Also, please see the site guidelines here: https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html. They include:
"Please don't post shallow dismissals, especially of other people's work. A good critical comment teaches us something."
- Gridlock is a wallet for end-users directly. Meemaw is a so-called "wallet-as-a-service", allowing developers to deploy wallets for their users, within their app. The experience is for each developer to define.
- Meemaw is open-source and designed to reduce risks on many counts: going from cloud to self-hosting and vice versa will be super easy, there will be open-sourced tools for end users to recover their wallet even if the company (whether Meemaw or developers using it) goes down, etc
Happy to discuss further if you feel like I misunderstood what Gridlock does!
It’s a different tool for a different use case.
Also, having your product open-sourced and/or audited increases trustworthiness. You mentioned going open-source and being audited in 2021 but neither happened as far as I can find. That’s fine, just different than OP’s project.
On the flip side, I noticed this Q&A from your docs that I think is at least re-assuring:
“What happens to my assets if Gridlock shuts down?
Should Gridlock ever become unavailable, you are still safe and protected! The built-in Eject Feature allows you to access your crypto independently without Gridlock. This is the definition of self-custody where you are in full control!”
PS. I’m not the target audience for these type of products. I stay away from most crypto stuff. I just stumbled upon this thread and wanted to share my thoughts :)