News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Formlabs Form 4 Teardown by edg5000 on Monday June 03, 2024 @04:41AM (#40560543)
I have been doing a lot of FDM for the past 10 years, but a few years ago, for FOMO reasons, I got really hyped up about resin printing. I got an Elegoo Mars and a very large expensive Chinese resin printer that I never got to work.

I ran into three problems that I was not able to overcome, even after tons of trial and error:

- Warping. With ABS, a heated chamber, ABS slurry, heated glass bed, completely solved all warping. With resin, I was unable to predict or fix warping issues.

- Model not sticking to the bed. Behaviour was inconsistent. With a good printer like the Form, that is probably not a problem. With FDM, having an all metal printer, with a glass bed and a good Z probe solved this for good.

- Mechanical performance was garbage. Very brittle.

- Always needing supports. With FDM, if you fully control the design process, you can completely eliminate supports (at least in my case, of course this imposes design constraints). With resin, you always need supports. The supports are more complex and harder to remove.

I still think resin may be the future, because the level of detail with resin is just amazing.

Re:Formlabs Form 4 Teardown by varjag on Monday June 03, 2024 @05:30AM (#40560823)
The main cause of warping is inadequate supports and/or unfortunate angles you place the part with. Remember you have both gravity and separation force pulling on the part each cycle, unlike with FDM.

Align the bed, clean it thoroughly with alcohol before printing and increase base exposure. Make sure there is no debris in the vat. It'll stick.

All printer resins are variation of acrylic and you have to design your parts with material limitations considered. However there's a range of premium resins for performance prints, look into Henkel Loctite or BASF offerings. We use BASF RG 35 and RG 9400 for small volume production parts. Also, make sure you do not overexpose: print an exposure target for any new resin to zero out the settings.

Supports are certainly unavoidable but are largely a skill issue. After hundreds of prints it takes me minutes to depanel very elaborate designs.

Re:Formlabs Form 4 Teardown by torginus on Monday June 03, 2024 @04:58AM (#40560618)
The warping one is strange, warping is caused by thermal expansion/contraction and resin doesn't really change temperature during the printing process. That's one of the reasons you

Sounds to me you either aren't printing at room temperature, don't have the resin dialed in or you got a bad batch of resin/

The other criticisms are fair, but not necessarily dealbreakers and can be mitigated.

PLA is brittle as well, about the same as standard resin. Just like with FDM, there are other formulations, but the materials are different, and perhaps there are no good analogs for FDM materials.

Imo resin printing is mostly useful for tabletop minis, not engineering prints.

As opposed to you, I don't think resin's the future, certainly not in the hobbyist space. The fact that it involves highly toxic chemicals and fumes means you need a separate space and be really cognizant about materials safety at all times.

It does have its niches, particularly in mini printing, where the high detail is useful, and you can load up the whole area with minis at no penalty to print time and have an entire army's worth of minis printed in a span of hours.

Re:Formlabs Form 4 Teardown by michaelt on Monday June 03, 2024 @05:45AM (#40560939)
> The warping one is strange, warping is caused by thermal expansion/contraction and resin doesn't really change temperature during the printing process.

In my experience with resin, you can get misshapen parts for a bunch of reasons:

1. Resin will change size a bit during and after curing. Not by a large amount, and of course it depends on the type of resin you use etc - but enough. And of course if your design has some thick bits and some thin bits, one might shrink more than the other.

2. Every time the machine exposes the resin, it sticks to the previous layer and to the projector screen/LCD. The machine then lifts the model, to unstick it from the projector screen. This applies force to the model, and can cause it to bend by a tiny amount - which can gradually build up over several layers.

3. Resin has to be somewhat UV transparent, for each layer to cure all the way through in a short exposure time. Because of that, UV curing later layers can pass through the part and cure resin that shouldn't be cured, on earlier layers. This is particularly the case if the shape has areas resin can pool up and won't run off.

> PLA is brittle as well, about the same as standard resin. Just like with FDM, there are other formulations, but the materials are different, and perhaps there are no good analogs for FDM materials.

For many printers, resin has to be brittle because of the way the printing process works.

You cure a layer, it sticks to the previous layer and the projector screen/LCD, then you raise it to unstick it from the screen.

If the resin is flexible, the unsticking process would cause the layer to bend, giving poor dimensional accuracy. So resin is formulated to be stiff and unyielding.

FDM can print flexible materials like TPU - common 'print upside-down' designs of resin printers simply can't. Although you undoubtedly could engineer a printer that could, such as a resin equivalent of an SLS printer, which doesn't face the unsticking issue.

Re:Formlabs Form 4 Teardown by torginus on Monday June 03, 2024 @08:13AM (#40561909)
All I can say that while you are theoretically probably right, all of this ends up not being a problem in practice.

1. Resin shrinking tends to be uniform, which is something to be taken into account if you plan on making parts that fit into holes, like screw mounts.

2. Peel force is absolutely a problem, that's why you need to minimize contact surface with the print film. With 28mm minis, this tends to be not a problem, but for large models, its recommended you hollow them out. This saves resin and prevents partially cured resin from being trapped inside. Bending tends not to be an issue.

3. Again not a huge problem in practice. If you look at a sliced model, you will see, that below each layer the layer below is almost the same, with most pixels shared between the 2, and with overhangs that stick out by 1-2 pixels. This means that leaking light will likely hit parts of the model that are supposed to be solid anyway. But both underexposure and overexposure can happen, with the former meaning that resin doesn't properly cure, leading to thing features disappearing, and the latter meaning that light leaking will cure unintended resin, which leads to thin cavities disappearing. This can be fixed by dialing in the exposure.

