News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Apple iPhone charger teardown: quality in an tiny expensi... by TamDenholm on Saturday May 19, 2012 @02:44PM (#3996661)
The thing is, Apple get away with charging a premium on its products because they are very well made. I'm no Apple fan but I admit the stuff that Apple produces, especially in hardware, is extremely well built.

In my own opinion, Apple products are probably about 30% better than competitors, but probably have 20% less features, however because they're simply better, they can charge probably 70% more than competitors simply because a lot people want and are willing to pay for the quality.

(Please dont read into the figures i've just used, i pulled them out my arse, they're for illustration purposes only.)

Re:Apple iPhone charger teardown: quality in an tiny expensi... by gouranga on Saturday May 19, 2012 @03:03PM (#3996719)
Having had piles of apple kit over the years, I can assure you that the quality is an illusion generated by the high price.

Here's what has died on me just outside a year since 2006 MacBook pro (logic board failure), iMac (won't boot), a MacBook (won't charge), just about every damn usb cable they've ever given me (broken at type a connector), airport express (melted). A friend of mine's MacBook pro caught fire. I won't even bother to catalogue the 22 dead iPhones my company has...

My iPod nano and a 2009 macbook are still fine.

conversely, my circa 2007 Lenovo t61 cost around $100 2 years ago and has been dropped, yanked off tables and has a couple of drinks in it and it just stares at you and takes it. It had a new battery last year and a new power connector (self installed) with no problems as they have full service manuals available.

That's engineering and service.

(I am a qualified EE so will not comment on the initial article as it makes me squirm a bit)

Re:Apple iPhone charger teardown: quality in an tiny expensi... by digitalchaos on Saturday May 19, 2012 @03:20PM (#3996761)
You clearly have a large pool of hardware. Your numbers mean nothing without knowing the hardware that DIDN'T fail.

To give a more useful metric, for the last 4 years I have maintained a company have about 150 machines. 50% are Macbook Pros. 50% are Lenovos. I saw, on average, 5-6 Lenovos have some sort of hardware failure per year. The Macbook Pros would see 1-2 hardware failures per year. The Macbook Pros were also giving about 6-12 months of extra life before needing to be replaced. The external packaging of the Lenovos would produce MUCH more wear year over year than the aluminum Macbook Pro.

Re:Apple iPhone charger teardown: quality in an tiny expensi... by swalsh on Saturday May 19, 2012 @07:17PM (#3997369)
I believe the Lenovo is just a terrible hardware producer. I got a T410S when I started at my new company. It was brand new. 3 months later the screen had a 1" thick white line on the monitor. I treated the thing like royalty. A few months later the plastic casing started to crack despite the lack of obvious impacts. 6 months later, a fan error prevented it from booting. I bought a mac book air at the same time, and it's still looks/works like the day I bought it!
Re:Apple iPhone charger teardown: quality in an tiny expensi... by jarek on Monday May 21, 2012 @07:56PM (#4005544)
I have a Lenovo-built T60p, built in 2006, I own it since 2008, works like new and looks much better than you'd expect a six-year-old laptop. Anecdata!
Re:Apple iPhone charger teardown: quality in an tiny expensi... by dsirijus on Sunday May 20, 2012 @03:47AM (#3998237)
And I assume those 50% Lenovos were in the MacBook Pro price range? Meaning, just the Xs?
Re:Apple iPhone charger teardown: quality in an tiny expensi... by gouranga on Saturday May 19, 2012 @03:32PM (#3996797)
I listed all the hardware I personally owned. It is all caveated on IMHO.

Lucky you :)

Re:Apple iPhone charger teardown: quality in an tiny expensi... by jrockway on Saturday May 19, 2012 @07:38PM (#3997423)
My experience is the same. I recently pulled my x220 off the table onto a hard floor. My first thought was, "what an idiot!" My second thought was, "oh, it's a Thinkpad, nevermind". The laptop is obviously undamaged. (I will admit the display is rather flexible, but so are all Apple laptops. Gone are the days when you could run over your laptop with a car, sadly. I guess being so cheap that you can replace them without caring is better peace of mind than any magnesium roll cage.)

