News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:How much is enough to FIRE in San Francisco? by dataflow on Thursday May 02, 2024 @01:07PM (#40238593)
Doesn't this depend heavily on inflation? With the ballooning US debt, how do people imagine the government will continue to pay interest without massive inflation in a few decades?
Re:How much is enough to FIRE in San Francisco? by gotaran on Thursday May 02, 2024 @01:12PM (#40238651)
The 4% rule accounts for inflation. The stock market on an average gives you 7% a year in returns adjusted for inflation. The 4% gives you enough cushion in case of economic turmoil.
Re:How much is enough to FIRE in San Francisco? by dataflow on Thursday May 02, 2024 @03:39PM (#40240579)
> The 4% rule accounts for inflation

"Accounts" wrongly, though? 4% inflation for the next half-century seems like complete fantasy. How do you imagine it possibly being sufficient to address the ballooning debt?

Re:How much is enough to FIRE in San Francisco? by AnimalMuppet on Thursday May 02, 2024 @01:17PM (#40238732)
The stock market on average has given you 7%. That may not be a safe assumption going forward - going far forward. I might live another 30 years. If you FIRE, you might live another 50. Will the stock market continue to yield 7% over the next 50 years? That's a larger assumption than I'm comfortable making.
Re:How much is enough to FIRE in San Francisco? by its_ethan on Thursday May 02, 2024 @01:29PM (#40238910)
Why is it such a crazy assumption? Going back to like 1870 a $SPY equivalent has yielded something like 8-10% on average if you reinvest dividends. In that time there have been two world wars, a handful of pandemics, election turmoil (oversea and aboard), many bubbles in tech and housing, and yet the long term average was 8%+.

FWIW there have always been and will always be spelling financial doom right around the corner, but betting that way has been a failing strategy save for lucky few who got the timing just right.

Re:How much is enough to FIRE in San Francisco? by AnimalMuppet on Thursday May 02, 2024 @01:40PM (#40239058)
Let's say you didn't invest in the US stock market, because you lived in, say, Japan. How did the Japanese stock market do since 1870? Pretty well, except for that part in 1945 when it went to approximately zero.

Ditto Germany in 1945.

Ditto Russia in 1918.

Ditto China in 1949.

Is the US going to be the US of history for the next 50 years? Or is it going to be one of Japan, Germany, China, or Russia?

Or is it just going to be, say, the UK? How did the UK stock market do over the last 50 years?

Re:How much is enough to FIRE in San Francisco? by its_ethan on Thursday May 02, 2024 @03:49PM (#40240668)
"Better be weary of making financial assumptions because you may end up on the losing side of a world war and then it will all be for naught" isn't very useful thinking imo

If you think America (or wherever you live) is going to end up like Germany in 1945, or Russia in 1918, then it won't matter in the slightest what you've invested in anyway - you plus everyone around you will be in the same (half underwater) boat.

"Ditto" for if $SPY suddenly tanks or underperforms. There are going to be much more immediate concerns for everyone if that happens.

Re:How much is enough to FIRE in San Francisco? by the_real_cher on Thursday May 02, 2024 @01:17PM (#40238721)
Yeah but have you seen the interest rate on the national deb and the amount the fed government is borrowing every year?

The interest we pay on the debt has just passed defense spending this year as a percentage of the federal budget.

I cant imagine how 4% inflation will continue to be the norm as the government has to print more and more money to pay for this stuff.

Re:How much is enough to FIRE in San Francisco? by hparadiz on Thursday May 02, 2024 @01:23PM (#40238815)
If China starts a war with Taiwan we're gonna be looking at WW2 level of taxation. Ordinance shortages are already here due to Ukraine.
Re:How much is enough to FIRE in San Francisco? by the_real_cher on Thursday May 02, 2024 @03:03PM (#40240195)
I mean most of our debt is to entities within the USA.

Which means instead of taxing the wealthy were paying them for the privilege of using their money.

So that could be a good thing.

When the rich were taxed heavily post WW2 the US was a pretty great place to live if you were middle class.

Not sure if that would work out still in a post-gold standard, modern uni-party ruling class USA where taxes may not be used efficiently.

Even some rich people question how little taxes they pay.

Re:How much is enough to FIRE in San Francisco? by diob on Thursday May 02, 2024 @01:11PM (#40238636)
Presumably their investments would inflate as well. Unfortunately, the asset owning class is protected by inflation in that way.

It's the lower / middle class who have cash savings that get wrecked by inflation.

