News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:This Message Does Not Exist by dfabulich on Sunday June 02, 2024 @01:30AM (#40551607)
I think this is an example of the "answering machine paradox," which philosophers have been writing about since the 1970's.

https://philpapers.org/rec/SIDTAM

> According to an intuitive semantics for 'I,' 'here' and 'now,' 'I am not here now' should always be false when uttered. But occurrences of 'I am not here now' on an answering machine seem to be true (when the speaker is not home).

(If you're interested, you can google for "answering machine paradox" for more takes on it.)

Re:This Message Does Not Exist by tempodox on Sunday June 02, 2024 @04:17AM (#40552409)
This is ludicrous. Failure to distinguish the person (“I”) from their recorded voice does not make a philosophical problem. It's pure and unadulterated stupidity.
Re:This Message Does Not Exist by skyechurch on Sunday June 02, 2024 @07:16AM (#40553166)
Alternatively: placing finger on the peak of Olympus Mons on Martian map

"I am not here now". I'm not seeing the problem.

There are a lot of philosophy 'problems' like this, which leads me to think philosophers lead blessed, problem-free lives.

Re:This Message Does Not Exist by bravetraveler on Sunday June 02, 2024 @07:26AM (#40553211)
> leads me to think philosophers lead blessed, problem-free lives.

I agree, perhaps with the qualification of 'eventually', having been both of these people:

    1) someone born dirt poor who had to spend every waking moment to feed myself
    2) someone who can pontificate in comment sections 
As my life became more blessed I could afford more philosophy.

Those who can't do, teach. Those who can't teach wander philosophically.

Playing with ourselves. Man plans, god laughs. Everyone has a plan until they get hit in the mouth. I could go on.

Re:This Message Does Not Exist by goatlover on Sunday June 02, 2024 @07:27AM (#40553218)
You probably haven't thought deeply about the problems. Usually they expose some issue with our concepts or assumptions. Things we take to be obvious and simple aren't always on careful reflection.
Re:This Message Does Not Exist by adammarples on Sunday June 02, 2024 @08:00AM (#40553403)
They normally expose some problem with our language, and nothing deeper than that. This is a perfect example.
Re:This Message Does Not Exist by vsuperpower2020 on Sunday June 02, 2024 @08:44AM (#40553647)
This may be true, but if it is the canadian journal of philosophy is doing their reputation no favors by publishing the "answering machine paradox". Paradox. Paradox. That's a funny word, isn't it? Paradox.
Re:This Message Does Not Exist by djur on Sunday June 02, 2024 @02:46PM (#40556379)
A paradox is just a statement that is self-contradictory. It doesn't mean a difficult or mind-bending problem as it is sometimes used colloquially.
Re:This Message Does Not Exist by Joker_vD on Friday June 07, 2024 @05:45PM (#40613306)
No, that's pretty much what the word "paradox" used to mean, but logicians of the late XIX–early XX century had hijacked it.

    PARADOX, in philoſophy, a propoſition ſeemingly abſurd,
      as being contrary to to ſome received opinion, but yet true
      in fact.
        No ſcience abounds more with paradoxes than geome-
      try: thus, that a right line ſhould continually approach
      to the hyperbola, and yet never reach it, is a true para-
      dox; and in the ſame manner, a ſpiral may continually
      approach to the point, and yet not reach it, in any number
      of revolutions, however great.

                                 Encyclopaedia Brittanica, 1771,
                                                  Vol. 3, p. 455
Re:This Message Does Not Exist by mannykannot on Sunday June 02, 2024 @09:11AM (#40553819)
On the one hand, these puzzles often arise as counter-examples to a theory within analytical philosophy, and unless you understand what they are a counter-example to, they seem pointless and even ridiculous. For example, when Russell posed his famous paradox to Frege, he was not trying to find out who shaves the barber.

On the other hand, perhaps we should consider whether analytical philosophy, following the linguistic turn [1], is creating problems for itself when it tries to find metaphysical truth by analyzing human language as if it were a formal system. For example, when David Chalmers says "even God could not create a male vixen", is he mistaking an accidental lexicographical fact for a metaphysical insight?