I am a qualified EE so will not comment on the initial article as it makes me squirm a bit.

I'm not, though I did take a lot of EE classes in college, and I think the article is fine. He took the thing apart and noted which components Apple used. He's not telling anyone how to engineer their own power supply.

Re:Apple iPhone charger teardown: quality in an tiny expensi... by jscheel on Sunday May 20, 2012 @02:53AM (#3998157)
I wouldn't say those days are gone. A buddy of mine accidentally ran over his MacBook pro a few years ago. Granted, it was in his backpack at the time, but still... that sucker just kept on trekking. Looked awful though. Bent the whole thing into a slight curve, pulled apart some of the seams, etc, but it still worked.
[deleted]
Re:Apple iPhone charger teardown: quality in an tiny expensi... by dfox on Saturday May 19, 2012 @09:37PM (#3997643)
There is no single fault that can cause short between primary side of transformer and the output connector casing, so it's OK. Also, isolation distances on orders of millimeters are relevant for open air or PCB breakdown (with PCB-air interface having lower breakdown voltage than air or PCB alone due to possible water condensation) and not for isolated wiring inside transformer. It's pretty hard to imagine any failure mode that would cause short between connector casing without also causing breakdown between transformer windings. The whole thing looks slightly over-engineered (L6565 seems to me as a bit of overkill for this application), but safe.

It's interesting to note that most cheap replacement chargers don't have significant safety issues but produce harmful EMI, on the other hand it's not too hard to find name brand power supply which have significant safety issues (eg. low impedance connection between otherwise unconnected ground of EMI filter on primary side and output ground), often caused by combination of safety, EMC and design/size requirements and weird interactions between them and between requirements of different jurisdictions (EMC, ESD and safety requirements of EU sometimes tend to be contradictory).

Re:Apple iPhone charger teardown: quality in an tiny expensi... by kens on Saturday May 19, 2012 @09:02PM (#3997585)
Note that many of the pictures don't include all the insulation. (I mention this in Footnote 5, so it's easy to miss.) In particular, there was a black plastic insulator over the USB output plug that only appears in the first picture. And there are several layers of insulating tape around the transformer. This should meet the safety standards; if it didn't, they wouldn't approve it after all.
Re:Apple iPhone charger teardown: quality in an tiny expensi... by jrockway on Saturday May 19, 2012 @08:56PM (#3997572)
UL didn't seem to mind. There is a lot of insulation between the primary and the USB socket: tape, plastic, the secondary winding, more tape, and so on. I can't imagine a failure mode for this system that would occur in normal use.
Re:Apple iPhone charger teardown: quality in an tiny expensi... by gouranga on Sunday May 20, 2012 @06:38AM (#3998461)
Tape melts, emits gas which is poisonous and is more conductive than the plain air gap. There's your failure mode.

Bear in mind my Airport express melted and blew my circuit breakers so shorts are definitely a possibility.

Re:Apple iPhone charger teardown: quality in an tiny expensi... by jrockway on Sunday May 20, 2012 @06:50AM (#3998481)
It also fails if subjected to a large amount of shrapnel!
Re:Apple iPhone charger teardown: quality in an tiny expensi... by zdw on Saturday May 19, 2012 @03:30PM (#3996793)
USB cable ends fraying has nearly always been undue strain or user error, in my experience.

I've seen literally thousands of Apple USB cables in my work, and, while they probably won't hold up against heavy abuse as well as a rubbery booted end, they tend to either be totally fine or fraying at the ends.

The funny thing is that people with fraying ends tend to have all their cables fraying, whereas those with undamaged cables tend to have all undamaged cables.

There's something about use case here where Apple's cables just don't hold up to common (mis?)use case by a subset of their users.

