News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Facebook’s stock should trade for $13.80 by cageface on Friday May 25, 2012 @02:14AM (#4022173)
The researchers found that the revenue of the average company going public between 1996 and 2010 grew by 212% over the five years after its IPO.

Assuming that its five-year return is equal to the stock market’s long-term average return of 11% annualized, Facebook shares currently would need to be trading at just $13.80.

I'm as bearish as anybody on FB but this seems like extremely lazy analysis. FB may be many things but average is certainly not one of them.

Re:Facebook’s stock should trade for $13.80 by tokenadult on Friday May 25, 2012 @08:52AM (#4023236)
FB may be many things but average is certainly not one of them.

Several of the other comments you have received relate to this idea, so please allow me to ask a specific question (directed both to you and to onlookers). What is not average about Facebook? For some commenting here, the specific question I have is what is above average about Facebook, related to its revenue, to suggest it will overperform the average of historic experience of companies that have IPOed? As an investor, interested in a non-lazy analysis, what should I look for to decide whether or not Facebook is a good investment at the current price of its stock? I note that you wrote,

I'm as bearish as anybody on FB but this seems like extremely lazy analysis.

so I'm not specifically asking you for a rationale for buying Facebook. Other comments at this comment level or below imply that there may be a rationale (perhaps unconvincing to you, but perhaps convincing to some onlooker) for buying Facebook's stock at today's price. What rationale is that? If I had some extra money, would I be well advised to invest it in Facebook stock? Why or why not?

I'd appreciate hearing from anyone who has an analysis that goes deeper than the news headlines of the last week since the Facebook IPO. Thanks.

Re:Facebook’s stock should trade for $13.80 by daguar on Friday May 25, 2012 @09:45AM (#4023404)
Well, the analytical question here is: what is the appropriate sample for comparison?

The article uses US IPOs 1996-2010 as the initial sample. I'd like to know how sensitive this is to expanding or narrowing that range. How does that average change if you adjust the range? (The academic article may have some note of this.)

Then, the article makes comparison to Google's current price-to-sales ratio as a benchmark (5.51-1). The analytic justification is nothing more than "[s]ince Facebook FB -0.64% is most often compared to Google GOOG -0.66%..."

Some questions I'd ask about this:

- What did Google's P/S ratio look like at IPO, and what was its growth?

- What does Facebook's P/S ratio look like compared a broader sample of tech companies' P/S ratios? Or including non-tech companies?

- Why not use price-to-earnings ratio? (I'm not a finance guy, but the subtle difference in wording here gives me pause to at least investigate the question.)

So what you're hearing me say is: we need sensitivity analysis. The assumed benchmarks appear arbitrary enough that we have to see how the results change when you adjust the inputs.

Lastly, there's the age-old fundamentals versus intangibles question: investors make their decisions based on both. The fundamental analysis (of earnings, etc., like the article does) is not deterministic: it just gives you context. Intangibles (faith in management, broader understanding of how the market will shift and affect the firm's competitive position) matter, too. They're just, well, intangible.

But also included under the umbrella of intangibles is how investor sentiment toward the company may change. If people think FB is going to make some huge announcements in the next year that will send the share price skyrocketing for a short (but not sustainable) high watermark, then that potential short-term return is worth buying.

[Edit 5/25 6:57a PT - changed range from 96-00 to 96-10 based on correction. Thanks!]

Re:Facebook’s stock should trade for $13.80 by brightrhino on Friday May 25, 2012 @09:55AM (#4023449)
The article says the analysis uses the 1996-2010 timeframe, not 2000, so that is a few more IPO's.
Re:Facebook’s stock should trade for $13.80 by jaxn on Friday May 25, 2012 @09:55AM (#4023455)
You don't want to use price to earnings for a company in a growth phase like this. The reason is that they are likely spending their revenue to grow the business (in the simplest example, buying more servers and staffing up).
Re:Facebook’s stock should trade for $13.80 by cageface on Friday May 25, 2012 @10:18AM (#4023564)
Bearish == skeptical. I don't intend to buy FB and I think it's overvalued.

But I say that because I think FB's style of social networking is a fad, not because I believe crude aggregate statistics of internet companies in general tell us something useful in FB's case.

Re:Facebook’s stock should trade for $13.80 by freshfunk on Friday May 25, 2012 @12:05PM (#4024054)
Social networking is not a fad. If anything it's becoming an underlying utility of the internet much like email, instant messaging and search. Any technology that's so core to the internet starts out as a standalone application (hotmail, AIM, Google) and becomes an underlying layer.

