News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Eight Feet Jolted a $180M Real Estate Deal by crazygringo on Wednesday May 01, 2024 @04:24PM (#40228872)
First of all, the headline is pretty clickbaity -- from the article it seems quite clear that this was a case of competing buyers, and the 8-foot setback is some spurious justification for why one of the buyers didn't move fast enough.

Second, many commenters here are arguing that perpetual clauses like this ought to be disallowed. It certainly makes sense to me that clauses like these ought to be converted to regular zoning laws that the city can then adjust as future generations deem necessary.

But third, this particular clause makes sense! You wouldn't want to get rid of it. All the buildings on the block have façades that are aligned with each other, to form a continuous "wall" of buildings. The last thing you want is for some random property owner to get to jut out 8 feet in front of all the other buildings. Ensuring some minimal level of architectural consistency on a dense city block is a good thing.

So keep the eight-foot setback. It makes perfect sense. But just convert it to be a city zoning regulation. It should be decided and modified if necessary via democratic means, not private contract.

Re:Eight Feet Jolted a $180M Real Estate Deal by noah91734 on Wednesday May 01, 2024 @04:52PM (#40229260)
> Ensuring some minimal level of architectural consistency on a dense city block is a good thing.

Check zillow. Of the 32 units for rent in Brooklyn Heights, the cheapest is a tiny $2,600/month studio. The median rent is $4,500/month, and that's for an apartment with one bedroom and one bathroom.

No, I don't think allowing a 200 year old private rule to reduce living space in an age of incredible housing scarcity is good. I could not care less about your architectural consistency when it is part of the reason why people are sleeping on the streets and others are paying most of their income on rent.

Re:Eight Feet Jolted a $180M Real Estate Deal by rwmj on Wednesday May 01, 2024 @05:32PM (#40229772)
There's zero chance this particular covenant is reducing living space, instead it's preventing some billionaire from building some obnoxious entrance across the existing sidewalk.
Re:Eight Feet Jolted a $180M Real Estate Deal by throwitaway222 on Wednesday May 01, 2024 @05:23PM (#40229655)
The us is huge
Re:Eight Feet Jolted a $180M Real Estate Deal by daedrdev on Wednesday May 01, 2024 @06:42PM (#40230534)
And the market has shown where people would like to live
Re:Eight Feet Jolted a $180M Real Estate Deal by forgetfreeman on Wednesday May 01, 2024 @06:52PM (#40230618)
If by like to you mean are forced to to escape poverty...
Re:Eight Feet Jolted a $180M Real Estate Deal by nradov on Thursday May 02, 2024 @12:52AM (#40232827)
Are you claiming that it's impossible to escape poverty by moving to North Dakota and getting a job in the oil & gas industry?
Re:Eight Feet Jolted a $180M Real Estate Deal by forgetfreeman on Thursday May 02, 2024 @04:17AM (#40233873)
Are you claiming oil patch jobs aren't a rounding error per capita? Lets be clear here, you're for real claiming that a career track that employs fewer people in the continental US than Pizza Hut is relevant to a discussion of rural poverty?
Re:Eight Feet Jolted a $180M Real Estate Deal by hanniabu on Thursday May 02, 2024 @02:05AM (#40233174)
Without sacrificing health working with chemicals
Re:Eight Feet Jolted a $180M Real Estate Deal by dann0 on Thursday May 02, 2024 @12:42AM (#40232759)
No, people go to where the resources and opportunities are.

Markets are for maximising profits. Housing should not be a market.