Re:How much is enough to FIRE in San Francisco? by rzmmm on Thursday May 02, 2024 @01:15PM (#40238698)
Depends on the asset, but usually salaries follow inflation more closely than investments.
Re:How much is enough to FIRE in San Francisco? by diob on Thursday May 02, 2024 @01:43PM (#40239102)
This doesn't address what I said though. Salaries may follow, but their cash savings do not.
Re:How much is enough to FIRE in San Francisco? by whimsicalism on Thursday May 02, 2024 @01:21PM (#40238781)
usually inflation helps the lower class - this has been the case historically and also the case for the most recent inflation
Re:How much is enough to FIRE in San Francisco? by diob on Thursday May 02, 2024 @01:47PM (#40239155)
Data?

https://www.forbes.com/sites/jackkelly/2024/04/08/how-inflat...

Inflation is absolutely a way to steal the already meager savings of the working class.

The only way it wouldn't be is if that "new money" actually entered their local economy, which I'd love to see.

Re:How much is enough to FIRE in San Francisco? by whimsicalism on Thursday May 02, 2024 @01:56PM (#40239252)
> Data?

Sure [0]. You can also look at historical US rebellions, such as Shays' rebellion - where a principle demand of the working class rebels was that the US government print more money.

> Inflation is absolutely a way to steal the already meager savings of the working class.

Exactly why inflation is generally beneficial to the working class, generally their savings are insignificant while their wages are very important - it raises their wages while reducing the value of savings & debt, which hurts people who have lots of savings and helps people who are living off of their wages.

[0]: https://realtimeinequality.org/?id=wealth&wealthend=03012023...

Re:How much is enough to FIRE in San Francisco? by diob on Thursday May 02, 2024 @10:38PM (#40243450)
You think Shays' rebellion is relevant here? That is quite the reach.

https://www.nber.org/system/files/working_papers/w31775/w317...

There is an overwhelming amount of data pointing in the opposite direction.

This is easier to answer through simple logic though. Do you think the ruling / wealthy class would allow inflation if it hurt them? Perhaps, but personally I find it a bit naive.

Let's break down your claim though

> Exactly why inflation is generally beneficial to the working class, generally their savings are insignificant while their wages are very important - it raises their wages while reducing the value of savings & debt, which hurts people who have lots of savings and helps people who are living off of their wages.

Reducing the value of debt is a real possible winner, but that helps the rich just as much. And the poor person's debt, believe it not, tends to be of high enough interest that inflation isn't going to help them as much as you claim. Especially since they are subject to variable interest rates more than most.

Savings? Once again, this is cash for them, and for the wealthy it tends to be assets that are not harmed by inflation (either by growing with them or outpacing it).

So let's get to the final claim. It raises their wages. Is that true? The wage is inflated, but their purchasing power doesn't actually improve. It tends to go down, as the things they spend their money on are, you guessed it, inflated.

It's wild to think that inflation is helping folks at the bottom.

Re:How much is enough to FIRE in San Francisco? by ww520 on Thursday May 02, 2024 @01:17PM (#40238725)
The 4% or 3% as OP put it withdrawal rate accounts for inflation.
Re:How much is enough to FIRE in San Francisco? by generic92034 on Thursday May 02, 2024 @01:13PM (#40238663)
The same as always? Pay old debt with new debt. Other countries might run into issues with exchange rates this way, but the status of the USD is dampening such effects.
Re:How much is enough to FIRE in San Francisco? by creer on Thursday May 02, 2024 @01:49PM (#40239175)
Even assuming there are always people, institutions and countries eager to buy the new debt, the government must still pay the ongoing interest on the debt. The concern is when that interest becomes a significant part of the annual budget. Then there is no money left to pay for the essentials - like, /s - government workers' salaries and retirement and military.
Re:How much is enough to FIRE in San Francisco? by generic92034 on Thursday May 02, 2024 @05:36PM (#40241630)
You can pay the ongoing interest with more debt. Sure, this will probably not work forever, not even for the USA and the special status its currency has. But "forever" is usually not a relevant concept for politicians.
Re:How much is enough to FIRE in San Francisco? by the_real_cher on Thursday May 02, 2024 @01:17PM (#40238735)
how long can you do that for?
Re:How much is enough to FIRE in San Francisco? by generic92034 on Thursday May 02, 2024 @05:38PM (#40241639)
Most countries in the West are doing that at least since WW2. To different degrees, though.
Re:How much is enough to FIRE in San Francisco? by the_real_cher on Thursday May 02, 2024 @07:21PM (#40242430)
> To different degrees, though.

There's quantifiable data on this and it's looking problematic as of now.

Re:How much is enough to FIRE in San Francisco? by the_real_cher on Thursday May 02, 2024 @01:13PM (#40238667)
I dont think people understand it or arent aware or are in blissful denial.

Im guilty of this, just a few years ago I started researching it even though its been a problem for decades or more.

The news media puts wars on the front page and the debt on the back page if its reported at all.

In my opinion this one of the biggest existential threats to America and the main stream media isnt even raising any red flags.