News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Tesla's Sales in Europe Fall to a 15-Month Low by ArtTimeInvestor on Wednesday May 22, 2024 @02:20PM (#40444230)
Tesla is all about self-driving now.

And they don't offer that in Europe.

As far as I know, there is no self-driving in Europe at all. No Tesla, no Waymo, no nothing.

Will Europe fall behind with self-driving like it did with the internet?

There are a similar number of cars on the road in Europe and the US. About 250 million. I wonder how much they are driven? Maybe one hour per day? That would be 250M*365 = 91B man hours per year. If we value an hour at $20, that is $1.8T per year which can be automated. That is about 10% of the European GDP. Plus many other benefits of self-driving cars, like more public space because fewer cars are needed, and they can park outside the center.

Re:Tesla's Sales in Europe Fall to a 15-Month Low by marcinzm on Wednesday May 22, 2024 @02:33PM (#40444438)
Europeans have already solved this problem without need for non-existent technology. It's called public transportation. That's why Americans spend 101 minutes per day driving on average while Germans spend 36.

Imagine how much more GDP the US would have had if they had done that...

edit: Of course, Europeans also use that extra time to enjoy life versus driving GDP that due to increasing wealth inequality won't benefit them in any tangible way.

Re:Tesla's Sales in Europe Fall to a 15-Month Low by ArtTimeInvestor on Wednesday May 22, 2024 @02:40PM (#40444551)
Which problem has been solved?

There are 250M cars on the road in Europe. Clogging up public space and requiring human labor to be driven around. There are cars everywhere in Germany.

Re:Tesla's Sales in Europe Fall to a 15-Month Low by marcinzm on Wednesday May 22, 2024 @02:42PM (#40444573)
The US has 280m with half the population.
Re:Tesla's Sales in Europe Fall to a 15-Month Low by ArtTimeInvestor on Wednesday May 22, 2024 @02:50PM (#40444667)
Public transport has pros and cons.

A self-driving car can take you exactly from where you are to where you want to go. Right now.

Public transport requires you to walk to an entry point, wait and then walk to your destination.

Self-driving cars will make things way more efficient. Similar how TCP/IP packets are more efficient than TV broadcasts, which required you to plan when to watch what and then wait for it.

So if you propose that Europe should try to achieve efficiency via more public transport, I think that is a losing battle. Electric self-driving cars are the future.

Re:Tesla's Sales in Europe Fall to a 15-Month Low by marcinzm on Wednesday May 22, 2024 @03:22PM (#40445098)
> Self-driving cars will make things way more efficient.

Road capacity has a physical limit. Unlike data you cannot convert cars into light of various wavelengths to pack more into the same physical space. Well you can but that's called public transit. In other words, public transportation has a higher capacity per road/rail area than cars ever will. We don't live in the metaverse after all.

As a result more people using cars (self-driving or not) means you hit the road capacity much more often. That means more congestion and longer trips. Any efficiency you gain by going point-to-point is utterly lost in the increased congestion and traffic.

As the other person noted, European cities are much denser and have significantly less road area than US cities. Thus more cars means significantly less efficiency as you spend more time in traffic.

Re:Tesla's Sales in Europe Fall to a 15-Month Low by ArtTimeInvestor on Wednesday May 22, 2024 @03:37PM (#40445338)
So what do you expect? That cars will continue to be manually operated and that the number of cars on the road will go down due to better public transport?
Re:Tesla's Sales in Europe Fall to a 15-Month Low by marcinzm on Wednesday May 22, 2024 @03:50PM (#40445512)
That's an odd straw man. I'd appreciate you not put words in my mouth. You're claiming that self-driving cars are better than public transit and will replace public transit in Europe (assuming they were available). I'm merely saying they won't because that is an inferior solution. I said nothing about manual cars or the shift of manual to self-driving for the segment that does drive cars.
Re:Tesla's Sales in Europe Fall to a 15-Month Low by pornel on Wednesday May 22, 2024 @03:07PM (#40444881)
In European cities it's often the opposite:

- A train will take you right into the city center, sometimes even where cars are not allowed. OTOH entering the city from suburbia can take an hour of being stuck in traffic.

