> Be angry and do not sin; do not let the sun go down on your anger, and give no opportunity to the devil (Ephesians 4:26).
And some additional reading of interested: https://www.ccef.org/be-angry-and-do-not-sin
A Tibetan teacher liked to say that westerners think that Buddhism is all calm and peaceful, and that compassion is soft and gentle, but when we're talking about waking up to the true nature of reality a slap in the face could be an act of compassion. It's just that most of us aren't awake enough to judge when a slap is compassionate, so we should probably not do that at the beginning of the path!
[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Five_Tath%C4%81gatas#Elements_...
[2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kleshas_(Buddhism)#Five_poison...
The excellent Youtube Channel "Religion for Breakfast" touched on this subject toward the end of his "Buddhism Has a Lot of Hells" video[1], where he explained that it's a case of orientalism (in the 'Edward Saïd' sense). In this case, since Buddhism was mostly imported in the west by hippy-style counter-culture movements, and since it was presented as an alternative to judeo-christian values, there was a tendency to omit things (like the concept of hell and damnation) that wasn't deemed foreign (to western culture) enough.
If one is interested in the history of religion, then I heartily recommend both "Religion for Breakfast" and "Let's talk Religion" Youtube Channels, they are truly amazing both in breadth and in quality.
Like it says on Wikipedia, by the Buddhist teaching, they are "poisons", and this also means that it is "poison".
I agree with what you say, there are skillful and unskillful ways to relate to all things that arise.
There are different kinds of anger. I have not doubt that some are useful, some are damaging, and some are both at the same time.
I think one kind of anger that can be particularly damaging is cited in the parent comment here. It's a chronic anger that was formed in childhood and accompanies a person through life looking for new threats, targets, and sources of outrage. I've known people holding that kind of anger, I've also been that person at least sometimes, and yes it's damaging to oneself and others. Profoundly maladaptive. A way to sabotage yourself, your relationships and your livelihood. That's a chronic anger.
But there are other forms of anger that might be momentary, and come up when something is going wrong that should be stopped. Maybe anger is the wrong term, but I'm talking about a sense of "this is wrong, and I'm going to intervene now." Sure, that can misfire, but it can also be useful and prevent a lot of harm.
It’s fine to have learned to get angry when witnessing injustice. Sometimes it is the best solution to be loud and noisy. And sometimes scaring a person is the only solution I know.
In a gestalt session at an anger management therapist, I told myself that there is always better solutions, I just don’t always know them yet.
That's exactly the Six Realms conception of hell beings. They are not in Naraka because they had done something bad and being punished for it, so much as, being consumed by anger, wanting to punish others, leaves them in a place of living in hell. There is both "hot" Naraka and "cold" Naraka, just as anger can run hot or cold.
There are two sides to every teaching. The Buddhas teaching may be touted as universal by the doctrine of the teaching itself, but for me it was destructive. Though as always I await a chorus of followers to tell me I was “doing it wrong”
Always thinking "broken cookie" when frustrations bubble up makes it a lot easier to not lash out at people around you and instead address the underlying issues.
Childish anger has an untamed destructive element. But the answer is to let anger grow and mature with the rest of your psyche. Not banish it and pretend it doesn’t exist. If you banish your anger, how could it possibly mature?
I don't think "avoided" is the right term for these teachings, but the emotion itself is generally not fruitful, particularly since it urges you to dwell on it. Injustice should be addressed because it's unjust, not because you're angry at the injustice. What does the anger add to the equation? Maybe motivation? Maybe it's important to explore why the injustice by itself is not sufficiently motivating.
Anger draws attention toward what’s important - for both ourselves and others. It says “hey! Something isn’t right here, and letting it slide wouldn’t feel right!”. It is a constant voice reminding you what you love and what you would sacrifice for that love.
There’s a lot of talk in certain communities about boundary setting. But I see boundaries as a natural part of the domain of anger. Boundaries are only hard to set if you either don’t hear your own anger internally, or don’t let that anger be expressed into the world.
Even if you know what matters to you, anger can still be a wonderful tool to communicate your desires and intentions to others. If a homeless person starts creeping on to my partner in the street, I’d almost certainly reach for anger when I tell them that they need to cut that out. It’s a powerful, direct way to speak straight from my lizard brain to theirs. Seems ridiculous to take that tool out of your toolbox.
