News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Bootstrapped GitHub Now Raising a Round from Andreessen H... by SeoxyS on Monday May 21, 2012 @11:24PM (#4006137)
Two questions:

- How is GitHub worth less than Pintrest?

- What could GitHub possibly gain from raising money? It's clearly not about money. Is this a liquidity event? Couldn't they just issue a dividend for that, they've clearly got plenty of cash… Or is this about the credibility of having a valuation. In that case, couldn't they have gone public? Amazon went public at a sub-$500M valuation, and look at them now!

Edit: come to think of it, I can see the possibility of wanting to acquire other companies, and not currently having the capital to do so. That's about it.

Re:Bootstrapped GitHub Now Raising a Round from Andreessen H... by dlokshin on Tuesday May 22, 2012 @12:35AM (#4006277)
I remember reading an interview with Pierre Omidyar (founder of Ebay) raised $5M from Benchmark, opened a separate bank account, and placed the $5M in there, untouched to this day because eBay was profitable from the very beginning.

He raised the money from Benchmark because he needed help recruiting executives to help run and expand the company. His recruitment efforts before that had been largely unsuccessful, and he openly admitted that no one took him seriously before he raised money.

Yes, the internet was a new and unproven phenomenon at the time, but there are other reasons to hitch up with a VC other than money.

Re:Bootstrapped GitHub Now Raising a Round from Andreessen H... by fusiongyro on Tuesday May 22, 2012 @12:41AM (#4006294)
> How is GitHub worth less than Pinterest?

I'll speculate.

Github's fighting a losing game. They are trying to charge for something they are also giving away for free, and their target market is people who are uniquely qualified to replace them. There are plenty of quality Github alternatives around right now. To stay on top they have to continue to be at the forefront development-wise and they have to continue to have the majority of developer attention to reap the network effects. It's precarious.

Compare to Pinterest. They make money, ostensibly, from every product someone pins. People pin lots of products, and the people doing the pinning and the browsing have higher conversion rates than people browsing Google or other sites looking for things to spend money on. Pinterest is also a brand; it will be hard to get everyone using Pinterest to switch just because a better version exists somewhere else. People can collaborate with Git without using Github; the only tangible loss is the pull request feature.

It takes Pinterest less work to convert a byte of bandwidth into profit. Not only do they need less development effort moving forward, they also stand better odds of making money on some random user.

Re:Bootstrapped GitHub Now Raising a Round from Andreessen H... by patio11 on Tuesday May 22, 2012 @12:52AM (#4006311)
If Github is losing sign me up for some of that please.
Re:Bootstrapped GitHub Now Raising a Round from Andreessen H... by fusiongyro on Tuesday May 22, 2012 @12:21PM (#4008522)
I'm not saying they're losing, I'm saying they're fighting a losing game.
Re:Bootstrapped GitHub Now Raising a Round from Andreessen H... by cracell on Tuesday May 22, 2012 @01:38PM (#4008879)
How is Pinterest not also fighting a losing game? I can see how it's harder for Github to stay up with competitors because their target market is more savvy and often tries out new tools. But doesn't Pinterest also suffer the risk of some new social sharing site appearing that appeals to users in a better or just different way?
Re:Bootstrapped GitHub Now Raising a Round from Andreessen H... by drx on Tuesday May 22, 2012 @08:29AM (#4007469)
Exactly what pops into my mind when people say things like that.
Re:Bootstrapped GitHub Now Raising a Round from Andreessen H... by smiler on Tuesday May 22, 2012 @04:26AM (#4006885)
Please link to all these quality Github alternatives? I haven't seen anything which comes close.
Re:Bootstrapped GitHub Now Raising a Round from Andreessen H... by njs12345 on Tuesday May 22, 2012 @05:33AM (#4007051)
I think it depends on your use case but Bitbucket is pretty close for simple usage. Of course, it's missing the network effects which make GH so compelling.

Having said that, switching costs are low because of the distributed nature of Git. Not sure what would happen if something genuinely better came along.

Re:Bootstrapped GitHub Now Raising a Round from Andreessen H... by bad_user on Tuesday May 22, 2012 @08:15AM (#4007428)

     switching costs are low because of the distributed 
     nature of Git
Switching costs from Google's search engine are low, because all it takes is to enter the URL of an alternative search engine. And nothing has shaken it, not even when this process is helped by the distribution network, like making Bing the default on Windows.

