News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Viral DNA in the human genome linked to major psychiatric... by AnthonBerg on Wednesday May 22, 2024 @08:00AM (#40439909)
For convenience here’s the paper: Integrating human endogenous retroviruses into transcriptome-wide association studies highlights novel risk factors for major psychiatric conditions by Duarte, Pain, Bendall & others: https://www.nature.com/articles/s41467-024-48153-z

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1038/s41467-024-48153-z

Open-access PDF.

(Kudos to the medicalxpress writer for actually linking to the paper.)

It seems to be quite readable. Just go fast enough to hydroplane on the surface, and jump as usual between the abstract, conclusion, abstract again, the middle part, the introduction and then put it away and sleep on it and come back to it and hydroplane and jump and… you know, all of that. Paper reading.

Before reading, in the headline I sort of saw the question whether embedded viral DNA might be getting “deployed into prod” and causing bad stuff to happen. The second ha-ha-contrarian-I-am-very-intelligent thought—also cheap to produce—was whether the ability to survive a viral onslaught brutal enough for the virus to embed itself in its quarry might be an indication that ancestral individuals had a more robust and aggressive immune system than peers who didn’t survive to reproduce. And if this could show up as a runaway inflammatory response in the current era. (From what I understand, psychiatric disorders are very very often accompanied by neuroinflammation. Practically… always?)

Such a great paper! I can speculate all this before I’ve even read the thing!!

Re:Viral DNA in the human genome linked to major psychiatric... by fellerts on Wednesday May 22, 2024 @08:19AM (#40440061)
Do you blog? I'd love to read more, and I really enjoy your writing style.
Re:Viral DNA in the human genome linked to major psychiatric... by AnthonBerg on Wednesday May 22, 2024 @10:04AM (#40441156)
I am very glad for your understanding. No, no blog at this time. Noted; humbly.
Re:Viral DNA in the human genome linked to major psychiatric... by kylebenzle on Wednesday May 22, 2024 @08:56AM (#40440363)
I found that way of writing terribly arrogant and annoying, like a smart 15-year-old.
Re:Viral DNA in the human genome linked to major psychiatric... by AnthonBerg on Wednesday May 22, 2024 @10:01AM (#40441125)
Thank you for your honest perspective! Sincere thanks. I guess it’s the approach of 45 years of age that I am unfazed.

I’ve heard a number of times that my persona in writing absolutely does not make sense to some people – until they meet me.

I think I can assure you of my non-arrogance. The wry, cynical, even flippant? note is directed at myself. My limitations and recklessness and jumping to conclusions.

If you find me, I offer you a cup of coffee. In return I’d like an equally honest reassessment.

(Full sincerity here!)

edit; Ah. Also. Another thing I can assure you of: Sometimes, afterwards, I come across my own writing and find it awful. in exactly that way. Like an annoying and arrogant 15yo had written it. Which is my greatest fear. To become that 15yo again, the person I certainly was for a decade or so. (Starting at around age 12-ish.) I knew I was annoying but I didn’t know I was arrogant. It turns out the two were related.

Re:Viral DNA in the human genome linked to major psychiatric... by dvaun on Wednesday May 22, 2024 @12:50PM (#40443146)
IMO there has been a growing undercurrent, in online discussions forums, of disdain for writing and authors who aren’t well-established as authority figures or known experts in their field. Tone and word choice is narrowing into a conversational style, and anyone “straying from the pack” sticks out like a sore thumb in online boards.

Anything sarcastic or playful can be perceived as insincere.

I’d be happy to read more of your thoughts—you should keep writing.

Re:Viral DNA in the human genome linked to major psychiatric... by hombre_fatal on Wednesday May 22, 2024 @02:16PM (#40444177)
You should just leave it at "people like different things" instead of making claims about why people don't like something (especially something that you like).

Because now you invite more negativity (on top of the original negativity and now yours) as people who didn't like their writing may now want to defend themself because they just didn't like the style and aren't part of some "growing undercurrent" who can't appreciate his brilliance because he's not "well-established nor a known expert".

Maybe they just think the writing is overwrought like when you outgrow John Scalzi's lamewad writing after briefly finding it clever in Old Man's War? (I think that's a decent place to end this because Scalzi is a very successful author.)

