 @05:04AM (#40631570)
It's the initial state for a self-replicating hardware procedural generator.
Re:A Revolution in Biology by ur-whale on Monday June 10, 2024 @11:47AM (#40634834)
> It's incredible that the information necessary to create a human is just about 750 MB

Have you not been playing with LLM's in the last year or so ?

They seem to compress a sizable chunk of human knowledge in about 7 Gig

And, when they find a gap, they lie through their teeth to provide a reasonable answer.

I wonder if there's some sort of similar process (hallucination) going on when the final human is rebuilt from the 750MB.

Re:A Revolution in Biology by Geee on Monday June 10, 2024 @12:14PM (#40635154)
DNA is just a "program", and a living cell is basically an advanced programmable nanorobot. When cells divide or reproduce, the whole nanorobot is cloned with some modifications. The DNA tells how to modify the cloned nanorobot, and it is also possible to reprogram any cell back to the original state. Nobody knows how to make a cell i.e the nanorobot from stratch. The information is not in the DNA, like a computer program doesn't contain the instructions to build a computer.
Re:A Revolution in Biology by wallon_brux on Monday June 10, 2024 @12:59PM (#40635592)
I guess that's without considering epigenetics which have some heritable marks. We are very far from knowing how much epigenetics contribute to the making of an organism and as a whole it is controversial. But one of the great lessons of the human genome project is that DNA coding does not account for all of the biologic information and that epigenetics may have a bigger part to play than what was previously thought. If we were somehow able to model every epigenetic marker the uncompressed information would be quite heavier