News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Crypto Mixer Samourai Wallet's Co-Founders Arrested for M... by aurareturn on Friday April 26, 2024 @10:10AM (#40169652)
People have longed said that crypto has no use cases. They're clearly wrong. There is only one true use case for crypto: Making it easier to skirt the law.

This includes: selling/trading unregistered securities, scams, rug pulls, money laundering.

Re:Crypto Mixer Samourai Wallet's Co-Founders Arrested for M... by JumpCrisscross on Friday April 26, 2024 @10:46AM (#40170000)
> one true use case for crypto: Making it easier to skirt the law

And gambling. That's a $580bn market on its own [1]. Add to that the $2 to 5tn of money laundering that occurs globally [2][3], assume a 15% take rate, and on the upper bound you have another $580bn market. Curiously, adding those together one gets 91% of the current "market cap" of Bitcoin [4].

Really, all Bitcoin has to do is displace every casino and every cartel and it would be worth over 90% of its current price.

[1] https://www.thebusinessresearchcompany.com/report/gambling-g...

[2] https://www.imf.org/en/News/Articles/2015/09/28/04/53/sp0210...

[3] https://www.imf.org/external/datamapper/NGDPD@WEO/OEMDC/ADVE...

[4] https://coinmarketcap.com

Re:Crypto Mixer Samourai Wallet's Co-Founders Arrested for M... by derangedHorse on Friday April 26, 2024 @07:12PM (#40175349)
I subjectively disagree with your sentiment but can objectively show you are not accurately quoting your sources. Source [2] and [3] show nothing about $2-$5 trillion dollars being laundered globally. [2] links to an article written in 1998 presumably re-published in 2015 because of the number's presence in the url path, and [3] links to the 'GDP, current prices' of the IMF. Maybe your estimate for the amount of money laundered globally is factual, but your links definitely don't show that.

Also, nothing is "curious" about you adding rough estimates together and getting a random percentage of something else.

Re:Crypto Mixer Samourai Wallet's Co-Founders Arrested for M... by tromp on Friday April 26, 2024 @10:19AM (#40169792)
Simple counterexample: I've use crypto to pay out bounties to anonymous coders for doubling the performance of my open source software.
Re:Crypto Mixer Samourai Wallet's Co-Founders Arrested for M... by bnchrch on Friday April 26, 2024 @10:53AM (#40170130)
It let me purchase and sell a small software app without going to the bank, signing documents, paying $75 just to orchestrate a wire transfer.
Re:Crypto Mixer Samourai Wallet's Co-Founders Arrested for M... by aurareturn on Friday April 26, 2024 @11:17AM (#40170487)
Yes, skirting the law. Banks/payments have regulations.
Re:Crypto Mixer Samourai Wallet's Co-Founders Arrested for M... by bnchrch on Friday April 26, 2024 @11:19AM (#40170520)
Nothing wrong / illegal about what we did. Legitimate business, Used stable coins, filed taxes.
Re:Crypto Mixer Samourai Wallet's Co-Founders Arrested for M... by aurareturn on Friday April 26, 2024 @11:26AM (#40170632)
Not the point. Crypto skips all the regulations.
Re:Crypto Mixer Samourai Wallet's Co-Founders Arrested for M... by megadal on Friday April 26, 2024 @11:48AM (#40170921)
> Not the point.

No that's exactly the point. The point is what is a legitimate use case for crypto, this use case is getting around pointless bureaucracy. You don't get around regulations, the responsibility of adhering to them just shifts from a third party to you, hence the person you're replying to paid taxes.

Are you implying avoiding operating fees is not a valid use case? Operating fees help facilitate adherence to regulation at scale but they themselves are not the regulation.

Re:Crypto Mixer Samourai Wallet's Co-Founders Arrested for M... by boringg on Friday April 26, 2024 @10:20AM (#40169798)
You have a sample size issue for your counter.
Re:Crypto Mixer Samourai Wallet's Co-Founders Arrested for M... by Kiro on Friday April 26, 2024 @10:39AM (#40169910)
It's a huge movement happening in the OSS space but HN refuses to acknowledge it.
Re:Crypto Mixer Samourai Wallet's Co-Founders Arrested for M... by bnchrch on Friday April 26, 2024 @10:52AM (#40170107)
HN unfortunately isn't very objective on this particular subject.
Re:Crypto Mixer Samourai Wallet's Co-Founders Arrested for M... by smohare on Friday April 26, 2024 @10:45AM (#40169979)
Do you have any stats to support this is some “huge movement” relative to whatever is considered standard practice? I ask this as an honest question since I’d never heard of the phenomenon, but am not steeped in OSS dev work by any means.
Re:Crypto Mixer Samourai Wallet's Co-Founders Arrested for M... by boringg on Friday April 26, 2024 @10:19AM (#40169793)
Why do you think it's doing so well?
Re:Crypto Mixer Samourai Wallet's Co-Founders Arrested for M... by eimrine on Friday April 26, 2024 @10:46AM (#40170002)
> There is only one true use case for crypto:

Same with the second amendmend: the only one true use case for firearms is

> Making it easier to skirt the law

...if (not if, when) the Government goes nuts.