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Linguistic_turn

Re:This Message Does Not Exist by dahart on Sunday June 02, 2024 @09:13AM (#40553833)
Hehe, you’re replying to a comment that exposed issues with the stated assumptions behind the so-called paradox.
Re:This Message Does Not Exist by skyechurch on Sunday June 02, 2024 @09:27AM (#40553927)
I was being glib, of course. Presumably there's some legitimate technical philosophical issue, and actual philosophers are capable of using answering machines and even landline telephones without having all their assumptions about reality collapse around them like a PKD novel (those born prior to 1980, anyway). But, like Jay Z, I've got problems of a more pressing nature, and legitimately don't see how this matters.

(See also the 'Problem' of Induction, which I had to spend a great deal of time on in college, and even after reading centuries of debate about it, is the least problematic 'problem' I've ever encountered. Maybe this is a linguistic issue, and philosophers should stop calling things 'problems' when the rest of us have to make rent.)

Re:This Message Does Not Exist by thecodedmessage on Sunday June 02, 2024 @10:15AM (#40554331)
Math problems are quite similar in this way!
Re:This Message Does Not Exist by skyechurch on Sunday June 02, 2024 @12:19PM (#40555285)
... not the ones involving the rent check.
Re:This Message Does Not Exist by lupire on Sunday June 02, 2024 @02:35PM (#40556288)
If you have problems of a more pressing nature, why are you faffing about on HN?

It smells like you are just mocking people for being interested in thinking about things. Why?

Re:This Message Does Not Exist by vsuperpower2020 on Sunday June 02, 2024 @06:04PM (#40557510)
This is also why people don't like philosophers. You have no monopoly on "thinking about things" and you aren't being mocked for doing that.
Re:This Message Does Not Exist by djur on Sunday June 02, 2024 @02:42PM (#40556356)
The implication here seems to be that people can't think about and discuss philosophical problems and also take care of more immediate physical concerns at the same time. Do you feel that way about other intellectual endeavors without immediate applications, like "pure" science and mathematics?
Re:This Message Does Not Exist by djur on Sunday June 02, 2024 @02:35PM (#40556290)
Do you think that mathematicians are drama queens because "2a = 4, solve for a" is a "math problem"? Just because something is intuitively simple doesn't mean that you don't have to account for it in a formal system. The intuitive solution for a lot of simple questions is incorrect in some cases. (How do you determine the length of a word?)

In your example, "here" is semantically different from the "here" in the answering machine case and doesn't result in a paradox.

Re:This Message Does Not Exist by Y_Y on Sunday June 02, 2024 @06:34AM (#40552987)
When you say "this", I assume you are referring to the message you were writing at the time.
Re:This Message Does Not Exist by BurningFrog on Sunday June 02, 2024 @09:45AM (#40554075)
I think that describes a considerable chunk of the Philosophy field.

But that's of course what an engineer would say.

Re:This Message Does Not Exist by andybak on Sunday June 02, 2024 @11:24AM (#40554894)
I find that the joy many commenters here have in both denigrating philosophysand at the same time proudly demonstrating no interest in knowing anything about it to be one of the more embarrassing things regularly on display.
Re:This Message Does Not Exist by bbarnett on Sunday June 02, 2024 @12:34PM (#40555389)
Oh "anything about it" isn't quite valid, now is it. We see gibberish with nonsensical blather thrown in, and zero logical reasoning behind it. It's not a science.

If you want to tell me it's akin to astrology, or some other pseudo made up framework, fine.

I don't have a problem with fantasy. I have a problem with those telling me it's real.

"I took a series of university classes, where we examined the natural laws in The Land, and Thomas Covenant's ring, and derived a measure of predictive weather patterns! I know science!" <-- philosophy

Re:This Message Does Not Exist by andybak on Sunday June 02, 2024 @12:55PM (#40555523)
I rest my case.
Re:This Message Does Not Exist by bbarnett on Sunday June 02, 2024 @01:25PM (#40555770)
Your case was "that made up 'science' is real, and you can't say no because you haven't studied it for years".