Facebook's advantage? They have a virtual monopoly on this utility. Not only that, switching costs are high (unlike email and search).

Look at the kind of growth apps gets from integrating with Facebook (Instagram, Viddy, Spotify). All social apps going forward will only reinforce their position by integrating with them.

Re:Facebook’s stock should trade for $13.80 by cageface on Friday May 25, 2012 @12:30PM (#4024205)
People used to say exactly the same things about Compuserve and AOL. Internet castles tend to be built on sand.
Re:Facebook’s stock should trade for $13.80 by jaxn on Friday May 25, 2012 @09:52AM (#4023439)
I think what makes Facebook above average is that at IPO they are looking better than Google did at IPO. I think we can all agree Google is above average.

1) Current P/E is 74 (Google IPOed at 132 and was proven to be undervalued).

2) Facebook has higher revenues than Google did at IPO.

3) Facebook has more users, and more engaged users than Google did at IPO (though there is some question as to whether or not FB can continue to grow users).

Yes, they have to figure out the "facebook way" of delivering ads, but if they do...

Re:Facebook’s stock should trade for $13.80 by quesera on Friday May 25, 2012 @12:26PM (#4024193)
Google IPOed into a growing market. It is not clear how FB's market or ARPU will grow from here.

They left negative money on the table at the table at the IPO. Good for them, and probably good for their long-term prospects (big buffer), but from a retail investor perspective, the business has a lot of catching up to do to meet the market.

I actually agree with the $10-15 conclusion right now, but the business has a chance to make up some of that gap before the share price goes there. Probably.

(not invested, and happily so)

Re:Facebook’s stock should trade for $13.80 by freshfunk on Friday May 25, 2012 @12:10PM (#4024097)
A lazy analysis but look at revenue they're getting from payments. From their S-1:

Mar 31, 2011: $94MM Mar 31, 2012: $186MM

Obviously it's only two data points but payment revenue has grown 100%. Payments revenue only represents 10% of their total revenues.

WRT to this, the question becomes whether they could ramp up payments. I'm guessing that their main driver for payments revenue is games.

They recently launched offers. That could potentially drive revenue.

I think that Facebook should take on Square and enter the payments market. They're in a unique position to create Facebook Wallet.

The biggest barriers I see from this is that Zuckerberg would have to drive this kind of strategy and it doesn't seem like a move he'd take.

Re:Facebook’s stock should trade for $13.80 by drumdance on Friday May 25, 2012 @01:05PM (#4024416)
The main argument is that Facebook has created a platform that reaches nearly 15% of the entire planet. Nothing like this has ever happened this fast. Coke and other consumer brands may have similar or even larger markets, but it took them many, many years to get there.
Re:Facebook’s stock should trade for $13.80 by mattmanser on Friday May 25, 2012 @09:24AM (#4023336)
Generally speaking it's that they haven't had their 'ah-ha' moment of monetization yet that Google had with ad-words.

Some think it'll never come. But it's a factor.

Re:Facebook’s stock should trade for $13.80 by wildbunny on Friday May 25, 2012 @10:15AM (#4023548)
They have, and it was facebook credits. If that didn't maximise their profits then nothing will.
Re:Facebook’s stock should trade for $13.80 by astrofinch on Friday May 25, 2012 @02:46AM (#4022257)
Standard bubble talk: "This is historically unprecedented! Everything is going to be different this time!"
Re:Facebook’s stock should trade for $13.80 by JumpCrisscross on Friday May 25, 2012 @06:54AM (#4022941)
Two issues:

1. FB doesn't behave like the sample mean

2. FB doesn't behave like the sample

1 does not mean 2. In fact, without any statistics of dispersion (which the Kauffman paper doesn't provide) we cannot rule on 2 whatsoever.

Re:Facebook’s stock should trade for $13.80 by Confusion on Friday May 25, 2012 @10:01AM (#4023475)
A. We're in a bubble.

B. We're not in a bubble

A. You're saying things people also say when we're in a bubble, so we're in a bubble

B. I'm saying things people also say when we're not in a bubble

B. You, on the other hand, are saying the exact things people say when we're not in a bubble

A. I'm saying things that those that are right also say when we are in a bubble

B. Well, I'm saying things that those that are right also say when we "are not" in a bubble.

It's all standard talk, both your comment and what you're responding to and it all gets said both inside and outside of bubbles. What 'is being said' is never an argument. Everything is always 'being said'.

