News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Adobe Is Buying Videos for $3 per Minute to Build AI Model by troq13 on Thursday April 11, 2024 @09:17PM (#40008546)
Weird spot. $3 per minute seems like a lot more than most AI companies are willing to pay, and a lot less than most creators who are not making slop would be willing to take.
Re:Adobe Is Buying Videos for $3 per Minute to Build AI Model by devoutsalsa on Friday April 12, 2024 @07:46AM (#40011468)
If I’d posted 10 minute videos weekly for 5 years and someone offered me $7500-ish to use them as training data, I’d think that was a pretty good deal. YMMV.
Re:Adobe Is Buying Videos for $3 per Minute to Build AI Model by endisneigh on Friday April 12, 2024 @08:03AM (#40011587)
Depending on the content that’s a terrible deal. Low ball is it takes an hour to produce a single minute of video. You’re being paid 3 bucks an hour. If it’s animation it could take a day to animate a single minute, in which case you’re being screwed even harder.

Suckers who don’t properly value their time is why BigCo generally wins.

Re:Adobe Is Buying Videos for $3 per Minute to Build AI Model by devoutsalsa on Friday April 12, 2024 @08:18AM (#40011730)
You can sell it more than once.
Re:Adobe Is Buying Videos for $3 per Minute to Build AI Model by replygirl on Friday April 12, 2024 @08:21AM (#40011751)
i reckon nearly zero of these creators are making videos for a single viewer. and as a film student, or even as a professor, you wouldn't spend $300 per movie just to reference in study. demanding even more than that can only be hedging against the idea that one will be out of a job
Re:Adobe Is Buying Videos for $3 per Minute to Build AI Model by altdataseller on Friday April 12, 2024 @08:05AM (#40011614)
Did they say they’re buying only high quality videos? What if it’s just a video of me talking through my coding sessions? It would be rather low effort and sounds like “free money” to me
Re:Adobe Is Buying Videos for $3 per Minute to Build AI Model by doublerabbit on Friday April 12, 2024 @08:09AM (#40011645)
Would it though? If they train your video, produced future videos based off that video, even charge for the next that then takes away your ability to talk about the next session for your video.

So you got paid a low ball amount only to be ripped off.

Re:Adobe Is Buying Videos for $3 per Minute to Build AI Model by replygirl on Friday April 12, 2024 @08:29AM (#40011825)
would it though? nothing would be stopping them. the idea something would relies on an assumption that we'll soon be able to generate long, coherent, and useful instructional videos with fully resolved text on demand, with such high quality and low cost that no one will be able to compete. but we already have people out there who can do this instruction/review live and off the cuff, and who would certainly be able to make use of this stuff in their own work
Re:Adobe Is Buying Videos for $3 per Minute to Build AI Model by doublerabbit on Friday April 12, 2024 @02:05PM (#40015843)
Yes it would.

Because it restricts you from creating such style videos. Your being paid a pittance for a bot to learn your style.

Why wouldn't you want more money?

Re:Adobe Is Buying Videos for $3 per Minute to Build AI Model by AnthonyMouse on Friday April 12, 2024 @02:39PM (#40016247)
> Why wouldn't you want more money?

Because that style isn't that unique, so the difference is between getting paid nothing and now there is a bot that can do the same thing, or getting paid something and now there is a bot that can do the same thing.

It hasn't even been established that they're required to pay you at all.

Re:Adobe Is Buying Videos for $3 per Minute to Build AI Model by doublerabbit on Friday April 12, 2024 @02:51PM (#40016360)
My style is unique. If I'm teaching folks something I'm skilled in I wouldn't want to be learned from $3 especially for a $$$ company that abuses trust.

Style is how teachers make learning happen. If teachers follow the general generic book mundaneness, you learn far less than of you apply your own style.

Besides, if they were using the content without my permission I should be allowed to seek costs for such.

Re:Adobe Is Buying Videos for $3 per Minute to Build AI Model by AnthonyMouse on Friday April 12, 2024 @03:07PM (#40016536)
> My style is unique.

"You're unique, just like everybody else."

It doesn't matter if the thing is using your exact style or one which is enough of a substitute for it that the difference isn't going to make up the difference between your $50 fee and the $0.01 in electricity it takes to have the AI do it.

> Besides, if they were using the content without my permission I should be allowed to seek costs for such.