Lock-in is not measured only in regards to the potential switching costs. Lock-in is also possible by providing the best possible service. Along with real network effects (people recommending your service to other people) then the global lock-in becomes inescapable, even if the theoretical switching costs are low.

And quite the contrary, GitHub locks people in simply because most developers have a GitHub account. People use GitHub these days to put their portfolio on display. And I've worked with a couple of companies that manage their projects on GitHub and it was a pretty painless process to send me an invitation for joining their private repos.

Even Linux is mirrored on GitHub and even Linus Tolvards has a GitHub account. GitHub is not only a really good Git hosting service, but in case you haven't noticed, it's also a vertical social-network built for developers. And their service keeps improving by leaps and bounds, compared to their competitors, which are merely followers. I'm so happy with GitHub that even though I can have as many private projects as I want on Bitbucket, I still pay GitHub for the privilege to have private projects.

Yes, something better can always come along. But just as Google did for search engines, with GitHub around it's pretty hard to build something better. And this to me is the best possible kind of lock-in and the sign of a thriving and growing company: the product being popular, not because it's forcing users, but because it's simply the best.

Re:Bootstrapped GitHub Now Raising a Round from Andreessen H... by fusiongyro on Wednesday May 23, 2012 @12:26AM (#4011543)
Linux was dependent on BitKeeper for about three years. Git was written from scratch and hosting Linux in a period of three months. Linus's use of a technology he didn't create is closer to a death knell than an endorsement.

Would you rather have stock today in MySpace or a hypothetical 5-year-old SubversionHub? Obviously, the answer is different for different people, and there are good reasons to support and use Github and good reasons to invest in it. That programmers are good at product loyalty simply isn't one of them.

Github is a decent medium-term bet, but Pinterest is a much better lottery ticket.

Re:Bootstrapped GitHub Now Raising a Round from Andreessen H... by bad_user on Wednesday May 23, 2012 @03:10AM (#4011939)
Git is popular because of Linus's excellence and marketing skills. And yeah, it took three months, but it took a lot longer for it to became popular and it was helped by Linus' endorsement. The comparison of BitKeeper to Git is not fair - you should compare it with Perforce instead.

     Would you rather have stock today in MySpace or 
     a hypothetical 5-year-old SubversionHub
I never liked MySpace or SourceForge, so if I had the option in front of me, I would have passed even at the peak of their popularity.

This is the criteria after which I judge companies:

(+) is the product solving a real problem for me? (yes)

(+) are they a sustainable, profit-generating business yet? (yes)

(+) is the product forcing users to remain customers? (no)

(+) are they smart and hard-working enough to adapt to new market conditions? (yes)

(+) do they still have growth potential? (yes, because GitHub is lately a social network for professional developers, being preferred over LinkedIn by many)

     That programmers are good at product loyalty simply
     isn't one of them.
My point wasn't about loyalty. Developers tend to use the best tool for the job. I still use Google's search engine, even though alternatives are available, because Google still gives me the best results. And this creates a cycle - because I use Google and I optimize my websites for Google and because I use Google's Analytics and the Webmasters tool, Google gets more data with which it can optimize my results better than anybody else can.

The same goes for GitHub. Even if I stopped being a GitHub customer, I would still go to GitHub because most popular projects are managed on GitHub or have a mirror there. Popularity in turn helps GitHub get valuable feedback, which it can use to further improve my experience, which in turn makes me a happier customer and so on.

Re:Bootstrapped GitHub Now Raising a Round from Andreessen H... by bradfa on Tuesday May 22, 2012 @12:14PM (#4008497)
Bitbucket, as of the end of 2011, didn't have any concept of a "company account" like GitHub's organizations. From their pricing pages, it looks like they still don't. That's why my company pays for hosted JIRA and uses GitHub, we would much rather pay the lower costs for Bitbucket and keep everything with Atlassian, but the organizations feature on GitHub won us over (we currently have about 30 private repos and 12 users).
Re:Bootstrapped GitHub Now Raising a Round from Andreessen H... by kristianc on Tuesday May 22, 2012 @08:13AM (#4007420)
Churn for enterprise software like GitHub tends to be very low - once it becomes embedded in the workflow of BigCorp its not trivial to change that overnight.