Re:Apple iPhone charger teardown: quality in an tiny expensi... by gouranga on Saturday May 19, 2012 @03:37PM (#3996810)
Undue stain? If they're fraying then it's bad engineering plain and simple.

A $5 set of Sony earphones goes through several orders of magnitude more shearing, twisting and pulling and last years. Why can't apple do that?

Because it looks pretty before it has sound engineering.

Re:Apple iPhone charger teardown: quality in an tiny expensi... by zdw on Saturday May 19, 2012 @06:42PM (#3997301)
Apple builds bulletproof, toughly built stuff when they need to - for example the "pulling out the prongs" example in the discussion root article, or devices like the original "toilet seat" iBook models.

Apple doesn't do it for everything for mainly aesthetic and packaging reasons - iOS 30 pin cables are much smaller than they used to be before the iPhone came out, to fit in even smaller packaging.

I'm sure there would be complaints about the "big, ugly cable" if Apple beefed up their cables ends, especially if the only benefit would be to the 20-30% of the population that is hard on their gear, and even in that case the enhanced durability would only increase the cable's lifespan slightly.

Re:Apple iPhone charger teardown: quality in an tiny expensi... by kens on Saturday May 19, 2012 @03:13PM (#3996739)
Please feel free to send me comments on the parts that make you squirm; I would be happy to update it and learn what I got wrong.
Re:Apple iPhone charger teardown: quality in an tiny expensi... by gouranga on Saturday May 19, 2012 @03:27PM (#3996782)
It's just the gushing over the thing that does me in. It's pretty standard for a vendor shipped item and TBH the only reason it's like it is, is due to the fact the last one they shipped was a pile of shite.

In the EU we have quite hefty electrical safety laws and I doubt it could be CE marked or approved in the UK at least based on the line voltage isolation.

Re:Apple iPhone charger teardown: quality in an tiny expensi... by marcusf on Saturday May 19, 2012 @08:32PM (#3997536)
I've gone through my fair share of Apple HW. I'll agree it's not without its failures. Broke a Powerbook G4 logic board, a MBP screen and one old iPod (abt 30% of what I've owned of Apple HW). What I've found which makes me happy though is they've always fixed it without charge and with no AppleCare, at least so far. I'll admit to only owning my own custom built PCs (and Nokia & SE phones) before that, at least for 10 years prior so I've nothing to compare with.

(Also an EE by education if not by trade, though that doesn't really count here)

Re:Apple iPhone charger teardown: quality in an tiny expensi... by gouranga on Sunday May 20, 2012 @06:43AM (#3998470)
I will say that they replace earphones readily. Unfortunately my dead MBP resulted in me being pretty much told to F Off depsite being literally 2 days out of warranty.
Re:Apple iPhone charger teardown: quality in an tiny expensi... by rmrm on Saturday May 19, 2012 @03:11PM (#3996733)
I come from an industrial (rather than consumer) background in electronics. There is nothing really interesting or impressive about this power supply. This is how you do it, you'd find similar designs in a wide range of industrial products.

What the real story is, is how cheaply power supply circuits are generally done in consumer electronics. They cut all kinds of corners and are quite amazing and often frightening. I actually find the cheap, hideous designs more impressive in some ways.

Re:Apple iPhone charger teardown: quality in an tiny expensi... by mbell on Saturday May 19, 2012 @03:43PM (#3996830)
As an EE myself I completely agree, this is a textbook SMPS topology used all the time, nothing technically special about it at all. The only interesting take away is that they didn't cut corners as is normally done in consumer gear.
Re:Apple iPhone charger teardown: quality in an tiny expensi... by CamperBob2 on Saturday May 19, 2012 @04:09PM (#3996920)
They cut all kinds of corners and are quite amazing and often frightening. I actually find the cheap, hideous designs more impressive in some ways.

Indeed. Mad Man Muntz (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Madman_Muntz) is alive and well and living in China.

