Re:Google's Moonshot Factory Falls Back Down to Earth
by julianpye on Thursday May 23, 2024 @08:44AM
(#40454008)
My former boss (CTO of a large multinational Electronics company) once explained to me that 'true' (unrestrained) R&D is only possible if you have a monopoly and want to lower your margins to avoid antitrust scrutiny.
This rings true to me. It also signals that Google is now entering a phase of real competition.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Google's Moonshot Factory Falls Back Down to Earth
by hifromwork on Thursday May 23, 2024 @11:41AM
(#40456102)
I think you present opinion of your former boss as if it were a fact.
Another commenter added some examples, I'll also add the whole public sector (research institutes, univerisities) and some governmental orgs. I did a lot of "pure" R&D (in the public sector and close vicinity) and never worked in a company even close to a monopoly.
Re:Google's Moonshot Factory Falls Back Down to Earth
by boojums on Friday May 24, 2024 @02:44AM
(#40463530)
A functional government has a monopoly on violence. Funding public sector R&D is tax money well spent, but it's still monopoly money.
Re:Google's Moonshot Factory Falls Back Down to Earth
by JackFr on Thursday May 23, 2024 @10:02AM
(#40454869)
> 'true' (unrestrained) R&D is only possible if you have a monopoly
* Bell Labs
* IBM Thomas J. Watson Research Center
* Xerox Parc
I always felt when DoJ was suing Microsoft for antitrust the best evidence of their monopoly was that Microsoft Research had started spitting out good work.
I think you're onto something wrt Google.
Re:Google's Moonshot Factory Falls Back Down to Earth
by rangestransform on Thursday May 23, 2024 @06:53PM
(#40460857)
well i'm glad it happened this way, rather than overzealous legislators ending the gravy train
it's so much more fulfilling to work on moonshot robotics compared to showing ads to people more efficiently