- metro and trams can skip traffic. Bus lanes are common. There are no "stroads". Average car speed in London is 12mph. That's slower than a bike.

- Finding a parking place can easily take longer than waiting for public transport, and it will probably be an underground garage, far away from your destination. Bus stops are much denser than parking garages, so they usually involve less walking.

The US experience of driving on an 8-lane highway and arriving at a mandatory-parking-quota asphalt desert in front of your destination is rare in Europe. The closest we get is a 3-lane motorway to an IKEA on the city outskirts.

Re:Tesla's Sales in Europe Fall to a 15-Month Low by ArtTimeInvestor on Wednesday May 22, 2024 @03:22PM (#40445104)
With self-driving cars, there is no "finding a parking place". You just exit and the car drives on to the next customer.

And without parking cars, streets become wider. Single lane becomes double lane.

Re:Tesla's Sales in Europe Fall to a 15-Month Low by pornel on Wednesday May 22, 2024 @04:48PM (#40446331)
Double lanes are still orders of magnitude less efficient than trains.

In some dense European cities there's physically not enough road surface to put every traveller in a car, self-driving or not.

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Route_capacity#/media/File%3...

Re:Tesla's Sales in Europe Fall to a 15-Month Low by marcinzm on Wednesday May 22, 2024 @03:41PM (#40445385)
So basically make the urban environment a sea of constant fast driving cars filling all available space. There's a reason a lot of cities are converting roads and urban centers into non-car area. Parking and car lanes replaced with bike paths and green areas. It's a much better quality of life. Which, oddly, some people prefer to a 1800s style corporate dystopia where most people's miserable lives are nothing but a means to drive ever more wealth to an elite minority.
Re:Tesla's Sales in Europe Fall to a 15-Month Low by zihotki on Thursday May 23, 2024 @09:20AM (#40454358)
This is EU, it would rather become a cycling path or some sort of park/recreational zone.
Re:Tesla's Sales in Europe Fall to a 15-Month Low by thefz on Thursday May 23, 2024 @01:27AM (#40450784)
Not having half of the population morbidly obese in EU somehow makes walking 5 minutes less of a problem.
Re:Tesla's Sales in Europe Fall to a 15-Month Low by joshl32532 on Wednesday May 22, 2024 @02:40PM (#40444548)
Just wait 10-20 years when self-driving is the norm, it will reduce congestions caused by human's behavior and accidents.
Re:Tesla's Sales in Europe Fall to a 15-Month Low by Ekaros on Wednesday May 22, 2024 @03:13PM (#40444964)
I will always argue that self-driving will increase congestions. There are so many behaviours that are on individual level superior, but on large scale worse. Send car to park somewhere cheaper doubling the number of trips. Have it circle around waiting to pick you up... And as felt cost of just sitting in car goes down, time spend in car can go up.
Re:Tesla's Sales in Europe Fall to a 15-Month Low by dilyevsky on Thursday May 23, 2024 @01:47AM (#40450908)
It will probably nearly eliminate individual car ownership which will free up a ton of real estate currently used for parking. Which will probably reduce congestion inside the cities. It may also reduce highway congestion because we can engineer it such that it knows how drive unlike most people on the roads today
Re:Tesla's Sales in Europe Fall to a 15-Month Low by marcinzm on Wednesday May 22, 2024 @02:46PM (#40444629)
How exactly will it reduce congestion? The cars are the same size. The trips are the same and are likely to go up in frequency with self-driving. The roads are the same as before. If anything you will have a ton more congestion. The vast majority of congestion is due to not enough capacity and too much demand. Right now that is caped due to the time you waste driving but if it's self-driving then the sky is the limit.

Public transportation increases the potential commuter density per area of road/rail while self-driving doesn't.

