News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The legal rule that computers are presumed to be operatin... by gavinhoward on Tuesday April 16, 2024 @12:13PM (#40053849)
I have seen a lot of dumb legal takes, usually by non-lawyers and non-judges.

But this is so very dumb.

Re:The legal rule that computers are presumed to be operatin... by mmcdermott on Tuesday April 16, 2024 @12:24PM (#40053974)
The linked document doesn't feel unreasonable to me. The concrete example given in the document is the Post Office Horizon Scandal where shortfalls in accounts were identified based on computer records. All the working presumption correctly would mean is that the defense can't be an idle "well, it's a computer it had bugs". If the computerized records are provided as evidence, the defense has to give a reason to believe that bugs account for those shortfalls.

The alternative would be to say that only a system that has been proven correct could be used as evidence which would force pretty much all accounting back to paper.

Re:The legal rule that computers are presumed to be operatin... by Infernal on Tuesday April 16, 2024 @12:36PM (#40054125)
> The alternative would be to say that only a system that has been proven correct could be used as evidence which would force pretty much all accounting back to paper.

Assuming that the paper accounting could be proven correct, when the computerized accounting could not, your proposed alternative would seem to be an upgrade.

Re:The legal rule that computers are presumed to be operatin... by bee_rider on Tuesday April 16, 2024 @01:11PM (#40054557)
Paper accounting seems significantly more error prone, at least for a given level of convenience, right? I mean the computer might be worried about comic rays flipping bits, but ink on paper can be smudged by fingers, and they don’t even have to be traveling at an appreciable percentage of the speed of light.

You can make paper backups of course, but you can also make electronic ones, the electronic ones can be shipped around the world basically for free.

Re:The legal rule that computers are presumed to be operatin... by cbsmith on Tuesday April 16, 2024 @03:03PM (#40055927)
The legal system already has checks and balances to account for errors in paper accounting. They don't require an assumption that the paper accounting is correct, but rather rely on the jury to make judgements, because juries are familiar with the limitations of paper accounting.

We're still a long way away from pulling that off with computers, but the idea that someone could have made a mistake shouldn't be that hard to grasp.

Re:The legal rule that computers are presumed to be operatin... by dragonwriter on Tuesday April 16, 2024 @01:14PM (#40054591)
> The alternative would be to say that only a system that has been proven correct could be used as evidence which would force pretty much all accounting back to paper.

No, there are many alternatives. Including, most critically, the one laid out in the paper under discussion. Which is – spoilers – not “only a system that has been proven correct could be used as evidence”.

Re:The legal rule that computers are presumed to be operatin... by sidewndr46 on Tuesday April 16, 2024 @12:58PM (#40054394)
Isn't the Horizon scandal the opposite? Everyone knew the software was faulty the whole time and no one cared about the consequences.
Re:The legal rule that computers are presumed to be operatin... by jcrawfordor on Tuesday April 16, 2024 @01:06PM (#40054509)
That's exactly what this proposal addresses. Consider the paper they cite, in part, for the proposal:

"It is a matter of surprise that important documentary records, such as the Fujitsu Known Error Log (KEL), were disclosed only in response to a direction from the court and in the face of opposition by the Post Office." (https://journals.sas.ac.uk/deeslr/article/view/5240/5083)

The proposal in this paper would require prosecution to disclose extant documents related to the reliability of the system. In the Horizon case, such documents existed, but were never disclosed, as current practices did not require the prosecution to do so.

Re:The legal rule that computers are presumed to be operatin... by sidewndr46 on Tuesday April 16, 2024 @01:11PM (#40054556)
OK, the original comment makes more sense now.

Are prosecutors in the UK required to disclose both incriminating and exculpatory evidence to the defendant?

Re:The legal rule that computers are presumed to be operatin... by chrisjj on Tuesday April 16, 2024 @03:17PM (#40056042)
Yes.
Re:The legal rule that computers are presumed to be operatin... by olliej on Tuesday April 16, 2024 @05:05PM (#40057217)
I believe so, but they have a notorious track record of not doing so.

But from other articles it sounds like these prosecutions involved some kind of parallel legal system just for the mail?

I think though that the issue that this saga hit is that the law was such that the computer “evidence” was presumptively correct so they tried to pretend any “bugs” they were aware of didn’t change that fact and so the existence of bugs was not “exculpatory” - obviously BS, but it seems like that was the core behaviour/belief of the post office. That put the victims in the position of having to disprove the accusation but the only “evidence” in the case was the presumptively true report from the buggy system.

Ie the only evidence presented was a system that was buggy, but the victim could not get evidence the system was broken without first proving it was broken.

Yay!

Re:The legal rule that computers are presumed to be operatin... by exe34 on Tuesday April 16, 2024 @12:38PM (#40054142)
Would that be a bad thing? If you want the convenience you either pay for something that is proven correct or you take the inefficiency of paper (under your implicit assumption that it's somehow invulnerable to error, burning down, etc), or you accept that you take the convenience but will not be able to use it in court as evidence. If you suspect somebody is stealing, you could always take further measures like switching to magical paper that can't go wrong, or set regular inspections, or new procedures, etc.

Don't pretend that fucking over innocent lives in the pursuit of profits is a law of nature.