Re:Viral DNA in the human genome linked to major psychiatric... by mannycalavera42 on Wednesday May 22, 2024 @01:20PM (#40443541)
I find your writing - at least in these 2 comments - amusing and insightful to read. thank you
Re:Viral DNA in the human genome linked to major psychiatric... by trewnews on Wednesday May 22, 2024 @01:52PM (#40443909)
You write like why the lucky stiff the author of why's poignant guide.
Re:Viral DNA in the human genome linked to major psychiatric... by suoduandao3 on Wednesday May 22, 2024 @09:26AM (#40440685)
I rather enjoy talking to smart 15 year olds. They're curious about the world and more likely to have fresh takes. What's not to like?
Re:Viral DNA in the human genome linked to major psychiatric... by dekhn on Wednesday May 22, 2024 @11:35AM (#40442271)
The problem is, even smart 15 year olds with fresh takes have to learn that no matter how interesting their ideas are, the scientific establishment is much more focused on finding good evidence to support incremental discoveries, rather than wide-eyed speculation about how complex biological processes work.

(I was that 15 year old, and then after many years of sciencing, realized that it was nothing like what I thought, and that all my best ideas were either wrong, ahead of their time, or stolen by more accomplished scientists.

Re:Viral DNA in the human genome linked to major psychiatric... by endofreach on Wednesday May 22, 2024 @05:44PM (#40447019)
...and why not encourage to keep being like the 15 year old instead of accepting the status quo?

The only problem i see here is, apparently this "establishment" got to you faster than you could remind yourself of what's truly important to you.

I hate when people get discouraged by other people who mostly don't care that much & are afraid... they feed on your Neugier. Don't feed them. Feed other minds alike & screw the establishment.

Re:Viral DNA in the human genome linked to major psychiatric... by dekhn on Thursday May 23, 2024 @03:21PM (#40458826)
becase when the 15 year old grows up, unless they are an absolute true genius (and even then), if they try to go around chasing wild ideas, they won't get funding or the ability to run the experiments to build a case for their hypothesis.
Re:Viral DNA in the human genome linked to major psychiatric... by suoduandao3 on Friday May 24, 2024 @08:29AM (#40465494)
That seems like a problem with society (maybe an academia) more than 15 year olds no?

Besides, a lot of people interested in a wild theory greatly ups the chances someone gets funding to test the hypothesis, no?

Re:Viral DNA in the human genome linked to major psychiatric... by heddycrow on Wednesday May 22, 2024 @10:16AM (#40441322)
Takes all kinds. I'm +1 the blog.
Re:Viral DNA in the human genome linked to major psychiatric... by garyrob on Wednesday May 22, 2024 @01:44PM (#40443815)
I find your harshness, in response to a purely positive and informative comment, to be terribly arrogant and annoying, like someone pretending to be as smart as a smart 15 year old.
Re:Viral DNA in the human genome linked to major psychiatric... by endofreach on Wednesday May 22, 2024 @06:01PM (#40447229)
I always think when people react so negatively on text (comments, articles, blog-posts), they reveal a lot about themselves.

Not in the sense of a "moral high-ground" type of argument that is usually aimed for with this phrasing.

Rather: To be so convinced about knowing how a text must have been meant or what the author must have thought that one writes a very absolute judgmental statement, the reactor is most likely either very narrow-minded and isn't capable of dealing with thoughts that are not the first to salute ones mind, or, they reveal that in their mind their proposed "intention" or background is the truth, because they themselves would have only written a similar text with that intention or background... so either way: people being so negative (especially to strangers on the internet) about positive things, for no reason & without being asked, are just full of... themselves... (like me, i mean who am i to ramble this irrelevant stuff).

(I was about to delete it again, as i usually do after writing things down & then realizing they're stupid or not polished enough to convey the idea, but hey, i am also just a 15-year old arrogant mind that already wasted his time... so now, that you are here, i successfully also wasted yours. Your welcome!)