Re:Crypto Mixer Samourai Wallet's Co-Founders Arrested for M... by RandomLensman on Friday April 26, 2024 @10:58AM (#40170207)
Only if it goes "nuts" in very specific ways: Anything that means the government can exercise large scale organized violence while backed by a sufficient number of people means it doesn't help.
Re:Crypto Mixer Samourai Wallet's Co-Founders Arrested for M... by eimrine on Friday April 26, 2024 @11:10AM (#40170389)
That is not a "very" specific way considering that the government has monopoly on violence by definition of the government.

Actually most of the governments are exactly on that ground abusing the fact that only few countries allows the citizens to own firearms.

Re:Crypto Mixer Samourai Wallet's Co-Founders Arrested for M... by RandomLensman on Friday April 26, 2024 @11:13AM (#40170427)
The stuff only helps if the government goes weakly nuts - otherwise unlikely to help much.

The large number of guns in Germany wasn't doing anything against the Nazis. The idea of violently overcoming an organised tyrannical and violent government that has millions of people supporting it is largely a US myth. Maybe the Russian revolution qualifies - but that kind of swapped things only.

Re:Crypto Mixer Samourai Wallet's Co-Founders Arrested for M... by JumpCrisscross on Friday April 26, 2024 @11:18AM (#40170500)
> idea of violently overcoming an organised tyrannical and violent government that has millions of people supporting is a US myth

It's designed to increase the cost of an unpopular takeover, not let Joe who thinks he can shoot 100 yards with a glock take on the U.S. army. The Nazis were popular when they came to power. Contrast that with e.g. Hong Kong.

Re:Crypto Mixer Samourai Wallet's Co-Founders Arrested for M... by RandomLensman on Friday April 26, 2024 @11:20AM (#40170530)
You are making my point: it is largely useless when considering how powerful but evil governments have formed or oppressed some minorities etc.
Re:Crypto Mixer Samourai Wallet's Co-Founders Arrested for M... by derangedHorse on Friday April 26, 2024 @07:21PM (#40175409)
Guns aren't a good analogy and the arguments against guns making a meaningful difference for a non-violent minority don't make as much sense. Money separated from state at least prevents the non-violent minority from having the fruits of their labor power those who might end up oppressing them.
Re:Crypto Mixer Samourai Wallet's Co-Founders Arrested for M... by mam2 on Friday April 26, 2024 @10:45AM (#40169990)
This includes

- making donation to ukraine if you're russian

- not have your asset frozen if you protest and the canada government disagree

- protecting yourself against false accusation

- protecting again a country that would turn communist in an election (closer than you think in some european ones)

- getting an additional veil of anonymity if you have to do something illegal in your state such as abortion or defending gay rights.

so yeah this is 'against the law' but sometime the law is not on the good side.

Re:Crypto Mixer Samourai Wallet's Co-Founders Arrested for M... by JumpCrisscross on Friday April 26, 2024 @10:50AM (#40170065)
> making donation to ukraine if you're russian

Crypto, much less crypto from Russians, hasn't been a meaningful contribution vector for Ukraine. Even when we look at the crypto donated, most (EDIT: half) of it was dollar denominated [1].

[1] https://www.coindesk.com/consensus-magazine/2023/07/27/ukrai...

Re:Crypto Mixer Samourai Wallet's Co-Founders Arrested for M... by eimrine on Friday April 26, 2024 @11:06AM (#40170333)
> Even when we look at the crypto donated, most of it was dollar denominated [1].

Have you at least read your source? 120 of 225M were BTC + ETH.

> Crypto, much less crypto from Russians, hasn't been a meaningful contribution vector for Ukraine.

Crypto is there barely since the Second Maydan, of course Ukrainians managed to survive without cryptocurrencies.

If you look closely on your arguments, you will find just a rejection without any arguments. Didn't you observe the recent news about Xenia Havana who donated $50 from her American bank account being in Russia and therefore went into jail?

Re:Crypto Mixer Samourai Wallet's Co-Founders Arrested for M... by JumpCrisscross on Friday April 26, 2024 @11:11AM (#40170397)
> 120 of 225M were BTC + ETH

Sorry, meant to say half. Corrected. Thank you.

> Xenia Havana who donated $50 from her American bank account being in Russia and therefore went into jail?