Re:Eight Feet Jolted a $180M Real Estate Deal by dangus on Wednesday May 01, 2024 @07:33PM (#40230927)
There are a lot of bad zoning laws and covenants out there that encourage housing scarcity. This is not one of them.
Re:Eight Feet Jolted a $180M Real Estate Deal by jmoss20 on Wednesday May 01, 2024 @07:15PM (#40230766)
"sleeping on the streets" and "living in Brooklyn Heights" are hardly the only two options here.
Re:Eight Feet Jolted a $180M Real Estate Deal by noah91734 on Thursday May 02, 2024 @03:03PM (#40240194)
No snowflake in an avalanche ever feels responsible.
Re:Eight Feet Jolted a $180M Real Estate Deal by rootusrootus on Wednesday May 01, 2024 @04:37PM (#40229057)
> All the buildings on the block have façades that are aligned with each other

What's interesting here is that in the picture they provide to document the 8 foot setback, the reason the buildings do not align with each other is because of that. Other buildings on the block go right up to the sidwalk.

Re:Eight Feet Jolted a $180M Real Estate Deal by ok_dad on Wednesday May 01, 2024 @04:38PM (#40229070)
Why do you want to limit people’s property rights for looks? Why does a row of buildings need to be exactly aligned? This type of thing and HOAs are a bane upon property owners. I’m glad I don’t have an HOA, and I’ll never understand the push to not allow semi-organically grown cityscapes. You need some zoning limits, but do it Japan style rather than for looks.
Re:Eight Feet Jolted a $180M Real Estate Deal by bradleyjg on Wednesday May 01, 2024 @08:16PM (#40231257)
Why do you want to limit people’s property rights for looks?

Literally is an overused word, but it fits here:

A covenant is literally a property right!

Re:Eight Feet Jolted a $180M Real Estate Deal by beaeglebeachh on Wednesday May 01, 2024 @08:21PM (#40231301)
Covenant is the equivalent of a Eula poisoned into software you've purchased. If you own it you ought have the ability to disable the Eula. A covenant is weird because it more often than not is contract entered unilaterally by some dead guy with himself somehow under the fiction it is an agreement with the land itself, it's not clear who the counterparty even is.
Re:Eight Feet Jolted a $180M Real Estate Deal by bradleyjg on Wednesday May 01, 2024 @08:39PM (#40231435)
The major problem with EULAs is the power disparity between the buyer and seller. It’s me vs Microsoft and I can’t practically opt out of MS Word. A secondary problem is that no one knows what’s in them because no one reads them.

A real estate deal is nothing like that. The buyer and seller have roughly equal power and everyone is represented by lawyers.

Re:Eight Feet Jolted a $180M Real Estate Deal by ok_dad on Wednesday May 01, 2024 @09:06PM (#40231628)
Equal power is if you had any control over the covenant. In most cases, it’s a take it or leave it situation. That’s not equal power, that’s a complete lack of it. I personally don’t see how a covenant on a property is anything other than the attempt to control the living world from the grave, and shouldn’t be allowed. Zoning laws can change with the times, they’re sufficient to protect the property owners from major nuisances.
Re:Eight Feet Jolted a $180M Real Estate Deal by freejazz on Thursday May 02, 2024 @11:40AM (#40237498)
Zoning laws require an entire legislature to enact or change. A covenant only runs between the parties to the covenant. This is such an absurd point that is repeated here.
Re:Eight Feet Jolted a $180M Real Estate Deal by beaeglebeachh on Wednesday May 01, 2024 @04:41PM (#40229123)
Yeah this is why I bought land with no HOA and no covenants and basically no codes and liberal zoning. Sure the roads are dirt 4x4 and my neighbors have livestock and wild noises at all times but if I wanted to regulate other land I'd buy it myself rather than using violence of enforcers sent in to stop it.

If you want 8 ft setback, simple solution. Build 16 ft from your property line,problem solved even if your neighbor hits the edge.

Re:Eight Feet Jolted a $180M Real Estate Deal by financltravsty on Wednesday May 01, 2024 @06:46PM (#40230581)
Because some of the USA (notably the north east) still gives a shit about the communities where they live rather than embracing rugged frontier individualism a la "trust no one, and get yours first."

Just because you own something doesn't mean you get a free pass to be a nuisance to others. Laws are there to keep society together, not to enable antisocial proclivities.