Re:Apple iPhone charger teardown: quality in an tiny expensi... by smackfu on Monday May 21, 2012 @03:07PM (#4004346)
Teardown of a cheap power supply, from Mike's Electric Stuff: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=T88ej64aXUM
Re:Apple iPhone charger teardown: quality in an tiny expensi... by tjoff on Saturday May 19, 2012 @03:43PM (#3996836)
They aren't really that well designed compared to the competition. Apple can only focus on one thing at a time (and cutting corners on everything else).

Example: LED backlight cinema display? Neat! Then they cheap out using a glossy coating, not even a HUD, no scaler, no inputs, the worst stand in the market for a prosumer monitor etc. etc. etc. You'd think that a company claiming to be focusing on quality actually cares about ergonomics, but apple only care about looks and perceived quality. God knows how they can uphold that image when peoples devices fail constantly, I don't even know of anyone that own a working iPod anymore.

They can't even design the cooling for their laptops decently. They are hot and they are noisy (no margins at all), and it's not like you get anything in return. Buying an apple product you should just be happy if you can even exchange the battery.

As always, there is one thing they do right. On laptops it's the trackpad. But the rest just doesn't impress and is at best on par with the competition (but lacking the extra features (which isn't really a bad thing (most of the time) - but it makes you wonder what you pay for).

Apple has obviously gone to extra effort to reduce EMI interference, probably to keep the charger from interfering with the touchscreen

I've yet to encounter problems with any mobile phone during charging, so that makes you wonder whether apple uses a cheaper touchscreen than everyone else, or if other charges are just as good in regards to the EMI interference or if apple has higher margins than everyone else (which I highly doubt considering the problems apple create just to look good (cable strain relief springs to mind)).

Re:Apple iPhone charger teardown: quality in an tiny expensi... by kaiuhl on Saturday May 19, 2012 @05:38PM (#3997155)
This is a silly comment. Apple's laptops are widely regarded as the best in the industry and have been for quite a few years. The cinema displays are not just displays either—they also include 2.1 speakers, a webcam, and an ambient light sensor, all in a package that looks really nice in a house or office. This is a package that other display manufacturers are yet to produce.

It's nice to oversimplify for the sake of argument, but these kinds of non-reality based posts just show how polarizing Apple is.

Good design is important to most.

Re:Apple iPhone charger teardown: quality in an tiny expensi... by tjoff on Sunday May 20, 2012 @05:19AM (#3998368)
> Apple's laptops are widely regarded as the best in the industry and have been for quite a few years.

Oh, well in that case. Sigh.

Speakers, webcam and ambient light sensor... Those are the kind of non-features that you typically don't have to deal with on an apple product, if you care about a crappy webcam, inbuilt speakers in the monitor etc. you most certainly should buy a PC - they are crammed with useless stuff like that.

These kind of non-reality based post just shows just how blindly loyal the typical apple customer is.

Re:Apple iPhone charger teardown: quality in an tiny expensi... by culturestate on Sunday May 20, 2012 @06:13AM (#3998426)
There are two main purchasers of Cinema Displays: those who own an Apple laptop and want to use the display as a docking station with the laptop in clamshell mode, and those who own a Mac Pro or Mac Mini. In both use cases, having a display that integrates a webcam, speakers, and ambient light sensor is hugely beneficial.
Re:Apple iPhone charger teardown: quality in an tiny expensi... by jrockway on Saturday May 19, 2012 @07:52PM (#3997462)
Does any consumer display come with an appropriate stand? For me, a high-quality monitor arm is something you buy when you buy a desk, and when you buy a new monitor, you don't even bother to look at the junk stand the monitor includes. Stands just don't have the adjustability necessary to be comfortable. So, including a cheap stand seems like a good engineering compromise; it's just going to get thrown away, so why bother making it good?