$50 is not meaningful.

Re:Crypto Mixer Samourai Wallet's Co-Founders Arrested for M... by VMG on Friday April 26, 2024 @11:20AM (#40170536)
> $50 is not meaningful.

for her it is, in many ways

Re:Crypto Mixer Samourai Wallet's Co-Founders Arrested for M... by JumpCrisscross on Friday April 26, 2024 @11:46AM (#40170896)
> for her it is, in many ways

Sure. I never said crypto is useless. But something being randomly meaningful to one person doesn't make it "a meaningful contribution vector for Ukraine."

Re:Crypto Mixer Samourai Wallet's Co-Founders Arrested for M... by eimrine on Friday April 26, 2024 @11:27AM (#40170643)
> $50

A human went to jail because of using obsoleted money transaction technologies and you are really judging the fact by the amount of her donation - just to protect your misjudgement about cryptocurrencies? Are you even Ukrainian?

> Sorry, meant to say half. Corrected. Thank you.

Even if it would be 99%, so what? Why are using this as an argument?

Re:Crypto Mixer Samourai Wallet's Co-Founders Arrested for M... by JumpCrisscross on Friday April 26, 2024 @11:35AM (#40170749)
> judging the fact by the amount of her donation

I said the dollar amount isn't meaningful. Because the original claim was that "crypto, much less crypto from Russians, hasn't been a meaningful contribution vector for Ukraine."

> Even if it would be 99%, so what?

It means crypto is being used to send U.S. dollars. It's a derivative financial system, and one completely subject to U.S. law, surveillance and sanctions.

The Ukraine example is not a case study for crypto delivering value add at scale.

Re:Crypto Mixer Samourai Wallet's Co-Founders Arrested for M... by eimrine on Friday April 26, 2024 @11:41AM (#40170828)
> I said the dollar amount isn't meaningful. Because the original claim was that "crypto, much less crypto from Russians, hasn't been a meaningful contribution vector for Ukraine."

Your saying isn't reasonable because you are talking about tangential things to cryptocurrency. Ability to donate from/to some dissidents despite of crazy thugs is meaningful. Amount of donated funds by Ukrainian anti-Russian adventure is not.

> It means crypto is being used to send U.S. dollars. The Ukraine example is not a case study for crypto delivering value add at scale.

It is as reasonable as to say that USD is being used to send Bitcoins. Why not, aren't you able to buy Bitcoins with USD?

Re:Crypto Mixer Samourai Wallet's Co-Founders Arrested for M... by JumpCrisscross on Friday April 26, 2024 @11:45AM (#40170882)
> Ability to donate from/to some dissidents despite of crazy thugs is meaningful

Sure. Still isn't "a meaningful contribution vector for Ukraine."

> as reasonable as to say that USD is being used to send Bitcoins. Why not, aren't you able to buy Bitcoins with USD?

No, it absolutely isn't. The U.S. Treasury isn't holding a pot of Bitcoins to back its value. A stablecoin holds dollars or dollar-denominated assets. This is particularly germane given the context of money laundering.

Re:Crypto Mixer Samourai Wallet's Co-Founders Arrested for M... by eimrine on Friday April 26, 2024 @01:31PM (#40172002)
> Still isn't "a meaningful contribution vector for Ukraine."

I don't say an opposite. An entire counter-claim about "donations to Ukraine was only 217M" is not an argument against Bitcoin, despite your efforts to present it so.

> The U.S. Treasury isn't holding a pot of Bitcoins to back its value.

LOL the crypto is one of established commodities perfectly fitting for inter-government trade.

> A stablecoin holds dollars or dollar-denominated assets. This is particularly germane given the context of money laundering.

I don't understand why it is important. A couple of thugs believes they can call "money laudering" anything they don't like, and what? Their presence is clearly diminishes because they have no ways to control cryptocurrencies.

Re:Crypto Mixer Samourai Wallet's Co-Founders Arrested for M... by MacsHeadroom on Friday April 26, 2024 @11:34AM (#40170727)
Dollar denominated crypto is still crypto.
Re:Crypto Mixer Samourai Wallet's Co-Founders Arrested for M... by JumpCrisscross on Friday April 26, 2024 @11:38AM (#40170794)
> Dollar denominated crypto is still crypto

Sure. But within the context of a money-laundering article, it's important to note that dollar-denominated crypto exists at the whim of the U.S. government. It is globally subject to U.S. jurisdiction, and uniquely vulnerable to U.S. surveillance and sanctions.

