News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The one-year anniversary of my total glossectomy by jseliger on Sunday May 26, 2024 @08:00PM (#40486415)
You're welcome!

I've been "reading the Internet" since the late '90s with sites like /., and, when I got diagnosed with the death sentence sentence—recurrent and metastatic head and neck cancer—I began looking into clinical trials, and I realized that I'd never read any good descriptions of what clinical trials are like from the patient's perspective.

So my wife and I decided that the thing that we needed to exist in the world didn't exist, and thus we made it. When my wife and I started writing in earnest about the clinical-trial process in particular ("Please be dying, but not too quickly" is the most comprehensive: https://bessstillman.substack.com/p/please-be-dying-but-not-...), I kept expecting someone to leave a comment or send an email saying: "Hey buddy, this has already been done, check it out here: _______." But that comment or email never came. Probably someone else's comprehensive essay and guide exists somewhere, given how big the Internet is, but I've never seen it.

Without having had this kind of experience, I think it's difficult to understand just how difficult and not-user-friendly the clinical-trial process is. If we can help move the needle on that, we might dramatically reduce the number of people who are in a position like mine. Personalized cancer vaccines are so close: https://jakeseliger.com/2024/04/12/moderna-mrna-4157-v90-new..., and I don't understand why the FDA hasn't approved Moderna's mRNA-4157 yet, apart from bureaucratic inertia and indifference to human suffering.

I hope no one who has read our work has to go through a version of what I've been through, or has friends or family who must, but, statistically, given that a couple hundred thousand people have seen it, someone will. And it is better to be equipped with some sense of what to do and how to do it, than to have to try to figure it from scratch. I've wound up emailing guidance to a lot of people about head and neck cancers, and clinical trials.

Re:The one-year anniversary of my total glossectomy by delichon on Sunday May 26, 2024 @08:09PM (#40486461)
I went through terminal cancer with both parents. It's infuriating that with that diagnosis the medical cabinet is open with respect to palliative care, in quantities that make an exit simple. But at the same time they feel the need to protect you from possible treatments. Potential accelerated death? Approved. Potential prolonged life? We'll need more evidence.
Re:The one-year anniversary of my total glossectomy by baggy_trough on Sunday May 26, 2024 @09:19PM (#40486797)
It's especially infuriating that federal restrictions on medical treatment are unlawful to start with (there's no constitutional basis for them).
Re:The one-year anniversary of my total glossectomy by Brybry on Sunday May 26, 2024 @11:48PM (#40487410)
I think the Commerce Clause is a pretty sound basis for most FDA regulation.

It just gets weird with the overbroad supreme court decisions that are like: "well, stuff that only happens in a single state but that might be used for interstate commerce or somehow impact interstate commerce indirectly" is also covered. [1][2]

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gonzales_v._Raich

[2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wickard_v._Filburn

Re:The one-year anniversary of my total glossectomy by baggy_trough on Sunday May 26, 2024 @11:52PM (#40487427)
One can only get from regulating interstate commerce to telling a terminal patient what medicine he may consume by a tortured logical process driven by motivated reasoning.
Re:The one-year anniversary of my total glossectomy by BurningFrog on Sunday May 26, 2024 @09:15PM (#40486767)
> I don't understand why the FDA hasn't approved Moderna's mRNA-4157 yet, apart from bureaucratic inertia and indifference to human suffering.

Both very in character for what FDA does.

Re:The one-year anniversary of my total glossectomy by baggy_trough on Sunday May 26, 2024 @09:17PM (#40486787)
The FDA is the most murderous of American bureaucracies.
Re:The one-year anniversary of my total glossectomy by deprecative on Sunday May 26, 2024 @10:26PM (#40487109)
I'd argue the DoT comes surprisingly close to the FDA. And let's not get started on how backwards the FDA and USDA are with their almost competing near miss regulatory areas.
Re:The one-year anniversary of my total glossectomy by ido on Monday May 27, 2024 @03:48AM (#40488610)
Department of Transport? Surely the DoD (the ones supervising actual murder) are at the top.
Re:The one-year anniversary of my total glossectomy by dredmorbius on Monday May 27, 2024 @09:57AM (#40490744)
The focus of the US military is the accomplishment of military objectives, not on indiscriminate slaughter.

