Re:Endlessh-go: a Golang SSH tarpit that traps bots/scanners
by nubinetwork on Thursday March 28, 2024 @07:20AM
(#39849771)
I don't think it matters, ssh bots will try any port that sends back the ssh banner.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Endlessh-go: a Golang SSH tarpit that traps bots/scanners
by skrause on Thursday March 28, 2024 @08:01AM
(#39850135)
But they don't scan every port. I've been running my SSH server on a non-standard port for a long time, it took four years until I had the first bot with login attempts. About a year ago I changed the port and haven't seen any bots since then.
Re:Endlessh-go: a Golang SSH tarpit that traps bots/scanners
by qwertox on Thursday March 28, 2024 @08:24AM
(#39850352)
You can surround your custom port by a couple of ports on which a simple server listens for connection attempts. Any connection attempt is considered hostile and the ip will then be blacklisted in iptables. This prevents portscans from reaching your port.
Re:Endlessh-go: a Golang SSH tarpit that traps bots/scanners
by metadat on Thursday March 28, 2024 @08:30AM
(#39850413)
Only works for sequential scans, most scanners are more targeted towards specific services.
Re:Endlessh-go: a Golang SSH tarpit that traps bots/scanners
by yard2010 on Thursday March 28, 2024 @12:32PM
(#39853858)
Excuse the old school metaphor - you put a lock on your door so your house is harder to break into, not to prevent anyone from breaking into your house.
Re:Endlessh-go: a Golang SSH tarpit that traps bots/scanners
by metadat on Thursday March 28, 2024 @03:34PM
(#39856343)
Absolutely agree, when I wrote this I was thinking more of defending against the low hanging fruit - mass scanners.
Once someone has deemed you a worthwhile target and is carefully proving all ports, these more nuanced approaches become more worthwhile. Even then, a sophisticated adversary may have many unique src IPs at their disposal.
Re:Endlessh-go: a Golang SSH tarpit that traps bots/scanners
by AlecSchueler on Thursday March 28, 2024 @09:13AM
(#39850915)
If they're targetting SSH specifically how are they going to guess i'm running it on port 1690 and not port 22 other than by scanning up in sequence?
Re:Endlessh-go: a Golang SSH tarpit that traps bots/scanners
by kevindamm on Thursday March 28, 2024 @10:47AM
(#39852252)
Different quality of locks in the ever-escalating arms race. Probably there are many many more sequential scanners out there. For the persistent actors who are doing random ordering or shuffle then you could add port-knocking for the real sshd... but then they just have to find a working client and sniff the connection requests... to which you add a TOTP step for determining which ports to use, and so on...
Re:Endlessh-go: a Golang SSH tarpit that traps bots/scanners
by dambi0 on Thursday March 28, 2024 @11:20AM
(#39852673)
There is a known upper bound they could randomise the guesses from the range.
Re:Endlessh-go: a Golang SSH tarpit that traps bots/scanners
by freedomben on Thursday March 28, 2024 @07:56AM
(#39850094)
The more targeted/sophisticated ones will, but there's a crapload of bots that just scan all publicly addressable IPs for port 22 and attempt to connect. If your goal is to trap as many bots as possible in the tarpit, you'll get a lot more if you run on port 22.
Re:Endlessh-go: a Golang SSH tarpit that traps bots/scanners
by michaelcampbell on Thursday March 28, 2024 @08:52AM
(#39850640)
That's the theory. I have an internet facing box using ssh on a weird port with fail2ban on it just in case.
In over 10 years I've never had a single probe on that port with ssh.
Re:Endlessh-go: a Golang SSH tarpit that traps bots/scanners
by AlecSchueler on Thursday March 28, 2024 @09:11AM
(#39850896)
Same, I went from logging thousands of attempts per day to zero per decade with a simple switch of ports.
Re:Endlessh-go: a Golang SSH tarpit that traps bots/scanners
by michaelcampbell on Thursday March 28, 2024 @02:49PM
(#39855822)
They CAN, but they don't.