Re:Tesla's Sales in Europe Fall to a 15-Month Low by warcher on Wednesday May 22, 2024 @03:37PM (#40445339)
I think self driving and public transport are actually complimentary. The principal benefits of owning your own automobile are convenience, as it’s always available for your use, and range— it will go wherever you want. Enabling vast fleets of on demand taxis is already well underway, making owning your own vehicle less attractive. The next step imho is bundling rides together, making NOT owning your car cheaper still. For urban cores, I would expect shared self driving to crowd out private cars pretty quickly.
Re:Tesla's Sales in Europe Fall to a 15-Month Low by bryanlarsen on Wednesday May 22, 2024 @03:03PM (#40444829)
I highly doubt self-driving is going to reduce congestion. Self-driving makes driving more convenient & useful, so people are going to use it more.
Re:Tesla's Sales in Europe Fall to a 15-Month Low by TheLoafOfBread on Wednesday May 22, 2024 @03:51PM (#40445529)
And it is also inefficient because it is used in cars taking 4 passengers max so it can not really scale.

But if a bus, a tram or a train would have a self driving... but that smells like communism to our techbros from Silicon Valley.

Re:Tesla's Sales in Europe Fall to a 15-Month Low by lm28469 on Wednesday May 22, 2024 @02:51PM (#40444681)
> Just wait 10-20 years

Musk said in 2 years, in 2012. Two more weeks brothers, two more weeks ... lol

Re:Tesla's Sales in Europe Fall to a 15-Month Low by mackman on Wednesday May 22, 2024 @02:28PM (#40444332)
Mercedes launched level 3 autonomous vehicles in Germany a year or two ago I thought?

https://www.caranddriver.com/reviews/a39966189/2022-mercedes...

Re:Tesla's Sales in Europe Fall to a 15-Month Low by ArtTimeInvestor on Wednesday May 22, 2024 @02:43PM (#40444588)
I have seen nothing that indicates that Mercedes stands a chance to catch up with Tesla.

All I have seen Mercedes do could have been accomplished by manual programming. But manual programming does not scale. Look at the progress Tesla made from FSD 11 to FSD 12. Nothing indicates that Mercedes is capable of this type of progress.

Re:Tesla's Sales in Europe Fall to a 15-Month Low by f1refly on Wednesday May 22, 2024 @03:26PM (#40445168)
I believe Mercedes takes full responsibility for its self driving cars while Tesla will still disengage autopilot like 1 second before impact and claim it's the drivers fault? Essentially, drivers legally have to be on full alert at all times in a Tesla while they can kick back and watch a movie during the ride in a Mercedes.
Re:Tesla's Sales in Europe Fall to a 15-Month Low by rurp on Wednesday May 22, 2024 @05:31PM (#40446855)
Right, even when FSD plows right into a solid object Tesla will try to pin 100% of the blame on the human driver. On top of all of the other reasons to not take Tesla's marketing BS seriously, their total lack of ownership of their own autonomous system should prevent anyone from taking their claims seriously.

That and the fact that Elon has spent the last decade saying they're 6-12 months from actual full self driving.

Re:Tesla's Sales in Europe Fall to a 15-Month Low by dzhiurgis on Tuesday May 28, 2024 @02:16AM (#40497861)
Look at 30 minute test drives at californian coastal city roads.

Tesla - 0 disengagements.

MB - 50 disengagements.

This is not even fair comparison. MB can take all the responsibility they want when no one is going to use their system.

Re:Tesla's Sales in Europe Fall to a 15-Month Low by Fischgericht on Wednesday May 22, 2024 @02:50PM (#40444662)
Yes, now it will no longer kill 40% of school children crossing the road, but only 39%.

LOOK AT THE PROGRESS!!!1

And with FSD 34 it will be able to take the easiest highway exit ramp there is on this planet, Mountain View on HWY101, without killing you.

