That's not to say there aren't other ills, but that's a pretty major one of large bureaucracies and causes serious effectiveness issues downstream.
It has side-benefits particular to the military mostly related to how adaptable the organization is when lots of its members are being killed and disabled at a high rate.
I don’t think you’d find a lot of takers for a rotating-post offer in the broader public sector, without far higher wages. I think most of the folks willing to do that for low wages are already in the military or the foreign service.
On the whole, I think it's still a net positive. The drag of unmotivated, apathetic, and/or inflexible employees is incredibly high, and then there's the additional efficiency drag of the systems that must put in place to ensure they meet minimum performance (i.e. filling out make-work forms to track performance).
Better to simply create a system by which they're weeded out.
Which I guess dovetails with the military "up or out" process.
From a giant organization perspective, there's a lot to admire in militaries. They're the worst systems, except for all the other ways organizations as large as them could be organized...
I agree with this. It's really just another way to say there should be mechanisms to hold people accountable.
>Which I guess dovetails with the military "up or out" process.
I don't think the military does a great job of this. From what I could see, it only forces out the absolute absymal performers (e.g., those who can't pass a PFT or have multiple DUIs etc.) I would argue it takes far too long (often only implemented once they've been in a decade or more and haven't made SNCO). This does a disservice to both the organization (the person is still around for a decade) and also the service member (they have now dedicated over a decade to a career that is a dead end, and usually over halfway to retirement).
On the officer side, especially in certain specialties, it's very much musical chairs... with an ever-decreasing number of chairs.
(Which admittedly creates a lot of its own issues by setting up zero-sum, don't-help-your-competition scenarios and politics at the higher ranks)
I think it heavily depends on the branch and what is considered “competence”. I remember meeting Airmen who could cite all the stats about weapons systems because that was on their test, but the couldn’t shoot. And Marines where it was the opposite. It’s also generally possible to get promoted by just hanging out, keeping out of trouble, and having reasonable fitness tests
The smartest people I've met either have plum book positions, military officers, or work as prosecutors.
>it is also not terrible at hiring very competent/smart people through their commission system
I suspect you would get a very different perspective if you talked to enlisted servicemembers (or subordinate officers). I would argue the commissioning system is better than the previous aristocratic commissioning system, but still relatively poor at mating skills to positions.
I think churn is a couple of problems for a couple of different potential reasons:
1) constantly moving positions tends to leave the more complicated problems unsolved. For one, it's difficult to truly understand the dynamics of a complicated system in a short period. Secondly, if someone is concerned with promotion, attacking small problems tends to get you a win during your tenure, while it's unlikely you'll make much headway on a really difficult or complicated problem. Even worse is the commander who has all kinds of great ideas they want implemented even before they really understand the problem (ie the 'good idea fairy' dilemma)
2) military churn can bias toward giving people responsibility beyond their capability, simply because they need someone to fill that role. This is especially with younger organizations (and the military definitely biases young). Meaning you tend to people with a lot of power/responsibility before their frontal lobe is even fully developed.
Now I do think the military does a pretty good job at accountability, which can mitigate some of those factors. But if that's the case, we should be trying to optimize for "accountability" and not "churn".
The better military organizations seem to have "churn" in the uniformed services in charge but a steady cadre of professional civilian staff supporting them.