Re:Viral DNA in the human genome linked to major psychiatric... by Sakos on Wednesday May 22, 2024 @08:13AM (#40440007)
Very interesting. The paper suggests though that for many of these it's unlikely it's due to an immune response:

> It is not clear yet how the expression of the high confidence risk HERVs may play a role in psychiatric disorders. It was previously hypothesised that differential HERV expression in psychiatric cases was likely to be a by-product of immune responses against current or past infections34. Indeed, HERV expression is modulated by exposure to several pathogens35,36 and can activate inflammatory cascades37. This is an interesting theory that corroborates the fact that individuals with psychiatric disorders typically have higher incidences of infections38,39,40. However, our main analysis found that 1238 HERVs expressed in the brain are regulated in cis, some of which in association with risk for complex psychiatric traits. This indicates that there are HERV expression mechanisms directly contributing to disorder aetiology, that are not simply part of compensatory responses, or triggered by environmental factors.

Re:Viral DNA in the human genome linked to major psychiatric... by AnthonBerg on Wednesday May 22, 2024 @10:12AM (#40441274)
Thank you! To me, this is a great example of how to read papers. I think I skimmed that section a couple of times after writing the comment and it didn’t register.

Thank you for making the connection.

Re:Viral DNA in the human genome linked to major psychiatric... by greg_V on Wednesday May 22, 2024 @10:19AM (#40441349)
The inflammation vs. psychiatric disorders link is very interesting. See also some findings about the gut biome, which is also involved in the process: https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC7830868/
Re:Viral DNA in the human genome linked to major psychiatric... by im3w1l on Wednesday May 22, 2024 @08:32AM (#40440171)
So uhm, can/should we start cutting these proviruses(?) out of our genomes? Unintended consequences?
Re:Viral DNA in the human genome linked to major psychiatric... by Terr_ on Wednesday May 22, 2024 @12:49PM (#40443127)
A gene-editing inquisition against anything viral could definitely go too far. For example, we already know of syncytin [0], a protein essential for normal reproduction (placental formation) which is encoded by an ancient proviral genes.

Let's imagine some antiviral inquisitors who are either ignorant of that fact, or else operate in a world where there are very similar genes that haven't been discovered.

If they were editing gametes/embryos, they'd probably discover the problem quite quickly, and either make an exception or abandon their work.

However if they were enacting some kind of retroviral edit on adults (which would be kinda-hypocritical) then things might look fine for a little bit... until someone realizes that there are no more babies anymore and the population is going to go extinct without a fix.

[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Syncytin-1

Re:Viral DNA in the human genome linked to major psychiatric... by COGlory on Wednesday May 22, 2024 @09:14AM (#40440541)
We can't (currently) cut them out because there's too many cells and they're brain cells. But if we could make complementary RNA, that could potentially neutralize them.
Re:Viral DNA in the human genome linked to major psychiatric... by lm28469 on Wednesday May 22, 2024 @09:40AM (#40440867)
I love humans, we discover a new interesting thing, think we're big boys who understand everything there is to understand and that we can shape things to our will with no adverse consequences

That's how we got asbestos in walls, lead in gas/paint, freon, pfas, &c. The same story over and over and over again. But sure go ahead and start slicing our dna, what could possibly go wrong?

Re:Viral DNA in the human genome linked to major psychiatric... by im3w1l on Wednesday May 22, 2024 @09:47AM (#40440958)
Of course there are risks. The question is how big the risk is, and how well we can mitigate it.
[dead]
Re:Viral DNA in the human genome linked to major psychiatric... by lm28469 on Wednesday May 22, 2024 @02:56PM (#40444743)
> And antibiotics, computers, fertilizer, electricity, cars, stem cells, etc

What did it bring ? At what cost ?

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Holocene_extinction

Re:Viral DNA in the human genome linked to major psychiatric... by Nasrudith on Wednesday May 22, 2024 @04:30PM (#40446064)
The Holocene extinction was started when pointed sticks were state of the art and we ate most megafauna to extinction. It would be more the Anthropocene to blame if anything. Blaming high technology is thus rather anachronistic.

Personally I'm of the opinion that the world was already on fire as it were, what with the mass extinctions caused when we became an invasive species out of Africa. If we were still stuck in the stone age like our predecessors we would still be an ongoing mass-extinction. There is some hope to eventually not be an ongoing mass extinction but that would require some combination of even better technology and the right priorities.

