News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Biden signs TikTok 'ban' bill into law, starting clock fo... by JumpCrisscross on Wednesday April 24, 2024 @05:28PM (#40149908)
> Twitter, Facebook, Instagram, Snapchat, YouTube, WhatsApp, will either have to stop operating outside of the Unites States or they will need to be sold to every country they wish to operate in

TikTok can sell to a French, Hungarian, Indian, Brazilian or even Iraqi person and be in compliance with this bill's terms. It doesn't require American ownership, it forbids control by a foreign adversary.

If the EU and U.S. passed legislation subjecting all tech companies to these rules, the only ones who would have to do anything are those owned and controlled by a foreign adversary state.

Re:Biden signs TikTok 'ban' bill into law, starting clock fo... by trog on Wednesday April 24, 2024 @07:04PM (#40150966)
Is it weird then that China is a "foreign adversary" that is otherwise allowed to sell the US the vast, overwhelming majority of consumer goods and participate in the economy in many other ways?
Re:Biden signs TikTok 'ban' bill into law, starting clock fo... by jszymborski on Wednesday April 24, 2024 @07:23PM (#40151173)
There's a current trade war in which the USA is trying to "friend-shore" manufacturing and has imposed massive trade tariffs on China.

China is unambiguously a foreign adversary of the USA, as well as many/all Western democracies.

Re:Biden signs TikTok 'ban' bill into law, starting clock fo... by trog on Wednesday April 24, 2024 @07:56PM (#40151447)
Just seems weird that this "foreign adversary" is also a critical "trading partner". Why is TikTok being singled out?

The discussion about data and privacy seems totally disingenuous. This seems like a free speech issue being hidden being a weird angle.

A quick legal hack to get TikTok off the table does little to address the underlying systemic issues here - broad, uncontrolled data collection, and mass media distribution platforms that can be weaponised by nation states.

We already know US companies are impacted by both these issues. They need to be addressed at a lower level and not by cherry picking up the individual examples on grounds that are inconsistent with the rest of the state's behaviour.

Re:Biden signs TikTok 'ban' bill into law, starting clock fo... by dpkirchner on Wednesday April 24, 2024 @08:41PM (#40151801)
> Just seems weird that this "foreign adversary" is also a critical "trading partner". Why is TikTok being singled out?

Because it's easy and cheap. It's a way for our representatives to claim they're doing something about the threat that may be posed by the Chinese government, without actually jeopardizing the interests of our industries.

Re:Biden signs TikTok 'ban' bill into law, starting clock fo... by trog on Wednesday April 24, 2024 @08:47PM (#40151858)
Yup. And I'm sure it's a completely unintended side effect that this massively helps US social media companies, who have been struggling to compete! Whoops!
Re:Biden signs TikTok 'ban' bill into law, starting clock fo... by jszymborski on Thursday April 25, 2024 @12:15PM (#40159403)
You're talking like this TikTok bill is literally the only salvo in this trade war. Just ask the Huawai folks if they think that's the case.

> A quick legal hack to get TikTok off the table does little to address the underlying systemic issues here - broad, uncontrolled data collection, and mass media distribution platforms that can be weaponised by nation states.

I have no love for FANNG, but there's a huge difference between a domestic companies invading privacy and possibly being soft targets for foreign adversaries, and a literal foreign adversary surveilling and shaping discourse.

So sure, if there is another bill that would curtail privacy invasion by domestic companies, I would be in huge support. But I fail to see how that stops blocking another privacy-invading app, run by a foreign adversary no less, is a bad thing.

There is this whataboutism in every comment on HN regarding the US and China that drives me nutty. A US company being bad does not cancel out a Chinese company being bad. A patchwork law is better than no law.

Re:Biden signs TikTok 'ban' bill into law, starting clock fo... by inetknght on Wednesday April 24, 2024 @07:08PM (#40151005)
Weird? Arguably. I would argue no. That's normal capitalism.

Dangerous? I would definitely argue yes.

Re:Biden signs TikTok 'ban' bill into law, starting clock fo... by trog on Wednesday April 24, 2024 @07:20PM (#40151143)
There are different types of danger and I'm not sure which one you're referring to - there's the general economic danger of relying too heavily on one trading partner (if China decides to put export tariff on anything to the US, for example), or literal danger, like national security stuff.

I assume you're talking about the latter because that seems to be what is talked about with TikTok. Again, it seems weird to me to decide, after however many decades of globalism and exploiting China's manufacturing prowess for cheap goods, that this is suddenly dangerous but then proceed to do absolutely nothing about it, except stifle TikTok.

Diversifying supply chains is a good idea - and the US is doing that already, though it seems to be much more in response to the first definition of "danger" than the second. Because if it was the national security aspect, we'd be seeing it happen with much more alacrity and urgency, and not some hand-wringing about TikTok.

Re:Biden signs TikTok 'ban' bill into law, starting clock fo... by throw310822 on Wednesday April 24, 2024 @06:49PM (#40150817)
> it forbids control by a foreign adversary.

