News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Andrew Huberman's Claims About Cannabis Annoy Drug Experts by kylecazar on Thursday May 09, 2024 @01:49PM (#40310825)
Why especially Sapolsky? Is he selling something (other than his book) that I'm unaware of? I get why you mention the others.

AFAIK he's just a biology professor convinced that we don't have free will.

Re:Andrew Huberman's Claims About Cannabis Annoy Drug Experts by labrador on Thursday May 09, 2024 @01:54PM (#40310895)
Because I watched him progress from a respected professor at Stanford to a self-promoter who sits on Twitter looking for mentions of his name, not that there's anything wrong with that. It's a personal experience for me, so it may not be generally true. I found his lecture on depression in the mid 2010's and it helped me a lot. By 2023, I mentioned on Twitter that I didn't buy his idea that we didn't have free will and a minute later he liked my tweet. I hope he's making good money with his no free will idea. He's out there promoting it enough.
Re:Andrew Huberman's Claims About Cannabis Annoy Drug Experts by afpx on Thursday May 09, 2024 @02:29PM (#40311326)
His book “Behave” seemed to be well done. He cites everything he claims (I’ve only looked at a few of them, but they seemed like legit studies). I haven’t followed much of his free will argument but it makes sense he’d go down that path because the premise of Behave is that our actions are just the result of many physical processes.

One thing that keeps me open-minded about free will is that, yeah my actions may be the result of natural processes, but I also have the ability to reflect upon those actions so that my responses change the next time. But, then again I would probably defend the idea of free will even irrationally. In my opinion even if I don’t have free will I still have to live like I do.

Edit: I just googled Behave citations and one of the first things to pop up was someone claiming he has bad sources. But, I didn’t investigate that person’s claims either. So, be skeptical I guess.

Re:Andrew Huberman's Claims About Cannabis Annoy Drug Experts by labrador on Thursday May 09, 2024 @02:56PM (#40311677)
I am not a religious person but I experience the Universe as a consciousness that pervades the entirety and contains all the intelligence required for it's operation. I agree with Erwin Schrodinger that "“The total number of minds in the universe is one. In fact, consciousness is a singularity phasing within all beings” and I call that singular consciousness God. Our brain does produce consciousness but tunes into it.

So you can see why I might vehmently disagree with people like Saplosky who attemt to reduce us to mere machines. How depressing, which is ironic, since Saplosky's Stanford lecture on depression really started me on the road out of my depression.

Re:Andrew Huberman's Claims About Cannabis Annoy Drug Experts by int_19h on Thursday May 09, 2024 @03:34PM (#40312112)
Does it really matter if there are many minds or one? That just shifts the question to whether this "universe mind" is fundamentally mechanistic or not.
Re:Andrew Huberman's Claims About Cannabis Annoy Drug Experts by labrador on Thursday May 09, 2024 @03:46PM (#40312233)
I'm confused by your question. I'm hearing it like "does it matter if there are many gravity wells or just gravity?" because I believe science will once day find consciousness is the 5th fundamental force, perhaps the one the ties the other four together
Re:Andrew Huberman's Claims About Cannabis Annoy Drug Experts by int_19h on Thursday May 09, 2024 @03:59PM (#40312352)
What I'm saying is whether consciousness is a fundamental force or not is orthogonal to whether it has free will.
Re:Andrew Huberman's Claims About Cannabis Annoy Drug Experts by labrador on Thursday May 09, 2024 @05:34PM (#40313185)
So you're saying a conscious Universe could still be Newton's "clockwork universe"? Well, Einstein did say "God does not play dice with the universe" but I think the quantum direction is where the riddle of consciousness may be be found. The beauty and terror of our own minds is the uncertainty that lies in the choices we make and the outcomes we get from those choices.
Re:Andrew Huberman's Claims About Cannabis Annoy Drug Experts by int_19h on Thursday May 09, 2024 @06:34PM (#40313617)
I don't think quantum mechanics fundamentally changes things, either. If you look at it from the Copenhagen perspective, sure, you get randomness, but I don't think many people would seriously argue that adding a true RNG to an otherwise mechanical contraption makes it any less mechanical, even if it becomes unpredictable - the real question behind "free will" is not whether branching is deterministic, but rather whether the entity has any degree of control over it. And if you look at it from the many-worlds perspective, then you just have parallelized determinism.

