Postscript: Some people seem to be interpreting me as making a stronger claim than I intend. There are obviously a few cases when a scatterplot truly is the right tool.
Inflammatory, overstated headlines are a rhetorical device that we're apparently stuck with for a long time to come. They're like television advertisements used to be: only curmudgeons[1] complain about them anymore because people assume the content wouldn't exist without them.
[1] Hello.
This graph by itself is arbitrarily lossy in that we don't know how many overlapping samples there are at each point. And we don't know if blue samples are overlapping orange ones or vice-versa. I'm not sure I would be as categorical as the author about never using scatter plots, but he makes a really good point.
I think the default should be a density plot. It's only in special cases that a scatterplot would be appropriate. For example, that Carsabi plot actually works well, due to the fact that the reader is interested in finding a specific data point rather than understanding the global behavior.
The same holds in two dimensions. Show me all the data, and include a regression line or a spline to highlight a trend. Only start hiding information when the scatterplot becomes misleading. That is, when overplotting prevents me from accurately assessing the actual distribution of the points.
Jumping immediately to a density plot also restricts me to your interpretation. The original data is lost. With a scatterplot, the raw data can be recovered from the plot, so i can do my own analysis should i be interested. This is common in meta-analyses that extract data from multiple published papers. If those original papers had used density plots instead of scatterplots, reanalysis will require direct access to the underlying data. Once the original author dies, or loses the data, all further use of the data is lost.
Best practice: http://www.nytimes.com/interactive/2012/05/09/us/politics/sa...
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Alpha_compositing
When overplotting, the usual compositing operator gives a final alpha of
1 - (1-alpha)^N
So your alpha = 1/5 overdrawn 5 times would give a final opacity of ~0.673. By its very nature, there is no alpha < 1 which when composited together a finite number of times gives alpha = 1.
Scatterplots can be a lot more useful when you do things like display the points in different colors or highlight a specific point of interest as in the Carsabi scatterplots.
Do you really think scatterplots should never be used? I think a headline like that takes away from your credibility. The problem isn't with scatterplots, it's choosing the right tool for the job.