I don't need to study astrology for years, to know it's nonsense in about 10 minutes.

Yet I've hear a lot more philosophical blather than that, and so yes, I have enough data to make a determination.

There's an inner logic to tarot cards, books and books on it, but that doesn't make it useful or valuable.

Re:This Message Does Not Exist by tadala on Sunday June 02, 2024 @02:02PM (#40556059)
Shocking comment. Do you think the scientific method is inbuilt in our DNA or something? Where do you think it all comes from?
Re:This Message Does Not Exist by bbarnett on Sunday June 02, 2024 @02:12PM (#40556129)
You think it comes from philosophy? This is like claiming our democracy comes from God, because he edictorially spoke through ancient kings!
Re:This Message Does Not Exist by djur on Sunday June 02, 2024 @02:18PM (#40556177)
The term "scientific method" is itself a philosophical term (as is "method" in this context). Read, or even skim, this and notice how many of the important figures listed were philosophers:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/History_of_scientific_method

Re:This Message Does Not Exist by Ma8ee on Sunday June 02, 2024 @01:59PM (#40556028)
You very clearly illustrate andybak’s point by showing that you just don’t even know what philosophy is.
Re:This Message Does Not Exist by bbarnett on Sunday June 02, 2024 @02:05PM (#40556081)
So your argument, is that one must spend years studying nonsense, to have an opinion on its worth?

I've already clarified why this is not so. Thus, your main, true disagreement is that you do not agree with my assessment.

Re:This Message Does Not Exist by Ma8ee on Sunday June 02, 2024 @02:12PM (#40556132)
No, my argument is that you lack even a rudimentary understanding what it is all about. You only need some curiosity and an open mind to get that. I’m certain there are something in Wikipedia that can help.
Re:This Message Does Not Exist by bbarnett on Sunday June 02, 2024 @03:52PM (#40556780)
I'm sorry my friend, but Wikipedia cannot help philosophy. Nothing can.
Re:This Message Does Not Exist by Ma8ee on Friday June 07, 2024 @10:28AM (#40609098)
It’s not philosophy that needs help.
Re:This Message Does Not Exist by djur on Sunday June 02, 2024 @02:02PM (#40556056)
Philosophy is not and does not purport to be a 'science'. The fact that philosophers make and discuss propositions that seem incorrect to you does not mean that the field of philosophy is fraudulent or unimportant.
Re:This Message Does Not Exist by sethammons on Sunday June 02, 2024 @03:27PM (#40556620)
> I don't need to study astrology for years, to know it's nonsense in about 10 minutes.

Copernicus deniers didn't need years of study either as their source material said differently.

I'm not saying anything either way on philosophy, I'm simply pointing out that your presented logic there is flawed

Re:This Message Does Not Exist by ryukoposting on Sunday June 02, 2024 @01:34PM (#40555842)
I wouldn't call myself a philosphy expert by any means (love me some Epicurus) but I think the previous commenter is right. As far as philosophical dilemmas go, the answering machine problem is contrived at best.

It relies on a pretty obvious mischaracterization of the situation at hand - there isn't a person saying "I am not here" at all, it's a machine playing a recording. With the necessary context, the dilemma becomes a pretty obvious non-dilemma.

If you're saying we should be willing to explore our minds through philosophical problems, I agree with you. I just think this particular philosophical problem is pretty lame.

Is the conclusion supposed to be that that formal meaning of any particular word is less important than the ability to communicate abstract ideas? That's an interesting notion though I'd argue that notion isn't helped by a half-broken analogy.

Re:This Message Does Not Exist by djur on Sunday June 02, 2024 @02:13PM (#40556142)
"Paradox" and "dilemma" and even "problem" don't have as strong a meaning in philosophy as they do in colloquial English. In this context, the claim is essentially that a particular system of analyzing the truth of statements will incorrectly analyze this particular type of statement. The "paradox" is in the system, not in reality. The paper linked offers a solution for modifying one particular system so that it will correctly resolve the paradox.