And what does "manual programming" even mean? Do you REALLY believe the xbox360-grade hardware in the tesla is doing AI inferencing? It's not. It's a heuristic.

Re:Tesla's Sales in Europe Fall to a 15-Month Low by jfim on Wednesday May 22, 2024 @03:59PM (#40445639)
They are doing inferencing on the vehicle for lane keeping, traffic sign detection, emergency braking, etc.

The biggest problem is really how do you get to 10^n miles per disengagement, for n>=5. Waymo is kinda getting there, Tesla isn't anywhere near that today.

Getting there is really hard, because that's when you get all of the long tail events like bears, moose, wild turkeys, horse mounted police officers, costume conventions, pickup trucks carrying traffic cones and road signs, flooded streets, construction pilot cars, vehicles driving the wrong way on the highway, downed electric poles, NYC steam plumes, and tons of other scenarios. Highway driving in nice and sunny conditions is easy compared to that.

Re:Tesla's Sales in Europe Fall to a 15-Month Low by Fischgericht on Wednesday May 22, 2024 @06:46PM (#40447698)
I am not sure how much really is done via inferencing, if at all. Just the way how "Tesla Vision" behaves in a parking garage does simply not look like what I would expect to come out of inferencing. It looks very, very, very much like a pretty bad heuristic. Just look what it makes out of blind spots, the parts the cameras can't see. There is absolutely nothing like "according to my model, there should be X on this spot". The same goes for their distancing sensing in these situations. "Oh, there is a pipe on that wall, which likely has difference distance to me than the wall. I might not wanna crash into that" is trivial on a level that nobody would even use that as a Captcha these days. A model that does not "know" what the third dimension is?

Do you know of any reverse engineering that proves that there really is running anything in regards of inferencing on the NPUs?

Also, just as you said - there are tons of corner cases in the real world, especially once you aren't on a 10-lane US highway which has been designed for monster trucks driven by 16 year olds (no offence) but one of the roundabouts of hell in Paris.

Where would the training data been coming from?

So, I have my doubts.

During summer, there is a red flower growing near the entrance of my parking garage. It constantly is seen as a red light, and the entrance of my garage is often mistaken for a huge truck suddenly magically appearing. Again: Nobody would use a Captcha these days: "Is this a red flower or a traffic light?".

Again, smells like heuristic. "Amount of red pixels in a certain form and spot".

Re:Tesla's Sales in Europe Fall to a 15-Month Low by jfim on Friday May 24, 2024 @02:17AM (#40463360)
Oh I see what you mean.

Typically, inference in a machine learning context means feeding a model some input and looking at its output. I'm pretty sure that they are running some model on the vehicle that takes pixels as input and says this part of the image is a car/truck/traffic sign/lane line/etc. It might be misclassifying things (eg. the flower as a red light), but would still be running some kind of model.

As you point out though, the model only seems to do some simple object detection, but doesn't have much of an understanding of what it sees (eg. does it make sense that there would be a traffic light at this location). There are plenty of videos of it getting confused by all kinds of situations (eg this one from a few years ago https://www.businessinsider.com/tesla-fsd-full-self-driving-... ).

Re:Tesla's Sales in Europe Fall to a 15-Month Low by Pingk on Wednesday May 22, 2024 @02:42PM (#40444570)
Self-driving in Europe is more problematic in a couple of ways.

Firstly the road structure is very different to the US, streets are much narrower and less car-centric so models are harder to train; secondly regulating it is much harder because the EU is a collection of countries, which is very different to a collection of states.

Thirdly non-car alternatives like trains and ebikes are a lot more viable due to a higher population density, many big cities (such as Paris) are pushing for better cycling infrastructure rather than better layouts for cars.

Re:Tesla's Sales in Europe Fall to a 15-Month Low by jfim on Wednesday May 22, 2024 @02:29PM (#40444369)
Argo AI used to be in that space in Europe, in collaboration with VW commercial vehicles and MOIA, until about a year and a half ago.