Re:The legal rule that computers are presumed to be operatin... by salawat on Tuesday April 16, 2024 @01:05PM (#40054493)
>The alternative would be to say that only a system that has been proven correct could be used as evidence which would force pretty much all accounting back to paper.

No. It'd actually just force authorship and disclosure of test cases.

Re:The legal rule that computers are presumed to be operatin... by icyberbullyu on Tuesday April 16, 2024 @12:17PM (#40053888)
This is just an assumption that generally, computers are doing what they're supposed to. It doesn't mean that you can't challenge it with evidence. With the amount of evidence being submitted being increasingly digital, I'm sure the intention behind this is to stop people from jamming up the courts by calling every single digital artefact into question.
Re:The legal rule that computers are presumed to be operatin... by minimalized on Tuesday April 16, 2024 @12:24PM (#40053972)
The article makes a strong case otherwise. Proving a system built and maintained by a large, well heeled entity is unlikely to be possible for all except other large, well heeled entities.
Re:The legal rule that computers are presumed to be operatin... by zardo on Tuesday April 16, 2024 @12:47PM (#40054259)
How are you supposed to get the evidence in a situation like this?

It's not like they're going to give you the keys to the server room.

Re:The legal rule that computers are presumed to be operatin... by cbsmith on Tuesday April 16, 2024 @03:05PM (#40055944)
> This is just an assumption that generally, computers are doing what they're supposed to.

It's more than that. You don't have to instruct a jury that they have to accept that a person does what they're supposed to do unless proven otherwise... unless that person wrote code for a computer.

Re:The legal rule that computers are presumed to be operatin... by euroderf on Tuesday April 16, 2024 @12:22PM (#40053950)
Your point is valid. But it does sound like a barrier to entry. In the sense of, increasing fixed costs for access to the legal system on a fair basis
Re:The legal rule that computers are presumed to be operatin... by Brian_K_White on Tuesday April 16, 2024 @01:25PM (#40054725)
But every single digital artifact is questionable. It's inconvenient but it's also true.
Re:The legal rule that computers are presumed to be operatin... by kd5bjo on Tuesday April 16, 2024 @12:24PM (#40053978)
I can understand how they got here: Most computer-provided evidence will be something like a printout of an email thread or a saved Excel sheet. Proving that the hard drive, printer, CPU, drivers, application software, etc. are all untampered and working properly is a huge amount of work that will very rarely end up finding a problem.

The original rule-makers probably never considered the idea of a giant, bespoke enterprise software system; it's just a particularly terrible edge case that got caught up in what looks like a reasonable efficiency measure.

Re:The legal rule that computers are presumed to be operatin... by cbsmith on Tuesday April 16, 2024 @03:06PM (#40055960)
> I can understand how they got here: Most computer-provided evidence will be something like a printout of an email thread or a saved Excel sheet. Proving that the hard drive, printer, CPU, drivers, application software, etc. are all untampered and working properly is a huge amount of work that will very rarely end up finding a problem.

Eye witnesses, expert witnesses, etc. can be unreliable. It's very difficult to prove that they have not made any errors. However, we don't ask juries to presume they are infallible.

Re:The legal rule that computers are presumed to be operatin... by NoboruWataya on Tuesday April 16, 2024 @04:20PM (#40056676)
> Eye witnesses, expert witnesses, etc. can be unreliable. It's very difficult to prove that they have not made any errors. However, we don't ask juries to presume they are infallible.

There is a difference between being infallible and being correct. No one assumes that computers cannot err, just that they have not erred unless there is reason to believe they have. Likewise, if a witness gives coherent evidence and no one has any reason to assume they are wrong or lying, that evidence will not generally be disregarded simply because humans are fallible and therefore the evidence is presumed to be flawed.

Re:The legal rule that computers are presumed to be operatin... by cbsmith on Tuesday April 16, 2024 @08:26PM (#40059060)
With an eyewitness, simply saying that you think they are mistaken, with no evidence as to how they are mistaken, is sufficient. In this case, it was easier for the courts to believe hundreds of people were lying and committing fraud, then that there might have been a problem in the software. The only way to change the court's perspective was to provide evidence that was not even accessible to the defendants.

There's no reason to think that programmers are less fallible than other people.

Re:The legal rule that computers are presumed to be operatin... by kube-system on Tuesday April 16, 2024 @12:26PM (#40053991)
No, this is dumb:

> required the prosecution to prove that a computer was operating properly at the relevant time before a document produced by such a computer could be admitted as evidence.

But I'm sure you actually mean to agree, and that your comment was just garbled in transit. :)

Re:The legal rule that computers are presumed to be operatin... by minimalized on Tuesday April 16, 2024 @12:28PM (#40054018)
It's over simplification of a nuanced situation. Over simplification in either direction is a problem.
Re:The legal rule that computers are presumed to be operatin... by kube-system on Tuesday April 16, 2024 @12:29PM (#40054027)
A presumption is not a simplification of anything. It is a starting point.
Re:The legal rule that computers are presumed to be operatin... by minimalized on Tuesday April 16, 2024 @12:33PM (#40054078)
That's fair. But as the article shows, that presumption ends up weighing heavily in favor of computers working correctly. The nuance is in the difference between plumbing, which generally works well, and the bespoke business logic of individual applications, especially when said logic was responsible for the existence of critical evidence in a criminal case. The difference matters enormously and is not observed at all in the law.