Re:Eight Feet Jolted a $180M Real Estate Deal by ok_dad on Wednesday May 01, 2024 @07:29PM (#40230888)
Check out Japan zoning laws, pal. I’m not some rugged individual, but I still believe in reasonable freedoms. Japan doesn’t have issues with nuisances with their zoning system. Far from it.
Re:Eight Feet Jolted a $180M Real Estate Deal by financltravsty on Wednesday May 01, 2024 @07:36PM (#40230945)
That's a cultural artifact. The same as why HOAs proliferated outside the puritan colonies: people could not be trusted to self-govern and self-regulate towards a common good.

Japan doesn't have issues with nuisances because -- culturally -- they're more aware of the effect their actions have on the world around them. The same cannot be said for a large portion of the U.S.A.

I'm of the opinion freedom as a detached goal for its own sake is a puerile pursuit, and a big driver of why we can't have nice things.

Re:Eight Feet Jolted a $180M Real Estate Deal by tomek_ycomb on Thursday May 02, 2024 @09:30AM (#40236019)
Are you sure / do you have specific Japanese knowledge?

My gut assumption, not having Japanese knowledge, was always that the production needs of WWII incentivized their mixed commercial -residential system.

It does seem that a mixed commercial -residential system would work better with a conscientious of neighbors society, but the zoning itself is also key

Re:Eight Feet Jolted a $180M Real Estate Deal by shermantanktop on Wednesday May 01, 2024 @07:27PM (#40230867)
A very, very right-wing coworker once said to me: "There is no such thing as society. There is no such thing as common good. These are fictions created to control you."

I was happy he had identified our fundamental disagreement so that we didn't have to argue further.

Re:Eight Feet Jolted a $180M Real Estate Deal by financltravsty on Wednesday May 01, 2024 @07:42PM (#40230993)
Yes, now throw him out deep into the Mongolian steppes and see how he fares without modern supply chains.

Everyone's a libertarian until you take away the fruits of industry.

Re:Eight Feet Jolted a $180M Real Estate Deal by beaeglebeachh on Wednesday May 01, 2024 @07:47PM (#40231043)
Mutual benefit is a thing, industry works fine when everyone is driven by selfishness as no one agrees to a transaction unless both parties are better off.

I'd much sooner live with that coworker in the steppes than cheerman mao or other charlatans in Asian history proclaiming about the common good.

Re:Eight Feet Jolted a $180M Real Estate Deal by balderdash on Wednesday May 01, 2024 @07:28PM (#40230870)
Adding a covenant to a deed is a property right, I think wanting to know invalidate them is anti-property rights.
Re:Eight Feet Jolted a $180M Real Estate Deal by ProfessorLayton on Wednesday May 01, 2024 @07:43PM (#40231004)
My parent's house in the Bay Area came with (Now unenforceable) covenants dictating that PoC cannot live there. The can and should be changed as necessary.
Re:Eight Feet Jolted a $180M Real Estate Deal by beaeglebeachh on Wednesday May 01, 2024 @07:56PM (#40231126)
But it is anti property rights to force someone to rent or sell to poc. Of course without government influence this becomes a dumb business plan because it depressed the utility of your property and hands business to competitors.

I would argue government should eliminate racial discrimination laws as it will just shake itself out in the market and it actually makes things harder on poc.

Re:Eight Feet Jolted a $180M Real Estate Deal by bruce511 on Wednesday May 01, 2024 @10:03PM (#40231991)
In a world where humans are have rational, then your argument would be correct. Alas that's not the world we live in, as history keeps telling us.

Firstly, let's consider "2 groups". This might be racial, or straight/queer or religion or immigrant status or wealth or whatever. This issue crops up all over history (think Irish immigrants) - society has a habit of splitting into us and them.

Ultimately the split is economic - one group contains much economic power, (which is largely analogous with political power) the other far less. The group with the economic power is seeking to preserve it, the other group is trying to move economically upwards.