I'm having trouble finding current comprehensive reports on casualties as a consequence of direct US military action, but we can look at the most recent major action, the US-initiated war in Iraq (2003--2011), in which the upper-bound estimate is about 645,000 casualties. That works out to about 80,000 per year. Low-end estimate is about 50,000/year. Note that this is now much reduced.

Highway traffic fatalities in the US are presently just under 50,000/year. Which is to say that peacetime fatalities due to transportation are on the order of total military deaths during a fairly major war. On a sustained basis, vehicles have likely killed more people than US military operations.

Another stat: more people had died from 2000--2019 in US traffic deaths than all US military casualties from both World Wars: <https://www.washingtonpost.com/local/trafficandcommuting/mor...>

Note that military casualties is not total deaths inclusive of all combatants and civilian deaths.

<https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_wars_by_death_toll#Mod...>

<https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Motor_vehicle_fatality_rate_in...>

Re:The one-year anniversary of my total glossectomy by reducesuffering on Monday May 27, 2024 @12:16AM (#40487509)
It is quite the conundrum today that the FDA is criticized harshly on all sides, left and right, for being both too restrictive and too permissive (food ingredient blacklist instead of EU whitelist, approving that Alzheimer's treatment that's probably going to do nothing but grift Medicare for billions of $).

Of course with a large number of food and drugs, they'll always be too restrictive on some things and too permissive on others, but I don't envy their position.

Re:The one-year anniversary of my total glossectomy by citizenpaul on Monday May 27, 2024 @01:25AM (#40487819)
It seems to me trying to look at it objectively. The FDA is in an impossible situation forever.

If they delay drugs they are bureaucratic and indifferent. Filling graveyards, as said.

If they release drugs too fast/unproven then they open the gates to scammers, unethical companies trying to sneak ineffective products they spent too much on, ect. Basically the whole reason the FDA was formed would be in question. Then it sounds self serving but the people in charge will start to ask why do we even have the FDA? Which will drain funding then eventually set us back to the reason the FDA had to be invented in the first place. Snake oil salesmen will run rampant and we will need an agency to prevent dying desperate people being taken advantage of for whatever remaining money they have.

Re:The one-year anniversary of my total glossectomy by A_D_E_P_T on Monday May 27, 2024 @04:05AM (#40488704)
The FDA's position is that it's better for 10,000 patients to die of neglect than have 1 patient die of quackery.

Drug development takes 12 years [1] and costs >$2B (on average) because the FDA requires >99.99% confidence that pharmaceutical companies are not selling quack cures. Do we need that level of confidence? Especially for cancer, is that degree of confidence warranted? Is the process efficient? I think that it would be absurd to even argue these points.

There's legitimate fear of quack medicine and scammers -- and then there's whatever the FDA is gripped by, which seems to me a lot like insanity.

[1] - https://pharmanewsintel.com/features/understanding-us-food-a...

Re:The one-year anniversary of my total glossectomy by WhitneyLand on Monday May 27, 2024 @06:01AM (#40489293)
I can’t see that this is true at all.

I don’t believe the FDA has any such quantitative constraint on approvals. The guidelines are strict, but each is evaluated individually.

There’s no such quota for how many drugs are approved, how many people can die, to say this is the FDAs position is not true.

Is something more desperately needed and deserved by people who re suffering? Of course yes, things should be better.

I’m just saying of the many important problems that need to be solved, the FDA having life death limits is not one of them.