My personal take on this is that the question itself is meaningless because we cannot define "free will" in any coherent way that is actually testable. It all boils down to defining what "conscious" and "self" mean, which are themselves very fuzzy concepts that elude clear definitions. My solution to all this is to just stop wasting time on it, since I don't think there are any practical implications to it (and if there's no free will - whatever that means in practice - then my opinion is itself predetermined in any case).

Re:Andrew Huberman's Claims About Cannabis Annoy Drug Experts by labrador on Thursday May 09, 2024 @06:59PM (#40313785)
I agree with you that the question of free will is a waste of time, which is why I generally avoid it. Maybe if you are a student of Catholic Church doctrine and have a final exam coming up? Sapolsky does not write from a Catholic perspective, but his audience might have been brought up with it so his writings might be provocative for them and thus profitable for him. I've been watching his career with more amusement than irritation. He is classic case of a regular guy becoming an "influencer." The same thing happened to Jordan Peterson. At the same time [2015] I found Sapolsky's lecture on depression I found Peterson's. Both not well known at the time. Both lectures really helpful. Both now well known influencers.
Re:Andrew Huberman's Claims About Cannabis Annoy Drug Experts by nojvek on Thursday May 09, 2024 @10:06PM (#40314871)
It’s natural for human brain to find explanations for the supernatural. We are born with a “God” placeholder in our brain, just as infinity is a concept.

The idea that consciousness is 5th fundamental force sounds great but doesn’t make any sense.

Everything in universe is interaction of particles in force fields. We have mathematical definitions for them in standard model of physics.

And consciousness is what we experience in our brains as a model of reality. It’s a much more complex emergent concept arising from how neurons are wired together to process input -> output signals. Consciousness boils down to signal processing. Which down the stack of atoms and subatomic particle requires the fundamental forces.

Very different things. Put in a different way, they are fundamental because they explain everything in observable universe.

That being said, I respect your right to believe.

Re:Andrew Huberman's Claims About Cannabis Annoy Drug Experts by labrador on Thursday May 09, 2024 @10:28PM (#40314954)
> emergent concept arising from how neurons are wired together

That's a magical concept as well. A theory like mine. Time will tell. I only wish I was around when they figure it out.

Re:Andrew Huberman's Claims About Cannabis Annoy Drug Experts by nojvek on Friday May 10, 2024 @09:45AM (#40318911)
The problem with consciousness is most people have varying definitions of what they mean by it.

Most don’t even believe any other animals other than humans can be conscious. Or that computers can be conscious.

Re:Andrew Huberman's Claims About Cannabis Annoy Drug Experts by labrador on Saturday May 11, 2024 @06:55PM (#40331144)
I regard consciousness as fundamental. I regard matter as derivative from consciousness. We cannot get behind consciousness. Everything that we talk about, everything that we regard as existing, postulates consciousness.

- Max Planck

Re:Andrew Huberman's Claims About Cannabis Annoy Drug Experts by maxdoop on Friday May 10, 2024 @03:57AM (#40316429)
Do you often discount studies and science when it comes to ideas that don’t align with your natural instinct?

Is addiction a disease or a moral failure? Is depression a chemical imbalance or is it your own fault, maybe just “exercise and smile more”?

Questions of that nature are fair but simply being against a researcher or author because they have a viewpoint different your own is entirely what’s wrong with so much of discourse today.

Re:Andrew Huberman's Claims About Cannabis Annoy Drug Experts by labrador on Friday May 10, 2024 @11:08AM (#40319929)
You're implying that Robert Sapolsky speaks the truth the contradicts my belief system. Maybe you're thinking I'm Catholic (I'm not) who see free will as a gift from God that allows humans to freely choose to love and obey Him. Catholic doctrine holds that free will is granted to humans by God as part of being created in His image and likeness. Without free will, humans could not be held morally responsible for their actions. The ability to choose between good and evil is fundamental to Catholic understanding of sin and redemption.