If something genuinely better comes along, the network effects would still be a huge source of inertia given the FUD around switching.

Re:Bootstrapped GitHub Now Raising a Round from Andreessen H... by ThomPete on Tuesday May 22, 2012 @01:47AM (#4006426)
Evernote is valuated at a billion + and as far as I know is not as profitable.

So something is surely off.

"It takes Pinterest less work to convert a byte of bandwidth into profit. Not only do they need less development effort moving forward, they also stand better odds of making money on some random user."

But they also need many more users to actually turn it into revenue.

Re:Bootstrapped GitHub Now Raising a Round from Andreessen H... by etrain on Tuesday May 22, 2012 @09:06AM (#4007582)
I'll bite. Investors don't value early stage companies the same way they value mature companies - for example, a public utility company serves a defined population in a defined geographic region, and operates at some predictable margin. Their value is simply the net present value of future distribution to investors (in the form of dividends, stock buybacks, or share price appreciation). They can still be good investments if the risk/return profile looks good.

Contrast this with early stage companies (which is what we're talking about here). VCs don't care as much if a company has a proven business model - what they're looking for is GROWTH opportunity. The opportunity to completely disrupt a huge market or invent a new one. While profitable companies have better odds of surviving long enough to get to that point, they may not be the best investments in the end.

To give you a concrete example of how this could affect investor decision making. Let's say that the total opportunity for Source Code Management solutions is $2bn/year in corporate spending (completely making this number up) - even if GitHub captures 100% of this market, which they won't, they're capped at $2bn/year in revenue, unless they figure out another way to make money. Once they're done paying the sales guys, engineers, and otherwise supporting operations, they make maybe $500mm/year in profit. With a standard P/E multiple, they'd be worth something like $5-$10bn.

Pinterest, on the other hand, has the potential to be the "facebook of online shopping" to amazon's "google of online shopping". If people really engage with pinterest, and they spend a lot of time on the site, and they're more likely to buy stuff when they're looking at what their friends like and are buying, then it could be worth a lot more than that. The point is, while they don't yet have predictable revenues or earnings, their potential market (online shopping) is so much bigger than github's, that it's possible to justify a high valuation based on growth potential.

I'm not saying I buy the Pinterest hype. I'm just saying that there are criteria beyond current profitability and cash flow on which one can value an early stage business.

Re:Bootstrapped GitHub Now Raising a Round from Andreessen H... by swalkergibson on Tuesday May 22, 2012 @12:39PM (#4008589)
The last line is truly indicative of the echo chamber that is Silicon Valley. Only in the Bay Area do companies without revenues generate valuations of $1B+ with simple hand-waving and conjecture. GitHub charges real money for real services and are thus valued less than someone with a Powerpoint presentation on "proposed revenue models." Quite frankly, it is sad.
Re:Bootstrapped GitHub Now Raising a Round from Andreessen H... by obtu on Wednesday May 23, 2012 @05:33AM (#4012308)
Here's a bit more about perverse incentives that make VCs' decisions less rational: http://www.danshapiro.com/blog/2010/08/vc-insanity-economics...

The differences between Pinterest and GitHub are that: GitHub is more unique (it's not strictly social media and there's more homework to do); it's bootstrapped and negociates from a stronger position; VCs want to give start-ups more money than they need because that's how they get paid.

Re:Bootstrapped GitHub Now Raising a Round from Andreessen H... by adventureful on Tuesday May 22, 2012 @01:59AM (#4006444)
I've seen zero evidence that Pinterest can actually generate a profit. They do not make money from every product someone pins, and there's no reason to think they ever will. The only thing I've seen so far is speculation and theoretical future business models that may or may not pan out.

Github however is profitable and has a proven, functional business model. Github is absolutely not fighting a losing game, because they're providing a service companies obviously desperately want to outsource (thus the mass usage). Providing that service in a secure manner is worth a lot of money, as Github is protecting something extraordinarily valuable.

