News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:An Electric New Era for Atlas by jvanderbot on Wednesday April 17, 2024 @01:49PM (#40067947)
Electric motors dont have a lot of "give", like hydraulics do. But yes force-torque controllers can be tuned to be squishier. Someday I think electric motors will be the muscles and we'll have some kind of elastic tendons. For energy efficiency, it seems obvious to harness impact energy in a mechanical spring system, as nature does.

Or just use wheels / a wheel. This whole humanoid thing strikes me as an addiction to old sci Fi stories.

Re:An Electric New Era for Atlas by Animats on Wednesday April 17, 2024 @02:29PM (#40068446)
It doesn't work that way.

Hydraulic systems have very little "give", unless you put a hydraulic accumulator (an air tank with a fluid/air barrier) in the system. Electric motors have plenty of "give". Forcing a motor to turn backwards won't hurt it. The gear train is usually the weak point. As motors and controllers have improved, robot gear reduction ratios have decreased, which reduces the load on the gear train and lets the motor absorb shock loads. Direct drive robots eliminate the gear train entirely. Here's a nice one.[1] "You cannot strip the teeth of a magnetic field" - General Electric electric locomotive rep, around 1900.

With modern motors, you can get huge torque with light weight, and cooling becomes the limitation. Schaft used water-cooled motors in their direct-drive robot. Google bought Schaft, ran them into the ground and killed them.

[1] https://shop.directdrive.com/products/diablo-world-s-first-d...

Re:An Electric New Era for Atlas by jvanderbot on Wednesday April 17, 2024 @03:27PM (#40069086)
I stand corrected! Thank you.

I'm still mostly convinced that harvesting the energy and re-using it ala elastic tendons is a decently good idea. But probably far too complex.

Re:An Electric New Era for Atlas by Animats on Wednesday April 17, 2024 @03:43PM (#40069269)
It's mostly for distance running. Humans get about 70% of energy back in running. Cheetahs, about 90%.

Variable compliance muscles are desirable, but hard to do. A pneumatic cylinder with adjustable pressure on both sides will do it, and Festo builds a lot of that for industrial automation. Two opposed springs pulled on by two positional actuators will do it, but that's kind of bulky. There's a hack called a "series elastic actuator", which is a rigid positional actuator with a stiff spring on the end. When it gets some pushback, the spring compresses, and the motor frantically tries to move the positional actuator before the spring bottoms out. This allows you to simulate a spring with off the shelf screw jacks.

Those new direct-drive motors are a good solution. Direct-drive pancake motors have been around for a while, but they used to be about a foot across. Now they're smaller. Probably a spinoff of drone motor technology.

Re:An Electric New Era for Atlas by Corrado on Thursday April 18, 2024 @10:16AM (#40076521)
Actually, that's a pretty good idea. Regenerative motion. Sort of like regenerative braking in an EV, they could capture some electricity with each step to help reduce the energy requirements.
Re:An Electric New Era for Atlas by tomp on Thursday April 18, 2024 @12:28PM (#40077916)
Do you know of any direct drive motors?

One of the cheapest low-gear-ratios I found was the RMD series: (which is 1:6 or 1:10 gear ratio).

https://ozrobotics.com/shop/myactuator-rmd-x4-16-micro-motor...

Re:An Electric New Era for Atlas by fragmede on Wednesday April 17, 2024 @02:06PM (#40068174)
It's not because of science fiction stories, it's because things designed for human to use, is designed for a humanoid form factor. If you want to accomplish a task, it's going to be reflected by that machine. Eg a conveyor belt doesn't look like a human. But if you want swap a robot where a human used to be, it's far easier if that robot is humanoid and has the same approximate capabilities. Thus, we have humanoid robots.
Re:An Electric New Era for Atlas by jvanderbot on Wednesday April 17, 2024 @03:26PM (#40069077)
Can someone point out where "powered rollerskates" are strictly worse than legs in civilized urban human environments, to an extent that a few extra hundred billion dollars of R&D are warranted? The "approximate capabilities" of a human are: moving around, and picking things up / fine manipulation. Wheels + arms does that just fine, and eliminates a lot of power, complexity, fragility. And it also potentially adds.

This is one of those 80/20 things that is just glaringly obvious. Like lvl 5 autonomous cars vs lvl 3-4.

Re:An Electric New Era for Atlas by lanternfish on Wednesday April 17, 2024 @03:39PM (#40069218)
The obvious answer is stairs. It seems like right now Spot is getting the most use as a highly mobile camera platform for automated inspection in industrial environments. Many of these have a lot of stairs.
Re:An Electric New Era for Atlas by hanniabu on Wednesday April 17, 2024 @08:25PM (#40071658)
And non hard/flat surfaces like carpet, grass, gravel, mud...
Re:An Electric New Era for Atlas by klowrey on Wednesday April 17, 2024 @02:06PM (#40068172)
Hydraulics shouldn't have any give, as the working fluid is considered "incompressible". Of course in the real world the tubing can expand slightly and there are friction losses, but the reason they went with hydraulics in the first place is they can set a position and not have to use more energy to hold it there (since the cylinders are pressurized).

If the gear ratio on these motors is high, then there can only be faked compliance in the tuned force-torque controllers you mentioned. MIT's little cheetah robot, on the other hand, deliberately used low-gear ratios to keep things naturally squishy if needed. This is the way to go; putting elastic tendons or spring elements seems like a good idea but then you can't actually model the non-linearity well (the 1st order motor becomes a 2nd or higher order system).

Re:An Electric New Era for Atlas by jvanderbot on Wednesday April 17, 2024 @03:27PM (#40069092)
Ah, thank you. I understand
Re:An Electric New Era for Atlas by madaxe_again on Wednesday April 17, 2024 @03:25PM (#40069076)
Wheels are useless in this world. If you’ve ever tried using a pushchair or a wheelchair on much of the planet, built environment or no, you’ll find wheels are useless.