News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Autonomous Overhead Powerline Recharging for Uninterrupte... by Terr_ on Friday April 05, 2024 @06:38PM (#39948137)
But you agree the loss exists, right? It's simply difficult to detect from some aggregate noisy flow at a centralized location, because the system was never designed to make that easily measurable.

The amount could be estimated by looking at how much flying the drones do between charges, or by suing for access to charging/position telemetry of the units.

Re:Autonomous Overhead Powerline Recharging for Uninterrupte... by SirSourdough on Friday April 05, 2024 @07:00PM (#39948293)
If the drones could meter their own consumption from the line using a utility-approved meter, anyone with a drone with said meter should be able to just tap onto lines at will and get a bill at the end of the month.

Not sure how that plays out in terms of the weight/packaging of the drone but seems feasible for at least larger drones.

Re:Autonomous Overhead Powerline Recharging for Uninterrupte... by plorg on Friday April 05, 2024 @09:35PM (#39949241)
Really depends who owns the lines; I doubt many T/D owners would want drones flying around by their lines, much less directly grabbing them.
Re:Autonomous Overhead Powerline Recharging for Uninterrupte... by pigpang on Saturday April 06, 2024 @08:16AM (#39951941)
A utility company can operate such drones without a meter, because they own lines and power.
Re:Autonomous Overhead Powerline Recharging for Uninterrupte... by _visgean on Friday April 05, 2024 @06:49PM (#39948221)
right now the loss does not exist. Its a cool experiment. If this was a big thing the drone fleet operators would simply get some kind of legal agreement with the transmission operator. But overall we are talking about really small amounts of energy.
Re:Autonomous Overhead Powerline Recharging for Uninterrupte... by Terr_ on Friday April 05, 2024 @08:05PM (#39948752)
> we are talking about really small amounts of energy

Napkin-math time: I see 4 motors, searching the model-number suggests max draw of ~380 watts, so let's assume it averages 1000 watts in operation, for 6 hours a day, with a local cost of electricity at $0.20 per kilowatt-hour, and this continues for one month.

1000*8/1000*$0.20*30 = $36 per month per drone.

That's not give-a-penny-take-a-penny territory.

Re:Autonomous Overhead Powerline Recharging for Uninterrupte... by SECProto on Saturday April 06, 2024 @12:40AM (#39950023)
That's bad napkin math. Per the video, it is charging at 50W. At worst, it would be charging 24hr/day, so 50Wx24h is 1.2kWh per day. Using your 20¢ rate, that's $0.24 per day or 7.20/month. That's the upper bound, assuming it only charges and does no work.
Re:Autonomous Overhead Powerline Recharging for Uninterrupte... by Terr_ on Saturday April 06, 2024 @12:50AM (#39950071)
> That's bad napkin math. Per the video, it is charging at 50W.

I previously pointed that out to someone in another comment, however I did not use 50 because the video-presentation continues with:

> The current in the power-line was approximately 300 amperes [...] a higher power-line current would result in a proportionally higher charging power. As future iterations of this system become more efficient, the ratio of time spent flying and time spent charging will significantly increase.

The point remains that once you reframe the electrical situation in financial terms, you will realize it is not just gleaning discarded ergs, and is instead significant enough to raise questions of theft and justice.

Re:Autonomous Overhead Powerline Recharging for Uninterrupte... by wglb on Friday April 05, 2024 @11:08PM (#39949666)
I would argue that it is less than an order of magnitude smaller than the coronal discharge or other losses.

I suspect we are talking about 24 watts as compared to eg 1000 megawatt 500kv line. This is seven orders of magnitude difference. Totally lost in the noise.

Re:Autonomous Overhead Powerline Recharging for Uninterrupte... by cdchn on Saturday April 06, 2024 @12:14AM (#39949895)
If companies could sue Nature for potential lost revenue, they would.
Re:Autonomous Overhead Powerline Recharging for Uninterrupte... by CSSer on Saturday April 06, 2024 @12:41AM (#39950029)
New FAA announcement:

Effective immediately, all airspace below 500 feet near powerlines is now classified as Class M airspace (for money). If your registered drone is detected nearby, you’ll be charged per second.

Re:Autonomous Overhead Powerline Recharging for Uninterrupte... by Terr_ on Friday April 05, 2024 @11:54PM (#39949806)
> smaller than the coronal discharge [...] lost in the noise

Technically plausible, yet ethically irrelevant. It's the same fallacy as: "It's OK for people to steal goods from that store, because the parent-company is very big and one theft won't even show up on their monthly financials."

You might that the physics means someone stealing 1.0 joule from point X is acktually only depriving someone else of 0.8 joules at point Y due to transmission losses, but it's still theft.

> I suspect we are talking about 24 watts

The video demonstration shows 50 watts of input.

Re:Autonomous Overhead Powerline Recharging for Uninterrupte... by jfoutz on Saturday April 06, 2024 @01:57AM (#39950334)
An alternative view, power companies point the finger at drones for outages or fires. Look the other way when people are stealing pennies. When the billion dollar bill comes in, hand it off to the police. Let them identify the operator, and put them on the hook for damages.