Yet I bet most folks who have memorized a poem or a passage---out of an affinity for it, not when demanded by a teacher---know the value. Memorizing something means you can roll it around in your head whenever you want, think about it from this perspective or that, and let the brain really absorb the ideas the words express.
It's good.
That's not to say that people can't memorize things accurately (there are plenty of kids who memorize Bible and Quran verses verbatim for example that can easily disprove that), but memories are fallible in ways that writing isn't, particularly when it comes to comparing sources for accuracy or historical value.
On the other hand, if the objective is to understand and appreciate the source, even simply for personal edification or enlightenment, then I agree completely: memorization is a wonderful technique for doing so.
That's also the reason little credence is given to coders who moan about college CS knowledge being useless memorization of stuff that can easily be looked up when needed.
I heard there are people who memorise the Quran without knowing the slightest bit of Arabic?
And there's also the Kiwi chap, Nigel Richards, who memorised the whole French Scrabble dictionary in order to win the French world Scrabble championship, without learning any French in the process.
(Whether you call what he did to the French word list 'understanding' is up for debate, I guess. I am fairly sure he went much deeper into understanding the underlying probability distributions of letters in French words than most speakers, but he couldn't read a newspaper.)
True, I am doing this myself. 4 days a week and plan to continue for the next 10 years. Memorized several pages so far with a lot more to go without understanding any of it.
In fact, being a Hafiz or your child being a Hafiz is a point of pride.
This in part goes back to Islamic lore/history.
Another part is that there is the belief that there are rewards associated with, being accompanied by angels iirc.
I think the main issue being described in the article and in the comments is that rote memorization like you described is both much harder and also meaningless. In fact, it is much harder because it is meaningless.
So yes, it can be done, but also: why?
People get hung up on the dead past rather than the living present. They say God is unchanging and eternal and neglect that he built an ever-changing universe of entropy for us to live in.
Even the "Gospel" means "Good News" or "Glad Tidings". What good news comes from 2,000 year old texts? It's not news at this point, it's history.
The Good News comes from people today choosing to be better, to do better, to not oppress, to not commit evil acts against others but to do good things to other people, to say kind words from a good heart because they believe in a better world coming tomorrow.
There's lots of stuff in the Bible. Much of it falls under the category you describe, but not all.
> The Good News comes from people today choosing to be better, to do better, to not oppress, to not commit evil acts against others but to do good things to other people, to say kind words from a good heart because they believe in a better world coming tomorrow.
Different people have different interpretations. What you describe sounds nice, but I don't think it's exactly the orthodoxy for many Christians.
Children understand how to get into heaven. Adults are the ones who have problems with it.
Be nice. Be better. Do your best. Apologize when you mess up. Grow.
If God wants more from you, God will tell you personally, in a way that can't be confused with schizophrenic mania or paranoid delusion.
Anything else is part of some hokey religion masquerading as spirituality.
You get in because you're predestined to? Sounds pretty simple to understand.
Or go to heaven because of faith alone, if you subscribe to a different strain of Christianity.
Or go to heaven because of faith and good works, if you subscribe to yet a different strain of Christianity.
Or any number of other interpretations you can find.
I don't think your homebrewn theology is necessarily better (nor worse) than the other guys' versions.
> If God wants more from you, God will tell you personally, in a way that can't be confused with schizophrenic mania or paranoid delusion.
I'm not doing anything at all, and God hasn't told me anything ever. So I guess I'm good by your interpretation?
More importantly, none of the gospels were created during his presumed lifetime.
(For the Christian tradition this seems like a minor difference, but we are exactly talking about oral vs written preservation and transmission here.)
Homer's works are an interesting parallel, because they are believed to have been transmitted orally first, before being written down later.
A similar reference-instance error occurs with the Bible itself: 'the Word of God' is Jesus, not the Bible, the Bible is a pointer to the Word.
Perhaps too much of a digression for this forum.
As to the actual gospel you may be interested in this
You know, until you put it in this context, it hadn't occurred to me how--from some perspectives--"convenient" that is. :)
We have left one on the moon! https://episcopalnewsservice.org/2019/07/19/the-only-bible-o...
Another fun fact is that there is nowhere in the Bible either in the Old or New Testaments that the God had promised to preserve its content and its veracity, only in the Quran that Muslim consider the Last and Final Testament [1][2][3].
Another reason it's a living miracle by the fact that many thousands of these Hafiz don't even understand Arabic but they can read it, just like you can learn Hangul characters in a few days but never understand Korean at all. It is like trying to memorize War and Peace in its original Russian (and French) in its entirety but your only language is Mandarin and the alphabets are totally differents. Heck, even Tolstoy’s wife Sofia who reportedly personally and manually copied the original manuscript twenty one times did not memorize it [4].
[1] https://quran.com/en/al-maidah/48:
"We have revealed to you [O Prophet] this Book with the truth, as a confirmation of previous Scriptures and a supreme authority on them."
[2] https://quran.com/en/an-nisa/82
"Do they not then reflect on the Quran? Had it been from anyone other than Allah, they would have certainly found in it many inconsistencies"
[3] https://quran.com/en/al-hijr/9:
"It is certainly We Who have revealed the Reminder, and it is certainly We Who will preserve it."
[4] Ten Things You Need to Know About War And Peace:
https://www.bbc.co.uk/programmes/articles/5lrPL2vWJG6Th9zmh1...
But the Bible does promise that it will be preserved to the letter regardless:
Isaiah 40:8
The grass withereth, the flower fadeth: but the word of our God shall stand for ever.
Matthew 5:18
For verily I say unto you, Till heaven and earth pass, one jot or one tittle shall in no wise pass from the law, till all be fulfilled.
Again, not a critique, just a curiosity.
This is a generalised critique against most commandments of many religions.
(If the deity didn't want me to commit act X, why is act X even physically possible?)
There are quite a few specific and also generalised responses to this critique. Look for eg "Why does God permit evil?", "Why does God allow suffering?" and similar.)
That's addressed in Job.
There's different answers, even amongst the same religion, but even more across religions.
Btw, you might like https://unsongbook.com/
The Pope Should be more concerned about the Gospel, I think.
You have access to many orders of magnitude more data, but it is substantially slower to access it.
All considered, I'm glad we did the upgrade.
But from this discussion, we see the old man may have been on to something! If understanding something deeply is necessary in order to memorize it well, then one might achieve understanding as a secondary effect by aiming to memorize something by heart.