So all the defense ministers in europe for example, who urge us to get ready for real war, are paranoid then?
25 years ago it was mostly peaceful, with a steady downward trend since then. And many people, including government officials, see now a war between china and US as inevitable. That is different from my youth, which was mainly optimistic, with the big players negotiating and demilitarizing.
That is about deterrence, no?
https://www.reuters.com/world/europe/have-peace-europe-must-...
It would be good to see the evidence for a war from the last two years would a) cause suicide and b) do it instantly.
True, but we are not talking about the last 50 years, we are talking about the future, for example, the next 5 years. People don't commit suicide if they think their future will be OK.
> Same goes for access to drinkable water, food, decent shelter, gender equality, freedoms, technology, etc.
- Item 2 and 3 ignore recent rises in food prices and housing prices.
- For the U.S., item 4 and 5 have been reduced in many places by various recent laws and judicial decisions (unless you are super rich), and this will probably continue for the near future.
- The last item - 6 - technology. I think for a non-tech-person standpoint, it really appears like technology primarily has ...
A) ... stagnated. Phones--the tech most people use daily--haven't done anything new and exciting for some time. The Internet hasn't given the non-tech public-at-large the next big thing after social media, either.
B) ... primarily become interested in putting monthy fees, ads and tracking on everything one does, and
C) ... a mission replace most jobs with A.I.
But, very few people people commit suicide purely in response to their despair concerning the state of the world. There are almost always deeper mental health issues involved. And as strange as it sounds, suicide goes in and out of fashion as well. In general, it's very difficult to drill down on causality of suicide rates.
Speculation, but I strongly suspect that only a blind Pinker follower would so confidently say that.
Do you happen to live on earth, Professor. Pangloss's disciple[1]?
Like, I'm sure someone in Flint a few years ago wouldn't begrudge more people having access to drinkable water but they're obviously going to be massively unhappy about having to consider the possibility of no longer having access to it themselves.
Peaceful? As in Russia, Ukraine, Israel, Gaza, Iran? Brazil is at great risk also.
I don't think so.
You are probably living in a different world than the rest of us.
though, the fact that there are no real issues could indeed be an issue.
There are so many things that statistics don’t cover it’s unreal.
One thing that especially comes to mind is that many of the illusions of society have been shattered by the younger generations. Things like believing you should be loyal to your employer because they’ll return the favor.
Nobody's believed that since, I'd say, the 1970s-1980s. Even Japan, famous for its culture of lifetime employment, phased that out in the 1990s. It's ridiculous to suggest that that's a new phenomenon.
50k deaths put this at roughly a Vietnam war every year.
It’s not that they were fully ignorant of the news in the past, but people used to get most of their “takes” and opinions from like, a weekly editorial column or Sunday paper or something that would sort of bubble up through various cultural filtering mechanisms. By the time it got to your typical 17 year old it has already gone through a “processing mechanism” where it’s been analyzed, contextualized, better understood. They’re not getting the messy information in raw form.
Now they get the raw information as it happens, and often bubbling up from agenda driven activists instead of disinterested analysts. Consequently, everything has a heavy emotional charge and is specifically geared to short circuit the rational mechanisms for understanding things and hit you in the lizard brain. The lizard brain is good for quick thinking and rapid reactions, but it’s not very good at emotional regulation, priority setting, or any of the other stuff that’s conducive to mental health.
https://cos.northeastern.edu/news/its-time-to-correct-neuros...
> "Russia & China constantly attacking countries' computer & physical infrastructure, etc."
Is this in any way comparable to physical warfare?
But their phone says this is different, so they believe it. Mission Accomplished.
To understand the differences between feudalism and capitalism, you must also understand the conflict between the feudalist aristocracy (god-given) and the capitalist bourgeoise (industrious accumulators of capital). This conict was really the source of the shift to capitalism. The aristocracy could not compete with the capitalists as the capitalists promoted a story of mobility by accumulating capital. Of course, however, only a few can achieve that, and they basically still argue that their abilities are god-given. But the claim about abilities and hard work paying off vs. simple i herited permanent roles results in a much more damaging psychology.
Unfortunately, people do tend to be happier if they're miserable among other miserable people, than if they were living comfortably among people with cooler things than them.
It is very well understood across all relevant metrics that younger people are less economically secure than their parents. Coupled with extreme and growing wealth inequality, this is bound to be a political problem whether you like it or not. And, these suicide numbers suggest it may be a serious psychological problem as well. Your platitudes don't change that.
Food that’s hyperpalatable, full of sugar, and devoid of nutrition. Case-in-point, the obesity crisis.
Sure technology is great but the internet has fucked our brains. The tech industry repeatedly creates hype bubbles like crypto to make a buck. And don’t even get me started about AI.
Gender equality is far from resolved for both men and women. Women still have to deal with harassment and men are now expected to fulfill contradictory roles of being both a progressive feminist and a traditional masculine man.
Sure things are great when you oversimplify and ignore the bad parts.
oh jeez, say that to the people of Palestine or the Congo. people who make these blanket generalizations are either tone deaf or come from a place of privilege.
Pointing to one thing going wrong so you can call people 'privileged' doesn't change it. Nuclear Mutually Assured Destruction (MAD), NATO, the EU, the USA, the generally calm dissolution of the British/French/Spanish empires, the end of new lands to find, has stabilised a lot.
[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_conflicts_in_Europe
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_modern_conflicts_in_th...
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/History_of_the_Arab%E2%80%93Is...
It's nonsense.
There's been a land war in Europe for the first time since WW2 going on, if you hadn't noticed. About a half million casualties.
We solved the ozone layer. The right just refuses to engage with climate change as we rush past the worst case projections.
Wealth inequality is at historic extremes.
Pretty much any honest review is going to be profoundly demoralizing.
Meanwhile Putin is itching for a rationalization to drop a nuke in Ukraine.
Those last 50 years were a side effect from one of two global powers catastrophically collapsing. The tensions that drive modern history didn't dissolve when that happened, they were just tabled as numerous contending powers with their own visions of the world reorganized and regrouped. Maybe we can all diplomatically navigate our way past the worst outcomes along the way, but the next 50 years simply aren't going to look like the last 50.
The world probably has never been as peaceful as in the last 50 years or so.
Same goes for access to drinkable water, food, decent shelter, gender equality, freedoms, technology, etc.
But I suppose your comment is a good illustration of the problem at hands (that so many people deeply believe that things are fucked)