You would have said the same thing about Google and Amazon last time around. For some reason, they were different. Don't make predictions if you don't have an outstanding track record to back them up. Otherwise, nobody has any reason to believe you.

Re:Facebook’s stock should trade for $13.80 by redwood on Friday May 25, 2012 @02:32AM (#4022217)
Yes and no... considering FB's incredibly massive eyes on page, today, which might not last... they've been pretty bad about monetizing and they've had about 6 years of knowing they were huge to do it. That's not a great track record (as far as making big returns)
Re:Facebook’s stock should trade for $13.80 by cageface on Friday May 25, 2012 @02:36AM (#4022229)
Sure. It's not hard to construct all kinds of failure scenarios for FB. I just don't think that crude averages are much use here at all.

In general I think that an average just isn't a very useful statistic. It throws away way too much information.

Re:Facebook’s stock should trade for $13.80 by codeka on Friday May 25, 2012 @03:46AM (#4022428)
It would be interesting to note what the standard deviation is on those figures. My guess is it's quite high, which does give Facebook a bit of breathing room.
Re:Facebook’s stock should trade for $13.80 by philbarr on Friday May 25, 2012 @04:32AM (#4022557)
I'm surprised how often a mean is quoted without a standard deviation. Especially in an analysis like this. It's only telling you half the story.
Re:Facebook’s stock should trade for $13.80 by hessenwolf on Friday May 25, 2012 @03:58AM (#4022461)
Reading Peter Thiel's lecture notes and I think it is the sixth one that goes into great detail about the returns of new companies following a power law. Hence, the average is mindbendingly irrelevant.

I am certainly not buying into facebook, but not due to this analysis.

Re:Facebook’s stock should trade for $13.80 by dododo on Friday May 25, 2012 @06:47AM (#4022922)
if it is a power law in the sense that a few companies return a lot, whilst most return a little, how does that make the mean irrelevant?

the mean of a power law of this form is more skewed by the few companies returning a lot than it is by the majority. assuming that more than 50% of the companies return a little, the median would be irrelevant, but the mean is very sensitive to outliers.

Re:Facebook’s stock should trade for $13.80 by tedunangst on Friday May 25, 2012 @10:38AM (#4023661)
Consider four companies' returns: [1, 1, 1, 100]. The median, 1, is a reasonable predictor for the next company's return. The mean, 25, doesn't seem like a likely outcome.
Re:Facebook’s stock should trade for $13.80 by dododo on Friday May 25, 2012 @01:02PM (#4024399)
there is not a normative way to discriminate between those two predictions.

it comes down to what kind of loss you incur for making an incorrect prediction. for mean, it's a squared loss (which penalizes you for being wrong in the tails more heavily) but for a median it's the absolute loss.

the argument being made was that fb is an outlier and (as I read it) the mean didn't reflect it, so the maths was "lazy" as it didn't take that into account. actually the mean does take these outliers into account (since it's corresponding loss function penalizes you harshly for being wrong in the tails) and so is probably not too unreasonable at predicting on outlier companies (certainly better than the median).

Re:Facebook’s stock should trade for $13.80 by patrickk on Friday May 25, 2012 @06:42AM (#4022906)
That's actually a great point. Even after reading those notes I still wouldn't have thought of applying the power law to my thinking about Facebook (I don't think Facebook will prove anything special long term but it's always useful to be critical in your thinking and consider multiple points of view).

As an aside, those notes are an incredible way of thinking about the world differently. I've gotten a lot out of it.

Re:Facebook’s stock should trade for $13.80 by daguar on Friday May 25, 2012 @09:29AM (#4023350)
"New companies" versus "companies that go IPO" are completely different categories.

It's an obvious point when you think about it. This is survivorship bias: many new companies fail (with a return of ~zero) before becoming a part of the IPO sample.

Re:Facebook’s stock should trade for $13.80 by hessenwolf on Friday May 25, 2012 @10:43AM (#4023689)
Yes, but a Pareto distribution looks just the same if you left censor it at some point.
Re:Facebook’s stock should trade for $13.80 by nandemo on Friday May 25, 2012 @05:12AM (#4022683)
> FB may be many things but average is certainly not one of them.

Do you mean the assumption of 212% growth over 5 years is lowish? If so, I agree.