4. PLA in my experience is just as prone to shattering as resin is. While truly TPU-like rubber resins might not exist (at least I've never used them), there are ton of resins with a slightly rubbery texture, which are solid, but are flexible enough that thin features don't break when you manhandle the models. Most official wargaming and board game minis tend to be made of a similar resin (which is probably not UV resin but has a similar feel)

Re:Formlabs Form 4 Teardown by michaelt on Monday June 03, 2024 @10:58AM (#40563249)
> All I can say that while you are theoretically probably right, all of this ends up not being a problem in practice.

I experienced every issue I mentioned first-hand, in practice.

I suppose it's possible I was uniquely naive in attempting to get engineering quality prints out of a consumer resin printer? It seems there's a good reason every resin 3D printer promotes itself with pictures of figurines rather than anything more demanding.

My experience was that getting good results when printing something like a plastic bottle cap wasn't just a matter of dialing in the exposure - I had to dial in the exposure, the room temperature, the conditioning of the resin, the support placement, the orientation, and design the item geometry with printing in mind. Even then the results were adequate rather than impressive.

Re:Formlabs Form 4 Teardown by torginus on Monday June 03, 2024 @05:17PM (#40567666)
People who use resin printers usually go for the high detail instead of engineering properties - main users tend to be either cosplayers or mini modelers.

Engineering prints are certainly possible I think, but you'd need some specialist resins.

Personally I'd stick with FDM for making functional prints.

Re:Formlabs Form 4 Teardown by ipsod on Tuesday June 04, 2024 @01:06PM (#40576713)
Thanks for sharing your experience.

Did you try engineering resins, like Siraya Tech's "Build", "Sculpt", etc.?

I make some small parts that I FDM print, then CNC mill for accuracy. Was hoping to switch to resin printing, instead.

Re:Formlabs Form 4 Teardown by mdorazio on Monday June 03, 2024 @06:03AM (#40561063)
This is factually incorrect. A quick search will show you plenty of flexible resins. Here's one: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=eely3rxr2to

Resin is also much less prone to size changes than standard FDM filaments. If you've printed FDM you should know how much tolerance you have to have in your parts (ex. hole diameters) to account for shrinkage post-print, not to mention the difficulty of printing things like ABS.

Resin has MANY drawbacks and in my opinion kind of sucks as a general user experience, but warping, material quality, and material options are not worse than FDM.

Re:Formlabs Form 4 Teardown by michaelt on Monday June 03, 2024 @06:12AM (#40561125)
> A quick search will show you plenty of flexible resins. Here's one: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=eely3rxr2to

OK, you make a fair point. People will sell you such resin.

But look at the video at the 4m40s mark - the dimensional accuracy is trash.

The makers of these printers will all claim they have 0.01mm layers and 0.03 mm x/y resolutions and stuff like that but the dimensional accuracy of the parts coming off them is far, far, far below that no matter what the marketers claim. That cube barely has 1mm dimensional accuracy.

Re:Formlabs Form 4 Teardown by mdorazio on Monday June 03, 2024 @08:50AM (#40562170)
I agree on quality varying widely for resins softer than something like ABS or PETG. And tolerances are definitely never to advertised spec. It’s worth noting that Formlabs themselves sell a “silicone” resin for a hilarious $350: https://formlabs.com/store/materials/silicone-40a-resin/

At that price point you might as well outsource it or at least print a negative and use a real silicone pour.

Re:Formlabs Form 4 Teardown by numpad0 on Tuesday June 04, 2024 @02:01AM (#40571154)
It really is just open loop resolutions. You can print really sharp tweezers in SLA, that's what they mean by that.
Re:Formlabs Form 4 Teardown by varjag on Monday June 03, 2024 @05:48AM (#40560955)
You absolutely can print flexible materials on resin printers.
Re:Formlabs Form 4 Teardown by michaelt on Monday June 03, 2024 @06:02AM (#40561058)
> Model not sticking to the bed. Behaviour was inconsistent.

Crank the exposure time for the first 10 layers up. Way up, like 10x the exposure time for normal layers. They'll come out noticeably oversized, maybe 0.3mm bigger than you wanted. Adjust the model to compensate.

(Assuming you've already levelled the print platform etc in line with the manufacturer's instructions and your resin is OK)

Re:Formlabs Form 4 Teardown by iCarrot on Wednesday June 05, 2024 @02:50AM (#40582081)
The common wisdom (this is back when I was still fiddling with an Elegoo Mars 2-3 years ago) was to print the model at an angle and elevated from build plate. There should always be rafts and supports under the model.
Re:Formlabs Form 4 Teardown by numpad0 on Tuesday June 04, 2024 @01:47AM (#40571072)
I learned hard way that you have to:

- have GOOD ventilation and don't bother with water washables,

- nail down Resin XP2 Matrix test prints,

- use BOTH stirrer wash and ultrasound, and dry prints for hours before curing to mitigate swelling(marginal effects),

- and use 10-15x longer exposure for first layer curing time,

for SLA prints. Otherwise resin crumbles apart, leaves ugly marks on surface for first half inch, and so on. If magnetic beds are used, Z limit switch trigger arm must be adjusted too. Support-free is possible, people doing skyscraper towns are to some extent cargo culting.

Re:Formlabs Form 4 Teardown by bearjaws on Tuesday June 04, 2024 @11:16AM (#40575474)
From my experience you will have these problems with Form Labs printers. Especially as a novice in resin printing.