Re:Bootstrapped GitHub Now Raising a Round from Andreessen H... by raarky on Tuesday May 22, 2012 @06:43AM (#4007191)
have you heard of affiliate links? you can make a good deal of money from them
Re:Bootstrapped GitHub Now Raising a Round from Andreessen H... by adventureful on Tuesday May 22, 2012 @02:04PM (#4009011)
Yep, I have. And I'm sure Pinterest can build a couple hundred million dollar business around it. And that's a fine business, it's just not going to be a juggernaut.
Re:Bootstrapped GitHub Now Raising a Round from Andreessen H... by taligent on Tuesday May 22, 2012 @06:56AM (#4007222)
If you can't think of ways Pinterest can make money then you simply lack creativity.

There are plenty.

Re:Bootstrapped GitHub Now Raising a Round from Andreessen H... by patrickod on Tuesday May 22, 2012 @07:09AM (#4007259)
Would you care to elaborate on how you think Pintrest will make a suitable amount of profit to fit its evaluation?
Re:Bootstrapped GitHub Now Raising a Round from Andreessen H... by lachyg on Tuesday May 22, 2012 @08:18AM (#4007439)
Affiliate links could make Pinterest an insane amount of money. Did you know that when someone clicks an Amazon affiliate link, everything they buy in a 24 hour period the affiliate gets a cut of?

There are a LOT of people using Pinterest, and a LOT of Amazon products on pinterest.

Re:Bootstrapped GitHub Now Raising a Round from Andreessen H... by adventureful on Tuesday May 22, 2012 @02:10PM (#4009041)
An "insane amount of money" - care to be a lot more specific? That's about as vague and unsubstantiated as you could get.

1) The assumption is that the affiliate link model and market will scale to the size of Pinterest's eventual traffic maximums, that's a big assumption.

2) The assumption is that Amazon will want to allow Pinterest to suck profit out the door at that scale, instead of Amazon competing with Pinterest in one form or another instead, just like they're now competing with Groupon / Living Social (despite an investment in LS).

3) Amazon has a very long history of directly competing with companies that touch their platform.

That's an extraordinarily shaky business model to say the least.

Re:Bootstrapped GitHub Now Raising a Round from Andreessen H... by adventureful on Tuesday May 22, 2012 @02:03PM (#4009005)
That sounds great.

I'm sure if I can't think of ways that Twitter and Tumblr can make outsized profits from their massive respective user bases, then I'm not being creative either. Oh snap, some of the best business minds are already on the problem and they can't figure it out either.

The same holds true for Pinterest, they're stuck in the same monetization box, and they're not going to suddenly show massive profitability either. It's blatantly obvious that platform will never monetize to the scale of their traffic.

Re:Bootstrapped GitHub Now Raising a Round from Andreessen H... by drusenko on Tuesday May 22, 2012 @01:35AM (#4006394)
> - How is GitHub worth less than Pinterest?

The fact that the top two comments are saying this is a sure sign we are progressing into a full-fledged bubble.

See George Zachary's interview: http://techcrunch.com/2012/05/17/in-the-studio-crvs-george-z... -- it sure seems like we are entering "Stage 2" (check out the video, not the article)

When we start discussing what we feel one company is worth based entirely off of the valuation of another, unrelated, presumably inflated valuation, it's the beginning of the end.

Re:Bootstrapped GitHub Now Raising a Round from Andreessen H... by tikhon on Tuesday May 22, 2012 @01:44AM (#4006416)
It's not a bubble 'til my mom owns pinterest stock. Then the end is near.
Re:Bootstrapped GitHub Now Raising a Round from Andreessen H... by koide on Tuesday May 22, 2012 @02:31AM (#4006533)
Please write a post about it when that happens and link it from HN.
Re:Bootstrapped GitHub Now Raising a Round from Andreessen H... by erikpukinskis on Tuesday May 22, 2012 @01:50AM (#4006431)
My mom is a software engineer, so you're saying if she buys a tech stock the end is near?
Re:Bootstrapped GitHub Now Raising a Round from Andreessen H... by ericflo on Tuesday May 22, 2012 @02:24AM (#4006516)
No, he referred specifically to his own mother.
Re:Bootstrapped GitHub Now Raising a Round from Andreessen H... by Aethaeryn on Tuesday May 22, 2012 @01:51AM (#4006432)
If there's a bubble, and it's related to the Facebook IPO, then why did Facebook lose 11% of its value on Monday?
Re:Bootstrapped GitHub Now Raising a Round from Andreessen H... by adventureful on Tuesday May 22, 2012 @02:03AM (#4006449)
Because the bubble is already over. The Facebook IPO marks the zenith of this relatively modest bubble period.