Re:Viral DNA in the human genome linked to major psychiatric... by Turing_Machine on Wednesday May 22, 2024 @10:52AM (#40441745)
That's also how we got fire, stone tools, agriculture, microprocessors, vitamins, hospitals that were more than just places to go die... and the very computer network you're using to post.

Did you have a point?

Re:Viral DNA in the human genome linked to major psychiatric... by Feuilles_Mortes on Wednesday May 22, 2024 @08:52AM (#40440326)
Definitely not. Current estimates put viral DNA at about 8% of the human genome.
Re:Viral DNA in the human genome linked to major psychiatric... by im3w1l on Wednesday May 22, 2024 @09:05AM (#40440450)
Would it be possible to consider them separately though? Like maybe it will turn out that say 10% of them are beneficial, 65% of them are neutral (either they do nothing at all or a mixture of benefit and harm), and 25% are slightly bad for us (can't be too harmful or we would have already known ig).
Re:Viral DNA in the human genome linked to major psychiatric... by AdamN on Wednesday May 22, 2024 @10:35AM (#40441527)
'Bad' is notoriously hard to figure out. It might be good for the group to have a few people with major psychiatric disorders even if it's not ideal for that individual or the people who have to directly interact with them.
Re:Viral DNA in the human genome linked to major psychiatric... by biophysboy on Wednesday May 22, 2024 @09:17AM (#40440577)
Delivering gene therapies into brain cells is a non-trivial task. Also, there's alternatives to cutting the original sequence out; you can also dampen the transcribed RNA with downstream therapies.
Re:Viral DNA in the human genome linked to major psychiatric... by suoduandao3 on Wednesday May 22, 2024 @09:27AM (#40440702)
I thought this was more of a 'designer babies' suggestion than a 'mess with the source code after it's finished compiling' one.
Re:Viral DNA in the human genome linked to major psychiatric... by maratc on Wednesday May 22, 2024 @09:32AM (#40440760)
This kind of science leaves me with lots and lots of questions.

E.g.: As our understanding of DNA progresses, and we link more and more of it to different traits, will we eventually get into a situation where a swab on the water glass tells potential employer much more than the interview?

Or: imagine that in addition to the discovery "viral DNA in the human genome linked to major psychiatric disorders" there's a discovery that "this viral DNA is much more prevalent in [a certain population]". What will be the consequences of this?

Re:Viral DNA in the human genome linked to major psychiatric... by viraptor on Wednesday May 22, 2024 @10:02AM (#40441128)
> where a swab on the water glass tells potential employer much more than the interview?

More likely RNA, because DNA doesn't mean traits are actually active. Also, only if you believe nature>>nurture and that experience doesn't matter. The level of understanding of your issues and how to counteract them makes a difference too.

In practice you probably want someone with issues they know how to cope with and lots of enthusiasm for $job rather than a rando with great generic potential and hating every minute at work.

Re:Viral DNA in the human genome linked to major psychiatric... by maratc on Wednesday May 22, 2024 @10:44AM (#40441624)
> only if you believe nature>>nurture

Imagine a situation where there are two presidential candidates, who are both somewhat bad, and then it becomes a matter of public knowledge that one of them has "Viral DNA in [his] genome linked to major psychiatric disorders". I don't think what I do or don't believe would matter in the larger scheme of things.

Re:Viral DNA in the human genome linked to major psychiatric... by viraptor on Wednesday May 22, 2024 @10:50AM (#40441714)
The assumption is that they're comparable with nothing that makes one stand out ("both somewhat bad"). In that case, sure, it could mean something. But you rarely see that situation, because it doesn't make sense to run against someone not very different from you.
Re:Viral DNA in the human genome linked to major psychiatric... by maratc on Wednesday May 22, 2024 @10:55AM (#40441785)
I guess on the DNA level there is not much difference between any two candidates for any $job ... yet. The questions I'm asking are not about the current situation, they are about potential (not yet existing) situations we can find ourselves in with the advancement of DNA science.
Re:Viral DNA in the human genome linked to major psychiatric... by r2_pilot on Wednesday May 22, 2024 @11:44AM (#40442360)
Well, in the US at least, if the presidential candidate is well supported by their establishment party, it seems like there would be little-to-no difference. (much like my voting activity in first-past-the-post systems)
Re:Viral DNA in the human genome linked to major psychiatric... by drtgh on Wednesday May 22, 2024 @11:52AM (#40442452)
> will we eventually get into a situation where a swab on the water glass tells potential employer much more than the interview?

