News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Meta's Onavo VPN removed SSL encryption of competitor's a... by cabirum on Sunday March 31, 2024 @04:11AM (#39882407)
What do you think Cloudflare is doing with its SSL termination/offloading?
Re:Meta's Onavo VPN removed SSL encryption of competitor's a... by LoganDark on Sunday March 31, 2024 @04:55AM (#39882592)
The difference is that people* know and accept that CloudFlare does this. They advertise it as a feature.

*most willing customers of CloudFlare.

Re:Meta's Onavo VPN removed SSL encryption of competitor's a... by xvector on Sunday March 31, 2024 @02:46PM (#39886884)
Users cannot consent to Cloudflare seeing their traffic and it's not an issue.

Users consent to Facebook seeing their traffic and it's suddenly a problem?

Re:Meta's Onavo VPN removed SSL encryption of competitor's a... by LoganDark on Sunday March 31, 2024 @03:22PM (#39887225)
> Users cannot consent to Cloudflare seeing their traffic

Users consent to the website seeing their traffic and the website consents to Cloudflare doing the SSL termination. This isn't too much different from the website consenting to analytics scripts monitoring webpage activity (i.e. Hotjar). If they did something shady, then users & the website would both be rightfully mad at them. But Cloudflare hasn't, so far at least.

Meanwhile, Facebook is known to do literally everything shady that is possible to do with a user's data, as well as plenty of things that weren't even a thing before they invented entirely new methods of tracking and selling data, so it's rightfully insane to trust them with anything, especially website traffic that they have no rights to.

Re:Meta's Onavo VPN removed SSL encryption of competitor's a... by viraptor on Sunday March 31, 2024 @10:23PM (#39890296)
Why would you idea stop at CF? Did they consent to hetzner / digital ocean / AWS / whatever hosting company seeing the traffic? The idea that the content producer decides how the content is served on the internet is the default.
Re:Meta's Onavo VPN removed SSL encryption of competitor's a... by LoganDark on Sunday March 31, 2024 @10:47PM (#39890429)
They don't see the traffic unless they analyze the memory of your running server, because the SSL termination happens inside the server. Encrypted traffic passes through their network, which they don't have the keys for. Cloudflare, on the other paw, literally offers to do the SSL termination for you, as in they hold the private keys and perform the decryption on their servers that they control. Then they pass the decrypted traffic through their network in order to do things like "optimize" your images, or inject JavaScript into your pages. Website owners consent to this, but I guess the question here is whether users should need to consent to this website's traffic being handled in decrypted form by Cloudflare before that is actually done.
Re:Meta's Onavo VPN removed SSL encryption of competitor's a... by viraptor on Sunday March 31, 2024 @10:52PM (#39890456)
They can see the traffic if you're using one of their load balancers. And even if not, snooping on VMs is pretty trivial. For example this project https://github.com/KVM-VMI/kvm-vmi makes it easy to look at memory / processes on a VM.
Re:Meta's Onavo VPN removed SSL encryption of competitor's a... by LoganDark on Monday April 01, 2024 @12:04AM (#39890806)
They can see the traffic if you're using one of their load balancers.

Only if you let them manage the SSL connection. Load balancers can easily relay individual TCP connections that are encrypted - load balancing doesn't require decryption.

> And even if not, snooping on VMs is pretty trivial.

They'd have to go out of their way to do this, and this would probably be the end of them if it were ever found out. So it's safe to assume any provider who wants to continue existing will not be doing this.

Re:Meta's Onavo VPN removed SSL encryption of competitor's a... by viraptor on Monday April 01, 2024 @01:17AM (#39891124)
It's not that hard for VMI and harder than you think for network.

I did work for a public cloud and we did think of VMI for diagnostics and malware checks. Once deployed and automated, it would be trivial to reuse for other purposes. I don't expect public cloud to use that daily, but I'd be surprised if they didn't have the process ready.

On the other hand, you want to process the LB traffic as fast as you can and any monitoring/reporting delay would have bad effects. Reconfiguring the filters / sinks at runtime takes effort too.

With experience in both areas, I can tell you they're comparable overall. You have to go out of your way to do it, but it's not too far.