Ditto for Groupon, Zynga, Pandora and the like having the insane valuations that they did, while generating zero profit - their valuations have imploded massively. Or a company like HomeAway, that was sporting a $4 billion market cap, and a 600 pe ratio; or LinkedIn with its 1,000 or so pe ratio. The bubble has already exploded for companies like Netflix, whose valuation has collapsed back to earth. A few more like CRM are temporarily defying gravity.

Re:Bootstrapped GitHub Now Raising a Round from Andreessen H... by drusenko on Tuesday May 22, 2012 @02:11AM (#4006471)
Public companies seem to be coming back to earth, but I'm not sure that's the case for private companies. The valuations there seem to be just getting more and more outlandish.

On the other hand, if it's all VCs and funds of funds losing silly-money, then no harm no foul, I suppose.

Re:Bootstrapped GitHub Now Raising a Round from Andreessen H... by adestefan on Tuesday May 22, 2012 @07:41AM (#4007328)
The problem will occur once the JOBS Act kicks in and anyone can lose their money. That's when the bubble will really pop.
Re:Bootstrapped GitHub Now Raising a Round from Andreessen H... by alex_marchant on Tuesday May 22, 2012 @04:38AM (#4006905)
The effects always ripple, even from far away private financial sectors.
Re:Bootstrapped GitHub Now Raising a Round from Andreessen H... by taligent on Tuesday May 22, 2012 @06:54AM (#4007219)
You do know that Groupon and Zynga have been making profits right ?
Re:Bootstrapped GitHub Now Raising a Round from Andreessen H... by adventureful on Tuesday May 22, 2012 @02:01PM (#4008993)
That's news to me.

For their last quarter (NY Times): "Zynga said its net loss was $85.4 million, or 12 cents a share, in the most recent three months."

Groupon has lost a lot of money the last four quarters. Their latest quarter could best be described as break-even, and negative with option expenses.

Reuters: "Groupon reported first-quarter pro-forma net income, which excludes option expenses, of 2 cents per share, versus a net loss of 41 cents a share, a year earlier."

No doubt the right direction. However, a company that's break even, with $2.x billion in annual sales, is not worth $8 billion. It's a lot better than the $20x billion they were formerly worth of course.

Re:Bootstrapped GitHub Now Raising a Round from Andreessen H... by nl on Tuesday May 22, 2012 @02:19AM (#4006494)
How is GitHub worth less than Pintrest

a) Media companies are generally pretty valuable. Pinterest allows users to show clear interests, which should be very easy to convert to commercial intent.

b) The potential market for Pinterest users is much larger, with much less competition than GitHub

c) Software development tools generally are difficult to make money on. Infrastructure can be slightly better, but still expensive. A16Z knows this market as well as anyone (http://www.hp.com/hpinfo/newsroom/press/2007/070723xa.html)

Re:Bootstrapped GitHub Now Raising a Round from Andreessen H... by swalkergibson on Tuesday May 22, 2012 @12:44PM (#4008607)
With regard to A, are we not seeing a major correction with the lackluster performance of Facebook on the public market? People have been "Liking" things on Facebook for some time, and they have not yet cracked that nut...
Re:Bootstrapped GitHub Now Raising a Round from Andreessen H... by nl on Tuesday May 22, 2012 @07:35PM (#4010678)
Not really. Google's shares have gone down in the past too.

Facebook's share price is very high compared to their current revenue. There are very valid questions about how quickly they can grow revenue, and those questions are reflected in the share price.

Re:Bootstrapped GitHub Now Raising a Round from Andreessen H... by jmonegro on Tuesday May 22, 2012 @12:29AM (#4006267)
Pinterest's potential market is much, much bigger than Github's will ever be.
Re:Bootstrapped GitHub Now Raising a Round from Andreessen H... by te_chris on Tuesday May 22, 2012 @12:43AM (#4006300)
So? If I create a product that gives everyone in the world free power my market would be huge, problem is, this product would be founded on the premise that one day I'll work out how to cover the huge cost of generating enough power to satisfy the world's desires. A much more reputable way to start a power company would be to charge for one's services at a point where MR > MC, but that's just me.
Re:Bootstrapped GitHub Now Raising a Round from Andreessen H... by nl on Tuesday May 22, 2012 @02:21AM (#4006505)
Clearly free-to-air TV must be worthless too.