So GATTACA (1997), a recommended movie treating the genetic discrimination, genoism, as main plot.

I don't think we will live to see it technologically speaking, but eventually our descendants may live through such hell of statistical speculation.

Re:Viral DNA in the human genome linked to major psychiatric... by maratc on Wednesday May 22, 2024 @03:39PM (#40445353)
Thanks for the recommendation, I really enjoyed it!
Re:Viral DNA in the human genome linked to major psychiatric... by suoduandao3 on Wednesday May 22, 2024 @11:09AM (#40441963)
I think we already know that, it's just there's usually a tradeoff for these things. Subgroups with higher average IQs also have higher rates of psychiatric disorders etc... If society's healthy there'll be lots of opportunities for subgroups to niche down. If it's not, everyone will be chasing the same rabbit and the inherent unfairness is going to compound that problem.
Re:Viral DNA in the human genome linked to major psychiatric... by llamaimperative on Wednesday May 22, 2024 @10:36AM (#40441544)
> E.g.: As our understanding of DNA progresses, and we link more and more of it to different traits, will we eventually get into a situation where a swab on the water glass tells potential employer much more than the interview?

For almost anything that an interview is designed to discover: no. DNA manipulates probabilities of certain things in one direction or another, but then that probability shift is amplified and attenuated through layer after layer of immensely chaotic biological, then psychological, then social processes.

The connection between genetic code and "things we care about" is extremely finicky, with the exceptions being certain types of diseases which emerge much closer to the genetic code than any sort of social behaviors do.

Re:Viral DNA in the human genome linked to major psychiatric... by maratc on Wednesday May 22, 2024 @11:00AM (#40441864)
Once we get past the diseases research, what's stopping us from going further? Could we discover e.g. a DNA sequence in human genome "linked" to higher intelligence, or better leadership qualities? And if yes, what can guarantee that instead of the Nazis' "master race" based on pseudo-scientific scull measurements we won't discover "master genes" based on actual DNA science?

What frightens me is not what we can discover, it's what we as human society will do with that information once we discover it.

Re:Viral DNA in the human genome linked to major psychiatric... by suoduandao3 on Wednesday May 22, 2024 @11:11AM (#40441984)
I think we're past that. Setting aside politically hot topics like IQ, Height is genetically determined and makes a huge difference in life outcomes. Now it's all about what we do with that information.
Re:Viral DNA in the human genome linked to major psychiatric... by maratc on Wednesday May 22, 2024 @11:14AM (#40442030)
You can tell a person's height just by looking at them — unlike other examples, you don't need any advancement in DNA science for that.
Re:Viral DNA in the human genome linked to major psychiatric... by suoduandao3 on Wednesday May 22, 2024 @01:48PM (#40443861)
That makes height an easy topic to talk about, but it's still challenging to think through the implications. If you can increase your child's height by 20% and thereby increase their likely income by 25% - is it morally right not to? Does it matter whether others can afford that intervention? Is it morally right not to fund public access to such interventions? Does the answer change if relative height is all that matters?
Re:Viral DNA in the human genome linked to major psychiatric... by roywiggins on Wednesday May 22, 2024 @02:01PM (#40443996)
Re:Viral DNA in the human genome linked to major psychiatric... by dekhn on Wednesday May 22, 2024 @11:38AM (#40442303)
I mean, read up on the history of eugenics. Mainstream establishment science has come up close to doing exactly this sort of thing in the past (including sterilizing people who were considered "unfit").

It seems almost certain that we will continue to find more DNA sequences that are correlated with increased intelligence.

