Also, there have been other early religions like Gnosticism in the west, which also falls into this category. Point is, even western religion has way more nuances.
(Kaizō in 1923 https://books.google.com/books?id=vLm4oojTPnkC&pg=PA262#v=on... )
> Scientific research can reduce superstition by encouraging people to think and view things in terms of cause and effect. Certain it is that a conviction, akin to religious feeling, of the rationality and intelligibility of the world lies behind all scientific work of a higher order.
> This firm belief, a belief bound up with a deep feeling, in a superior mind that reveals itself in the world of experience, represents my conception of God. In common parlance this may be described as "pantheistic" (Spinoza).
https://www.gutenberg.org/files/3800/3800-h/3800-h.htm
(Ethics was one of the hardest reads I had back in modern philosophy class)
And while it is a gross simplification of Ethics, from news://rec.humor.funny ( https://everything2.com/title/Existence+of+the+System+Admini... )
1. The System Administrator is defined as the most perfect user possible.
2. The property of necessary existence means that anything which possesses it must necessarily exist.
3. If existence is better than non-existence (see the ontological proof), then necessary existence is better still.
4. Any perfect user must possess the property of necessary existence.
5. Therefore the System Administrator must necessarily exist.
However:
6. Being perfect, the System Administrator cannot make mistakes, delete the wrong account, trash the root directory, mess up a tape load, etc.
7. Being perfect, the System Administrator can not be capable of goal-directed action, because such action would imply that the network is somehow less than perfect in its current state.
8. Therefore, the System Administrator is really more of a force of nature within the system.
9. Arguably, then the System Administrator *is* the system itself.
Counter-argument:
1. None, since the System Administrator has been defined to the point where it is a totally useless concept, there's no point in arguing.
At least this resolves one of the major issues: the Spinozist argument proves that *if* the System Administrator does exist, it cannot be intelligent.
---The God of Spinoza and Einstein is the magnificence of the universe as it reveals itself to us. The universe is real as is its majesty.
I don't claim to know the particular religion of his village and/or lineage, but I understand his God to be something closer to the Consciousness that (supposedly) gives rise to all of reality.
Bhakti does.
https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bhakti
>covers quite a few
Tons.
>Hinduism
There is no such thing.
The term is a Western invention, by complacent sneering so-called scholars about India.
And of course there is "such a thing." You even described what it refers to, a definition which is sufficient for the purposes of this thread.
Hey academic philosopher, God is everything, and there is nothing else, so God can be emotion and emotion can be God :) :) :)
Don't you know about Brahman?
There is nothing else ;)
https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Brahman
QED.
It would be more right to say, "(according) to my poor, half-baked, biased and largely incorrect knowledge"...
https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40047773
>stop posting vapid, bitter, empty responses.
My response was specific, and none of those things.
I wonder if you know the meaning of the words you use.
>I don't claim to know ...
>but I understand ...
>something ...
>(supposedly)
Those are the typical weasel words of a worse-than-an amateur Indic "scholar", or amateur scholar of any other kind, in fact.
Put your money and your conviction where your mouth is, bro, substantiated by facts, or at least, by better scholarship.
Until then, GTFO.
The problems is that they are more nuanced and complex than that. Hinduism, buhddism, Taoism are all lifestyles, thought processes, philosophys, self help, educational, informational... They dont fit in the neat little bucket that western thinking wants to put things in. This is one of those things that you wont find a satisfactory explanation for and needs to be experienced, consumed, lived rather than taught in a rote manner.
I highly recommend that you start with something like Sidhartha by Herman Hesse, and maybe the Tao of Pooh as just a primer on how different these things are. Getting past the surface of hinduism is going to be a battle that would require not only some reading but engaging with actual hindus (who are almost always happy to share).
https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dunning%E2%80%93Kruger_effec...
You have at least 3 spelling mistakes:
>buhddism
should be Buddhism
>philosophys
should be philosophies
and
>Sidhartha
should be Siddhartha
, not to mention capitalisation errors, like hinduism and hindus (both should start with a capital H).
And most of all, you are talking to a guy who is a Hindu by birth (and with plenty of knowledge about the subject, via family and friends and good books, not your pulp fiction kind), dummy, though not necessarily by conviction any more, at least for the traditional form of it.
And Hermann (not Herman) Hesse is junk when it comes to understanding anything about Hinduism.
Did you know that he was mental?
We grow up on a diet spiced, on almost a daily basis, with some combination of cumin, coriander, clove, cinnamon, cardamom, ginger, turmeric, pepper, onion, garlic, fenugreek, mustard, sesame, fennel - and many [1] other spices less or not known to the West or via "curry" (!) restaurants and YouTube cooks.
[1] For example, have you ever heard of mango ginger, karonda, mahani, green pepper, black cumin, white vs. black sesame, or long pepper, to name just a few of those, off the top of my head?
Betcha not, mostly ...
And we relish all( )spice (pun intended).
Mildly contemptuous and somewhat snarky, I definitely can be, intentionally, in some justified contexts, such as in the context of replying to your original comment, which was intellectually unsound, vague and vapid (using your own word against you). Weasel words, like I said elswhere in this subthread. (And don't pretend that your words to me are not contemptuous either. Can't handle tit for tat, or an eye for an eye?)
A troll I am not, although I don't expect you to agree with that. Opinions, bro, opinions. Mine is as good as yours. You don't get to lay down the standard for what is right or wrong, even though it might be a wet dream of yours.
>You might find Reddit a better place for your edginess.
He he, I left Reddit a long time ago, so as to come here and trouble passive-aggressive people like you (just kidding).
>It's not welcome here.
Neither is your kind of crap talk. In fact, I'd hazard a bet, that my kind is more welcome, among the HN cognoscenti (a.k.a. the sane ones), who exist, although they are probably much fewer in number than the hive mind or echo chamber crowd here. Normal distribution and all that, y'know.
for most jewish, christian, and muslim mystics and some theologians, as well.
the 'new atheist' conception of what "all christians" think about when they think about god is, well, not very representative.
From https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Srinivasa_Ramanujan#Personalit...
> While asleep, I had an unusual experience. There was a red screen formed by flowing blood, as it were. I was observing it. Suddenly a hand began to write on the screen. I became all attention. That hand wrote a number of elliptic integrals. They stuck to my mind. As soon as I woke up, I committed them to writing.
That doesn't seem like an emotion at all. It's a very visual, concrete image. It's closer to the "western atheists" view of god that just an abstract feeling of some sort you were describing, wouldn't you agree?
Indian philosophy is diverse and vast. See the comparison of these philosophies [2]
[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Charvaka
[2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Indian_philosophy#Comparison_o...
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/New_Atheism#Criticisms
No one in the philosophy world takes the works of the New Atheists seriously. They are pop-culture writers, not serious philosophers (other than Daniel Dennett.)
If you want a serious thinker's thoughts on atheism, you are better off picking up a book by Nietzsche, Charles Taylor, David Bentley Hart, the Oxford Handbook of Atheism, or any other number of thinkers, or browsing the articles here: https://plato.stanford.edu/search/searcher.py?query=atheism
Although this aspect of Hinduism seems to be changing and becoming a bit more hardline