Not making it is way better

Depends on what you do with dug out oil instead of making plastic. If you do almost anything else it's worse than making plastic and landfilling it neatly at the end of useful life.

That’s leaning into a false dichotomy. Not extracting it in the first is clearly the best option

Of course. However if not making plastic means extracting more to burn to haul around heavier glass then it better to make and landfill plastic.

We are in terrible situation and nothing is simple and even simple stuff is hard to implement and can turn out negative when we implemented.

Things backfire. People are buying plug-in hybrids but then they almost never charge them so material is wasted and de facto ice cars are unnecessarily heavier.