The programming analogy would be that processing a particular type of data will often have hidden pitfalls for the most intuitive approach. It might be easy to avoid those pitfalls by modifying your program, but someone had to notice and document the problem and the workaround.

Re:This Message Does Not Exist by tadala on Sunday June 02, 2024 @02:01PM (#40556050)
On the other hand, the other response to OP's comment is a perfect display of what he means. A lot of tech bro hubris/idiocy.
Re:This Message Does Not Exist by ryukoposting on Sunday June 02, 2024 @03:11PM (#40556519)
In that case, let me go a step further: although I wouldn't respond the way some other folks have, I get why they would. Many of my most memorable and most intellectually stimulating classes were those that weren't related to my engineering degree. The philosophy classes, though, never even approached "intellectually stimulating" status. I wrote a good 80-100 pages of pseudointellectual drivel about half-baked analogies like the "answering machine paradox," and accrued thousands in debt in the process.

Another thing: The great thing about Philosophy is that there are no wrong answers. But, the bad thing about philosophy classes is there are wrong answers. Open-endedness and free thinking don't scale to 150-seat lecture halls, indifferent TAs, and PhD-candidate "professors" doing the bare minimum to get a diploma.

Re:This Message Does Not Exist by ordu on Sunday June 02, 2024 @02:00PM (#40556040)
I wouldn't say so. If we mark this a stupidity, then a lier's paradox is a stupidity also. If people could easily deal with such statements and understand them correctly, it doesn't mean there is no problem. Problem arises when you try to devise some formal system describing all the statements, and then you find some more statements and the system doesn't work for them.

Zeno's paradoxes for example show us the weaknesses of Ancient Greek's system of reasoning, the weaknesses of their kid of logic and math. But will have troubles seeing them as paradoxes if they do not know logic at all or if they know modern logic and modern math which solve all of the Zeno's paradoxes (or most of them?). Now Zeno's paradoxes are not paradoxes at all, but the silly mistakes of reasoning.

It reminds me of edge-cases in programming, you designed a beautiful program and then edge-cases started to pop up, you patch your program, patch it some more, and in no time at all your beautiful program becomes a heap of spaghetti code. The only way to avoid it is to code something that you coded before many times and know all the shenanigans allowing you to combine beautiful design with the practical applicability.

Here is the same thing, if you do not know what the system the author uses, you cannot judge if his reasoning stupid or not.

I don't know either, but I believe, that it is an interesting observation. The person said "I'm not here now", and it was obviously false, when they said it, but when answering machine says it the statements becomes true. I'm not sure what the problem is, but I think, that the problem starts biting you hard, when you try to define a set of all such statements and to choose a condition of their truthfulness. Of course, you can use your intuition as a tool for demarcation, but philosophy doesn't work that way, it seeks an objective criteria, preferably a formal one.

Re:This Message Does Not Exist by runlaszlorun on Sunday June 02, 2024 @08:58AM (#40553740)
Absolutely off topic, but does remind me of a Mexican movie ‘I Am No Longer Here’ that I’d seen not long ago was astonishingly good for something I hadn’t heard of.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/I%27m_No_Longer_Here

Re:This Message Does Not Exist by rayval on Sunday June 02, 2024 @10:27AM (#40554443)
By the way, that is a great movie. Or do I say "was"?
Re:This Message Does Not Exist by earth-adventure on Sunday June 02, 2024 @03:07PM (#40556495)
Thats a great movie, if you are just making that statement.

That was a great movie, if you've just finished watching it.

Re:This Message Does Not Exist by croniev on Sunday June 02, 2024 @01:12PM (#40555682)
Many commenters here seem to be hostile towards philosophy. Heres a take for you:

This is only a paradox if you think of language as a way of describing some "real", static state of affairs in the world (look up " correspondence theory of truth"). There is no paradox here if we think of language as pragmatic, action directing, since it is obvious what the sentence should convey (look up "pragmatism"). Some people will argue that there is some sort of static meaning hidden behind the actual words which enters the consciousness of the listener, others will say that the meaning is only generated by the person hearing the words.

