Re:Apple iPhone charger teardown: quality in an tiny expensi...
by gouranga on Saturday May 19, 2012 @03:37PM
(#3996810)
Undue stain? If they're fraying then it's bad engineering plain and simple.
A $5 set of Sony earphones goes through several orders of magnitude more shearing, twisting and pulling and last years. Why can't apple do that?
Because it looks pretty before it has sound engineering.
Re:Apple iPhone charger teardown: quality in an tiny expensi...
by zdw on Saturday May 19, 2012 @06:42PM
(#3997301)
Apple builds bulletproof, toughly built stuff when they need to - for example the "pulling out the prongs" example in the discussion root article, or devices like the original "toilet seat" iBook models.
Apple doesn't do it for everything for mainly aesthetic and packaging reasons - iOS 30 pin cables are much smaller than they used to be before the iPhone came out, to fit in even smaller packaging.
I'm sure there would be complaints about the "big, ugly cable" if Apple beefed up their cables ends, especially if the only benefit would be to the 20-30% of the population that is hard on their gear, and even in that case the enhanced durability would only increase the cable's lifespan slightly.
I've seen literally thousands of Apple USB cables in my work, and, while they probably won't hold up against heavy abuse as well as a rubbery booted end, they tend to either be totally fine or fraying at the ends.
The funny thing is that people with fraying ends tend to have all their cables fraying, whereas those with undamaged cables tend to have all undamaged cables.
There's something about use case here where Apple's cables just don't hold up to common (mis?)use case by a subset of their users.