>but there's also much stronger gating of promotions by competency tests there, right?
I think it heavily depends on the branch and what is considered “competence”. I remember meeting Airmen who could cite all the stats about weapons systems because that was on their test, but the couldn’t shoot. And Marines where it was the opposite. It’s also generally possible to get promoted by just hanging out, keeping out of trouble, and having reasonable fitness tests
On the officer side, especially in certain specialties, it's very much musical chairs... with an ever-decreasing number of chairs.
(Which admittedly creates a lot of its own issues by setting up zero-sum, don't-help-your-competition scenarios and politics at the higher ranks)