So to your first point - exclusivity might depress utility, but it increases value. The free market offers high premiums to exclusivity. So far from being a dumb business plan, it maximized business returns.

Above all, rich people want to live in a bubble of rich people - and zoning laws, the free market, etc (controlled by rich people) work towards this goal.

Then we toss in the notion of "my home is an investment." When you see your home as a store of wealth, then you make communal decisions to preserve that wealth (at all costs.) Will that new bridge, school, office block, anything, make the value of my home go up or down? Pretty much nothing rlse matters.

From this arises push-back laws that try and regulate the worst of these tendencies away. They're almost always fighting the inclinations of the haves to the have-nots. They are often contentious because they go against the natural inclinations of the economically advantaged.

Fundamentally your argument is flawed because those with economic power work hard to keep it. Part of that is actively working against the interests of those without. The market is very much not free.

Re:Eight Feet Jolted a $180M Real Estate Deal by freejazz on Thursday May 02, 2024 @10:38AM (#40236823)
>I would argue government should eliminate racial discrimination laws as it will just shake itself out in the market and it actually makes things harder on poc.

Yeah, many people did, and then it turned out that it wasn't working!

Re:Eight Feet Jolted a $180M Real Estate Deal by beaeglebeachh on Wednesday May 01, 2024 @07:37PM (#40230955)
If the covenant was added by a dead guy and the counterparty doesn't exist but now it's enforced by a government court against the wishes of the property owner who owns the 'right' is it really property rights at that point? I'm willing to be convinced but it's not super clear to me.
Re:Eight Feet Jolted a $180M Real Estate Deal by freejazz on Thursday May 02, 2024 @10:41AM (#40236857)
It's a property right for whoever would benefit. If no one benefits, then who is enforcing it? The gov't doesn't do so voluntarily, covenants are enforced through the civil court system.
Re:Eight Feet Jolted a $180M Real Estate Deal by caseyohara on Wednesday May 01, 2024 @05:59PM (#40230054)
I'd argue this is a bit different than your typical suburban HOA restrictions.

Cities are shared spaces, and design consistency is pleasing to humans. Beautiful architecture and good city planning are obviously subjective, but aesthetically, design consistency creates a sense of harmony, unity, and comfort compared to a disjointed hodgepodge without a cohesive architectural through line. Functionally, it can also promote things like walkability and sustainability, making it a nicer place to live and work and visit.

The 99% Invisible podcast recently had an episode about Sante Fe, NM. The city has strict guidelines for architecture and design which have ultimately been a big factor in the city's success as a tourist destination. https://99percentinvisible.org/episode/roman-mars-describes-...

Re:Eight Feet Jolted a $180M Real Estate Deal by ok_dad on Wednesday May 01, 2024 @07:32PM (#40230912)
When I see a city with organic development, I feel cozier than with the cities that all look the same and were built all the same. I think the American idea of “unity” in these matters is a bit insane and very exclusionary.
Re:Eight Feet Jolted a $180M Real Estate Deal by caseyohara on Wednesday May 01, 2024 @08:07PM (#40231206)
I meant "unity" the design principle, not the patriotic sense.

Reasonable restrictions and a bit of city planning don't preclude organic development, New York is probably the most organic city in the US. I'm not advocating for every city to be completely uniform and same-y and soulless, just cohesive and thoughtful. Cohesive != uniform.

https://www.invisionapp.com/defined/unity-principle-design

Re:Eight Feet Jolted a $180M Real Estate Deal by ok_dad on Wednesday May 01, 2024 @09:04PM (#40231609)
I think we probably agree mostly. I’m also talking about design. I prefer a less constrained design system for a city, I think it gives life. Trying to control every bit of the look of a place makes it boring and conservative, IMO. In the USA, I also think that design unity is used to get rid of undesirable persons, and keep things a certain way for certain types of people.
Re:Eight Feet Jolted a $180M Real Estate Deal by Starman_Jones on Wednesday May 01, 2024 @08:05PM (#40231193)
If there's one thing you can say about America, it's that we're nowhere near as independent and individualistic as the rest of the world. New York is tentpole of homogeneity compared to Barcelona or Lyon.
Re:Eight Feet Jolted a $180M Real Estate Deal by shiroiushi on Thursday May 02, 2024 @01:14AM (#40232917)
Come to Tokyo if you want to see a city full of radically-different buildings right next to each other.

