Provided that a house draws competing offers, the everyday residential home buyer expecting to finance their mortgage needs to offer comparable or greater value in some other way, such as by making a substantially higher offer than the all-cash buyers. Many of these traditional buyers find it hard to anticipate how much higher their offer will need to be (the value of a more reliable escrow is subjective) and are often bidding mostly blind anyway. Further, affordability is already strained for most of these buyers and many shop by list price, unable to effectively compete in a bidding wars.
A high rate of all-cash offers usually correlates with a much more difficult and fatiguing home buying process for traditional in-community middle class buyers and sustained high prices. The article is basically just affirming that this dynamic currently (continues) to be at play in SoCal even as other markets soften.
The highly regressive nature of housing appreciation has long drawn criticism, but the raft of policy choices that produce this outcome has historically been defended by the notion that most Americans benefit. Rich Americans benefit more, but most Americans own vs rent, so most Americans benefit, at least in nominal terms. Changes in the composition of demand are notable, and this is an indicator. When investment demand begins to exceed consumption demand, when most Americans do not benefit, there are electoral consequences to our democratic process that might signal a secular shift in those policy choices.
The indicators are worth watching.
You're missing something that many/most states have laws that the seller/buyer must disclose, not the price the house is sold for, but how much of a loan was issued for the house. If they are not disclosing this then it's likely they are committing a crime by not doing so. The fact we are seeing larger amounts of 'paid in full' on houses is a significant anomaly and represents a change in market dynamics, and all changes in market behavior should be monitored. For example when we saw leading up to 2008 crash the "interest only loans", it was predicted by a sizeable number of people that a crash was happening 'soon', and in which it did.
Of course this varies by state, so other laws can apply.
Also, would I be right to presume that this applies only to standard real estate loans? Are margin loans against stock required to be reported? Or private loans from parent to a child? I'd thought the reporting requirement had more to do with cases where the loan acts as a lien against the house.
Edit: Here's a Bogleheads thread that summarizes my understanding: https://www.bogleheads.org/forum/viewtopic.php?t=352355. It looks like in California markets (where the article is about) there are various companies that specialize in short term loans to enable "all cash offers".
As far as I know, this is usually not true. Neither the buyer nor seller must disclose the existence of a loan on the property. For example, many loans are between family members who would prefer to keep them private, and the law allows that. Practically, however, any commercial lender (even a seller who offers financing) will record a mortgage with the county recorder so that he has priority in a foreclosure.
The sale price, however, usually is disclosed at least to the county assessor for property tax purposes. The exceptions would be where an heir inherits a property and the value is not reassessed.
The biggest takeaway really is that people are likely leveraging existing equity, so there's likely a generational and class element to the purchases.
(ie. people are "all cash" because they sold their old highly valuable house, and buying a new one)
the whole article is about how the high interest rates aren't having the effect the fed wants on buyers bc buyers don't have a mortgage payment if they just have the cash available
Not sure if I would consider that a cash offer; financing can still fall through and scuttle the deal.
Avoiding contingencies like this can be a good thing, since depending on the other contingencies it might make the deal more likely to go through, or to go through more quickly. But in most cases the buyer still has contingencies for inspections and probably a whole bunch of other things that will let them back out if they really want. Whether it's an "all-cash offer" or a standard mortgage, unless they are providing seller financing (rare), the same amount of money gets wired to the seller's back account at closing.
Am I missing something? Or is "all-case offer" in a headline indeed an empty phrase that usually signifies that the article is probably selling a false narrative based on misconceptions?