Re:Crypto Mixer Samourai Wallet's Co-Founders Arrested for M... by MacsHeadroom on Sunday May 05, 2024 @01:01AM (#40262370)
This is not a property of stable coins, but of permissioned stable coins only. Decentralized permission less stableclins like DAI etc. are beholden to none.
Re:Crypto Mixer Samourai Wallet's Co-Founders Arrested for M... by mam2 on Friday April 26, 2024 @01:04PM (#40171761)
The volume of contribution is not the point.
Re:Crypto Mixer Samourai Wallet's Co-Founders Arrested for M... by elsonrodriguez on Friday April 26, 2024 @10:56AM (#40170177)
Bit of a tangent, but the fundraiser that the Canadian government froze was initially organized by a Canadian secessionist and a white nationalist, and during that protest (and possibly unrelated) weapons were seized at a border crossing from members of diagalon, a white nationalist group that wants to carve out parts of Canada and USA to make a “white” nation.

Unlike your other examples, that one is an example of using crypto for nefarious reasons.

Re:Crypto Mixer Samourai Wallet's Co-Founders Arrested for M... by 49para on Friday April 26, 2024 @11:23AM (#40170573)
You mean the Diagolon group who's leader is a cocaine using ceramic time travelling goat ?

https://www.tiktok.com/@alphaaaroxy_teammoto/video/716155578...

The Diagolon that the House of Commons said was a "violent extremist organisation." but has never committed a crime ?

The same Diagolon that the RCMP determined: "DIAGOLON does not pose a criminal or national security threat." - Royal Canadian Mounted Police https://finance.yahoo.com/news/documents-reveal-shocking-rcm...

Diagolon is a meme and you don't get it, which is ok but stop spreading misinformation.

Re:Crypto Mixer Samourai Wallet's Co-Founders Arrested for M... by elsonrodriguez on Friday April 26, 2024 @12:15PM (#40171123)
Ah, so there was a procedural issue in prosecuting the group with a cache of guns that wants to carve out a white nation out of Canada and the US. My mistake.

This doesn’t change the point that from the perspective of the Canadian government, they were facing 2 racist separatist groups at a time, and one of the groups was raising a LOT of cash while leading an occupation of the capital.

This is a valid scenario for seizing funds, though maybe the fact that groups like Diagalon and Wexit are a “meme” should be considered more closely.

Re:Crypto Mixer Samourai Wallet's Co-Founders Arrested for M... by 49para on Friday April 26, 2024 @01:07PM (#40171812)
Where are these racist separatist groups coming from ?

Sure Wexit is a separatist group but I fail to see where you are getting racist from.

One of the originators of Diagolon is black.

Re:Crypto Mixer Samourai Wallet's Co-Founders Arrested for M... by elsonrodriguez on Saturday April 27, 2024 @12:10AM (#40177145)
In the case of Wexit, Tamara Lich was a founder, and she buddied up with Pat King for the fundraiser, who is a self avowed white supremacist, like he's literally on twitter saying white people have the "strongest" bloodline.

If someone who is involved with multiple "Canada for Canadians" movements joins forces with a known racist, I would take the odds and bet good money that person is a racist.

Re:Crypto Mixer Samourai Wallet's Co-Founders Arrested for M... by mam2 on Friday April 26, 2024 @01:06PM (#40171791)
I was talking about the truckers during covid. and once again : not the point. Money is neutral, it's what you do with it that's bad.

The law pretends decidiing everything about right or wrong, but there are plenty of legitimate cases where the law is on the wrong side.

Re:Crypto Mixer Samourai Wallet's Co-Founders Arrested for M... by RandomLensman on Friday April 26, 2024 @10:52AM (#40170114)
Which European countries are close to becoming communist? And what protection does it offer then if said communist countries use violence to collect private wealth?
Re:Crypto Mixer Samourai Wallet's Co-Founders Arrested for M... by mam2 on Friday April 26, 2024 @01:07PM (#40171823)
Mélenchon in France has big scores wants to take 100% (everything) on income tax above 30k per month per individual. Do this and I will instantly get paid in crypto and have a new nationality
Re:Crypto Mixer Samourai Wallet's Co-Founders Arrested for M... by RandomLensman on Friday April 26, 2024 @01:52PM (#40172246)
Even if that were to happen (which I cannot see as the PS polls around 12%) it would be a far cry from actual communism. Also, how would crypto help if the situation would be permanent and you stayed there?
Re:Crypto Mixer Samourai Wallet's Co-Founders Arrested for M... by eimrine on Friday April 26, 2024 @10:50AM (#40170079)
Also if you are Russian living outside of Russia then good luck having a bank account, since European scumbags effectively consider any Russian as villain.
Re:Crypto Mixer Samourai Wallet's Co-Founders Arrested for M... by mam2 on Friday April 26, 2024 @01:08PM (#40171829)
hence crypto.

Also there are many other countries than europe and russia