(Oddly, I seem alone in this view. At Google, where a monitor stand is just a helpdesk ticket away, I've only seen about five other people that use them. Some people even use big stacks of paper to support their monitors. It's crazy!)

I also agree about Apple hardware running hot. I have a new mac mini on my desk and that thing is always very hot to the touch and often makes a lot of noise while under load. (To compare, I never hear a peep out of my generic 6-core tower, and that thing is always under heavy load.)

Re:Apple iPhone charger teardown: quality in an tiny expensi... by tjoff on Sunday May 20, 2012 @05:09AM (#3998353)
IPS monitors typically have decent stands. The Dell ultrasharp series for example are quite good in my opinion.

I don't think I've seen a cinema display with a monitor-arm, I'm a bit skeptic that people that buy the cinema display could ruin the aesthetics of the display with an arm (not that the cinema display is that good looking anyway).

I don't feel that an arm is needed when a good stand is included, and a good arm can easily cost as much as the monitor in the first place. Better to buy two monitors with good stands than one monitor with a crappy stand and an arm - in my opinion.

Re:Apple iPhone charger teardown: quality in an tiny expensi... by culturestate on Saturday May 19, 2012 @10:44PM (#3997748)
My MBP becomes a jet engine when under load, but I've honestly never heard the fan in my various Mac Pros after 5+ years.
Re:Apple iPhone charger teardown: quality in an tiny expensi... by christoph on Saturday May 19, 2012 @09:15PM (#3997602)
When I plug my Galaxy S2 into a cheap generic USB wall charger, the touchscreen is almost unusable. The problem certainly exists and is not limited to Apple hardware.
Re:Apple iPhone charger teardown: quality in an tiny expensi... by smsm42 on Saturday May 19, 2012 @03:24PM (#3996775)
Some of it is well-built. But IMHO charger cables are not among them. Every charger for Apple hardware I used had cables to break down after less than a year of use, and I had to repeatedly replace them. The reason is the design of the connector that is very fragile and not resistant to constant bending and moving around that is common for a mobile device. When I used laptops from other providers, chargers - including cabling - lasted for years without any substantial wear - it was common to retire a laptop but the whole charger was still working as new. For Apple ones, it's definitely not the case. Cables are very weak and new L-design laptop connector is worse than old T-design and breaks twice as fast in my experience. They made it look much better than ones from, say, Thinkpad, but at the cost of durability. So here's a part that is definitely worse than the competitors.
Re:Apple iPhone charger teardown: quality in an tiny expensi... by pearle on Saturday May 19, 2012 @03:30PM (#3996792)
I agree with this. I have several IBM/Dell/Lenovo adapters and they are all in fine shape. My Apple adapters? Not so much -- they're all in various stages of cable breakage.

I really do not care how the connector sleeves look on my cables. I'd prefer them to last longer than a year or two.

Re:Apple iPhone charger teardown: quality in an tiny expensi... by ricardobeat on Saturday May 19, 2012 @04:59PM (#3997046)
90% of me thinks that maybe 70% of the figures you quoted are 40% pointless.
Re:Apple iPhone charger teardown: quality in an tiny expensi... by its_so_on on Saturday May 19, 2012 @03:17PM (#3996747)
I agree with the gist of your post, however I must say that in my experience Apple products are manufactured to a standard that is 170% that of competitor's (really, just put a Macbook next to a Dell, or an iPhone next to a Blackberry and pore over the differences). On the features, I would say that roughly 75% more features are accessible to a casual user: you can simply do more without even thinking about it. However, to the professional user, only 15% of the features are available. (!) A professional user who got a degree in this subject can simply do literally six and a half times as many things on an Android or on a Linux desktop than with an iPhone or Mac OS X.

On pricing, I don't have any figures but do not consider it out of line to consider an Apple product as being a durable replacement for several cheap plastic versions. An investment in OS X in the guise of a $1800 MacBook Pro could easily take the place of a $700, a $500 and a $600 laptop bought over the same period of time. By the end of the period the specs of the MacBook would be severely out of date, however in other respects its usage may be preferable to the usage of the new $600 laptop. If you are not comparing on this basis, Apple products may be up to 300% as expensive as their competition, again as shown by the laptop example.