As for the average return: the author is fixing a price at T+5years, so if you assume a higher-than-average expected return for Facebook, then its current stock price should be even lower.

Also note that even as a back-of-envelope estimate, his analysis is flawed because the 212% figure was calculated by comparing revenues adjusted for inflation, while the 11% figure is for non-adjusted total return. The corresponding real (inflation-adjusted) average return is 7%:

http://www.simplestockinvesting.com/SP500-historical-real-to...

Re:Facebook’s stock should trade for $13.80 by lunaru on Friday May 25, 2012 @05:38AM (#4022754)
I think it's even lower than 7% if you go back far enough: http://home.earthlink.net/~intelligentbear/com-dj-infl.htm

The truth is, the stock market, given a long enough timespan, barely beats inflation.

Re:Facebook’s stock should trade for $13.80 by rjtavares on Friday May 25, 2012 @06:37AM (#4022892)
I'm not even going into how they change official statistics arbitrarily on a particular time period, but the article itself says that "Dividends are excluded, so the chart only shows capital gains. The dividend yield of the S&P is running near 2%."

So, 1.9% above inflation plus 2% dividend yield, plus 2.3% current CPI, plus 2.7% "shadow CPI" (the number is from that article you posted) you get a 9% return. That means that facebook should be worth more, not less (since you are discounting at a lower rate).

Re:Facebook’s stock should trade for $13.80 by meric on Friday May 25, 2012 @09:47AM (#4023413)
Also the dividend payout has not been 2% for all time - back in the 50's it was around 7%.

http://www.financialsense.com/contributors/ronald-griess/com...

Re:Facebook’s stock should trade for $13.80 by z92 on Friday May 25, 2012 @05:50AM (#4022780)
> The truth is, the stock market, given a long enough timespan, barely beats inflation.

I want to believe that.

Re:Facebook’s stock should trade for $13.80 by johncarpinelli on Friday May 25, 2012 @02:29AM (#4022204)
FB is a much larger company than the average IPO. Larger companies often grow slower as they dominate their markets. With 900 million users, it would seem that the developed countries are fairly saturated and won't see much growth in the user base.

I would be interested to see some projections for FB costs over the next five years. They no longer have the lure of pre-IPO equity to attract new employees. They might have to pay higher salaries instead. Many insiders will be cashing out in the coming months and moving on, so I would guess that FB salary costs are going to climb significantly.

Re:Facebook’s stock should trade for $13.80 by xyzzyz on Friday May 25, 2012 @07:09AM (#4022971)
900 million users are not their customers, they are the product. I'm sure that there are lots of people and companies that haven't been advertising themselves on facebook so far -- I'm not suggesting they should, it's just the market isn't really saturated.
Re:Facebook’s stock should trade for $13.80 by ChuckMcM on Friday May 25, 2012 @02:23AM (#4022189)
Agreed. I read this and said "You are looking back to 1996? Seriously?" Now I am sure that the market will figure out what to do with the company but I sure as heck don't see these guys shorting a few hundred million shares.

But there is a lot of challenges in wrapping your head around the economics here as well. This is why a lot of people don't understand Google's profitability either.

Re:Facebook’s stock should trade for $13.80 by StandardBub on Friday May 25, 2012 @02:30AM (#4022209)
The 1996 to 2000 period was remarkable as the dot-com IPO crazy period. It's the closest, and most optimistic investment environment to what we are seeing today, thus makes a good comparison for making an optimistic valuation model for Facebook.
Re:Facebook’s stock should trade for $13.80 by pyoung on Friday May 25, 2012 @03:38AM (#4022410)
Are you serious? The two periods are hardly comparable. See link.

http://www.hbs.edu/units/finance/pdf/Where%20Have_April_3_20...

Re:Facebook’s stock should trade for $13.80 by ChuckMcM on Friday May 25, 2012 @03:28PM (#4025062)
That is a great paper btw. It's nice to see some analysis of the impact of velocity on startups and IPOs rather than just regulation.
Re:Facebook’s stock should trade for $13.80 by pbreit on Friday May 25, 2012 @04:05AM (#4022480)
Too bad the study's period was 1996 to 2010.
Re:Facebook’s stock should trade for $13.80 by JumpCrisscross on Friday May 25, 2012 @07:10AM (#4022974)
Actually, it's June 1996 to December 2005 [1]

[1] http://bear.warrington.ufl.edu/ritter/post_ipo_report_052220... (page 9, Panel C)