Given the reaction to even the most basic deployment of a new technique, I doubt there will be mass adoption of more complex technique that alter gene expression any time soon.
However, these tools are too powerful to ignore. The most likely outcome is that these tools will be approved to cure rare diseases (CRISPR is already approved for sickle cell for example). A few decades of use will help ease anxiety about their use and safety.
The latter group is more likely to be involved in vaccine approval processes.
I'd rather have skeptics involved in high risk approvals.
of additional note, 2 FDA officials resigned during the votes on approving booster shots. They were simply replaced, and their concerns were moot. They were hardly anti-vaxxers.
But putting that aside, since I don't think it's a productive discussion- I'm simply pro zero bias. The only bias that should exist is a bias towards non-intervention over interventions. This used to be the standard for evaluating any medicine or vaccine. Or any medical procedure in general.
The real important bias issue that I see with the FDA doesn't have so much to do with vaccines specifically, but more with the incestuous relationship between FDA and Pharmaceutical companies, with there being a revolving door of blurry incentives. There's a long running issue of FDA officials, after approving various drugs and treatments for big pharma...then promoting into a big fat salary with a pharmaceutical company. I'm not sure what the solution is, as it makes logical sense that someone at the FDA would share the same skillsets as a big pharma exec, but- the only solution I can think of is to ensure that there are always skeptics on approval boards.
I do not take your claim of "zero bias" seriously while you make comments about "covid vaccine injured and damaged people" - sic.
I do not take your claims about "bias towards non-intervention" seriously when you cannot mention the far higher incidence of heart issues etc that results from deliberate withholding of vaccinations.
> ensure that there are always skeptics on approval boards.
I think that the issue is still that there is more than one definition of "skeptics" and as said above, the anti-vaxxer ideologues simply do not think things through well enough to be of any benefit. See your non-serious claims above.
FWIW, I had some issues that showed up after getting not-covid. They seem to have gone away after a few months of cardio workouts; hope your friends recover.
I'm glad you recovered, and thanks for the well wishes.
There are no sides or spectrum to this, vaccines are one of the most life saving inventions in human history. To be pro-vaccine means being rational.
> I'm simply pro zero bias
There’s no such thing.
> Before 2005, a major problem with the proposed therapeutic use of mRNA was that in vivo use led to inflammatory reactions. A key insight came about when Karikó focused on why transfer RNA (tRNA), used as a control in an experiment, did not provoke the same immune reaction as mRNA. [...] Karikó and Weissman determined how specific nucleoside modifications in mRNA led to a reduced immune response: by replacing uridine with pseudouridine.
> Another important achievement by the researchers was the development of a delivery technique to package the mRNA in lipid nanoparticles, a novel pharmaceutical drug delivery system for mRNA. The mRNA is injected into tiny fat droplets (lipid nanoparticles) which protect the fragile molecule until it can reach the desired area of the body.
"But they threw the first punch" is a rather reasonable response, but unfortunately we have to play the hand we've been dealt, not the one we'd like to have been dealt.
Did you know, anti-vaxxers are not the only humans who are not perfectly rational? Try to imagine a scenario where it is you on the other side of the rationality table, but cannot realize it (as is the case with anti-vaxx/etc buffoons).
Everyone is doing their best, but hardly anyone is trying their hardest.
> I totally understand the side of the antivaxers but also think many of them are based on false information and propaganda some people are pushing and I have a hard time not judging those particular antivaxers.
This is largely a consequence of them being humans raised in Western culture in the year 2024 - everyone is this way, through the degree and ways in which vary, in ways that are mostly only believed to be known - as the saying goes: a fox cannot smell his own den.
There has been a tremendous hesitancy to using more advanced gene editing and expression modifying techniques in a clinical setting. People just don't like it. So, yes, this would likely work, but it would be very difficult to bring to market for human use.