Re:Meta's Onavo VPN removed SSL encryption of competitor's a... by ben_w on Sunday March 31, 2024 @04:59AM (#39882603)
Given Snowden, I have to assume Cloudfare is under the thumb of at least the NSA.

For example, all the usual arguments against backdoors are going to be used by intelligence agencies to justify "providing assistance", which isn't even merely a euphemistic excuse given how incredibly valuable it would be for normal organised crime to spy on some of the encrypted data… but also is at least a bit of a euphemism, as I have to assume the controversies about terrorist groups using Cloudfare are only pemitted to happen because someone in US intelligence knows how to squeeze secrets from those groups.

In theory, messing with SSL is one of Cloudfare's features, not a secret; in practice I suspect most end users treat all this as magic — I've directly witnessed magical thinking with the padlock icon in browsers.

Re:Meta's Onavo VPN removed SSL encryption of competitor's a... by fragmede on Sunday March 31, 2024 @04:27PM (#39887770)
that isn't even so much of a conspiracy theory if you look at what happened to qwest
Re:Meta's Onavo VPN removed SSL encryption of competitor's a... by supriyo-biswas on Sunday March 31, 2024 @05:23AM (#39882709)
Why single out Cloudflare? They are not the only CDN or PaaS with SSL fronting.
Re:Meta's Onavo VPN removed SSL encryption of competitor's a... by thistletame on Sunday March 31, 2024 @07:31AM (#39883274)
They explained pretty clearly why they think that's the case. You're both right though. It's likely not the case that cloud flare is the only company conducting and cooperating with government agencies to do these types of things. In my opinion it would be very silly to assume that.
Re:Meta's Onavo VPN removed SSL encryption of competitor's a... by isodev on Sunday March 31, 2024 @06:29AM (#39883003)
I honestly can't think of one without googling. Cloudflare is kind of everywhere. Just like Google... can't really get rid of them even if you want to.
Re:Meta's Onavo VPN removed SSL encryption of competitor's a... by akerl_ on Sunday March 31, 2024 @07:44AM (#39883348)
You can’t think of anybody else in the CDN or DoS mitigation business other than cloudflare?
Re:Meta's Onavo VPN removed SSL encryption of competitor's a... by fragmede on Sunday March 31, 2024 @04:33PM (#39887825)
I'm sorry but that means your nerd card will expire at the end of the month. I see you've had it for quite a while, but being unable to name any CDN companies besides Cloudflare means your nerd card will lapse. If you'd like to apply for a newer issue one, an LLM agent will be along shortly to help you.
Re:Meta's Onavo VPN removed SSL encryption of competitor's a... by isodev on Monday April 01, 2024 @06:31AM (#39892574)
Now obviously my comment is not about "just a CDN provider" right?

The SSL stuff that Cloudflare offers to protect your websites/APIs etc so you don't have to, their DNS products. The fact that iCloud Private Relay uses Cloudflare under the hood (and so all browsing there happens through their gateways etc).

Re:Meta's Onavo VPN removed SSL encryption of competitor's a... by fragmede on Monday April 01, 2024 @06:54AM (#39892712)
I mean, if it's just the case that you've drank that much of the Cloudflare Kool aid that Akamai, AWS, and GCP don't have competing options in your mind, then that's a different problem entirety. Good for Cloudflare's wallet, and kudos to their marketing team though.
Re:Meta's Onavo VPN removed SSL encryption of competitor's a... by viraptor on Sunday March 31, 2024 @08:16AM (#39883573)
That's different. I have a lot of problems with CF, but when you sign up for a service which requires to see the traffic and you configure it explicitly to see your traffic... what's the complaint here?
Re:Meta's Onavo VPN removed SSL encryption of competitor's a... by renaudg on Sunday March 31, 2024 @09:46PM (#39890098)
Onavo users signed up, consented to their traffic data to be used for market research and were actually compensated for it. What's the complaint here ?
Re:Meta's Onavo VPN removed SSL encryption of competitor's a... by viraptor on Sunday March 31, 2024 @10:14PM (#39890247)
Did they? I mean, did they understand the privacy violation possible in this case? Or was the technical point they wouldn't understand somewhere in the middle of an agreement nobody reads anyway?

The difference in awareness is massive between those two use cases.