An autistic friend said something to me a few years ago that changed my perspective on it completely. She said “Seph, I never know with you whether you’re actually calm or you just seem calm. It’s like you’re an oven and whenever I stick my hand in, the oven feels cold. But then one day the house will suddenly be on fire”. I thought I was helping by suppressing my anger, but it was actually stressing her out because she couldn’t calibrate. People want to know if they’re doing something that’s pissing you off so they can decide if they’re going to cut it out. Now, sometimes I think of it as “oh, I feel about a 2 out of 10 anger now. What does 2/10 anger look like?” - and then I try to communicate that. If the situation gets better, my anger dissipates and I relax. If the situation gets worse, fine, now we go up to a 4 out of 10 or something. And I try to express that. My voice and posture change, and I do the human equivalent of growling.
My friends point is that predictability is a virtue. People hate it when you’re angry all of a sudden, out of nowhere. But they weirdly like it when things escalate and deescalate naturally. To do that, it’s important to be able to accurately communicate exactly how angry you feel along the way so people know where they stand with you. (Even, and especially if that’s just a very slight 1/10 frustration).
It’s a skill as much as it’s an emotion. I wish people practiced their anger more.
I don't know who your teacher was, and I'm sure their motivation was coming from a good place, but I have to say that I think they were wrong about that. Was it a Theravada tradition perhaps?
Anger itself is not bad, but reacting out of anger unskillfully is. Yes, the Buddha many times all over the Pali cannon says to abandon anger, that it is a poison, but that doesn't mean that we should generate aversion for it. How can we abandon aversion if we don't look at our anger directly?
At the beginning we might have to put it aside, but we'll always have to come back to it and deal with it at some point. One of my teachers told a story that sort of relates to this in one of his talks, just to emphasize that we need to look at these emotions and deal with them directly. In case people are interested, it starts after the opening meditation at about the 20 minute mark: https://phuntsok.org/media/Meditation-NYC/080417_Healingthet...
Christianity has both the idea of anger as a deadly sin and the concept of righteous anger.
Anger, just like any other human emotion is neither good nor bad. Prescribing a human emotion as good and another human emotion as bad takes a certain degree of self righteousness. After some growing up, I've since learned to try and let my emotions guide me rather than run away from them and that's made all of the difference.
Addressing the problem that lead to anger, or moving away from what causes would.
Sorry to hear that you encountered buddhist practitioners who made you think that. Don't think shame is part of buddhist teaching. However, this kind of techniques quite common across all religious zealots, buddhist or not.
Unfortunately, in modern day life, the power anger gives us is generally useless, so we are paying the price for nothing.
As I understand it, anger is wrong just as pain is wrong in that it’s a sign that something is wrong. Touch a hot object and you instinctively know it was a bad idea, but anger doesn’t come with the same innate revulsion. To be angry at yourself for feeling angry is missing the point, anger isn’t the failing it’s the notification of failure.
/not a practicing Buddhist
You can also impact the outside world to address the situation, but the situation and how you feel about the situation are different matters.
Sorry if the above is incoherent, I’m operating on little sleep.
The closest I could come up with is it might make your body language more convincing. But it’s not hard to fake being angry.
"You will not be punished for your anger, you will be punished by your anger."
bu also: "You will not be punished for your anger, you will be punished for making other people angry too."
EDIT: proof is if I say anger is normal, it's not good or bad it's just part of what we are, it's simply that our societies that are based on the fiction of the merciful god - especially in the US - have decided to treat it like a bug in the system, there are some fluctuations in the votes that this comment receives.
If I said the same thing about sadness or fear or joy or surprise, nobody would have found it controversial.
Even though sadness kills a lot of people every year (and fear makes people angry, many angry people are simply scared).
I would think that if we could easily quantify anger, then measure protests over the years, we'd discover that as time goes on they get less angry. Hell, some of them today seem almost depressed and despondent.
Maybe punishing anger is a good thing. But we shouldn't pretend we're not doing it.
Anger plays a big role in what we humans are, just like fear, sadness or joy.
> A lot of people make a career out of anger
A lot of people make careers out of being good at killing or at criminal behavior in general, doesn't mean that societies encourage it.
I wrote in the edit of the original comment (and fear makes people angry, many angry people are simply scared)
Yet nobody thinks that fear is bad or should be eradicated from society or you should take fear management classes if you're scared.
another take is that in competitive and adversarial society, anger is natural response to outside hostile action, and the goal is to use it as a source of focus to push back on hostility, but in calculated and cold blooded way. Anger releases lots of hormones which could be very useful in difficult situation if one can control himself.
"You will not be punished for your anger, you will be punished by your anger."
This saying is supposed to be from Buddha's teachings. I remember having an immediate talk with my friend, almost breaking down, thinking about all the years behind that I have been trying to tame this.