News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Google Meet rolls out multi-device adaptive audio merging by buro9 on Sunday May 26, 2024 @01:28PM (#40483859)
If Meet did "autorecord" combined with "autoshare recording with recipients" (specifically including Google Group recipients)... then it would be perfect.

As it is, we're gradually shifting more things to Zoom where that's either part basic functionality, or part easy to automate as things like Zapier are well integrated into the API.

We only use Meet for team meetings now, and we did use Gong.io to solve the above... but Gong is pretty expensive just to allow those who were out that week to catch up on a recording when they're back and if they care to.

Re:Google Meet rolls out multi-device adaptive audio merging by samcheng on Sunday May 26, 2024 @01:34PM (#40483903)
Hmm. We natively record and transcribe many meetings via Meet. Maybe it’s a function of the plan we’re on?

I wouldn’t want “autorecord” though - it’s better for culture and rapport to not feel like every conversation is “on the record.”

Re:Google Meet rolls out multi-device adaptive audio merging by PeterStuer on Sunday May 26, 2024 @03:16PM (#40484616)
You might be surprised finding out that nearly all meetings are recorded by one or more participants for transcription, automatic notes, summaries and action points.
Re:Google Meet rolls out multi-device adaptive audio merging by buro9 on Sunday May 26, 2024 @01:45PM (#40483978)
Well I'd hope that's a property of a specific meeting and not all meetings, but team weeklies where those not present want to catch up, and the recording is only going to those regular attendees (members of a specific Google Group)... sure, that's a thing we would like to have.
Re:Google Meet rolls out multi-device adaptive audio merging by nicd on Sunday May 26, 2024 @01:53PM (#40484043)
Not sure what Gong's pricing is, but we evaluated a few different notetakers and settled on https://fireflies.ai/. $18 / month gets a recording and summary sent out to all invitees to the calendar invite, uploaded into Hubspot, etc. Very valuable for our sales calls.
Re:Google Meet rolls out multi-device adaptive audio merging by adobrawy on Sunday May 26, 2024 @04:41PM (#40485201)
Meeting recordings are available in Google Apps Script.

Autosharing can be easily solved by simple Google Apps Script. I scan my personal calendar and share recording to Slack channel when I detect group meeting with recording available. Mail me, so I can arrange something for you.

Autorecording - yeah, this is missing. There is paid Chrome Extension which do that, but I have never tested it.

Re:Google Meet rolls out multi-device adaptive audio merging by prmoustache on Monday May 27, 2024 @03:57AM (#40488654)
I record all meetings locally regardless of the tool with OBS. But that is only useful to me as I don't ask for authorization and not sharing them. It is only because I know my mind will sometimes drift and I want to be able to replay part of the meeting.

Having said that, so many people don't record meeting I or someone else can't attend. This is annoying. It should be automatized so that if you miss part or all of a meeting you can still watch the record as long as you were invited.

Re:Google Meet rolls out multi-device adaptive audio merging by walthamstow on Monday May 27, 2024 @07:08AM (#40489650)
That's a great idea to record locally. Do you keep a deep history or wipe after 30/90/365 days? Do you need any special hardware for it?

My memory is not great. I'm starting to have more calls with clients and it would be great to have a record rather than trying to take notes and conduct a conversation at the same time.

> It should be automatized so that if you miss part or all of a meeting you can still watch the record as long as you were invited

People generally don't like knowing that everything they say is being recorded

Re:Google Meet rolls out multi-device adaptive audio merging by prmoustache on Monday May 27, 2024 @12:51PM (#40492469)
> That's a great idea to record locally. Do you keep a deep history or wipe after 30/90/365 days? Do you need any special hardware for it?

If there is anything I want to keep, I will usually take notes but sometimes I cut the small part I need and store it in a special folder. I just wipe once in a while the main "obs" directory, every other week or so. if I haven't felt the need to play back a video, I doubt it will in the future so I don't keep a lot of retention, it is pretty much only to help me when I am getting distracted or multitasking during a meeting. Most of the time when I feel the need to play back the video, it is immediately after the meeting because I know something important had been said but wasn't 100% focused and want to be sure I haven't missed anything.

But I don't have lots of meeting, a handful a week usually. I don't need special hardware, obs seems to be heavily multithreaded. It might hurt the battery usage if I am not plugged but no core is going very high in term of cpu and I don't feel any slowness. I am recording in the 2500/160kbps veryfast(medium CPU usage, standard quality) setting at 1080p, it takes like 1MB every 3 seconds.

Re:Google Meet rolls out multi-device adaptive audio merging by ssl-3 on Monday May 27, 2024 @01:28PM (#40492816)
Recording meetings with OBS is pretty simple.

The process is exactly like that of streaming a computer game along with local microphone audio, except one pushes the "Start Recording" button instead of the "Start Streaming" button inside of OBS. There's got to be a million (or more) howtos written on the subject.

Hardware-wise, it's pretty straight forward: GPUs (including the ones that are a part of most non-Xeon Intel CPUs) have been up to the task of realtime video compression for around a decade or maybe more, which allows for the heavy lifting to be done in specialized silicon.

A bigger concern than the technical practicality might be legal concerns that generally surround audio recording.

For instance: In my state, I am permitted to record any conversation that I am a participant in -- I don't need permission from anyone but myself, and I don't need to notify anyone.

But in the US alone, there's also 49 other states worth of laws on the subject, and they can vary quite a lot.