On what basis? How is it different than someone teaching their students your style, so the students can make their own original works in the same style? It's directly analogous to classroom use, which is an explicit example of fair use from the copyright statute.

Re:Adobe Is Buying Videos for $3 per Minute to Build AI Model by replygirl on Friday April 12, 2024 @03:32PM (#40016772)
keeping in mind $0.01 for something like an hour lesson, or a full class, is entirely theoretical
Re:Adobe Is Buying Videos for $3 per Minute to Build AI Model by AnthonyMouse on Friday April 12, 2024 @03:40PM (#40016842)
The AI is the thing being taught, not the thing teaching a class. Once you have a model, $0.01 is the correct order of magnitude for the cost of generating an image from a prompt. If anything it's an overestimate.
Re:Adobe Is Buying Videos for $3 per Minute to Build AI Model by replygirl on Friday April 12, 2024 @03:44PM (#40016880)
it's barley short of what a 1920x1080 image costs from openai, but we're in a thread about instructional video, which is neither economical nor available yet
Re:Adobe Is Buying Videos for $3 per Minute to Build AI Model by AnthonyMouse on Friday April 12, 2024 @04:01PM (#40017044)
Video would cost more than still images for the obvious reasons, but still likely much less than the cost of however many frames per second times that number of images, because nearly all of the frames will be minor variations on the previous frame. Meanwhile it's going to be a couple years before that technology exists because you'd have to develop something that can sync video with audio etc., by which point the hardware would be more power efficient.

So now we're speculating on the cost of something that doesn't exist yet, but it's highly likely that hardware is going to get more power efficient over time, so the question then isn't whether "AI can do this for a lower price than humans" will happen, it's just a question of how long before it does.

Re:Adobe Is Buying Videos for $3 per Minute to Build AI Model by doublerabbit on Friday April 12, 2024 @03:16PM (#40016620)
This is moot. For sake of sanity, and that I said what I wanted to say and I'll agree to disagree.

This just shows that anyone is willing to cloned for less than their actual worth which is calculated on their own basis.

If you'd rather be ripped off, having a class taught for $5 from some AI bot from your own teaching style earning a single $3 than yourself teaching and earning $5 from each class, be my guest.

Edit: I'm now post capped, so can't comment/reply on HN for another four hours anyway. Old news.

Re:Adobe Is Buying Videos for $3 per Minute to Build AI Model by replygirl on Friday April 12, 2024 @03:30PM (#40016754)
it restricts one from making more videos? how? i understand your comment as reiterating the assumption i was responding to then reframing that assumption with a generalization. of course fair pay is good, and my point is we don't have a solid foundation to assume ai will impact that more any other creative technology we've seen on computers in the last few decades
Re:Adobe Is Buying Videos for $3 per Minute to Build AI Model by sebzim4500 on Friday April 12, 2024 @08:27AM (#40011799)
Yeah but if you have already made the content then you're getting $7500 for free.
Re:Adobe Is Buying Videos for $3 per Minute to Build AI Model by endisneigh on Friday April 12, 2024 @08:28AM (#40011814)
Per the article you’re paid to make new content.

Even if that were not true, releasing the rights for so little is dumb.

Re:Adobe Is Buying Videos for $3 per Minute to Build AI Model by 0cf8612b2e1e on Friday April 12, 2024 @03:46PM (#40016896)
As opposed to the Pile where the authors got nothing for the privilege of their content being used to train the LLMs.
Re:Adobe Is Buying Videos for $3 per Minute to Build AI Model by lightedman on Friday April 12, 2024 @08:42AM (#40011932)
"Low ball is it takes an hour to produce a single minute of video."

As some of us like to say, "Fuck it, we'll do it live." As in, that's the only take you get and it goes right to production zero editing and processing. Everything gets set once, fired once, and it gets uploaded immediately.

Re:Adobe Is Buying Videos for $3 per Minute to Build AI Model by sebastiennight on Saturday April 13, 2024 @09:45AM (#40023103)
Well, with AI video editing like what we do at OneTake AI, you can have this cake and eat it too...

You shoot it "live" and let the AI deal with the editing and processing for you.

