You're right, most people do that, but that's because they haven't trained themselves to be inventors. This is a skill that definitely needs to be developed more, but finding truly creative (and sometimes backwards-seeming) solutions can sometimes mean thinking about problems in a completely different way.
However, all LLM's do this. That's one of the points of the article.
I don't think handwaving about exclusively outputting training data and random punditry via article really holds up here.
It's wrong for so many reasons, from the training data having more perspectives, to the "Fat Tony" test, empirically, we can go make it output novel combinations right now, to the CS test, we can have it emulate arbitrary Turing machines.
First they have a very small sample size of around n = 150. Second, they don't represent average husband, they use people working on mechanical Turk for $9 an hour.
Finally, they don't have any standard measures of divergent thought - they just use 4 different types of question answering problems, and those are supposed to measure creativity. Whether they do or don't would require us to evaluate the questions.
It's important to be clear that this is saying that LLMs might be more creative than low paid workers on mechanical Turk, given no training time. That's not a very good representation of the average human, or the fact that humans need training.
So for example, an average doctor or scientist might still be more creative than LLMs.
Tldr; this is not a good paper to throw around if you want to convince people. It's truly awful in its design, and the way it's presented is not always honest.
So, yeah, between that, and that both your average person and someone arguing from Turing tapes can show AI doing things not in the training data, I'm going with actual data thats being "thrown around" rather than the rando blog post that argues from "by definition it can't be creative because it isn't original because it only repeats training data" Call me when they're at N=152 on a blind test.
LLM’s degree of adherence to training patterns can be directly tuned, per request (up to whatever the maximum it is capable of.)
Can this be leveraged to build a framework around an LLM for brainstorming usefully? I’m not sure. But “Nope, because LLMs just directly adhere to existing patterns” is definitely not a useful answer to that question. It is the kind of answer someone who just parrots common patterns with surface-level knowledge of the subject area would come up with. (Huh, did a default-settings LLM write this article?)
I think people often forget the behavior of instruction following is still based on SFT training data. This is exactly "adherence to training patterns". Prompt engineering is not elixir, it's just a way to utilize the patterns seen in training data.
I’m not talking about prompt engineering when I talk about per request tuning of how closely it follows established patterns, I’m talking about inference parameters (temperature, top_p, top_k, are common for most models and ways of calling them, some others may be available, too.)
The obvious problem is that these logic and arithmetic operations don't really need exhaustive training examples. Training the LLM is supposed to teach it a method or process by which it arrives at the answer, not just the question answer pair itself, which tends to only lead to very good approximate results. That is ok when using language, since your exact words don't really matter if you can express yourself in another way, but when it comes to algebras, accuracy is key.
It really is strange that when one wishes for a more capable LLM that one is told how stupid one is for wanting such a thing. What exactly is so wrong about giving the model a price list and an example of an order at a restaurant and then asking how much the whole order costs and expecting the correct total sum? For some strange reason I'm getting numbers that would make sense if I generated the text in a vacuum without the price list, as if they are following some existing pattern...
“Brainstorming” and “doing precise arithmetic” are wildly different tasks. It is a complete non-sequitur to ask how a suggestion about the former will help the latter.
how do you know?
This is a myth. Just because you don't really see blinding insight every day doesn't mean it doesn't exist (and it's more spectacular when you do see it!)
Another reason that this seems to happen is that innovation and invention tend to happen in more esoteric and technical realms today, and so they're only really fully understood by experts in that field.
"What has been will be again, what has been done will be done again; there is nothing new under the sun."
- Ecclesiastes 1:9 (circa 250 BC)
That's a lot like claiming no one says anything new because we're also using more-or-less the same words we were using last century.
I think you're missing a lot.
As a part-time generative artist for several decades, a user of Monte-Carlo methods on a daily basis, and author of some papers on the topic, I personally believe that randomness is not a good answer to anything creative. Randomness is boring, and average. Randomness only helps you when you have a high quality Markov model constraining what your RNG chooses between, and that’s more or less all LLMs actually are. Adding more randomness to creative works in general makes creative works muddy and lowers quality, it needs to be guided. Randomness is a useful tool, but is widely misunderstood IMO and not very effective at brainstorming style exploration; brainstorming is about solving problems in interesting ways, i.e., there is reasoning behind it, not slightly more random word salad.
I would say, try reading a conspiracy theory forum - or simply wait for one to get posted on HN, and then revisit this particular conclusion.
I don't think this is a unique failure of LLMs, except insofar as LLMs have less of a physical grounding in reality then humans do: but we have people out there who have convinced themselves they can project forcefields, and take that all the way through to getting punched in the face by a martial artist when it turns out that, no, they can't.
When I'm brainstorming math or cryptography or philosophy with an LLM it is only because of the connections and leaps that I introduce that leads to novel and amusing discoveries.
You have to develop successful patterns. Coaxing and condensing. Drilling into numbered lists. Asking for tables with progressively more columns and altered sorting. You have to know the spatial reasoning limits of the model. Asking for enumeration and disabling of social niceties. The number of skills needed is probably beyond most people's imaginations.
The problem with this argument is that people do the same thing, we’re not that great at brainstorming either. When we brainstorm in groups, we’re just bringing multiple points of view together. The more data LLMs are trained on, the more viewpoints it might be able to bring that you haven’t considered.
That said, LLMs and all NNs so far are built to interpolate, and they are bad and have unbounded error when extrapolating outside their training examples. That is a good reason to not expect today’s AI to come up with new ideas.