Re:Viral DNA in the human genome linked to major psychiatric... by llamaimperative on Wednesday May 22, 2024 @01:11PM (#40443424)
Because DNA won't tell you whether the genetically-genius person smashed their head on a rock and is now totally unfit for your high-paying engineering job.

Nor will it tell you whether the genetically-average intelligence person spent 14 hours per day for the last 8 years in the code mines building awesome stuff.

I.e. it won't tell you the types of things that interviews are designed to suss out.

Re:Viral DNA in the human genome linked to major psychiatric... by londons_explore on Thursday May 23, 2024 @03:36AM (#40451658)
Any test mixes signal with noise (Maybe that superstar candidate is just awful at interviews? Maybe the super lazy coder puts their laziness aside only for the interview day?)

Combining many noisy factors into one, with the correct weighting, will always, on average, give better results than a single test.

That means that as soon as DNA tests give even a weak prediction of 'iq' or 'leadership abilities', companies will integrate them into hiring processes if legal and cheap.

Re:Viral DNA in the human genome linked to major psychiatric... by roywiggins on Wednesday May 22, 2024 @01:32PM (#40443673)
If there were single genes that produced high intelligence scientists probably would have found one by now. Those sorts of traits are almost certainly highly polygenic. Any single gene is likely to have both small and unpredictable contributions to the traits in question. Even totting up all your "good" and "bad" genes to try to come up with a genetic score is fraught due to complicated interactions; perhaps two "good" genes interact badly and make a bad result, or similar.
Re:Viral DNA in the human genome linked to major psychiatric... by holonsphere on Wednesday May 22, 2024 @10:03AM (#40441146)
What makes you think this hasnt already been done?
Re:Viral DNA in the human genome linked to major psychiatric... by barbariangrunge on Wednesday May 22, 2024 @01:14PM (#40443468)
Please don’t give anybody ideas, hiring practices in tech are already so shitty
Re:Viral DNA in the human genome linked to major psychiatric... by ndynan on Wednesday May 22, 2024 @09:45AM (#40440946)
Maybe someone can provide a better understanding, I'm a clinical psych doctoral student, but this is outside my area of research + methods.

On very quick review, it looks like there are is significant association between HERV genetic factors and specific diagnoses given PIP. However, what's not clear to me is effect size or correlation coefficient.

I'm not sure if I'm missing this or it's not reports. There might be a relationship, but at a very small percentage.

Re:Viral DNA in the human genome linked to major psychiatric... by andrewflnr on Wednesday May 22, 2024 @10:21AM (#40441377)
I'm sure this is good research but I'm also sure it's the basis of the next generation of antivax propaganda.
Re:Viral DNA in the human genome linked to major psychiatric... by gradientsrneat on Friday May 24, 2024 @02:48PM (#40469278)
As another commenter pointed out, the expression of these genes doesn't cause inflammation. So, maybe the antivaxxers will ignore it, as it doesn't fit well enough into their existing framework.
Re:Viral DNA in the human genome linked to major psychiatric... by andrewflnr on Saturday May 25, 2024 @12:02AM (#40472564)
If antivaxxers held themselves to a consistent model, they would be gone by now. For instance, long ago it used to be about the mercury based preservative that's basically never used now, but somehow vaccines are still evil somehow. Some other way, for sure. They've just got "vaccine = bad" stuck in their head and they'll grab any scrap of info that confirms their bias.
Re:Viral DNA in the human genome linked to major psychiatric... by byteknight on Wednesday May 22, 2024 @10:41AM (#40441584)
Someone with a better grasp of the scientific method perhaps you can answer this.

I am under the impression we (science) hasn't definitively determined causation for depression. How can you definitively determine a link without knowing the underlying causes. It would imply you know how it works, doesn't it?

Re:Viral DNA in the human genome linked to major psychiatric... by xkcd-sucks on Wednesday May 22, 2024 @11:17AM (#40442065)
> Someone with a better grasp of the scientific method perhaps you can answer this.