No, I think Robert Sapolsky's focus is too narrow and materialistic, ignoring almost everything that makes us human. In the story of the seven blind men and the elephant, Robert Sapolsky is the blind scientist that feels the trunk and proclaims the elephant is a snake. Robert Sapolsky's science is flawed. If human behavior can be explained by chemicals then why do we need his colleagues in other departments at Stanford, such as the psychologists?

My point was he was doing what he does to make money Malcolm Gladwell style and I thought there was nothing wrong with that but that was a reason why I didn't take him seriouly.

Re:Andrew Huberman's Claims About Cannabis Annoy Drug Experts by cooper_ganglia on Thursday May 09, 2024 @02:19PM (#40311208)
He couldn’t help but like your tweet, he had no free will.
Re:Andrew Huberman's Claims About Cannabis Annoy Drug Experts by alecst on Thursday May 09, 2024 @02:21PM (#40311240)
I was terrified when you lumped Sapolsky in with those other guys, but if this is the worst you’ve got then I’m breathing out a sigh of relief.
Re:Andrew Huberman's Claims About Cannabis Annoy Drug Experts by labrador on Thursday May 09, 2024 @02:25PM (#40311287)
Good! I like him. I'm an American capitalist so I'm not going to critisize a guy for making a buck.
Re:Andrew Huberman's Claims About Cannabis Annoy Drug Experts by dotsam on Thursday May 09, 2024 @02:23PM (#40311263)
What makes you think his promotion of the book was particulary motivated by making money rather than any other reason an author might promote their book?
Re:Andrew Huberman's Claims About Cannabis Annoy Drug Experts by labrador on Thursday May 09, 2024 @02:27PM (#40311308)
He is either

a) extremely passionate about the idea that we have no free will

b) loves the paychecks that arrive after appearing on podcasts and selling books

c) is compelled to do all these things because he has no free will

edit: formating, code blocks don't work anymore?

Re:Andrew Huberman's Claims About Cannabis Annoy Drug Experts by kiba on Thursday May 09, 2024 @02:51PM (#40311631)
I agree with him on the notion that we have no 'free will' to speak of. In the end, we are just physical beings that must operate according to cause and effect, whether we are 'compelled' or not.

Sound depressing, but that gives us incredible freedom to investigate causes of human misery and correct them.

Re:Andrew Huberman's Claims About Cannabis Annoy Drug Experts by dotsam on Thursday May 09, 2024 @02:42PM (#40311511)
Does this come down to the fact that you don't like the topic of his book? As you have said elsewhere that you're not going to criticize someone for wanting to make money.
Re:Andrew Huberman's Claims About Cannabis Annoy Drug Experts by labrador on Thursday May 09, 2024 @02:58PM (#40311700)
Hacker News put a delay on my response to you because it thought we were arguing so I responded to user afpx. Yes, you're right. I vehemently disagree with him.
Re:Andrew Huberman's Claims About Cannabis Annoy Drug Experts by nojvek on Thursday May 09, 2024 @10:16PM (#40314903)
The topic about free will is similar to debating “are we in a simulation?”

In a perfect simulation, there is absolutely no way to escape it. A simulation is essentially like a virtual machine running some opcodes. There is absolutely no way to escape it unless the programmer is shit at implementing the opcodes with buffer overflows.

If we cannot computationally reduce, we have no option than to let the simulation play out. So far our universe is not computationally reducible. I.e we cannot compute where subatomic particles will be faster than letting them actually play out.

Whether we have free will or not doesn’t matter. If we cannot computationally reduce, person B cannot compute ahead what person A will do with absolute certainty.

To compute the future, we need to simulate every subatomic particle in universe faster than the the natural speed of universe with fewer particles. That itself is impossible.

We can approximate, yes! But not absolute certainty.

So we have no free will because universe is deterministic. But we also have free will because we need a universe sized computer to know what will happen and the only way to do that is to let the universe play it out. We cannot do that faster than the universe if we are inside the universe.

We are in a simulation. But it does not matter because it makes no difference if we are in a simulation or not.

God exists, but God also doesn’t exist. If God is non-interfering then it absolutely doesn’t matter.