And I guess you think Newspaper profits (used to) come from the price people pay for them.

Re:Bootstrapped GitHub Now Raising a Round from Andreessen H... by mryan on Tuesday May 22, 2012 @08:11AM (#4007413)
Underneath your sarcasm, I believe your point is that these models were sustained by paid advertising, thus Pinterest could become profitable by following the same model.

The cost of ads has plummeted in the last few years, and I seriously doubt Pinterest would remain profitable if its primary revenue stream is ads.

Re:Bootstrapped GitHub Now Raising a Round from Andreessen H... by nl on Tuesday May 22, 2012 @07:33PM (#4010670)
Untargetted advertising has always been cheap to buy, and worth roughly the same amount.

Google's search advertising has shown targeted advertising is one of the most profitable business models ever. In some ways Pinterest is even more targeted than search.

Re:Bootstrapped GitHub Now Raising a Round from Andreessen H... by petercooper on Monday May 21, 2012 @11:49PM (#4006187)
To #1, why does a paramedic earn less than a relatively unknown football player? There are lots of variables to take into account, many of them soft or cultural ones.
Re:Bootstrapped GitHub Now Raising a Round from Andreessen H... by vm on Tuesday May 22, 2012 @12:36AM (#4006279)
re: #1 - Pinterest has dramatically more users and potential users. Will it be able to monetize them as well as GitHub? Hard to say without knowing the details.

The other factor is hype. Pinterest is the next hot social company and their comps are Facebook, Twitter, LinkedIn, and Instagram. Easy to let your imagination go wild if you're an investor.

re: #2 - they would raise money to a) grow faster, b) acquire companies, and/or c) provide shareholder liquidity. b & c are self explanatory, so let's focus on a):

The wad of cash lets them hire faster. Let's say they have 70 employees today and they want to grow to 200 by year end (for enterprise support, for example). Hard to triple your salary expense that quickly if you're operating off cash flows. GitHub have a network-effect business, so why not lock-in every company on the planet as quickly as possible? It'll lead to a much, much greater profits in the long-run.

It's only worth the dilution if you expect your equity to be worth more than 1/(1 - n) [See PG's essay: http://paulgraham.com/equity.html]

Re:Bootstrapped GitHub Now Raising a Round from Andreessen H... by chii on Tuesday May 22, 2012 @02:08AM (#4006465)
> The other factor is hype ... Easy to let your imagination go wild if you're an investor.

hype investment is a poor investment, unless you are looking to cheat the late comers to the 'hype', instead of looking to create value (in which case, the investor is a blood sucker, and should be hated).

Poor investments looses society wealth. In other words, it should not be that a hyped up fad of the month company garners more investment monies than a real, profitable company.

Re:Bootstrapped GitHub Now Raising a Round from Andreessen H... by dave1619 on Monday May 21, 2012 @11:31PM (#4006160)
My guess is that Github wants to expand more aggressively (probably into enterprise) and extra cash will speed that up.
Re:Bootstrapped GitHub Now Raising a Round from Andreessen H... by benackles on Tuesday May 22, 2012 @12:34AM (#4006275)
What does "[going] into enterprise" mean? Almost every fortune 500 company is using GitHub in some capacity. Isn't "[going] into enterprise" simply marketing jargon when you're talking about SaaS products like GitHub.
Re:Bootstrapped GitHub Now Raising a Round from Andreessen H... by bitops on Tuesday May 22, 2012 @02:07AM (#4006460)
> What does "[going] into enterprise" mean?

Going into enterprise means more than having just a behind-the-firewall solution. Deploying code behind the firewall means that you are at the mercy of the customer's environment and have to be much more forgiving than running in an "opinionated" SaaS environment.

To wit, here is a laundry list of things you have to deal with for enterprise customers, and they all require time, money, and support.

+ Slower release cycle than SaaS - you may not be able to push updates to customer environments at will. They may require that they decide when to take updates, which means their codebase could be several months behind. (Not always, but it can happen).

+ Data & privacy laws, particularly for European customers. Do you love S3? A lot of companies don't, and governments especially don't. This means potentially rolling your own elastic file storage which must also be deployed behind the firewall.