As a (recovered, former) neurobio phd it seems the "grasp" is mostly there + the clarity you want just doesn't exist here

I.e., the concept of "depression" is pretty hard to nail down quantitatively in the first place: The best model we've got is a kind of self-contained proven-by-internal-self-consistency thing bootstrapped from questionnaires, which is of course further abstracted away onto those model systems we're allowed to kill: For example, calling "how long do mice swim before giving up if you chuck them into a tank of water" is roughly equated to "amount of depression" (this is oversimplified a bit; you correlate a bunch of those measures etc. but still a lot of very weak signals). Even "relevant quantitative data" like fMRI / ECoG is bootstrapped from questionnaires when it's something undefinable like "depression"

Which isn't the end of the world, everything started out like this, it just sucks when people take these results too seriously or infer too much from them.

And even the human black-box stuff in the DSM manuals admits a lot of different subtypes, lots of different and sometimes opposite symptom clusters, etc. It is entirely possible that mechanistically "depression" is a diverse group of mechanisms all boxed up into the most familiar mainstream concept/word.

Re:Viral DNA in the human genome linked to major psychiatric... by byteknight on Wednesday May 22, 2024 @04:01PM (#40445659)
Firstly, thank you.

> For example, calling "how long do mice swim before giving up if you chuck them into a tank of water" is roughly equated to "amount of depression" (this is oversimplified a bit; you correlate a bunch of those measures etc. but still a lot of very weak signals).

Do I understand this? A purely reductionist view of my understanding: this is quantified as "the amount of will to live"? If my understanding is proper, how do you measure this without killing people? I grok that it is an extreme example, I am attempting to glean applicability of such an experiment to humans.

> And even the human black-box stuff in the DSM manuals admits a lot of different subtypes, lots of different and sometimes opposite symptom clusters, etc. It is entirely possible that mechanistically "depression" is a diverse group of mechanisms all boxed up into the most familiar mainstream concept/word.

Totally unrelated, but wife is an LCSW and I've glanced at the DSM. I've become convinced that book is near entirely for insurance purposes, similar to the ICD-10.

ICD-10: W220.2XD: Walked into lamppost, subsequent encounter.

Re:Viral DNA in the human genome linked to major psychiatric... by xkcd-sucks on Friday May 24, 2024 @04:13PM (#40470092)
> Do I understand this? A purely reductionist view of my understanding: this is quantified as "the amount of will to live"? If my understanding is proper, how do you measure this without killing people? I grok that it is an extreme example, I am attempting to glean applicability of such an experiment to humans.

I mean in this is one model and typically a "result" means several models are all consistent with the researcher's mental model of the thing. But yes, the forced swim test is one measure of "will to live" and it's treated as that because of similarities to "that which we call 'depression'" or whatever

It is better than nothing, unless one takes it too seriously.

[0] mice float, they don't drown when they give up, assuming you take them out quickly enough [1] https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC4401172/ [2] https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3353513/

Re:Viral DNA in the human genome linked to major psychiatric... by suoduandao3 on Wednesday May 22, 2024 @10:54AM (#40441772)
My understanding is they've demonstrated a correlation. I don't think they've made any claims about causation.
Re:Viral DNA in the human genome linked to major psychiatric... by freshpretzels on Wednesday May 22, 2024 @10:29PM (#40449743)
Could CRISPR or a tool like it be used to “cut out” these parts of someone’s DNA and cure them from those disorders?
Re:Viral DNA in the human genome linked to major psychiatric... by londons_explore on Thursday May 23, 2024 @03:06AM (#40451453)
How sure are we that this viral DNA in our genome isn't occasionally activated to make fully fledged viruses?
Re:Viral DNA in the human genome linked to major psychiatric... by londons_explore on Thursday May 23, 2024 @03:29AM (#40451616)
This embedded viral DNA would presumably make all cells more susceptible to similar real viruses, since the MHC class I signalling methods couldn't be used to find them.
Re:Viral DNA in the human genome linked to major psychiatric... by marmadukester39 on Thursday May 23, 2024 @10:15AM (#40455027)
Just for fun - does this sound like what the remnants of ancient genetic engineering experiments on primates to increase their intelligence might look like to anyone else?
Re:Viral DNA in the human genome linked to major psychiatric... by gradientsrneat on Friday May 24, 2024 @02:32PM (#40469116)
I'm partial to the null hypothesis, but one thing to check would be junk DNA in other extant species, and ancient human remains.