At least this vindicates the choice all the countries that consider the US an adversary and have blocked US social media. While the US has always characterised the block as the hallmark of illiberal regimes.

Re:Biden signs TikTok 'ban' bill into law, starting clock fo... by paulddraper on Wednesday April 24, 2024 @05:54PM (#40150208)
Correct. Any other country on earth, other than:

* China

* North Korea

* Iran

* Cuba

* Russia

* Venezuela

Could sell it to Pakistan, Syria, Yemen, Somalia, Afghanistan, Belarus, etc.

Re:Biden signs TikTok 'ban' bill into law, starting clock fo... by mywittyname on Wednesday April 24, 2024 @06:19PM (#40150536)
Honest question: what's stopping them from being transferred to a Belizean shell company owned by a company in Delaware with a board full of puppets who blindly do the bidding of the previous owners? Do the CxOs need to be replaced? Are Chinese senior staff members being replaced? Low level staff? What concrete changes are going to be made that will change their behavior?

I oppose this bill because it doesn't seem to do anything to address the actual threats posed by social media. After all, foreign adversaries openly operate on Facebook. Why isn't Zuckerberg being forced to divest? Either all social media is a threat, and that threat needs to be addressed, or this is all theater meant to satisfy the population without tackling the actual issues (if we are honest, the same politicians pushing for this bill benefit from social media influence) .

Re:Biden signs TikTok 'ban' bill into law, starting clock fo... by Marsymars on Wednesday April 24, 2024 @06:54PM (#40150871)
> what's stopping them from being transferred to a Belizean shell company owned by a company in Delaware with a board full of puppets who blindly do the bidding of the previous owners?

What stops the puppets from ignoring the previous owners?

Re:Biden signs TikTok 'ban' bill into law, starting clock fo... by chronic639291 on Wednesday April 24, 2024 @07:01PM (#40150935)
> What stops the puppets from ignoring the previous owners?

A big paycheck.

Most readers on HN would happily pledge loyalty to the CCP if it meant $1M+ TC.

In fact, many American and European businesses do exactly this.

Re:Biden signs TikTok 'ban' bill into law, starting clock fo... by Marsymars on Wednesday April 24, 2024 @07:13PM (#40151060)
> A big paycheck.

So what happens after they’ve received the big paycheque?

I think you’d have a hard time aligning the amount of the paycheques such that the puppets couldn’t get bigger expected future paycheques by doing what they wanted with tiktok.

Re:Biden signs TikTok 'ban' bill into law, starting clock fo... by someplaceguy on Wednesday April 24, 2024 @07:48PM (#40151398)
> I think you’d have a hard time aligning the amount of the paycheques such that the puppets couldn’t get bigger expected future paycheques by doing what they wanted with tiktok.

Presumably the puppets wouldn't have access to the tiktok platform (its code including AI algorithms, data, employees, etc), they'd just be a middle-man that would take the finished product (e.g. the APK) and publish it to distribution platforms (Google and Apple's app stores)?

Re:Biden signs TikTok 'ban' bill into law, starting clock fo... by woooooo on Wednesday April 24, 2024 @07:06PM (#40150978)
Doing business is not necessarily pledging loyalty.

You think I pledged loyalty to various employers, even? I mean I told them I did, but I was lying.

Re:Biden signs TikTok 'ban' bill into law, starting clock fo... by jltsiren on Wednesday April 24, 2024 @07:03PM (#40150956)
When it comes to major national security interests, the spirit of the law can be more important than the letter. The law can always be changed, and the eventual outcome will often be worse after each rewrite.

Consider the sanctions against Russia, for example. Some European companies continued doing business in Russia. Everything they did was perfectly legal, and they complied with the sanctions to the letter. But because some officials considered those companies were aiding the Russian war effort, the next round of US sanctions targeted those companies specifically. Then they had to stop all business indefinitely, because no bank was willing to deal with them anymore.

Re:Biden signs TikTok 'ban' bill into law, starting clock fo... by itemize on Thursday April 25, 2024 @01:06AM (#40153661)
probably nothing beside more scrutiny at point of sale of the buyers
Re:Biden signs TikTok 'ban' bill into law, starting clock fo... by woooooo on Wednesday April 24, 2024 @07:05PM (#40150968)
I was about to ask how "foreign adversary" is defined, thanks. Nice to have it official.
Re:Biden signs TikTok 'ban' bill into law, starting clock fo... by josu on Wednesday April 24, 2024 @06:03PM (#40150327)
What about Hong Kong?
Re:Biden signs TikTok 'ban' bill into law, starting clock fo... by Moto7451 on Wednesday April 24, 2024 @06:08PM (#40150397)
That’s very much China.
Re:Biden signs TikTok 'ban' bill into law, starting clock fo... by paulddraper on Wednesday April 24, 2024 @10:27PM (#40152647)
As of the executive order on Hong Kong Normalization [1], there is no policy distinction between Hong Kong and China.

The more interesting question is Taiwan, for which the US has taken no official position on sovereignty.

[1] https://www.federalregister.gov/documents/2020/07/17/2020-15...