Remember Valve is a company that normally celebrates and promotes the modding community, even when using their IP directly (i.e. Black Mesa). Valve's decision was totally and exclusively because it included BOTH their and Nintendo's IPs in the equation.
It's entirely possible that Nintendo don't care, but the chance of Nintendo agreeing to go on the record about such things is basically zero.
On the flip side, there are plenty of other open source PS1 SDK options that have been written from scratch, do not reimplement the same API as Psy-Q and can thus be considered clean for the most part. Here's a few of them:
- https://github.com/grumpycoders/pcsx-redux/tree/main/src/mip...
- https://github.com/ChenThread/candyk-psx
- https://github.com/cuckydev/CKSDK
- https://github.com/spicyjpeg/ps1-bare-metal (shameless plug)
Doesn't that mean it's not clean room? Since even having those docs in the first place would not be legal?
I've seen others claim that clean room can only be an option if development was done without any input from anyone who has even read their docs, not just whether you have yourself or not.
For example in the N64 world some might say development is forever tainted because it's almost impossible to get information that wasn't sourced somehow ultimately from the oman dump.
Is there not a cleanroom SDK for the PS1? I doubt Sony cares too much at this point, but selling a course which relies on leaked proprietary tools still feels a bit dicey.
The Portal N64 demake got shut down because it used the leaked N64 SDK rather than cleanroom tools.