The FDA's position is that it's better for 10,000 patients to die of neglect than have 1 patient die of quackery

Re:The one-year anniversary of my total glossectomy by A_D_E_P_T on Monday May 27, 2024 @06:18AM (#40489379)
lol. It's not an explicit rule. It's their revealed preference. They're incredibly slow to act on approvals, inflexibly demanding of "data" that is difficult to obtain at best and completely unnecessary at worst, and they don't give a damn about the cost. (Both the near-term human cost, and the financial cost -- which goes on to reduce innovation in the drug business, leading to a further toll in human suffering.)

In the end, they've killed an awful lot of people via inaction, lack of urgency, lack of efficiency. But that's okay, because killing people via inaction is not quackery, after all. Better a million die of neglect than another thalidomide, the FDA would say.

Re:The one-year anniversary of my total glossectomy by citizenpaul on Monday May 27, 2024 @12:11PM (#40492106)
Unfortunately this is one of those subjects that turns off people's brain and turns on their emotions. It's disappointing to see so many HN'ers with their pitchforks out on this topic.

All the people on here with advanced degrees got them to kill orphans with drones right? Just like all the doctors they are accusing of killing people went to med school so they could kill people indirectly though policy.

The entire reason the FDA exists is that there is only a tiny sliver of people that can offer any real medical help to a dying person. Yet there are endless streams of con artists that will enthusiastically take the money of a desperate dying person because its easy. Shut off brain forgets that.

Based on my experience the actual solution is greatly expanding the FDA to allow them to be able to handle the highly increased flow of new research and create a central point for dying patients to find and get in programs. Right now they don't have the resources and have to rely on strict bureaucracy. Again the idea that the overwhelming majority of doctors would not jump at the chance to save people rather than put them in the ground slower is absurd.

The FDA needs overhauled so start contacting your senators is pretty much all we can do.

Re:The one-year anniversary of my total glossectomy by A_D_E_P_T on Monday May 27, 2024 @12:55PM (#40492510)
I don't think you understand how the process works.

The FDA's job isn't to hold your hand and get you into scientific research studies.

The FDA mandates certain steps -- the collection of certain data -- before it allows drugs to be marketed. Phase 1 is a safety study, Phase 2 is an efficacy study, and Phase 3 is a broader efficacy study. It is on the companies to collect this data; the FDA merely reviews it. (And then reddit-votes on which drugs to approve, with results that are sometimes funny, sometimes nakedly unethical e.g. flibanserin, and sometimes just ridiculous e.g. aducanumab.)

Having more FDA employees would not speed-up the process by much, as the data collection itself is the arduous bit, nor would it reduce expenses at all.

The best possible thing to do would be to simply get rid of Phases 2 & 3. That's how they did things until the early 1960s -- and, lest we forget, the 40s-60s were known as "the Golden Age" of drug development. Instead of increasingly onerous and expensive trials, allow drugs to be marketed once they're proven safe, and subject them to mandatory postmarketing surveillance.

Besides, that hard-won efficacy data is often interpreted (by the FDA!) in subjective and bizarre ways, so its value is not awfully high. It's not worth the price society is paying for it.

Re:The one-year anniversary of my total glossectomy by BurningFrog on Monday May 27, 2024 @10:11AM (#40490876)
I agree, but I it's important to understand why.

If/when someone dies of something FDA approved, it becomes a big scandal. Heads might roll, funding constrained.

If 10,000 people die from something that an unapproved treatment could cure, it's not news at all. People have always been from that.

FDA, like any organization, responds to incentives and does what's best for it.

Re:The one-year anniversary of my total glossectomy by sam2426679 on Monday May 27, 2024 @04:04AM (#40488693)
> I hope no one who has read our work has to go through a version of what I've been through

I’ve had a partial glossectomy for the same PD-L1 negative cancer and have been reading your posts since before I was metastatic recurrent. I think about you relatively often. (I might have even seen you at UCSF a ~couple months ago, but I didn’t want to awkwardly ask if you were the guy from the internet.)