https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wE5G1kTndI4
His video description: "Nothing that exists in North America fits the definition of true high-speed rail. If we actually ever started building a network, where would we start? And how would we know when we were done? This video details a methodology for answering all those questions, then counts up 56 city pairs we really should've had high-speed rail service between long, long ago."
That analysis makes several idealistic assumptions, e.g. frictionless international borders. It’s a good starting point, but his other videos analysing specific corridors seem more grounded.
China has the same problem... they simply made it a priority to build the infrastructure.
There is nothing stopping us from doing the same thing.
Well what's stopping us is:
1. prioritization of private property ownership over every other possible measure of societal health, people can drag out these projects fighting over the land in court for decades
2. government cronyism isn't even organized enough to stomp out the issues with #1 using eminent domain, because all the small fractious governments of states and local municipalities are working against each other to each win the cronyism battle. at least in more centralized governments, the cronysim is organized enough to get the project done while skimming 75% of the money off the top.
If you look at China's HSR map, they have exactly one line that goes into the western half of the country (from Lanzhou to Urumuqi). It only takes 9 hours, only a few stops in between.
No reason these couldn't be linked up and are more populous than many equivalent regions with HSR. It's like power grids, noone is arguing that one big one from SF to NY is the right solution.
However achieving property rights for the land needed for the project is a much bigger issue in the US than in China, where I doubt they receive much dissidence from people affected due to their infrastructure improvements.
China has almost four times the population density of America’s (146 per square kilometre to 37).
The USA is a bit better, 25% live in the western half (mostly on the west coast though).
If they get the beds and service right, it would be because it’s convenient and comfortable. Like, have a Michelin-class meal, good wine, reliable service that knows the regulars and comfortable beds and good shock absorbers and you’re trumping planes as the first-class option.
It doesn’t have to beat flying in all cases to be successful. Price always seemed like a weird niche for passenger rail to aim for—planes don’t have to maintain track!
Well, they have to maintain airports, but there's a lot of federal funding that goes into that too. It's always interesting to see where the costs of infrastructure are borne. Rail seems to be one of the few where the carriers (and consumers) are almost entirely directly responsible for the infrastructure. (Admittedly, citation needed.)
The rewards on a Bay Area-Los Angeles flight are de minimis if you’re a frequent flier. I am one, and I was planning on taking the Coastal Starlight up next month until I learned—in this thread—that it’s kaput for the time being.
The problem is that it’s not, at least from the standpoint of property rights covering that land. For example, the path from San Francisco to LA is relatively densely populated. And on top of that, the US has an intractable legal system for building infrastructure.
I feel like even if we were to do it, folks would sabotage it for politics here. It's tiring.
It's convenient and depending on your distance to an airport, only slightly longer, but much more convenient. I'm a big fan.
That said, having successful train systems in the US is hard. The US is a huge country with a lot of empty space. If it's a regional train in dense areas, it can make sense (like the NE regional). Maybe the traffic of LA <-> SF makes sense, and if it does and it can be done cost effectively, then it'll work out.
My assumption is that after building all the infrastructure into place, the cost of the tickets plus the additional travel time will not be worth it to most who are making this trip. I would love to be wrong, but I'm not counting on it.
I love the experience of taking a train, and I take them a good bit here in the North East. That said, they're not the best solution in the US currently, it's it's hard to see a world where they become the best for travel outside commuter rails (the MBTA commuter rail is also fantastic) and dense areas (again, like the NE regional).
Trains are not a catch all solution in the US. I hope for them to grow in popularity when they're appropriate, but I see a ton of online discourse (granted, it's likely from a vocal minority) about how trains are always better. They're not, and you can't compare US rail logistics to many regions to Europe.