These numbers are scientific, have high statistical confidence, and good to eighteen decimal places. I show them with only one or two significant figures, however the full figures are going through a process of peer review and should appear soon in the IEEE Spectrum. Or not...

Re:Apple iPhone charger teardown: quality in an tiny expensi... by pooriaazimi on Saturday May 19, 2012 @03:24PM (#3996773)
> A professional user who got a degree in this subject can simply do literally six and a half times as many things on an Android or on a Linux desktop than with an iPhone or Mac OS X.

I almost agree with you on Android/iPhone (though 6.5 times is a big, big exaggeration, more likely 40%), but absolutely disagree with you about OS X/Linux. To me (I don't do kernel debugging, but use tons of 'pro' development tools daily), they're on par, with Linux a tiny bit (a few percent) in the lead. OS X is more shiny and is more pleasant to use as a development machine, but in Linux your hands are freeer.

Re:Apple iPhone charger teardown: quality in an tiny expensi... by smsm42 on Saturday May 19, 2012 @03:56PM (#3996884)
If only Mac OS X ever got a proper packaging system (one not for installing nice GUI apps, but for deploying infrastructure things like libraries) - then it would be on par. Right now, unfortunately, it's still subpar - doing the same things takes more time. I know theres ports and fink and homebrew, but each of them has its deficiencies, and they regularly step on each other's toes and make a mess of the system.
Re:Apple iPhone charger teardown: quality in an tiny expensi... by krrrh on Sunday May 20, 2012 @01:10AM (#3998004)
I might be out of line here but it sounds like you may not have given homebrew a decent enough chance. Fink and macports have always had problems, but a fresh Lion install + homebrew has about the same number of issues as a package manager as apt-get/dpkg on a stock Debian system, which is to say, not many. It definitely doesnt mess up the system without a great deal of willful effort to do so. Give it another chance.
Re:Apple iPhone charger teardown: quality in an tiny expensi... by smsm42 on Sunday May 20, 2012 @01:27AM (#3998034)
I had a lot of trouble explaining homebrew difference between i386 and x64 builds and getting it to build the right ones. It does not mess up the system by itself, but getting it to do the right thing requires some serious digging into the config formats - or at least it did when I needed it about a year ago.
Re:Apple iPhone charger teardown: quality in an tiny expensi... by quarterto on Sunday May 20, 2012 @08:45AM (#3998634)
There's a simple answer to that one. It's "don't use multiple package managers, you numpty". Use Homebrew. If it's missing a package, write a formula. Fork the repo on Github, brew-tap it [1], and if you think other people could use it, open a pull request.

[1]: https://github.com/mxcl/homebrew/wiki/Homebrew-0.9

Re:Apple iPhone charger teardown: quality in an tiny expensi... by smsm42 on Sunday May 20, 2012 @04:38PM (#4000016)
> If it's missing a package, write a formula.

That's exactly the problem. I don't want to write formulas. Just as on Linux I don't have to write RPMs - I just download them and install them. Yes, I can write a formula. Yes, it is not hard (in 90% of the cases). But it takes time, and I don't have extra time for it. And it takes learning yet another thing, which I don't need - and I have enough things to learn already that I do need.

I don't want to spend mental energy on it - I just want it to work. Linux achieved it, to a great degree, and Mac OS X still didn't.

Re:Apple iPhone charger teardown: quality in an tiny expensi... by stephencanon on Saturday May 19, 2012 @04:39PM (#3996993)
> A professional user who got a degree in this subject can simply do literally six and a half times as many things on an Android or on a Linux desktop than with an iPhone or Mac OS X.

They offer degrees in using a smartphone? Amazing that I've been able to get along with one for so long.