Re:Adobe Is Buying Videos for $3 per Minute to Build AI Model by asah on Friday April 12, 2024 @08:43AM (#40011936)
Price is determined by the value to the purchaser, not the cost of production. Particularly for digital products with no per-use COGS.
Re:Adobe Is Buying Videos for $3 per Minute to Build AI Model by rakoo on Friday April 12, 2024 @01:45PM (#40015588)
If I learn through the press that Adobe is willing to pay amount A and this information is very peblic, I can at the very least assume they are making 10x more so I'm willing to sell it 20x more and see where this goes
Re:Adobe Is Buying Videos for $3 per Minute to Build AI Model by fennecbutt on Saturday April 13, 2024 @11:13PM (#40028345)
It takes 1 minute to produce 1 minute of video.

It takes an hour to produce 1 minute of scripted content and fancy graphics for a professional YouTube show.

Re:Adobe Is Buying Videos for $3 per Minute to Build AI Model by baobabKoodaa on Friday April 12, 2024 @08:22AM (#40011755)
These AI video systems will need huge amounts of random videos showing things like leafs rustling in the wind, car driving, etc. so you don't even need to put in 10 hours of effort to create a 10 minute video, you can just grab your camera and go for a walk and publish that as it is, and it will be valuable training material.

$3 per minute would be a pretty high price to pay for "man walks outside" video.

Re:Adobe Is Buying Videos for $3 per Minute to Build AI Model by zingelshuher on Saturday April 13, 2024 @01:15PM (#40024499)
As you mentioned models need _random_ videos. Just 'walk outside' will produce more or less the same. My guess Adobe is more interested in 'family' sort of videos, with humans. This is what most users will be asking for. Getting them in other ways will be either illegal or really expensive.
Re:Adobe Is Buying Videos for $3 per Minute to Build AI Model by baobabKoodaa on Saturday April 13, 2024 @04:19PM (#40025713)
I'm not suggesting that anyone here will make $3 per minute shooting random videos, whether those videos are "man walking outside", or "family gathers at the fireplace". The distinction between those types of videos was not pertinent. I was pointing out that making videos for the purpose of training AI doesn't require you to put 10 hours of effort into making a 10 minute video, like for example, Youtube creators might do.
Re:Adobe Is Buying Videos for $3 per Minute to Build AI Model by zingelshuher on Sunday April 14, 2024 @04:52PM (#40034374)
Yes. And there are many forgotten accounts on youtube, their owners now have another way to monetarize. Not sure why Adobe didn't talk to Youtube directly.
Re:Adobe Is Buying Videos for $3 per Minute to Build AI Model by doublerabbit on Friday April 12, 2024 @02:06PM (#40015866)
Why wouldn't you want more?
Re:Adobe Is Buying Videos for $3 per Minute to Build AI Model by ysavir on Friday April 12, 2024 @03:02PM (#40016474)
If I was in that situation, the last thing I'd want is to provide an AI video generator the means of creating videos like mine and that would compete with me.
Re:Adobe Is Buying Videos for $3 per Minute to Build AI Model by paxys on Friday April 12, 2024 @07:49AM (#40011493)
If it's a non exclusive deal then of course they'll take it.
Re:Adobe Is Buying Videos for $3 per Minute to Build AI Model by troq13 on Friday April 12, 2024 @05:21PM (#40017796)
"you already used these socks, why wouldn't you sell them to a stranger for $3"
Re:Adobe Is Buying Videos for $3 per Minute to Build AI Model by voxic11 on Friday April 12, 2024 @10:04AM (#40013050)
Its a non-exclusive deal so you can film something for your youtube channel and make money there while also getting some extra bucks from adobe.
Re:Adobe Is Buying Videos for $3 per Minute to Build AI Model by Legend2440 on Friday April 12, 2024 @05:11PM (#40017708)
Videos that are good for training data are very different from videos that are good content.

They do not want theatrical productions, they want raw footage of the real world.

Re:Adobe Is Buying Videos for $3 per Minute to Build AI Model by jgalt212 on Friday April 12, 2024 @07:16PM (#40018608)
preferably with a descriptive voice-over track.
Re:Adobe Is Buying Videos for $3 per Minute to Build AI Model by raincole on Saturday April 13, 2024 @04:55AM (#40021613)
My question is how they're going to tag these videos? Videos without any text doesn't seem that useful.
Re:Adobe Is Buying Videos for $3 per Minute to Build AI Model by zingelshuher on Saturday April 13, 2024 @01:09PM (#40024450)
It doesn't affect creators life as they guarantee (likely) it will not be made public. So it's just side income. Likely creators make a lot of fragments which don't get into the final version. The problem for Adobe is most of these videos will be similar which, if not filtered, will make AI model biased. In other words they will pay and throw away significant part.