This is as philosophical of a question as it gets, and has been debated even more heatedly ever since Wittgenstein.

If you do not see that debating these questions is relevant and interesting, but would rather reduce all of philosophy to that first obvious-seeming and thus "not a real problem" position, then I wish you a good time bathing in your ignorance.

However, if you comprehend that what we take for granted in every area and discipline can be subjected to reasonable reflection, then I welcome you to the dark side. Nothing is clear, no knowledge absolute - many engineers seem to forget this while over-indulging in an overly simplistic world view :)

Re:This Message Does Not Exist by nuancebydefault on Sunday June 02, 2024 @02:02PM (#40556062)
I think it is okay to philosophise about situations and events that seem a bit paradoxal but the explanation is obvious. Even more, that is a core trait of philosophy.

There are many similar situations where what we hear, read or see is technically incorrect. Since the sender (or the activator of an agent) of the message in such case assumes the interpreter has enough common knowledge, it is a perfectly okay communication.

A video tape containing a recording: "your watching this means I'm dead."

A secretary of a company impersonating the company when sending a message to many recipients.

An actor speaking about his character, as if they are somebody they know very well.

Writing that an AI hallucinates.

My car informing me that one of the tyres is low on pressure, even though it does not know what a tyre is, let alone how to measure pressure.

Re:This Message Does Not Exist by HocusLocus on Sunday June 02, 2024 @09:44PM (#40558642)
> [...] My car informing me that one of the tyres is low on pressure [...]

Thank you for putting this in a larger philosophical prospective. For I have something on the next level, a car that tells me "a tire has low pressure", but does NOT tell me which tire it is. I did the best I could to understand why my beloved car would do this, but gave up and had to interpret it as a deliberately malicious act.

My suspicions were confirmed when 1 of 4 sensors (inside the tires) had failed, and the technician read the diagnostic and proceeded directly to the tire in question. I had been desperately holding on to the remote possibility that the car really didn't know which tire has low pressure or which sensor failed, but it told the technician but not me.

I am wondering if it would be best to give the car to the technician to ensure my personal safety. How would the next aspect of this dislike manifest? Most scenarios I can think of result in the car's own suicide, but perhaps it will run me over? Please help.

Signed, LOW TIRE PRESSURE

Re:This Message Does Not Exist by nuancebydefault on Monday June 03, 2024 @03:08PM (#40566302)
Weird that tires have pressure sensors. I really thought that the control unit's logic simply averages rpm values to identify low pressure tires. I'm glad my car informs me which tire it is convinced of to suffer from 'depression'. I already checked that it identified the correct one.
Re:This Message Does Not Exist by IIsi50MHz on Tuesday June 04, 2024 @11:19AM (#40575502)
Two different design philosophies: indirect (not all wheels rotating at a expected speed for current steering), or direct (wireless sensor in the tire).
Re:This Message Does Not Exist by garfieldnate on Monday June 03, 2024 @01:59PM (#40565344)
Lots of linguists only work on static structures, diagramming morphosyntax and semantics of a standalone utterance. All of the fuzzy social context stuff doesn't generally get broken down into a "mathematical" structure in the same way. The piece we're missing here is called "grounding", the mapping of words in the utterance to entities in the context. I think it gets largely ignored because of this study of static structures. I don't know of any generic parsing framework/theory/tool that comes with grounding out-of-the box. It's just not done. Please prove me wrong if you know of a tool that does this. Other keywords are "deictic" and "pragmatics". Generally you only start to worry about grounding when you're doing some kind of robotics or other human-computer interaction and you need a human's words to map to sensor data or something on the screen to understand what the intention is.

As a possible exception, anaphora/cataphora resolution is pretty well-studied and for example is supported in spaCy (https://spacy.io/universe/project/neuralcoref), but this is mapping one word in an utterance to another word in the utterance, rather than to an entity in the context.