But ask any normal American, and they'll tell you the city is "ugly" because all the buildings don't look the same.

Re:Eight Feet Jolted a $180M Real Estate Deal by renewiltord on Thursday May 02, 2024 @02:01AM (#40233155)
I wonder if this is a cultural thing imported by the original immigrants to the nation or some other factor. The American desire for uniformity is almost German. There needs to be "consistency" and "unity" in design. This is probably why so many houses are all grey and stuff. I much prefer the organic Asian form of things, and I think the US (which is generally quite awesome) would be well improved with that.
Re:Eight Feet Jolted a $180M Real Estate Deal by codexb on Wednesday May 01, 2024 @06:17PM (#40230282)
Typically, covenants are meant to cover issues more locally than zoning could, like a permanent easement for the benefit of an adjoining property or setbacks for all the properties on one street to achieve a particular aesthetic. You could make them zoning laws, but they would be rather complex and have to refer to particular parcels.

They can be removed, but typically you have to prove that removing the covenant isn't negatively impacting another property owner for which it was originally added. It can be done by unanimous agreement of the property owners, or more commonly, by just buying up all the adjoining properties.

Re:Eight Feet Jolted a $180M Real Estate Deal by bobthepanda on Wednesday May 01, 2024 @07:18PM (#40230798)
you can also invalidate a convenant through laws.

a good portion of the US has racial covenants saying what properties can be sold to whom, but none of those have been legal or legally enforceable since the Fair Housing Act. https://www.alta.org/advocacy/housing-opportunities/discrimi...

Re:Eight Feet Jolted a $180M Real Estate Deal by codexb on Thursday May 02, 2024 @12:59PM (#40238490)
Good point. Another famous example are the "entails" that many inherited estates in Britain had at one time (and a major plot point in the show Downton Abbey).
Re:Eight Feet Jolted a $180M Real Estate Deal by pc86 on Wednesday May 01, 2024 @04:27PM (#40228930)
Doesn't your argument that this should be converting to a zoning regulate kind of negate your point that we should want to ensure some level of consistency on a dense city block?
Re:Eight Feet Jolted a $180M Real Estate Deal by crazygringo on Wednesday May 01, 2024 @04:38PM (#40229066)
No, the point is that the zoning maintains the consistency.

But that if someday in the future there's a greater public need for something that outweights the architectural consistency, there's the flexibility to consider that too, through the existing public mechanisms of zoning changes.

Like if the entire block gets purchased and torn down to put in a single school building, then the setback is no longer needed, because a new kind of consistency can take its place.

Re:Eight Feet Jolted a $180M Real Estate Deal by sam1r on Wednesday May 01, 2024 @04:51PM (#40229247)
So in other words, this feat was a well worthwhile hack
Re:Eight Feet Jolted a $180M Real Estate Deal by renewiltord on Thursday May 02, 2024 @01:46AM (#40233067)
Personally, I think rent is far too high. We need real change. Perhaps hard-working worker co-ops could build homes designed to a consistent pattern by artists like me for us to live in. Housing is a human right, so the government should build them. It's sheer Mammon-worship if someone were to make a profit so we should ensure that doesn't happen. We could call the project El Sombrito.
Re:Eight Feet Jolted a $180M Real Estate Deal by freejazz on Thursday May 02, 2024 @11:37AM (#40237459)
Isn't it absurd for a zoning regulation to pertain to only one city block? Isn't that actually the antithesis of the concept of zoning?