+ You get into managing a cluster for the customer, not just a single instance.

+ Your software must fit the security scheme of the customer. In a SaaS environment, you typically have a great deal of control over the network topology. Behind the firewall, company policy may require that only certain ports be open. This might mean re-writing code to either serve a lot of protocols over port 80 or being on long support calls while people file tickets and wait for IT to punch open holes for you. (And then sometimes close them right back up, requiring you to repeat the cycle every time you deploy).

+ It's also not uncommon to have a dedicated team just for the enterprise customers, or even a dedicated team just for one enterprise customer. This requires hiring people who must be trained and brought up to speed. As I'm sure you're aware, engineer salaries are a big cost factor.

+ If time differences are too large or too inconvenient, you may need to hire people in other parts of the world. This means needing to comply with local laws and regulations. Which usually means hiring lawyers, additional HR people, etc.

The list goes on and on. Deploying for the enterprise can be much more involved than what you might think.

Re:Bootstrapped GitHub Now Raising a Round from Andreessen H... by nowarninglabel on Tuesday May 22, 2012 @12:37AM (#4006287)
Well, there is a vast difference between "every fortune 500 company is using Github in some capacity" and "every fortune 500 company is paying for the Enterprise version of Github." I think it'd be an easy sell on a lot of companies, since, as you say, many of the developers are already using it. Heck, I even want to convince my company to get the Enterprise version of GitHub, but we're a non-profit and too small for it.
Re:Bootstrapped GitHub Now Raising a Round from Andreessen H... by benackles on Tuesday May 22, 2012 @01:01AM (#4006326)
That still doesn't answer why you need to raise VC money. How does VC money add value to a company which already has an "enterprise" solution and is a known brand to almost all Fortune 500 companies? GitHub is already making a lot of money via cash flow and VC money will only make them beholden to outside interests. Stack Overflow tried to spin why they were raising money after spending years railing against VC-backed ventures. This seems to be a similar scenario.

[1] https://enterprise.github.com

Re:Bootstrapped GitHub Now Raising a Round from Andreessen H... by Soliah on Tuesday May 22, 2012 @01:17AM (#4006359)
Last week, I deployed the GitHub Enterprise product in the company I work for (SME, 500+ employees but only 20~ developers). Though the setup process was rather painless, any time I wanted support the only point of contact was an email address[1]. To make things more difficult, because I'm located in Australia the time difference meant most of the time I'd have to wait until the next day to get a reply.

I'd imagine VC would help them create much better support options for the enterprise (the company I'm at usually don't even consider products without commercial support), such as 24/7 local support, support contracts etc.

[1] [email protected]

Re:Bootstrapped GitHub Now Raising a Round from Andreessen H... by benackles on Tuesday May 22, 2012 @06:52PM (#4010553)
I should clarify, I'm speaking as it relates to raising capital; not on the existence of 24/7 support at a premium price point. It still seems to be a common theme where companies raise venture capital for the sake of "going into enterprise". There is a big difference between using cash flows to add 24/7 support and raising VC money. The downside of bringing in outside money seems to outweigh the quick cash infusion.

My suspicion is the founders are taking money off the table in a similar manner as 37signals did when they took money from Bezos Expeditions [Jeff Bezos]. Considering the fact that they're bootstrapped, profitable and growing like a weed it seems reasonable to sell a portion of the company to the greatest advisor [Marc Andreessen].

Re:Bootstrapped GitHub Now Raising a Round from Andreessen H... by nowarninglabel on Tuesday May 22, 2012 @01:38AM (#4006399)
I've been to their offices just a couple months ago. Github is pretty small, there was literally just 7 people there when we went over (granted most work from home). If they want to expand, they need to hire people for sales and support. VC money seems reasonable for that.
Re:Bootstrapped GitHub Now Raising a Round from Andreessen H... by raarky on Tuesday May 22, 2012 @06:47AM (#4007196)
"How is GitHub worth less than Pintrest?"

Markets aren't rational.

Re:Bootstrapped GitHub Now Raising a Round from Andreessen H... by abraham on Tuesday May 22, 2012 @11:48AM (#4008385)
I could see there being a need to bolster the payroll for a growth strategy and needing to temporarily bankroll it with outside funds.