I believe VW still has a group working on this.

Re:Tesla's Sales in Europe Fall to a 15-Month Low by UncleOxidant on Wednesday May 22, 2024 @02:27PM (#40444330)
Isn't Mercedes ahead of Tesla in self driving tech?
Re:Tesla's Sales in Europe Fall to a 15-Month Low by ripjaygn on Wednesday May 22, 2024 @02:35PM (#40444467)
It's not. Mercedes just follows the car in front and even that in very limited scenarios. It's just used as an anti-Tesla talking point on the internet, so lots of people believe what you said.
Re:Tesla's Sales in Europe Fall to a 15-Month Low by k8sToGo on Wednesday May 22, 2024 @02:27PM (#40444325)
Europe already has self driving to a degree. Mercedes was faster than Tesla.
Re:Tesla's Sales in Europe Fall to a 15-Month Low by Fischgericht on Wednesday May 22, 2024 @02:28PM (#40444341)
Of course they are selling it in Europe:

https://www.tesla.com/de_DE/autopilot

But this feature simply does not exist. It's a myth spread by Tesla fan boys who do not want to admit they got screwed over.

To be clear: If I drive a very easy street through my town, which is near a school, my Tesla - just like EVERY Tesla - is able to detect about 90% of trash bins on the side of the road (impressive detection rate), but only about 60% of pupils crossing the road.

If I would use Tesla's "full self driving" feature, I would be on average killing about 20 school children EVERY SINGLE MORNING.

So, no, it's not that.

Re:Tesla's Sales in Europe Fall to a 15-Month Low by brandonagr2 on Wednesday May 22, 2024 @02:45PM (#40444612)
And yet billions of miles have been driven on FSD, there is no epidemic of mowing down school children, and Tesla is ranked as having the best automatic emergency braking in the industry ( https://www.forbes.com/sites/johnkoetsier/2022/09/07/tesla-m... )
Re:Tesla's Sales in Europe Fall to a 15-Month Low by Fischgericht on Wednesday May 22, 2024 @03:00PM (#40444786)
"Says Elon."

There is absolutely no actual data to verify this claim. How would you know how many "billions" of miles have been driven with "FSD"?

Tesla isn't publishing any data. They just have been caught actually hiding crash report data to the NHTSA.

"My" anecdotical data is simply watching the amount of trash bins vs kids vs other objects the Tesla I am driving is able to detect. But that is still better linking to an unrelated Forbes article talking about damage done to a car when crashing it into a wall, which does not have anything to do with "FSD" in any car.

Actual facts here instead of "Elon says":

https://static.nhtsa.gov/odi/inv/2022/INCR-EA22002-14496.pdf

Re:Tesla's Sales in Europe Fall to a 15-Month Low by fdgjgbdfhgb on Wednesday May 22, 2024 @02:36PM (#40444478)
Mercedes offers it in Germany
Re:Tesla's Sales in Europe Fall to a 15-Month Low by thefz on Thursday May 23, 2024 @01:24AM (#40450765)
> Will Europe fall behind with self-driving like it did with the internet?

I beg you pardon?

Re:Tesla's Sales in Europe Fall to a 15-Month Low by xela79 on Thursday May 23, 2024 @05:32AM (#40452514)
> As far as I know, there is no self-driving in Europe at all. No Tesla, no Waymo, no nothing.

https://etsc.eu/europes-first-cars-with-level-3-automated-dr....

/thread

Re:Tesla's Sales in Europe Fall to a 15-Month Low by rsynnott on Thursday May 23, 2024 @07:26AM (#40453327)
> As far as I know, there is no self-driving in Europe at all.

Mercedes' "level 3" thing has been around for a couple of years in, at least, Germany. I'm not sure that there's all that much to "fall behind on", though.

> If we value an hour at $20, that is $1.8T per year which can be automated.

Can it, tho? Like, the last 10 years of promises about self-driving cars would indicate no, at least not any time soon.