Why not get paid to create open source software?
Personally, I have no problem with this - in fact, I'm paid to write FOSS - but some people feel uneasy with the commercialization of the work that traditionally belongs to communities of volunteers, and in certain situations I feel the same.
He specifically complained about them taking money to do it. I genuinely don't see how you could read that as "I would prefer it if you did not create an embeddable emacs at all." His comment very strongly suggests that he was fine with them doing the work, but he didn't want them to be paid for it.
> Personally, I have no problem with this - in fact, I'm paid to write FOSS - but some people feel uneasy with the commercialization of the work that traditionally belongs to communities of volunteers
I agree, and that's the attitude I'm arguing against. Free software has never been about demanding that people not take money for their troubles. It has often worked out that way for the vast majority of contributors, but I don't see how the unprofitability of OSS development is a good thing. More money going into free software means more free software and quite possibly higher quality free software (since they don't need to be distracted by other work that puts bread on the table), which is good for everyone. I have no problem with somebody like you or the OP taking money in return for making useful software.
If posting links to interesting technical projects that try to gain mindshare with an eye on eventual VC backing is appropriate to HN (and that seems a fairly uncontroversial proposition to me), why would posting links to interesting technical projects that try to gain mindshare with an eye on kickstarter backing NOT be appropriate?
2. AFAIK, "Kickstarter" does not imply "open source".
3. Even the Linus'es of this world occasionally stop hacking to eat, and food costs money.
Having said that, I think anything including the term "Emacs" is "scratching your own itch". I do not hold this as a paragon example of the usefulness of Kickstarter.